Do you like to use EA (robot) or manual trading?

[wolfkamikaz]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

[hardworks]

There are many EA's in the market which have same nature or some changes in them. The point is, try some EAs and you will know the result. In my opinion, EA will wipe your account at one stage. So, its better to go for manual trading and improve your trading skills by this.

[newentry]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

i prefer use manual trading, always than i use EA, and i have a reason for it...
with manual trading it means that we always get practice again and again and with this i can develop my system and strategies and then i can make EA by myself...if necessary..
manual trading is a good way to develop, grow up our skills and ability..

[wolfkamikaz]

I think the Robot contains strategies not change but the market changes so much manual is much more effective we can use robots but you have to choose well

[yogesh]

No - i dont think performance of EA can be even near to an experienced forex trader, if am afraid that they act on mechanically on predefined instructions and so cannot take right decisions as per market requriements. For e.g. if i trade in gold and see panic in silver i can be alert instantly and take safety measure as that will affect gold sentiments also, but i dont think a robo will do that.

[speedy]

I like to trade manually because still I have not experienced the trading with EA. In my opinion a trader should first learn all about forex trading and when he learned A_Z about forex then he should try the EA trading. I don't suggest a beginner to start trading with EA.

[yogesh]

yes, agreed, beginners should use manual techniques, do not think about robots,

sometimes beginners are tempted by advertising campaign that provides guaranteed 100% profit on the Internet so they use a robot without knowing the basic analysis, and this will make them always fall because beginners traders not have more experience

Hmm i agree!
We cannot give our account to someone else to trade, as we shall be incertain what the other will do with our account and it will keep us unrested, and we are happy by trading our own because in case of mistakes we learn from them. Then how can we give our account to a program that we know is going to work on pre-feeded instructions.

[mayengbam]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

i love to do manual trading, to improve self in this business. but i also believe there are many robots which are doing great in this business though most of them are paid ones. I havent tried any of those yet but ho[pe will try them someday in the near future

[realfun07]

I prefer to trade manually based on my analysis and study and have confidence on my skills and abilities so I do not trade with robot as they can not trade in uncertain markets and react to news updates.

[dmambi]

Actually i would like to use the robot for trading and make profit out of it, but i am not sure whether the EA which i purchase works fine or not. Also EA is not sensitive to the news release which makes it more pron to loss during news release.

[Mr. Tukul]

Actually i would like to use the robot for trading and make profit out of it, but i am not sure whether the EA which i purchase works fine or not. Also EA is not sensitive to the news release which makes it more pron to loss during news release.

many EA sold via the Internet, but many also commit fraud ...
I've fooled EA bought over the internet, so I'm not interested anymore to use EA ... except that I can get it for free ...

[s19]

many EA sold via the Internet, but many also commit fraud ...
I've fooled EA bought over the internet, so I'm not interested anymore to use EA ... except that I can get it for free ...

in my view buy EA is not good before watching the live performance...
may be seller use EA with very high margin and EA always give profit if we have a hug amount i our account.
first we see how its work ...and what is the minimum balance required...

[sameerjazba]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

main dono trading style pasand karta houn kioun k main market k mizaj k mutabik chalta houn kabhi manual trading karni parti ha or kabhi ea or indecators se help lene parrti esi liye main to dono style se he trading karta houn

[sasa0220]

I'm still a beginner in forex trading. There fore i would like to trade my own and gert experience in the market. So i prefer manual trading more than using an EA. I have also use EAs. But they did not provide very good results so now i'm stick with manual trading

[s19]

I'm still a beginner in forex trading. There fore i would like to trade my own and gert experience in the market. So i prefer manual trading more than using an EA. I have also use EAs. But they did not provide very good results so now i'm stick with manual trading

if any one new in forex then its must he trade manually...with the help of manuall tradging we can understand that how market move...and when its will change the trend...
manuall trading give us experience of trading that is very good if we want to become a successful trader.


I usually like to trade Forex manually not with Forex robot as forex robot trade like they were program and its good to trade when there is no news time.

this is the bad point of robot that its was unable to trade according to news. but if any one going to trade with EA then at the news time he can disable their EA...when market movement become normal he can again start EA.

[anitagala124]

i was a manual trader before,i used to hate automation or expert advisor named bird would have such a big capability to make a work easy..now i shifted to automation in trades before i have a job to do. its better i do a job peacefully in day and can come down in the evening and check the updates to my balance.but to enjoy this privilage u have to program ur EA in such a way that it earns.

[newentry]

I usually like to trade Forex manually not with Forex robot as forex robot trade like they were program and its good to trade when there is no news time.
for me, manual trading is better than i used robot and i do not want use it anymore,,,
with manual, we can develop our system trading time by time and this is a good thing that should the traders do..do not depend to the robot or EA...or we just nothing at forex trading

[wolfkamikaz]

now i use the 2 method but there's time to use the robot when the robot stable strategy and the market stable but manually is very security for me and i think trade with robot is very dangerous if u are nerves man :)))

[jadhav]

i prefer use manual trading, always than i use EA, and i have a reason for it...
with manual trading it means that we always get practice again and again and with this i can develop my system and strategies and then i can make EA by myself...if necessary..
manual trading is a good way to develop, grow up our skills and ability..

[mayengbam]

now i use the 2 method but there's time to use the robot when the robot stable strategy and the market stable but manually is very security for me and i think trade with robot is very dangerous if u are nerves man :)))

Obviously manual trading is the best to develop our skills and knowledge of t he market. But i wont say robots are not bad either because if one sets the right setting and trade using a robot he may be making good profits, the robot need to be tweak of course to suit the market conditions

[adahidayat]

as a newbie, i prefer to trade manually , because i can handle everything by myself and can make a good plan for my manual trading....and also i think that EA can be used effectively by experts...so still i need more time to know about it and learn it well before using it...otherwise i will just suffer losses and make a fault use of EA...

[atif58]

I prefer manual trading. Using EAs is not easy and also unsecured. EAs can not understand a sudden change in market. Sometime the wiped your account. So best thing is to do your own analysis and trade manually.

[zdaina]

hello, i want trading manual , because i don't trust any one or any thing except my self , another reasons i don't try EA in trading. how i can make a good experience when i use EA in trading?

[barmanitrade]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

main to gi sahi bat ha manual trading he pasand karta houn or ea or dosrey systems ko use bhi nahi karta or na he un par aetbar karta houn main sirf apne khud k analysis par he bharosa karta houn

[anubhavsingh]

I prefer to trade manually based on my analysis and study and have confidence on my skills and abilities so I do not trade with robot as they can not trade in uncertain markets and react to news updates.

me bhi hamesha manual trading hi prefer karta hon kyunki khud se study karke trading karne se apko abhut sari cheze seekhne ko milti hai jo ki long term me aapke forex account me bahut kaam aati hai..iske alawa manual trading ak sucess rate zada rehta hai aur kayi log issi ko use kana recomend karte hai

[forexman]

i am using only manual trading at present as i can manually check my positions and have a good control over them but i dont know much about ea's and how they work actually but manual is best for me

[muhammadatif]

EA robots can give you an idea about market position but not help in decision because forex market is not a track or predefined program market is change position time to time, robots are predefined programs so they cannot analysis current market position so manual trading is better than EA robots.

[aadrika]

I love to do manual trading. I like the fact that I am in control of my profits. Also, I cannot really trust an EA because it is someone's profitable strategy which has been written into a script or program. Manual trading also gives me a good feeling when a I make profits because it lets me know that I am improving in my analytical ability in forex trading.

