Printable View
I love to trade by hand because I'm a beginner and my pal have explained which i haven't to consider EA till I learn about foreign exchange buying and selling. I'm buying and selling inside a demo account and i believe manual buying and selling is preferable to EA because in manual buying and selling we are able to decide at our very own.
i prefer using expert advisor than trading manual. it help me to trade more discipline, beside that i don't need to be 24 hours in front of computer. there are many important things to do beside trading.
Yes forex trading is all about gaining. how you trader it dont mater if you get profit it is very think for a trader. So if you use robot an gain then good.
I also trade both but i like manually trading.
Good suggestion for newbie I also think learn first about forex then you should think other way. If you really trade forex then you need to learn and then learn about robot then you can use robot it will help you to how robot works.
i do not like using ea..it is too dangerous..market is very volatiile and it can unpredictable..but some ea may be profitable but actually,the profitable ae is not too sale..i heard in one forum that the most profitable ea..it is calling angeliic ea..and now,some broker banned the account who use that ea...how a cheat broker..
The idea of using robots to trade forex is a great one for me. But i would only consider to trade forex trading markets only with manual since i have never found an EA or robot that is making the best of results.
mujhey manual trading ziaada pasand hey ,kunki jo kaam khudi kia jaye us per ziaada satisfaction hoti hey, robot mein ney jitnay dekhay hien,sab mein koi na koi defect zeroor hota hey or woh account urah detay hien
if I prefer to use both, because it has the advantages of each. Using the EA that I sometimes when I'm resting, or are there other concerns. I then use the manual even if only occasionally, because it is still a bit traumatized by yesterday had been lost. So for now I am more likely to use forex trading EA for this,,
using a trading robot is a bad experience for me ..
my trading account has a margin call last month for using a trading robot ..
I currently prefer to perform manual trading, and seek to comply with the rules of trading and money management
as a beginner in this business I prefer to trade with the manual. because the trading manual will enhance our ability to analyze. if we use expert advisors, we can not learn many ways to analyze because it's all done by the expert advisor.Quote:
Originally Posted by wolfkamikaz
but maybe if I was an expert in manual trading, I will make my own expert advisor. made under the system that I use in manual trading
yes my brother hume manual hi karna chahiye manual se humari kafi practice hoti hai jis se hum apni kami mein sudhar la sakte EA to maine kabhi kiya hi nahi ki ye hota kaise hai main isko pasand hi nahi karta hoon jo expeience apne hath mein hoga wo hamesha kaam ayegaQuote:
Originally Posted by hpanoo
I like to trade manually, with all the human involvement. EA trading or auto trading is not of my liking. Its just tasteless excercise to trade in auto trading.
Quote:
Originally Posted by wolfkamikaz
i use a trailing stop ea while trading, even though all my trades are manually opened i close them with the ea because this helps me close a trade faster, it is just 1 click instead of 3 to 4 clicks to close a trade
I like to trade manually because still I have not experienced the trading with EA. In my opinion a trader should first learn all about forex trading and when he learned A_Z about forex then he should try the EA trading. I don't suggest a beginner to start trading with EA.
I prefer to trade manually instead of using a robot trading. I think that by trading manually will make me more able to control my trading position and will make me continue to learn to make the trading signal and analysis of market movement...
EA/robots ka sabse bada nuksan yahi hota hai ki wo achanak se aayi hui news ke hsiab se react nahi kar pate jabki agar aap manual trading karte hai to aap kisi bhi fundamental ke hisab se apni trading aur strategy change kar sakte hai. forex me manual trading hi prefer kari jati hai
nahi g main to sahi baat ha k robot k haq main bilkul bhi nahi houn maoin to sirf or sirf manual trading pasand karta houn or es ko he use karta houn manual trading sab se bast strategy ha or es main loss bahot kam hota haQuote:
Originally Posted by wolfkamikaz
I didnt like EA too much,sounds that i didnt trust my self to trade my money,so i didnt use even for trying that programs,
i had see many EA are didnt makes any changed to our money,only loss
You won't be able to learn forex trading if you are using EA or robot for your trading and then these EA and robots cannot be trusted fully. They often work for some time under certain conditions and then they start to make loss in your trading.
One reason is that you stated and the other is that you gain experience only when you trade by yourself. If you use EA or robots for your trading then you will no gain any kind of experience to yourself.
