Technical Analysis ya Fundamental Analysis par trading?

[cumil]

I was like-minded with you that we will not know where markets respond after news was released, and indeed the data are hard to observe separately at much better and will wait until the extent of the impact of the news

yes, that's the case, where prices will move we don't know, I had a trauma at the time the news was Realease, I'm trading with a relaxed and I think not considered that the effects of the NFP news could kill my account, and turns in an instant I lost my money and all mySL was touched , this is a bad experience, and I will never repeat again

[anubhavsingh]

in the past, i used to be a technical trader, but time after time, i followed fundamental more, i fount its easier to learn fundamental since we dont have too look many indicator in the screen, and market movement is dominantly from fundamental news

fundamenatls to study karna kafi easy hota hai techncial ke comparison me
fundamenatkl news market ko bahut zada affect kartio hai..
techncial studies zadatar fudnamenatls ke saamne bekar ho jati hai

[bestlooser]

for me it is all about technical analysis and I have my own way of these technical analysis and it works and I just do not follow any kind of news too. I just believe that we can be stronger by depositing more and more money into our trading account. more money we have more power we have and we can play more safely without taking much of risk.

[cumil]

and CPI, those 3 are killer(NFP is the main killer since it will make a pair jump of fall easily), to understand those news we have to put our self as the one who affected directly by it, like when NFP news out, we have to put our self as american people

if there is news NFP, CPI and PMI I will wait until stopped, because thats news all my analysis technical does not work, thats news for me is news has a high impact
for NFP range of price movements :100-150
for CPI and PMI range of price movements 50-80

[SG Trader]

Not all news has a long-term impact because you have some news that long-term and there were not a lot but can make the transfer to long-term trends such as the NFP

yeah, NFP have a short term impact, like today you can see your MT4 chart. besides NFP i think Halifax HPI, Services PMI news in gbp pairs have a same impact too.
maybe news has a long term impact happen because circumstances in a country, such crisis in europe recently

[anubhavsingh]

that is right, both of analysis is very important. if we can combine both analysis i think we will have best strategy.

jis trader ne fundamenatl aur techncial studies ko combine karke trade kiya, wo hamesha market ko jeet ke niklega
forex market techncia laur fundamenatl studies pe hi depend rehta hai

[fravash]

yeah I agree with you because there is some news that has an adverse impact if it is bad news such as interest rates, the NFP and the like, and how we understand the news was not to get caught up in trade

and CPI, those 3 are killer(NFP is the main killer since it will make a pair jump of fall easily), to understand those news we have to put our self as the one who affected directly by it, like when NFP news out, we have to put our self as american people

[vicky]

Not all news has a long-term impact because you have some news that long-term and there were not a lot but can make the transfer to long-term trends such as the NFP

its true not all the news have great impact which we can see in economic calender of high impact and low impact but before i see high impact news have no doubt big impact on market but sometime low impact news also play great rule and for this if we trade with news then we need always careful.

[fravash]

maybe my lack of patience waiting for the effects of news in the long run ... because I always see the chart every day to cover daily position ...

its almost invisible brother, you perhaps notice it on your chart, but if you put a pin on every time huge impact news out then you will realize that news have many impact to the pair on the long run

[fravash]

yeah that's really the style of a merchant or a fundamentalist in making trade at the time the news will be released they will wait for the news come out and see how the market response

you re correct brother

fundamental news is more difficult to predict long-term ...
I prefer to use technical analysis ...
but if there is news I choose not to trade ...

i think the opposite, most of the longer term trend are created from cumulative of news impact, the example were 2008 recession when the market fall because of many bad news about credit default