[s19]

From past two years i have been trading manually and i prefer to continue the same. I like to do manual trading because of the hassle which is involved in setting the EA or robots, its not for me.
i agree with you if we are able to do a good manual trading then we should trade manually but if we are not able to do good manual trading then we can go for robot trading.
but before using EA we must checkout the result of ea trading in demo account.
with EA trading we should give a good margin for trading.

[anubhavsingh]

Right forex ea work as they are just programmed and need to be changed from time to time so stop trading with ea and trade with manually and earn profits in consistent way.

mujhe kabhi bhi EA pe poora bharosa nahi hua isliye me hamesha manual trading hi karta hon..manual tarding karne se zada ache se cheeze seekhi jati hai aur utna hi zada experience bhi hota hai..jabki EA ki amdad se aapko itna kuch seekhne ko nahi milega..isliye har trader ko manual trading hi karni chahaiye

[Snoopy1234]

Hi,

i am trading on different broker and accounts with ea. But on one only manual. If you do a fulltime job for trading so you can do it manual or as a hobby. If you want to liv from the money you must do trading with ea. With ea you do not need so much on investment because the market will watched and traded 6 days a week and every day 24 hours. So no chance will be forgiven.

[Mehak]

I prefer the manual trading because is say learning hoti ha...experience gain hota hai, apni mistakes nazar aanay lagti hain...aur ap bohat kuch seekh letay hain...

[twinkling star]

yeah I like to trade using the rebots. but I donnot have a knowlege as how to handle the rebots? manual trading ki apni value hain but us main experience gain kernay kliyay time lagta hain and us time tak rebots use kernay chahiyay plz tell me about EA- (robot) which can I use in my trading

[forexman]

i will still prefer manual tarding only and i dont have any experience with eas up to now and even dont want to use them at present as i am a newbie i will try later after having some experience in trading forex

[kulonikilaregunung]

I am trading with the manual way, I would like to combine fundamental and technical analysis, if trading with EA, it means you are using pure technical analysis, and ignore the news

[zeghbadrahem]

for me i like to trdae monually but when i have a good expert i will use it too but steal lways trade with manually methode well as i know that th expert always lost what did thy make after some times of prfit so i gues that the mnul mthde is th prfct thing i yo want to make money

[asingh601]

I am Like Manual Trading Because it Encourage to learn market read market when i am in loss and i feel very happy when i am in Profit and this is not possible if u using EA or Robots they can earn money for u but they not give the genuine happiness to trade in forex.

[lax]

I prefer to trade manually based on my analysis and study and have confidence on my skills and abilities so I do not trade with robot as they can not trade in uncertain markets and react to news updates.

[ermaniso2011]

l think we can use both.l mean it is better to have more accounts so that you can use one for manual trading only one with expert adviser and other with PAMM and other one with COPY TRADE.so as you can see there are so many options for we traders.l think the main problem of most us.we dont have that big amounts for all of this.we got small accounts and we want to grow it very fast then mistake on mistakes.and we always loose our deposit.this is the the main problem most small traders has.the solution is to be patient and work for our goals slowly.at the end there are so many good forex robots and trading strategies.but we have to keep the total control over our trading carrier so that we can be successful.

[forexman]

in manual trading we can control our trades and i feel manual trading is better than the ea's for me inorder to trade safely so i will still prefer manual trading than the ea;s and i did not hear that ea's will work for all people so i am not interested in eas

[hsngs14]

yes i like ti use robot ea i use it always to test my strategy and may money management i am always try to get the best from forex i have not a lot of time to test so i have to use robot.

[fxquest]

I haven't used forex robot yet, but people use it to save their time as it automates trading process. May be people earn money by these EAs but i dont find it worth because it will not help to improve our experience and knowledge.

[venkiaries61]

Do you like to use EA (robot) or manual trading?

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...


If you are interested to trade using EA, then try it in demo account. Don't ever try it in real account. Do manual trading and learn some thing daily to get some experience. EA can also be tested with strategy tester within some minutes, do it and know the nature of the EA on your own.

[forexman]

i really still cant understand that some guys still say that they make money with ea's and some say no but i will prefer to trade manually as in manual trade we can control more than the automated trading so i prefer manual trading only

[sangam]

prefer like manual trading,
i just don't believe EA works,system has been built from calculation,analisis,in the past graphic.
question is,if i really have a good EA,why i sell to other?better i using it for my self
buying EA in 1 thousand dollars?


When we learn the trade and start doing the trading manually then we are able to understand how to make the profits. Unfortunately this is not the case with the EA based trading in which we have no role to play and the results also cannot be guaranteed at all.

[fxquest]

I prefer to trade manually based on my analysis and study and have confidence on my skills and abilities so I do not trade with robot as they can not trade in uncertain markets and react to news updates.
I totally agree with you, I too have the same mentality and I always prefer to do any type of my work on my own. I even cook for myself on my own :D.

[HakunaRilious]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

Manual trading is good because you learn at the same time but EA is good for busy people but the outcome is good but you dont learn how does it work.

[anubhavsingh]

A robot or a EA can not react to news update and perform right trade in right direction , so it is better to trade manually and also EA can not trade in uncertain markets so it is better to trade manually based on your analysis.

aapne bilkul thik kaha..ye baat to maien bhi bahut bar notice kari hai ki agar ap manual trading karet hai to news ke effect ka asar aapko zada ache se smajh me aa sakta hai jabki forex robits uspe ache se react nahi karenge..isliuye traders ko hamesha manual trading ki hi salah di jati hai

[issamlitim]

i like to use robot for testing strategy and management because manual testing take a long time to see the result and i prefer to trade manual after take a look about my strategy on robot.

[sonia]

i usually trade manually. it seems ok for me. on the other hand, EA/robot sometimes cant pick the real world economic condition and then a loose our money. it is better to trade manually.happy trading

[adil.iub]

i preferd mannualy trading based on my skills and ability i dont bealive in robot trading , beacuse if it is true then why famous trader r not using it why they r using there mind tottaly scam

[forexman]

i agree with you if we are able to do a good manual trading then we should trade manually but if we are not able to do good manual trading then we can go for robot trading.
but before using EA we must checkout the result of ea trading in demo account.
with EA trading we should give a good margin for trading.
yes you are right and we have to test with eas first in demo accounts and then we have to go for live account with eas only when they are working otherwise better to trade manually and control your trades

[gosians]

i agree with you if we are able to do a good manual trading then we should trade manually but if we are not able to do good manual trading then we can go for robot trading.
but before using EA we must checkout the result of ea trading in demo account.
with EA trading we should give a good margin for trading.

I don't think so that if a person is not good in manual trading then he can be good in EA or robot trading. Robot trading requires good experience, only expert traders can make the profit in robot trading, so try to be successful in manual trading.

[kameeelforex]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

nahi gi main to manual trader houn or main to robot ko use he nahi karta houn kioun k mugh ko us par aitbar nahi ha main sirf apne analysis par he bherosa karta houn kioun k main apne liye ziyada acha soch sakta houn or kafi care se trading kar sakta houn esi liye main ne kabhi bhi auto trading nahi ki ha main sirf manual trading he karta houn or es ko pasand karta houn

[motiurbd]

Earning money is not that simple... If there is really a working ea then why people needs to work on 9-5 job.. Why bill gates, warren buffet works hard this much.. whey banks, corporate house security exchange still hires trader to trade their balance? Are they stupid? Or they dont know about it?

[gala]

You won't be able to learn forex trading if you are using EA or robot for your trading and then these EA and robots cannot be trusted fully. They often work for some time under certain conditions and then they start to make loss in your trading.

