Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

[monir.bd]

I think brokers can not know when market positions goes up and when it goes down because there is no system to know that for a broker, i think.

[sayinifx]

Forex me jo broker hoti hai unko bhi market ke baar me utna hi pata hota hao jitna ki ek trader ko hota hai kyunki forex market ke movement ko samjhni asana hi hoti hai aur forex broker ke pass bhi koi news ke jada jankari nahi hoti hai.

[fxind]

My friend no one can control the forex trading it is tough to assume that what the market behaviour would be by any one. so I think it is not possible to know the ups and downs of the market by any body. So we have to understand the trend of the market and need to trade accordingly.

[FAHEEM66]

Broker news share karty han and different analysis karty han so wo janty han k maket ki fluctance kis traf ha or kya condition ho gi incoming trade main so bot say so mary hasab say broker market ki movement say wakaf hoty han or wo bater jaty han but market bank and investor ki investment say chlti ha

[david]

nahe mere khiyal main to bhi ye nahi janta ha sirf andaza he laga saktey hane k ab values up houn gi ya down lekin bilkul sahi koi bhi nahi bata sakta ha ager kisi ko pata hota to woh sab se ziyada he ameer hota forex trading main ha aisa karna chahiye

[sheikhadeel]

koi shaks nh jan skta ka position ab up ho ge ya down agr aisa hota to kbhe kisi ko loss na hota ya sb qismat ki baty ha har trading mai profit or loss hota ha.en chezo sa darna nh chaheya trading mai kbhe zada position high ho jate ha kbhe kam.

[fxkas]

brokers has no ability to control the market. though they are trade on stock, commodities or forex market, they'll following big players who play with bigger more capital. has chance to make profit when trade according to the trend, or major pressure of order. while lack chance to make profit if we are trade against the trend or pressure.

[attamuhammad]

yes, my dear, brother, jab position up ya down hoti hai to brokers ki nazar bhi us pa hoti hai. balkay brokers hamaray accounts per trading ki her nakalo hamal per nazar rakhtay hain. aur hamay watch kertay hain.

[shakoor]

dear it is not the business of the broker that he know about the position ,they just follow our instruction if we will give the instruction to buy ,then it will buy and charge the commission and place our order it is really the simple thing

[arelonso2015]

No., broker also like us. They are trader too. The future investment is predicted by an expert from their own expert. But they can monitor which their client do a fraud within their trading.