Two sets of opinions based on the same gathered data, and neither contradicting the other's data. A weaker person would develop a nervous twitch from this confusion. Particularly when you consider the obvious – they're both right! So, does it come down to a coin toss?
No. The first mistake a Forex trader can make is to have a dead-set opinion and then search online for opinions supporting his pre-conceived notions. If anyone looks long enough and hard enough, they're going to find someone somewhere to agree with him. Taking that into account, the question still remains: Who do you listen to?