Printable View
In my opinion, the principle of Money Management is not just limited to a trading system. But also how one can survive and do not trouble financially. Auto Trade (EA) I think is also a solution for it. Auto Trade Of course the true and proven and profitable. So, there are funds that we direct trading manually and we also trade in Auto.
You are right but also if the robot trading system or the expert adivors is coded well with all the rules of the manual profitable strategy it will be more profitable than manual and less risky also as there is no greedy and it will not breaking the rules of the strategy because it wants to earn more like we do also it will trade 24 hours a day so it will take all chances that we will not take them all.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark
You are right also if you have scalping strategy and you trade with it manually you will need to open and close trades so fast and when you do that manually you will find that opining or closing orders takes about 3 seconds while if the expert advisor do that take only 1 second so it is better to convert our manual strategy to be coded to be expert advisor.Quote:
Originally Posted by lionstar
Autotrading is nothing but a total waste of money.If you downloaou some auto trader the also you are losing something cause you will not earn anything by these auto traders but you have to keep open your pcs to trade by these autotraders.
ibelieve it but i do not want it, because i will get nothing with it, no experiences then i will and always depend to them
trading manual is better and make me mature in this business, i can develop and fix my mistakes and problem by myself or just share with each others and this is very nice for me
and i beieve that i can become a good trader and achieve my goals with my hand and mind
Auto trading? a step of progress made in terms of trading leh traders and programmers that brings together the theory of trading and technology to make something that's easy to do .... something really good ....
we should be trading auto conditioning as a way to make it easier to execute at any or only limited help onlyQuote:
Originally Posted by mhchomsi
because if we rely on the same auto trading course we can not believe that we make with less analysis
EA could have used, but before using it should several trials. Sometimes we hear there are good and profitable EA, but in my opinion, we do not immediately believe it. Because maybe EA's first profitable, but it may be now that EA is not profitable.
I think ea can be profitable in certain market conditions, but can be detrimental in other market conditions.
Therefore, I believe ea can be very profitable if we could know the exact time to use it.
and ea can not run 24 hours because I think it is very dangerous
An interesting opinion. Perhaps it is the use of EA have given time, meaning there is 24 hours. I have heard, many traders lose money because he/she uses the EA without interruption for days. At first it was profitable, but ultimately also MC ....
I do not seem too confident with it. I've tried many times with a variety of automated trading even stated that this is the best robot. in fact, precisely what happens is I find my equity is lost without trace. everything is changed to zero even at early times all seemed successful.Quote:
Originally Posted by adil.iub
No never because i think k auto trade sa bhtr ha k insan khud trade kre aur mere khyal sa jo trading manual hoti ha woh zeydha achi hoti ha banisbat auto trading k auto trading ko jo bataya geya ho wohi krti ha aur jab k manual trading ma hm apne damagh sa b kam le lete han.Quote:
Originally Posted by adil.iub
me hamehsa manual trading hi karta hon aur mujhe lagta hai ki trading karne ka yahi sabse acha tarika hota hai
manual trading se trader jo kuch bhi sekehta haoi wo aage chal ke uske forex career ke liye bahut faydemand hota hai..isliye har trader ko manual traduing ke liye hi bola jata hai
i am a scalper but sometimes i do long term too but for my trading i do not want let the robot work for me, i prefer to use manual trading and it is better make me comfortable and also i can become a mature trader with some good knowledge then i never depend to the others thing..
if the trader use EAs as their robot then they have to updates it time by time and here than to updated the robot, it is better to update our skill
I am not yet too interested in auto trading, it is the new trend in forex currency trading business. I still not know its results and reliability so i would prefer to make sure that i skip it and depend on manual trading business.
I can not bealive in auto trade because which indicator work to auto trade i set it manually than trade. I used a robot the name of Dolly but it give make a trade so i can not agree an auto trade.Quote:
Originally Posted by adil.iub
i'm also more interested in trading manually. previously i'm the kind of trader that loves to trade using expert advisor. i even create my expert advisor/robot. some were huge success but later on it bring me disaster. so finally i'm back again with manual trading, where everything controlled by me only.Quote:
Originally Posted by my-forex
I believe in the past with auto trading, forex robot I've tried and the resulting profit can be consistent, but it's only a few weeks only, after a month of forex robot that I use to show oddities, almost all of my position and eventually loss of margin call. since then I never again trust the automated trading. Automatic trading is good at first, but after a few months usually will decrease the performance of the robot, I would not recommend to use a trading robot that you do not understand.
