Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

[pentkor]

I do not think so they could know when the positions goes up or when the positions go down, it is totally impossible because no one can control the Forex trading market, they can just assume that with good analyst while trading in the market.

that's right, the movement of the market is influenced by transactions that enter the market, so that no one can know where prices will move, as market participants was very big around the world, so the broker will not know where prices will move, not even that could affect price movements, so I think the forex market is a market that is fair.

[vexedebe]

If they should know what is essence of forex trading, like saying that a broker in stock exchange is able to know the direction of stock hundred percent all the time. If they should know the too can trade with other to make money.but the main issue that no body know for certainty the direction of the market. that is fund of forex trading

[Bigboss]

Mery hisab se tu unhy pata nai hota ha kiu ke ye market me chalny wali news se hota ha ke market kaisy move kary gy is liya unhy be shayad pata na ho market me jab be news aty ha tu ye us hisab se up or down move karty ha

[ASHOK]

no, broker ko market ke bare me knowledge ho bhi skti hai or nhi bhi mjhe to nhi lagta hai agr hota to broker apne pasie bhi market me lagta per wo to broker se hi profit le rha hai, mjhe to lagta hai ki jo news hoti hai unki wjh se hi market up down hoti hai to jo meeting me faisla liya jata hai unko pta hota hai.

[sayinifx]

Market me price up aur down hota hai yeh broker ko pata nahi hota hai market ke movement ke baare me kuch bhi nahi pata hota hai lekin broker ko apne trader ke trade ke baare me pata hota hai broker ke pass jitna jada trader hoga utna jada profit hota hai.

[kimo586]

News and events are big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others. Brokers, banks, pro traders all follow
the market will move. it all happens according to the buyers and sellers and trades

---------- Post added at 11:56 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:07 AM ----------

News and events are big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others. Brokers, banks, pro traders all follow
trading and no they are not gods to predict the future market movements

[Medo.Forex]

I do not think so they could know when the positions goes up or when the positions go down, it is totally impossible because no one can control the Forex trading market, they can just assume that with good analyst while trading in the market.

[fanforex111]

No dear forex banks aur business econimical condition pe run kerta hai price ki movement bhi issi waja se hoti hai brokers ko bhi future ka pata nahi hota qu ke next kiya hoga koi nahi bata sakta just experience aur strategy aur indicators ke base pe trading ki jati hai jo 80% tak confirm hoti hai ,,

[waqaryounus]

News and events are big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others. it all happens according to the buyers and sellers and trades

[a_for_apple]

I think even though the broker will not understand 100% market movements, in fact many brokers who went bankrupt when the phenomenon earlier this year UCHF
there are some brokers who went bankrupt because of this, which means they also can not see the price movement very well. broker is actually only a distributor of our entry into the global market