[gala]

One reason is that you stated and the other is that you gain experience only when you trade by yourself. If you use EA or robots for your trading then you will no gain any kind of experience to yourself.

[alam]

aap ne sahi kaha newbie k liye manual tradign hi bdiya hoti hai.
manual trading se sikhne ko bahut milta hai.
EA to khud hi trade krta hai usme hame sikhne k liye khuch b ni milta hai.

[nilesh]

I prefer manual trading. Using EAs is not easy and also unsecured. EAs can not understand a sudden change in market. Sometime the wiped your account. So best thing is to do your own analysis and trade manually.

[newentry]

honestly i prefer to use trading manually...yes this is my choice and make me better in this business, i did not depend to the robot so i can trade with better ...
and then i can get much knoledge from my trading and this is very useful to develop my strategies

[sohelforex]

I dislike trading by EA. This is a robot which only offers to give you some benefit when the market is in unchanged situation. But the fact my friend, market condition is not in our hand neither in the hand of robot. My opinion says to trade in a traders own experience and fundamental analysis.
THanks.

[lgarhboularbah]

i think that it does not matter to use the EA or not the important thing that we steal trade i think that when i have learn about the mq4 languge i will make my robot to trade and steal trade manually too we should always trade to get the experience that we need it to put it at the EA

[ishvara]

I prefer to trade manually based on my analysis and study and have confidence on my skills and abilities so I do not trade with robot as they can not trade in uncertain markets and react to news updates.

Manual trading is also my style in forex currency trading. It is super effective and we will never have to blame anyone for our faults. It also encourages internal developments of a forex traders skills.

[rinjani]

Manual trading is also my style in forex currency trading. It is super effective and we will never have to blame anyone for our faults. It also encourages internal developments of a forex traders skills.

I'm still trading manually, and I am comfortable with the strategy I use in trading.
of course we should also be able to know how the trading by using a robot.
It could be a good tool if the trader does not have enough time to continue to be in front of chart.

[dog]

in forex trading i always prefer manual trading.because it is easy and comfortable for me.i don't depend on trading with robots.from my view trading with own anlaysis is best in forex trading

trading manually will helps you to improve your knowledge about forex trading as well as improve the trading strategies.so trading manually is better than robot trading

[pooja]

EA operates in one way and that is the way it has been programmed to operate. Most of the EA's can not trade in uncertain markets and trade on news updates so manual trading is much better.

[pooja]

A robot or a EA can not react to news update and perform right trade in right direction , so it is better to trade manually and also EA can not trade in uncertain markets so it is better to trade manually based on your analysis.

[wazid201118]

My lord has provided me with a brain to use this for my bussiness walefare.So i want to use it and practise it for making my skill huge and to the proper system of forex trading.A manual thing can help me to get myself profetional forex trader in future.So i do not need any EA.

[Morshedul]

I always prefer to use manual trading where i can explore myself. In manual trading, i can analysis and then take decisions what to do. In other cases, it is not possible to analysis and we have to depend on others which i dont like at all. Even trading manually can give a higher chances of getting higher profits.

[wolfkamikaz]

I tried all the methods of trading manual or automatic, but if someone really wants to win he used the manual method because it's you and you decided that you know very well why you buy or sell back

[realman]

I don't like to use Robot. Also many expert use robot for best trading. Day by day robot populated. Robot actually a expert sentiment. A programmer can make it. But I am not a programmer for that I have depend another for making it. Although I could edit program. But I am not agree to do it. Almost I am happy to trading manually. I see the Forex as a business. I don't play funny. Forex included in blood.

[greentrader]

In my opinion, there is nothing better than trading manually, we can feel the movement of prices, how prices will move and where. Eyes and my brain is the best trading tool

[xiaotanghao]

For me, I do not like to use EA during my trading.I usually think EA may suggest us some wrong signals about the trend.While the munal trading help us to improve our trading skills so much there.So I prefer to use munal trading.

[anitagala124]

Both are important but more important is good strategy because if you have very large capital and don�t have any good strategy for trading you cannot earn profit and lose you money but if you have small capital with good strategy you can earn good profit.

[Tarek]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

I do not like to trade with robots, it is true that there are many robots that benefit many points, but to use a robot to take advantage and succeed you must have a VPS server, and a good conection.

[ahmedfx]

for me i like manual trading and i dislike expert because in manual trading i can control my own transaction and try to find solution to close it in entry point and then money management and available balance and Robot cannot make it ... only close it in losing or making stop loss :D

[wolfkamikaz]

I preffered manual trading and not against robot trading.There's a lot of people he wants to become rich but he thinks it wrong trying to put a robot to the robot manages all but he can make big mistakes and we lose any money because he always repeats the same spots

[kitt]

robot is great for dailly trading because the robot will never miss any chance to open the deal robot is always ready but for the swing i prefer the manual trading and manual analysis.

[wazid201118]

My mind says that to trade with EA or robot would be a foolish plane for the trader.Because a Ea can trade easily and will be profitable.It just continue its trading by its level skill and profit will come out by its own trading skill too.So its needed for the traders who trade manually can exceed his skill day by day and also can enhance his profit.So i think Ea is never suitable for continue his trade profitable.

[iwan]

though I never use forex robot (EA), because in my opinion, the market is fluktuativ and only a man can control because we have feelings. not to be represented at a tool that knows only a matter of mathematics, with manual trading anyways we can get more profit.

[riskfx2012]

I love to trade by hand because I'm a beginner and my pal have explained which i haven't to consider EA till I learn about foreign exchange buying and selling. I'm buying and selling inside a demo account and i believe manual buying and selling is preferable to EA because in manual buying and selling we are able to decide at our very own.

[miracle]

i prefer using expert advisor than trading manual. it help me to trade more discipline, beside that i don't need to be 24 hours in front of computer. there are many important things to do beside trading.

[jai]

Yes forex trading is all about gaining. how you trader it dont mater if you get profit it is very think for a trader. So if you use robot an gain then good.
I also trade both but i like manually trading.

[amit]

Good suggestion for newbie I also think learn first about forex then you should think other way. If you really trade forex then you need to learn and then learn about robot then you can use robot it will help you to how robot works.

[dalino]

i do not like using ea..it is too dangerous..market is very volatiile and it can unpredictable..but some ea may be profitable but actually,the profitable ae is not too sale..i heard in one forum that the most profitable ea..it is calling angeliic ea..and now,some broker banned the account who use that ea...how a cheat broker..

[ishvara]

The idea of using robots to trade forex is a great one for me. But i would only consider to trade forex trading markets only with manual since i have never found an EA or robot that is making the best of results.

[jai]

mujhey manual trading ziaada pasand hey ,kunki jo kaam khudi kia jaye us per ziaada satisfaction hoti hey, robot mein ney jitnay dekhay hien,sab mein koi na koi defect zeroor hota hey or woh account urah detay hien

[leo]

if I prefer to use both, because it has the advantages of each. Using the EA that I sometimes when I'm resting, or are there other concerns. I then use the manual even if only occasionally, because it is still a bit traumatized by yesterday had been lost. So for now I am more likely to use forex trading EA for this,,

[oscar]

using a trading robot is a bad experience for me ..
my trading account has a margin call last month for using a trading robot ..
I currently prefer to perform manual trading, and seek to comply with the rules of trading and money management

[bambang]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

as a beginner in this business I prefer to trade with the manual. because the trading manual will enhance our ability to analyze. if we use expert advisors, we can not learn many ways to analyze because it's all done by the expert advisor.
but maybe if I was an expert in manual trading, I will make my own expert advisor. made under the system that I use in manual trading

[ilovemyindia]

i like manual trading. i do not believe that robots can do forex trading well due to the uncertainty and the chaotic behavior in forex price movements. robots might be able to follow the technical indicators but then how to follow the fundamental effects. it is risky to use robots in forex.

yes my brother hume manual hi karna chahiye manual se humari kafi practice hoti hai jis se hum apni kami mein sudhar la sakte EA to maine kabhi kiya hi nahi ki ye hota kaise hai main isko pasand hi nahi karta hoon jo expeience apne hath mein hoga wo hamesha kaam ayega

[ahmedlinkers]

I like to trade manually, with all the human involvement. EA trading or auto trading is not of my liking. Its just tasteless excercise to trade in auto trading.

