Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

[dmambi]

Brokers are also like us humans who are placing orders on international banks on behalf of small traders like us and they don't have any clue about the market movement but they have access to the news sources which are more reliable than ours.

[sachin]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[netra]

Brokers ko pata to nae hota laykin on kay pass kafi ziada capital hota hay iss liay wo achi trade ker saktay hain. phir mayray khyaal say on ko apnay traders may say best trader ki trades ka bhi pata hota hoga, to kya pata wo oss ko hi follow ker laytay hoon

[netra]

aesa nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading volume.

[tajdarbet]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

nahi es k barey main koi bhi nahi janta ha k ye kab down ho gi or kab up ho gi main ne khud es ko kafi samghne ki koshish ki ha or kafi guess lagaye hane par phr bhimain forex trading k mode ko nahi samgh paya ye bahot mushkil ha guess karne main

[netra]

Mere hisab se broker ko in sbaka koi bhi andaza nahi hota kyunki market ke bare me koi kuch nahi keh sakta bas apne analysis ke hisab se predict kar sakta hai..amrket ki koi bhi sure shot move nahi hoti chahe jitna bada trader kyu na ho ya broker kyu na ho..market ke bare me 100% kuch bhi nahi keh sakta

[krishan]

Brokers are unaware of market movement. They do follow the market same as we do. They only earn from the spreads that they have given. If there would be any thing like that they could now about future then they can trade much more then traders. News , fundamentals are the factors on which the market is moving.

[amit]

kuch log mind mein ghelt baat bitha detay hien k broker jaan bhuj ker stop loss legwaatey hien, ek trader k loss honay mein broker ka bhi haath hota hey lekin yeh ek ghelt concept hey, broker wahan jaye ga jahan market us ko ley ker jaye gi or na hi broker ko humary position ka peta hota hey

[raka999]

As far as I am concerned,I think the brokers will not know when a position goes up and when it go down.You see,if the brokers can know it,I think you can trade in forex with that much money in their companies,which I think can help them earn more money rather tahn just help the traders there.

You are right. broker will never know the market's movement. they only distribute our funds. but, there are many types of forex broker. There are indeed deliver our capital into the forex market, there is also acting as a dealers. These brokers that we need to beware. because we are going against the broker. the more we lose, then the broker is getting profits. These brokers often commit fraud against the trader.

[xiaotanghao]

As far as I am concerned,I think the brokers will not know when a position goes up and when it go down.You see,if the brokers can know it,I think you can trade in forex with that much money in their companies,which I think can help them earn more money rather tahn just help the traders there.