Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

[sangar]

Although it is not know for sure but we can analyze that expect to follow currency movements, it is better we always learn and train the instinct of our analysis. It is important in our trade. and principle number in forex market is no one can predict where price movements... broker also can't to predict price movements... but it is depends from type of broker... if broker type is dealer, that is means that broker make price movements by itself... and this condition make trader will very hard to get profit...

[xiaomi]

they are like us preparing for analysis if they ney they will only trade. As far as i know broker have plen of trader or managers handling clients they are the same as us, we just divided my the measurement of experience and knowledge. If they give advice from there financial analyst then good but ther analyst same as us but with higher level only. and I agree with you can not control anyone else's business, and no one will ever know when the price will go up and when prices are going down for sure all the analyzes in this business just to get them to maximize trade themselves in this trade by analysis

[sachit]

I dont think they can know in advance which way the prices shall move, but they sure have upper hand as by the data of their clients they can get some idea about traders sentiments e.g. their pending orders stop and target. I think broker will never know the market's movement. they only distribute our funds. but, there are many types of forex broker. There are indeed deliver our capital into the forex market, there is also acting as a dealers. These brokers that we need to beware. because we are going against the broker. the more we lose, then the broker is getting profits.

मुझे लगता है कि एक ब्रोकर को एक घंटे के बाद के आंदोलन का पता नहीं चलेगा, लेकिन मुझे यकीन है कि ब्रोकर का एक बार बहुत अच्छा विश्लेषण है, और बहुत अच्छी सटीकता है, लेकिन यह भी 100% गारंटी नहीं देता है कि ब्रोकर हमेशा एक लाभ है हर दिन। यह मुझे लगता है, कृपया वरिष्ठ व्यापारी से सलाह लें।
और वे बाजार में आने वाली बड़ी खबर से सिर्फ भविष्यवाणी कर रहे हैं ... यहां तक कि, अगर वे बाजार की आवाजाही जानते हैं..तो, उन्हें ब्रोकर खोलने की कोई जरूरत नहीं है, सिर्फ हाय हाय पाव लागा कर के काफ़ी काम करते हैं.. किसी ने मुझे बताया कि आंदोलन ने दिखाया mt4 प्लेटफॉर्म को किसी व्यक्ति द्वारा प्रबंधित किया जाता है

[vedzfx]

I don't think any broker knows whether prices will move up or down. Because it is not their authority to control prices on the forex market. But you should know, and this has never been discussed by many people, the prices that occur in the forex market, everything works because of the system. All movements that occur normally within 5 x 24 hours are due, by the system.
And if there is a drastic or volatile movement in the market, or at the time of high news, it is the intervention of the central bank over the market.
So I am very confident about this, because of my deepening of the forex market with my knowledge regarding the global conspiracy by global elites.

[zahid2016]

I dont think they can know in advance which way the prices shall move, but they sure have upper hand as by the data of their clients they can get some idea about traders sentiments e.g. their pending orders stop and target. I think broker will never know the market's movement. they only distribute our funds. but, there are many types of forex broker. There are indeed deliver our capital into the forex market, there is also acting as a dealers. These brokers that we need to beware. because we are going against the broker. the more we lose, then the broker is getting profits.

[quraf]

I think a broker will not know the movement of an hour later, but I'm sure the broker has a very good analysis once, and have a very good accuracy, but it also does not guarantee 100% that a broker is always a profit every day. It seems to me, please advise from senior trader.
and they are just predict from big news came into market... Even, if they know movement of market..then, they no need to open broker just apne hi paise laga karke kaafi kama lete..par somebody told me that movement shown over mt4 platform is managed by some person

[koplok]

i agree with yogesh here a very good observation hats off to you yogesh, brokers earn money regardless of whether someone earns or looses money trading and no they are not gods to predict the future market movements. they won't be forex broker business. instead they will use all their capital for trading where they can make tons of money. and that's nice quesition but i also don't know about that even i don't know that where forex operate from .. but i can share general experience that if broker has some experience expert people they could know that where market will go .. up or down .. but its not confirm we will need to research about that ..

[sachit]

Forex trading business ek aisa business hai jo kikisi ke control mein nahi hai aur koi bhi ye nahi bata sakta hai ki agla step kya hone wala hai saari cheezen knowledge aur experience ke aadhar par kiya jata hai aur technical indicators ko read karke analysis kar ke predict kiya jata hai but market predictions ko follow karega aisa nahi hai hamein bas ek chance lena hai aur jyadatar samay indicators sahi hote hain.

हर कोई बाजार को ऊपर और नीचे जानता है, अगर हम बाजार का पूरी तरह से विश्लेषण और भविष्यवाणी करते हैं। विदेशी मुद्रा पर अच्छे ज्ञान और ट्रेडिंग में अनुभव के कारण यह पूर्णता आएगी। दलाल पूरी तरह से प्रतिभाशाली हैं, यही कारण है कि वे विदेशी मुद्रा कंपनियों को खोलेंगे। इसलिए, वे बाजार की प्रवृत्ति को जानते हैं। लेकिन ब्रोकर से जानकारी प्राप्त करने का प्रयास सही नहीं है। अपने मस्तिष्क का पालन करें।

[yumna]

g bhai g ap ki bat thq ha par bhai g m ap ko yehi kahun ga k ap is m full time kam karo gay demo m to ap ko indi ketar say ap ko markit jab move hoti ha to ap ko indiktr say bhai ap ko pata chal jay ga or is say ap ko los honay k bi bohat hi kam chans han is liye bhai g m ap ko yehi khanun ga k ap chat ko dehk kar hi tarding kiya karo phr hi bhai g ap kam yab ho sakty ho.

[wahaji]

Forex trading business ek aisa business hai jo kikisi ke control mein nahi hai aur koi bhi ye nahi bata sakta hai ki agla step kya hone wala hai saari cheezen knowledge aur experience ke aadhar par kiya jata hai aur technical indicators ko read karke analysis kar ke predict kiya jata hai but market predictions ko follow karega aisa nahi hai hamein bas ek chance lena hai aur jyadatar samay indicators sahi hote hain.