[preetfx]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...


i use a trailing stop ea while trading, even though all my trades are manually opened i close them with the ea because this helps me close a trade faster, it is just 1 click instead of 3 to 4 clicks to close a trade

[siddesh]

I like to trade manually because still I have not experienced the trading with EA. In my opinion a trader should first learn all about forex trading and when he learned A_Z about forex then he should try the EA trading. I don't suggest a beginner to start trading with EA.

[kaji]

I prefer to trade manually instead of using a robot trading. I think that by trading manually will make me more able to control my trading position and will make me continue to learn to make the trading signal and analysis of market movement...

[chetan]

EA/robots ka sabse bada nuksan yahi hota hai ki wo achanak se aayi hui news ke hsiab se react nahi kar pate jabki agar aap manual trading karte hai to aap kisi bhi fundamental ke hisab se apni trading aur strategy change kar sakte hai. forex me manual trading hi prefer kari jati hai

[tajdarbet]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...
nahi g main to sahi baat ha k robot k haq main bilkul bhi nahi houn maoin to sirf or sirf manual trading pasand karta houn or es ko he use karta houn manual trading sab se bast strategy ha or es main loss bahot kam hota ha

[andhwrey]

I didnt like EA too much,sounds that i didnt trust my self to trade my money,so i didnt use even for trying that programs,
i had see many EA are didnt makes any changed to our money,only loss

[chirayu]

You won't be able to learn forex trading if you are using EA or robot for your trading and then these EA and robots cannot be trusted fully. They often work for some time under certain conditions and then they start to make loss in your trading.

[chirayu]

One reason is that you stated and the other is that you gain experience only when you trade by yourself. If you use EA or robots for your trading then you will no gain any kind of experience to yourself.

[rajesh]

Hmm i agree!
We cannot give our account to someone else to trade, as we shall be incertain what the other will do with our account and it will keep us unrested, and we are happy by trading our own because in case of mistakes we learn from them. Then how can we give our account to a program that we know is going to work on pre-feeded instructions.

[rajesh]

No - i dont think performance of EA can be even near to an experienced forex trader, if am afraid that they act on mechanically on predefined instructions and so cannot take right decisions as per market requriements. For e.g. if i trade in gold and see panic in silver i can be alert instantly and take safety measure as that will affect gold sentiments also, but i dont think a robo will do that.

[sunil]

i usually trade manually. it seems ok for me. on the other hand, EA/robot sometimes cant pick the real world economic condition and then a loose our money. it is better to trade manually.happy trading

[rajesh]

There are many traders who do not like the EA just because of the reason that they do not know how to use the EA and other most important thing is that they do not have the money to use its services.

[rajesh]

I don't think so that if a person is not good in manual trading then he can be good in EA or robot trading. Robot trading requires good experience, only expert traders can make the profit in robot trading, so try to be successful in manual trading.

[chirayu]

You do not need experience to trade with EA. Just buy a robot and install it but only install first on a demo account. You can use EA on demo account and still be learning to trade by yourself at the same time.

[narendra]

Of course EA will not be able to respond to any rise or fall that will come due to news just because EA does not have any intelligence, EA has to do everything according to programming. Manual trading is much better from EA because we can decide much better at the time of news.

[lights]

I am more interested in trading manually, because there is a challenge when we are trading manually. in addition, only trading robot based on technical analysis, while 85% driven by market fundamentals. some people say they often experience a margin call when they use the robot

[deathzz]

I actually prefer to use the robot for trading but that was then, now I prefer to trade manually. Trading using a robot is good because it is not affected by emotional factors, but also a new robot will stop trading when we've had a MC account. :(

[vineet]

Good suggestion for newbie I also think learn first about forex then you should think other way. If you really trade forex then you need to learn and then learn about robot then you can use robot it will help you to how robot works.

[waqtitrader]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...
main manual trading karta houn or robot k nisbat es ko he prfer karoun ga per wese abb mainne auto trading karna bhi shura kiya ha par main phr bhi kisi ea ko use nahi karoun ga kioun k mugh ko pata ha k ea se trade karna kafi risk ha or main forex main kaam he risk leta houn

[ShoSho]

I do not know why there is many traders that do not like to trade with expert adviors for me i think they are best than manual trading also they are both the same as if pro trader that have profitable manual strategy then he can code it to be expert adisors and code it with the all rules of his strategy then t will be better than manual strategy as this will take all chances as it works 24 hours and trad with no emotions.

[Amitab]

i love to do manual trading, to improve self in this business. but i also believe there are many robots which are doing great in this business though most of them are paid ones. I havent tried any of those yet but ho[pe will try them someday in the near future

I prefer trading manually, by what I can see what's happening before my eyes, but trading with robots is a bad deal, given the robots lose their dice d�con�xion the servers, so I do thee not recommend using these methods.

[Abdo22]

you are right my brother, the best is the trading manual trading, by using this method that you can see the change in market 24/24 hours, that sometimes when using robots in the market changes its direction instantaneously, and robots do not understand it well, and we will lose our capital, so it's better to go for manual trading.

[edmar6969]

I like using EA because even I'm away from my computer, the robot still trades for me.
And also emotion is eliminated so i don't worry much.

[over580]

I prefer manual trading , because it is safer and better in terms of learning and skills development , can earn a good experience and techniques of manual trading , and this is what it takes to work at Forex

[vineet]

ham manual trading se loss ko cover kar sakte hai. lekin EA bi es traha work karta hai ki wo bi apne loss ko cover kar le.
mere khyal se EA loss main trading close nahi karta hai.
EA trading main profit hone ke baad hi trading close hoti hai.

[patil]

apne manual karne se apne ko apni galti ka pata chalta hai aur apni manual mein jo bhi kami hoti hai wo oobher kar bahar aati hai fir hume manual se kuch na kuch sikhne ko milta hi rahta hai so manual hume karna chahiye..

[vineet]

yes manual humara experience hota hai jo humare pass hamesha rahta hai manual hi best strategy main kabhi other signal par believe nahi karta kyun ki other signal jaydatar false hote hai aur ho hunar humare haath mein hoga us se hum jo marzi kar sakte hai kabhi kisi aur ka wait nahi karna padega.

[sagar]

There are many traders that like to trade manually as they like it to trade manually.Expert advisory can give you good returns but its not better if news has come suddenly.

[anchitkole]

Right forex ea work as they are just programmed and need to be changed from time to time so stop trading with ea and trade with manually and earn profits in consistent way.

[sagar]

honestly i prefer to use trading manually...yes this is my choice and make me better in this business, i did not depend to the robot so i can trade with better ...
and then i can get much knoledge from my trading and this is very useful to develop my strategies

[jai]

Better is the manual trading then the robot trading as in the manual trading,you can decide and control the trade perfectly but in robot trading as that is a software ,the failure possibility is more ,though traders can take more rest and time also may be saved but the best trading Robot selection is really a big work.and the cost is also more.