Hmm i agree!
We cannot give our account to someone else to trade, as we shall be incertain what the other will do with our account and it will keep us unrested, and we are happy by trading our own because in case of mistakes we learn from them. Then how can we give our account to a program that we know is going to work on pre-feeded instructions.
No - i dont think performance of EA can be even near to an experienced forex trader, if am afraid that they act on mechanically on predefined instructions and so cannot take right decisions as per market requriements. For e.g. if i trade in gold and see panic in silver i can be alert instantly and take safety measure as that will affect gold sentiments also, but i dont think a robo will do that.
i usually trade manually. it seems ok for me. on the other hand, EA/robot sometimes cant pick the real world economic condition and then a loose our money. it is better to trade manually.happy trading
There are many traders who do not like the EA just because of the reason that they do not know how to use the EA and other most important thing is that they do not have the money to use its services.
I don't think so that if a person is not good in manual trading then he can be good in EA or robot trading. Robot trading requires good experience, only expert traders can make the profit in robot trading, so try to be successful in manual trading.
You do not need experience to trade with EA. Just buy a robot and install it but only install first on a demo account. You can use EA on demo account and still be learning to trade by yourself at the same time.
Of course EA will not be able to respond to any rise or fall that will come due to news just because EA does not have any intelligence, EA has to do everything according to programming. Manual trading is much better from EA because we can decide much better at the time of news.
I am more interested in trading manually, because there is a challenge when we are trading manually. in addition, only trading robot based on technical analysis, while 85% driven by market fundamentals. some people say they often experience a margin call when they use the robot
I actually prefer to use the robot for trading but that was then, now I prefer to trade manually. Trading using a robot is good because it is not affected by emotional factors, but also a new robot will stop trading when we've had a MC account. :(
Good suggestion for newbie I also think learn first about forex then you should think other way. If you really trade forex then you need to learn and then learn about robot then you can use robot it will help you to how robot works.
main manual trading karta houn or robot k nisbat es ko he prfer karoun ga per wese abb mainne auto trading karna bhi shura kiya ha par main phr bhi kisi ea ko use nahi karoun ga kioun k mugh ko pata ha k ea se trade karna kafi risk ha or main forex main kaam he risk leta hounQuote:
Originally Posted by wolfkamikaz
I do not know why there is many traders that do not like to trade with expert adviors for me i think they are best than manual trading also they are both the same as if pro trader that have profitable manual strategy then he can code it to be expert adisors and code it with the all rules of his strategy then t will be better than manual strategy as this will take all chances as it works 24 hours and trad with no emotions.
I prefer trading manually, by what I can see what's happening before my eyes, but trading with robots is a bad deal, given the robots lose their dice déconéxion the servers, so I do thee not recommend using these methods.Quote:
Originally Posted by mayengbam
you are right my brother, the best is the trading manual trading, by using this method that you can see the change in market 24/24 hours, that sometimes when using robots in the market changes its direction instantaneously, and robots do not understand it well, and we will lose our capital, so it's better to go for manual trading.
I like using EA because even I'm away from my computer, the robot still trades for me.
And also emotion is eliminated so i don't worry much.
I prefer manual trading , because it is safer and better in terms of learning and skills development , can earn a good experience and techniques of manual trading , and this is what it takes to work at Forex
ham manual trading se loss ko cover kar sakte hai. lekin EA bi es traha work karta hai ki wo bi apne loss ko cover kar le.
mere khyal se EA loss main trading close nahi karta hai.
EA trading main profit hone ke baad hi trading close hoti hai.
apne manual karne se apne ko apni galti ka pata chalta hai aur apni manual mein jo bhi kami hoti hai wo oobher kar bahar aati hai fir hume manual se kuch na kuch sikhne ko milta hi rahta hai so manual hume karna chahiye..
yes manual humara experience hota hai jo humare pass hamesha rahta hai manual hi best strategy main kabhi other signal par believe nahi karta kyun ki other signal jaydatar false hote hai aur ho hunar humare haath mein hoga us se hum jo marzi kar sakte hai kabhi kisi aur ka wait nahi karna padega.
There are many traders that like to trade manually as they like it to trade manually.Expert advisory can give you good returns but its not better if news has come suddenly.