[sagar]

as a beginner in this business I prefer to trade with the manual. because the trading manual will enhance our ability to analyze. if we use expert advisors, we can not learn many ways to analyze because it's all done by the expert advisor.
but maybe if I was an expert in manual trading, I will make my own expert advisor. made under the system that I use in manual trading

[jai]

I totally agree with you, I too have the same mentality and I always prefer to do any type of my work on my own. I even cook for myself on my own .

[scorpian7]

I never trusted on EAs (Robots) since they are based on ideal market condition and on technical analysis , where as Forex market at times moves abnormally so it may have negative consequences on your account . So I prefer manual trading.

[jai]

I haven't used forex robot yet, but people use it to save their time as it automates trading process. May be people earn money by these EAs but i dont find it worth because it will not help to improve our experience and knowledge.

[rahul]

ham manual trading se loss ko cover kar sakte hai. lekin EA bi es traha work karta hai ki wo bi apne loss ko cover kar le.
mere khyal se EA loss main trading close nahi karta hai.
EA trading main profit hone ke baad hi trading close hoti hai.

[manibhai2012]

Do you like to use EA (robot) or manual trading?
I always like the manual trading because I think that I can work better than any robot, robot do only that work which we tell to do, but on the other side I think we can trade according to news also and robot are not able to read or execute the news so I am on the side of manual trading.

[nuh514]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

I do not rely on any robot or something like this. I always prefer to do manual trading and I mostly rely on my own abilities and hope to earn huge money through my abilities. So I would also like to suggest other newcomers to try to trade by their selves and try to work hard and learn maximum strategies about the trading.

[Nabi Ahmed Gill]

[B]Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

main forex trading main sub sa zadia pasand karta hoon manual trading ko both zadia pasan karta hooon is layia main trading main aya hoon or main trading main abi abi aya hoon is layia main forex trading main kam and forex trading is the largest and all over the world comapny.

[Forexboy]

I think using the manual trading is more good than using EA negotiation because: negotiating with the manual this means that we always practice again and again and with that I can develop my system and my strategies, then I can do EA by myself. But if it is necessary. So to summarize using a manual trading is good for EA.

[playfx]

right now i'm still more like to use manual trading for my strategy. i don't know if it can perform same good result if i converted into an expert advisor?
perhaps if i've done using it and make enough money then i will change it into robots.

[ritesh]

but robots can never make good profits & constant
they always have mistakes as they depend only on indicators & don't put in mind the effect of news or the traders psychology
which can be expected by the human trader himself but the robot can't do that

[ritesh]

of course manual trading is much better than depending on robots
because robot may be technically right, but the trader's psychology, they don't have it
& many people who tried them were not satisfied by their results, they give many wrong signals

[zahidrock]

Manually trade all time best for this business. I like to trade on manually. Because i can easily change my strategy on manually trading. I think this market is dynamic and strategy modify is most important for making profit on all situation. But robot can't do this.

[darksaimon]

I equal to class manually because console I hold not toughened the trading with EA. In my persuasion a merchant should eldest see all around Forex trading and when he scholarly A to Z almost Forex then he should try the EA trading. I don't declare a initiate to advantage trading with EA.

[naziafarhan]

No I dont like the ea and I like trading manually cause I know that the EA are working on certain rules and no rule is perfect for forex trading. And they are less effecient in handling the extreme situations of forex market and they make a huge loss in that situation.

[ishvara]

of course manual trading is much better than depending on robots
because robot may be technically right, but the trader's psychology, they don't have it
& many people who tried them were not satisfied by their results, they give many wrong signals

I love manual trading and i also prefer it to using robots that are just programmes. Manual trading gives us the required knowledge in order to be able to get trading knowledge and confidence.

[joget]

I prefer to trade manually instead of using a robot (EA), it is because I want to know the process of trade in what I do. so I can learn from it and evaluate the results in order to get the best way to get and increase profits and minimize losses by finding and making the system exactly the way I trade.

[kaji]

Manually trade all time best for this business. I like to trade on manually. Because i can easily change my strategy on manually trading. I think this market is dynamic and strategy modify is most important for making profit on all situation. But robot can't do this.

yes, I also prefer to trade with the manual. because I've had a painful experience when using the EA trading account where I was devastated at the time because I had a loss again and again until my money runs out

[tervarto]

There are many of the Expert Advisors and every one of them has a certain way to work on it, but the problem is that most of the Expert Advisors does not deal very well, especially in the time of the news, leading to great loss, especially the experts of scalping, and I tried both, and the best manual labor instead of working on the Expert Advisor

[sabutkelaparasaduren]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

I do not like to use a robot, because the robot is something that stupid. he can only obey our orders but can not decide everything yourself when things are not in accordance with our orders. then what happens is, at first we are going to profit, but such conditions do not correspond with what we ordered, we will loss even MC.

[tearsdontfall]

All the strategy that was created course aims to earn profit and not the opposite. However, each person had a target in accordance with his desire. So I think it does not matter if the result will be different for each person, but the main objective remains the same thing: profit.
You can not give the same satisfaction for everyone, despite using the same strategy.

[wolfkamikaz]

Experts have their own advantages over manual trading namely that it is convenient and we do not have to have any knowledge of forex before using an expert advisor.

[mita]

EA robots can give you an idea about market position but not help in decision because forex market is not a track or predefined program market is change position time to time, robots are predefined programs so they cannot analysis current market position so manual trading is better than EA robots.

[gava]

mjhe to EA ya robot bilkul pasand nae hain. jo websites ya load ye EA or robot sell kertay hain on ki mjhe ye samaj nae aati kay agar un ka robot itna hi acha hota hay to wo khud oss say dhair sara paisa keuun nae kama laytay.

[rahul]

bhai mien kabhi prefer nehi keroon ga robot ka , or ager aap robot ka new trader ko bolo gey to definitely woh forex seekhna chhor dien gey or robot hi lega ker baith jayein gey jab k haqeeqat yeh hey manual trading ziaada behter hoti hey robot trading sey kunki robot aap ka account ager urana chahien to 1 ghantay mien bhi ura sektay hien

[mita]

trading manually will helps you to improve your knowledge about forex trading as well as improve the trading strategies.so trading manually is better than robot trading

[barkiman]

EA robots can give you an idea about market position but not help in decision because forex market is not a track or predefined program market is change position time to time, robots are predefined programs so they cannot analysis current market position so manual trading is better than EA robots.
however, manual trading, is the best. if you use ea, you can not learn about the psychology of trading, analysis and reasoning in the decision-position. and is very annoying, robot never ignore, how much of your capital.

[babu]

you are right my brother, the best is the trading manual trading, by using this method that you can see the change in market 24/24 hours, that sometimes when using robots in the market changes its direction instantaneously, and robots do not understand it well, and we will lose our capital, so it's better to go for manual trading.

[avi]

I don't think so that if a person is not good in manual trading then he can be good in EA or robot trading. Robot trading requires good experience, only expert traders can make the profit in robot trading, so try to be successful in manual trading.

[faesa]

I certainly would prefer the manual trading. I do not like EA, I believe more in myself than the robot. I would feel satisfied if I can generating profit through me. and the thing to remember is that a robot was not necessarily profit, so you should believe in yourself.

[babu]

You won't be able to learn forex trading if you are using EA or robot for your trading and then these EA and robots cannot be trusted fully. They often work for some time under certain conditions and then they start to make loss in your trading.

[sspences88]

bro mere khayal me to manual trading hi best ha ku k forex robot bohat ziada efficient nahi ha,or jb ye loss krate ha to bohat ziada hota ha loss or aise trading ko auto pr chorna is to risky, mere khayal me manual trading best ha hr cheez hmare hatho me hoti ha k hm kia kr skte ha,or loss ko b km kr skte ha apne knowledge k mutabik:respect:

[babu]

One reason is that you stated and the other is that you gain experience only when you trade by yourself. If you use EA or robots for your trading then you will no gain any kind of experience to yourself.

[moti]

I don't think so that if a person is not good in manual trading then he can be good in EA or robot trading. Robot trading requires good experience, only expert traders can make the profit in robot trading, so try to be successful in manual trading.

[sudsind]

Best is manual trading, but the robots you are talking about are commercial robots and they have been created for the purpose of earning money by selling them, no robot out in the market could work well all the time, but that doesn't mean ea's don't work, many big traders automate their own strategies to ease their work but they don't sell those eas in the open market

[bhai]

A robot or a EA can not react to news update and perform right trade in right direction , so it is better to trade manually and also EA can not trade in uncertain markets so it is better to trade manually based on your analysis.

[waqarme2]

actually i am the newbie and even don't know something about the robot, as i like the manual trading in forex and i know that manual trading is one of the best trading technique, but on the other hand i totally disagree with the robot trading as i don't see that, that's why i not feel it good.

[Awan]

If you trade manually, you better have a calm mind and a sound plan. It must be your priority goal - to be calm and confident about the trades you enter, and not making emotional decisions if the trade goes one way or another - instead, you should wait and exit .

[bhai]

EA operates in one way and that is the way it has been programmed to operate. Most of the EA's can not trade in uncertain markets and trade on news updates so manual trading is much better.

[tarun2305]

i would recomment to do manualk trading becoz if u use EA then first of all it requires high balance and if u maintain the high balance then there is no surity that it will ghive ony profit loss ke bhi chances bahut rhte hai...

[faesa]

I prefer the manual trading, I can analyze the market and also use the strategy that I have. I do not believe in robots. because the robot would not be guilty if I have a loss. I am pleased to be able to manage their own money. so that someday my skills improved and I will become a professional trader

[bjbh427]

I personally like to trade manually and i prefer to take things in my hand, I don't rely on bots etc.
I guess people should understand that these bots etc are not the ones who can understand the market news etc. They just work on the market historical trends.

[Maham Gill]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

main trading manual karata hoon or main is forum main newbie hoon or main itina trading k bara min nahi janta hoon islayia main sirf or sirf manual trading he karta hoon or is k bad min or koi trading nahi karta hoon

[dineshji]

robot is great for dailly trading because the robot will never miss any chance to open the deal robot is always ready but for the swing i prefer the manual trading and manual analysis.

[netra]

But now a days more advances robots are available you can configure them at your own level even they offer money management and risk management level too. So why not adopt some good automated trading robot along with manual trading because in this way we can emphasis on more pairs and can do this emotion free.

[maurya]

i love to do manual trading, to improve self in this business. but i also believe there are many robots which are doing great in this business though most of them are paid ones. I havent tried any of those yet but ho[pe will try them someday in the near future

[yaar]

Obviously manual trading is the best to develop our skills and knowledge of t he market. But i wont say robots are not bad either because if one sets the right setting and trade using a robot he may be making good profits, the robot need to be tweak of course to suit the market conditions

[kutuk]

i prefer to use ea but i do not believe that ea can work alone without control. I think ea should still be controlled and sometimes must be modified in order to remain compliant with the ever-changing market circumstances. so when i use ea i always control them while i learn the other strategy.
Your word is true even if the robot but must remain in control and sometimes we have to change its settings to fit our strategy, but until now I have never used a real account at most, I use the demo account because I would trust my own strategy

[cac4a26]

i adopt use chiral trading, consistently than i use EA, and i accept a acumen for it. with chiral trading it agency that we consistently get convenance afresh and afresh and with this i can advance my arrangement and strategies and again i can accomplish EA by myself.

[talha007]

I like to manual trading .Forex robot maximum time does not work properly .maximum time it have a chance to become fake and cause of lose money .But manually is safer .You can able to trade in your own analysis.

[mr revo]

I don't believe in Forex robots; i just don't use them anymore. I have used a few robots in the past such as Fap turbo and although I was stunned by the impressive trading outcome, never the lss I now prefer to trade manually.

[waleedkhan]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

may jo hai dono tried kia hain manually aur EA...
wasa jo hai woh most important jo mera liya hai woh how to trade well aur kion kay understandin aur trading itself have been able to gain pips........

[wendhrie]

I would like to use the robot for trading and make profit out of it, but i am not sure whether the robot which i purchase works fine or not. Also robot is not sensitive to the news release which makes it more pron to loss during news release.

[mr revo]

i do not believe in forex robots because i like to trade manually and robots can not realize the market situation they only run few some rules and coding, so i didn't know why people run to achieve holy grail like forex robots.and one thing is that its marketing is so good then people attractive to buy this .

[fajar]

obviously I would prefer a manual with the level of risk that is much easier to control ..
ea and in contrast to a run in accordance with the system, and not a fundamental ..

[ishvara]

I like to manual trading .Forex robot maximum time does not work properly .maximum time it have a chance to become fake and cause of lose money .But manually is safer .You can able to trade in your own analysis.

I also like to use the manual trading in my forex currency trades. This suggests that manual could be the best. I dislike robots since it never gives me any chance to learn forex and have a knowledge of my own.

[fxlover]

as a newbie in forex market i do not like or want to use EA. because if i depend on EA from now i will deprive from forex learning's. at first i want to earn more knowledge about forex market. after i use EA in my real trade.

[sudsind]

i am testing many EAs these days but no ea is upto the mark or none is on which i can rely upon, so all the commercial EAs out there are just crap, with a bigger risk and smaller profit, if someone can name an ea that is working properly with a good risk to reward ratio i would be very grateful to him

[sudsind]

what i think if someone with a good working strategy, and with a set of rules to follow programme his strategy and rules into an ea, than this ea could work great as it is based on his own profitable strategy that he has been trading manually, but for that you need some programming knowledge or hire some expert but again the problem is that all strategies cannot be programmed into an ea

[khaled6969]

I try my use of EA (robot) on the demo account and I decide to watch those results and you use it or not, but if the robot does not EA Use it canceled trading manual

[ishvara]

Manual is the one that i would always prefer in this business of forex. It is simpler and above all, we traders know how to control our trading results based on this manual trading. But robots controls everything in forex.

[taufiqbd]

I always like to manual trade because it is more secure and safety. Forex trading by using robot is very dangerous and it may help to hack your trading account information and balance. It also destroy your analytical knowledge about forex. Never earn good profit by using robot.

[aina]

I am very much happy with the manual trading. I had been in use of the EAs for one or two times but they did not show any good results. Therefore I have never tried to utilize them in my trading then after.

[wendhrie]

I am comfortable with the strategy I use in trading manually. Of course we should also be able to know how the trading by using a robot. It could be a good tool if the traders are busy do not have enough time to continue to be in front of desktop.

[plabonseu]

I think manual trade is the best trading in forex market.A person can take proper decision and can make handsome profit from this market

[redlion]

i prefer to rely on my own analysis of the market and like to take my own decissions. if u do the trade u analyze the charts and interpret the indicator signals and depending on your knowledge and experience u open a trade. irrespective of the fact that the trade is profitable or not, u know u have done everything u could in your capacity and that gives u satisfaction if your trade is profitable or u learn from your loss and never repeat the same mistake. sometimes the market moves in very strange ways then it cannot be helped and its not your fault. with the use of a EA you entrust your money with a programme that u have limited control of and if that program looses your money u learn nothing and end up with nothing. so why not do it yourself.

[got2luvyou25]

I'm still trading manually, and I feel comfortable with the strategy I use in commerce. of course we also need to be able to figure out how to trade using robots.

ye baat to theek ha ki robotic system k bayajeye hum logon ko manaul system use kerna chahaye , lekan manual system b aisa hona chahaye jo k waqi kam kerta b ho ye na ho kahrab or poor strategy use kareen hum or bad hain manaul b kam nahi kerta
wiase apki strategy konsi ha commerce wali ?

[mbie123]

i prefer to rely on my own analysis of the market and like to take my own decissions. if u do the trade u analyze the charts and interpret the indicator signals and depending on your knowledge and experience u open a trade. irrespective of the fact that the trade is profitable or not, u know u have done everything u could in your capacity and that gives u satisfaction if your trade is profitable or u learn from your loss and never repeat the same mistake. sometimes the market moves in very strange ways then it cannot be helped and its not your fault. with the use of a EA you entrust your money with a programme that u have limited control of and if that program looses your money u learn nothing and end up with nothing. so why not do it yourself.

This is true, because by learning to trade manually, we'll know more in how to read charts and use indicators, my advice is, if we use an EA, it is good we learn before using it, we must learn to compute a strategy that we use.

[dmambi]

I also feel sometimes to use EA for my trading , but right now i don't have knowledge develop my own one. And i don't have money to purchase the reliable EA. I want to do trading manually right now because of this and once i get enough experience and good strategy is developed same can be later converted to an EA.

[dintera]

I prefer to manually pick up my trades as i have more control of my open positions. We must try to apply our own strategies and understand the market well before start trading. To be a successful traders, we have to acquire trading skills and experience and therefore developing a personal skill is essential in a long run.

A majority of us have probably tried one or more systems and seen them fail. Of course, when we spent thousand of dollars on a systems to do our trading, we expect it to work and when it doesn't , it is quite a disappointment . The common reasons why the system failed is due to lack of testing and the released software was completely built around the current market conditions.

I think a good trading system should be based on a proven strategy that has worked for many years and then is only slightly modified as the market conditions change.

[yakult]

I'm more comfortable trading their own than with EA. Moreover, if the EA that I did not know the reason of the EA open position. there are some EA that I have ever tried and profitable, I just keep it less convenient.

[tarun2305]

i always try to do short term trading because its good to make some fast profits by just using some simple strategies and just doing scalping which is also liked by most of the traders.

[kapil_chemical_07]

I like to use robot for a certain condition.If you are not know well about forex,you should use robot.But, if you are good in forex trading, then you should not use forex trading robot.Because, it will make you blind.

[kaia]

I prefer to use my own Traffic. Because I feel, if we continue to use its own Traffic then will gradually increase our capacity. different if we use the robot, then we will ramp up capabilities in place, and it's certainly not our desire.

[forexgain]

i like to use the manual trading method. i know that i ma good at the trading and there is no need for me to purchase a robot and then test it and then use it. may be there are chances that i loose my money

[traderapes]

If you do not have much time to trade, use the expert advisor is not a problem. But if you want to get serious in the world of forex, use manual trading, learn the strategies you use and develop it. It's better for you.

[vanigota]

I also think some time EA dont understand sudden market change. I think some time handling EA is difficult for trader. But if you have good knowledge with technical and fundamental analysis then trader can trade manual and trader can monitor them salve.

[hitesh]

Right forex ea work as they are just programmed and need to be changed from time to time so stop trading with ea and trade with manually and earn profits in consistent way.

[rahulsagar]

There are many traders that like to trade manually as they like it to trade manually.Expert advisory can give you good returns but its not better if news has come suddenly.

[bamboe]

Perhaps many traders prefer to use the EA in forex trading, because it saves time. Just make me more comfortable trading manually.
Maybe because I have more time at the computer in the appeal of others. :)
After all, I was less comfortable if EA is the basis of his logic I do not know.

[sumonmia0526]

bhai EA par hume bharosa rakhna bhi nahi chahiye. kyun ki ye sirf ek automatic system hai jo 90% loss dene ki takat rakhti hai.:)))isliye main inko kabhi bhi prefer nahi karta hoon main sirf manual trading karta hoon. aur main fundamental par jayda concentrate karta hoon.:)

most of we don't like automatic system coz it can decide with an logical algorithm not form the live economic condition ..but it's not impossible to say that there is few robot can give excellent performance .now question is which robot that is??do u know actually?

[tariktanjaoui]

in opinion i like manual trading for many reasons :
i want to gain experience
with practice we can be a good traders in the futur
i hate to use EA (robot)
i can't give my account for the EA (robot) because he commited the mistakes

[tashnotashi]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

main to sahi baat ha k koi bhi ea ya auto system use nahi karta houn main to sahi bat ha k sirf or sirf manual trading karta houn or us ko he pasand karta houn es liye main to yahi kahoun ga k app bhi manual trading karo ye bast ha

[rk225325]

maine apne real account mein kabhi forex robot use nahi kiya,maine robot ko apne demo account mein use kiya tha mujhe bahut loss hua tha.main mannualy trading karta hun aur hamesha karta rahunga,kyunki main chahta hun ki main apne mehnat se paisa kamaun.

[hitesh]

bhai mien kabhi prefer nehi keroon ga robot ka , or ager aap robot ka new trader ko bolo gey to definitely woh forex seekhna chhor dien gey or robot hi lega ker baith jayein gey jab k haqeeqat yeh hey manual trading ziaada behter hoti hey robot trading sey kunki robot aap ka account ager urana chahien to 1 ghantay mien bhi ura sektay hien

[rbs]

Manual trading is the best option for maximum traders ,
who are having minimum investment capital and can't afford the EA's high price or don't know its working pattern ...


With good technology within your reach, forex traders can now get a software to automate trading and you don't have to worry about determining the right timing to trade and being able to monitor the best time to get the best profit.

[golpo20]

There are several investors which choose to buy and sell personally because they like it to buy and sell personally. Pro advisory will give anyone great earnings but it is not necessarily greater if reports possesses occur out of the blue.

[zeshan]

i am trade with the robot and myself i fell i trade the best rather then the robot when i start the trading i use it but now i trade myself better then the robot

[Muhammad]

Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...

mai to filhaal new entry ho trading main , filhal mian EA kay kabil nahee ho ku keh main is ke bay main zayada nhe janta, main is main kuch kamyabi kay bad hi EA kay baray main socho ga filhaal main manual trading ko he pasand kro ga or isi ko he trajeeh do ga, or apnay dosto say is kay baray main mazeed seekh raha ho

[omofx]

i have a bad experience with EA (robot) when i started trading forex, i stop using it and i start trading manually most of those EA out there are not good

[naijafx]

There are robots that still has this kind of trading results. They open many positions and still close them in losses.

[Fahad]

as per my experience, we should not trust on any kind of robot, i tried robot once tome ever, but it was a bad experience for me, we should trust on our abilities and mind

[barkiman]

for me, manually trading will be better, compared to trading with the robot. with the manual, you can learn about trading psychology, strategies and money management. I think, automated trading can be profitable at first alone, then you will see a loss after loss.

[golpo20]

Having beneficial technology as part of your achieve, currency trading merchants is now able to obtain a software program to automate trading and it's not necessary to concern yourself with finding out the suitable timing to industry and having the capacity to check service provider to find the greatest income.

[999999999]

for me, manually trading will be better, compared to trading with the robot. with the manual, you can learn about trading psychology, strategies and money management. I think, automated trading can be profitable at first alone, then you will see a loss after loss.

actually not about first or second but about the market characteristic, most robot are being successful at asian market but when they use it on American market the result totally different, if we know the robot characteristic then we can earn money using them

[tarun2305]

forex me aap trade roj kare ya kabhi kabhi isase kuchh fark nahi padta hai par aap ko market ke touch me roj rahana chahiye ,analysis bhi karte rahana chahiy aur iske liye Ea ki jarurat nahi padti hai

[mmassi]

At present I am a new trader, and I'm still about to learn because I entered this business for 4 months so I was not yet enough information about the area and I am still about to learn the platform for Expert Advisor but I'll try later, after some experience in forex trading.

[zeshan]

i think we are trade on our behalf the robot is not the good traders and who much time u depend on the robot u must work manual it is right that some days difficult but after some days u can trade manual and good then the robot

[hitesh]

bhai mien kabhi prefer nehi keroon ga robot ka , or ager aap robot ka new trader ko bolo gey to definitely woh forex seekhna chhor dien gey or robot hi lega ker baith jayein gey jab k haqeeqat yeh hey manual trading ziaada behter hoti hey robot trading sey kunki robot aap ka account ager urana chahien to 1 ghantay mien bhi ura sektay hien

[deep]

A robot or a EA can not react to news update and perform right trade in right direction , so it is better to trade manually and also EA can not trade in uncertain markets so it is better to trade manually based on your analysis.

[deep]

EA operates in one way and that is the way it has been programmed to operate. Most of the EA's can not trade in uncertain markets and trade on news updates so manual trading is much better.

[brutu]

since the first in a long time I had a lot to test the ea and the result is always falling, since then I do not believe in such thing as a robot and just horrible to see such a large drawdown, I prefer the safe with a manual trading system

[didikebenaran]

since the first in a long time I had a lot to test the ea and the result is always falling, since then I do not believe in such thing as a robot and just horrible to see such a large drawdown, I prefer the safe with a manual trading system

so far I have not used the EA to trade me because I feel I am more comfortable to use a manual trade in my trade and I can feel better in the trade

[zahidrock]

so far I have not used the EA to trade me because I feel I am more comfortable to use a manual trade in my trade and I can feel better in the trade

Manually trading is best then EA trade. I think nobody fell comfortable with EA because EA can't give consistent profit. And this market are dynamic so EA can't face all situation. So it is better trade with manually and avoid EA on this market.

[spread]

Do you like to use EA (robot) or manual trading?
Some traders like to use manual trading and some traders like to use EA in trading. What is your opinion about these condition? Do you like to trade with manual trading or using EA and why do you like to use one of them? Share your opinion and experienes here...
I do not like using EA as they often do not bring good results, I only trade EA with a demo account because I do not believe in it ."Manual trading" which is always good to use the good trader ( use the experience and analysis )

[richardpower324]

My recommandation is to trade mannually coz the robot is made of our idea but not by the Gods idea...So there may be more wrong in this creation .....So f u trade by ourself u can be most gainer to be good in forex trade business

[eoneadit]

That depend on how good the robot is. I would like to have a robot that can simulate trading like human do, without martingale, can adapt in the sideways market or the trending market. Oh no, there is no such robot can do both. Well, so back again, just manual trade is way way much better.

[hamadmuneer]

main to hamasha manual trading ko he prefer karta hoo n kion ke manual trading main hum ziada profit kama sakty hian aor EA main ager kuch mil be jay to thora sa warna bilkul be nahi

[puri]

Right ea are basically trade with they programmed and when news comes ea can get you huge loss and this disadvantage makes ea not better than manually trading in forex.

[ahmad]

automatic trading is when you employ a robot for your trading and you set parameters for it to sell or buy,they are good as there is no emotions in there decisions.but the disadvantage is that they are profitable during one market condition but lose perfectly when conditions change.eg range to trending markets plus they dont have factors like news to look out for

[zytuy11]

i am a newbie and i am developing my own skills in the trading,, ow a day i dnt very much trust on the robot trading and yes robots can also make mistakes, i depend on my own skills

[Rabon]

by manually trade one can gain easily.

[silenteyes]

Manual trading is always better in long run as robot will fail after some time. The cost of purchasing a robot is also high and it is not suitable for newbies. Moreover, robot or EA will mask your abilities to become a good trader.

[bdays]

You are right as we must before entering any trade we must to put to ourselves some rules and apply it this rules will make us not greed as if we achieve our daily target we will stop saying i want more and more.

[masudraj]

I tried all the ways of trading manual or automatic, however if somebody very needs to win he used the manual methodology as a result of it's you and you made the decision that you just understand all right why you purchase or sell back.

[bdboy]

I hate EA. One should never use it. Manual trade is better than a EA. a EA kills your knowledge and make lazy. U can analyse the market by study and read the news. EA not the perfect way of trading. It gives u some profit some time. But it also make a loss also. so be aware about it and also check EA in demo account first.

[joru]

You won't be able to learn forex trading if you are using EA or robot for your trading and then these EA and robots cannot be trusted fully. They often work for some time under certain conditions and then they start to make loss in your trading.

[joru]

One reason is that you stated and the other is that you gain experience only when you trade by yourself. If you use EA or robots for your trading then you will no gain any kind of experience to yourself.

[intel580]

very true friend, for my particular trading in forex and new players, better use manual trading and learn technical and fundamental, because I think trading robot only for experienced traders, they said trading robot also requires a certain time

[bassem15]

it depends on the trader i traded many times before with ea robots they made me good profit at first then they made big loss but i think the problem is from me because this ea robots need an experienced trader to direct them and to put good strategy on them so it's not bad like many people say it can be profitable if we use them in the correct way but now i manual trading because i am not an expert to use ea robots

[zahidrock]

You won't be able to learn forex trading if you are using EA or robot for your trading and then these EA and robots cannot be trusted fully. They often work for some time under certain conditions and then they start to make loss in your trading.

Yes you are right. Nobody can't learn more about forex if he use any robot on trading. And robot are not trusted because they can't give your 100% correct information about this market. If you use manually then you can easily modify your strategy which can give you consistent profit.

[intel580]

yes i agree with you to search for Shark EA or to search for megatroid, they are popular EAs that many traders are using in forex trading. But it is not easy to trade with these robots all the time, it has disadvantages also.

[sabuz]

if u a good analyser not just good very good u can use EA robot. another u use your manual trading.

[pkdoo7]

main manual trader hoon aur robots ka istemal nahin karta
robo trades risky hai aur kabhi kabhi usmain bahut losses ka samna karna padta hai
jo hum nahin rok pate .

[Ksal33m]

main nay robot trading use nahi ki hay abhi tak aur naa main iss main interested hoon aaindaa any waley dinoo main muj ko manual trading hii samaj atai hay aur uss main hee main relax feel karta hoon meray dost ney aik ea robot use kia taa apney account main likin woh srif eur/jpy per hee kaam karta taa uss ney muj ko b bola kay use karo likin main kuch khass satisfy nahi howa uss say. muj ko manual trading he achi lagti hay.

[shamtek]

i think manual trading is better than auto trading because auto trading mostly doing trade on average market movement witch is mostly wrong but in manual trade you can trade after study of market trend, forecast analysis report so manual trading is best according to me

[v jay]

i do not trust mechanical things because they fail without permissions. If I do the analysis, I will find out perhaps before it is late that I made a mistake but if robot did for me, I may put much confidence on it and so loose