Auto trade is nice think for a trader on forex market. I like it very much but not enough then manual trading. Manually trading is the best way to earn money from forex market. A lot of trader offer this auto trading. It is not safe but if a trader knows about terminal programming he can use it properly. because best of trader create robot trader. i like this type of trading system. But I will be use it when I understand terminal programming.
yes these type of many system are available in forex market ,lekin mere khyal me ye theek nahi ,ku k wo hme 100% profit me to rkh nahi skte phr in auto trading systems ka kia faida,or aksr auto trading systems ma ne daikhe ha k wo km pips ka proft gain kra daite ha lekin jb loss hota ha to ziada pips ka,:)))
jis se hm overall loss me chle jate ha,so auto trading is not good idea:(
no, I never even trust my money with the use of automated trading is often called a forex robot. because this is purely business and trade can not be represented on a device that knows only the language of mathematics without any element of instinct and emotion.
carefully using a robot / ea if you do not know enough about the specifics must not use it, although we backtest not work like in the demo, ea use to make it easier for me just open it, until now I still manual trading
main forex trading main koi ek saal se houn par main ne kabhi bhi auto trade nahi kiya tha par ab main soch raha houn k main bhi auto trade karoun kioun k mere pass itna time nahi hota ha na s liye main to ab auto trading ka soch raha hounQuote:
Originally Posted by adil.iub
I think auto trading se manual trading ziada effective hogi because with auto trading we can earn only a limited and fixed profit but with manual trading we can enhance our profit limit to maximum level with our hard work. So I always will speak and write against auto trading.
I do not quite understand what you mean about the auto trade. if you mean by trading forex auto trade is with the use of EA or robot, it must be analyzed first. EA can not all go according to what we expect, it became safer to test the EA on demo account first before we use the EA on real account.Quote:
Originally Posted by adil.iub
EA should do this test should use a demo account so that we can see the capacity and strength of this EA for a few months and it will be suitable we use in a real account so that way there is no concern of ours to leave the EA is setting our own work in accordanceQuote:
Originally Posted by Sri Hartono
Trading automatic it has several advantages :
1 . Not too wasting time . You simply taking a little time the internet in weekly to seek and analyzes a system of trading , professional traders which nice according to you and wiil you apply in trading automatic you .
2 . Not requiring knowledge analysis forex ( technical & amp ; the fundamental ) , because you analysis is performance of system / / traders individuals . Nevertheless knowledge common about forex and analysis stay important . You should stay symbolical knowledge this at leisure you . :yahoo:
Some people say that auto trade is really good for forex trader. But i dont believe that it is really important. In auto trade, if you loss your money, then you will think that it is not your fault and this done by the auto trade system. But in manual trade, all the profits-losses is up-to you and you cannot blame to others. I always i prefer manual trading rather than auto trade.
In my opinion, Auto Trade is a quick way to do Trading. The basis of the Auto Trader Trade made by using technical analysis, so minimize the subjectivity factor in trading. I believe that the Auto Trade can work well. But of course we have to enter Stop Money Management Lost or factor. Selection of an Auto Trade used to be prudent, in accordance with our knowledge and skills as well. If not then the Auto Trade be not well controlled. An Auto Trade is also usually only suitable for certain pairs, not all pairs.
Auto trade is the principal thing which is popular in fx currency exchange trading. I FX broker offers it now however, i dot really like the idea given that it may well not be particularly 100% safe and secure to utilize. It would additionally create me personally to stop reading fx and additionally depend on their trades.
l think auto trading is different than PAMM or COPY TRADE system which instaforex is offering.with these systems you will attach your account to another trader and you account will copy his trades without your intervention.and you will pay commission if he will profit.so instaforex will be middleman here.but auto-trading is using EA for trading .it means trading with robots.
Dear Seniors
Please suggest a suitable Auto trade for me as i am fresh in forex trading and don't mush about trading softwares.
i believe in automated trading system but does not like to trade personally. forex market is continuously changeable. so we need to keep eagle eye on the market situation. other to do automated trading require more equity which i do not have now.
expert advisor or robots are meant to be use by professinals only, so if you're still very newbies, it's very recommended if you start the manual way first. understand the basics and try to develop your own simple strategies. after you manage it then you can think about using expert advisor.Quote:
Originally Posted by srasool
in my view auto trading is not good.
we can not learn nothing in auto trading. in auto trading there is no manual trading technic EA and robot trade based only their trading concepts.
may be we got loss when news is too strong and we have less margin.
yes i do, provided you know how the market moves in different situation and you are able to tweak the robot or EA to suit it. Its another advantage is the total elimination of emotions in trading because the robot trades as per the set of rules provided with it
I think auto trader is a robot that can represent us in taking a position on the open market when we can not do it alone. Thus it is actually very helpful, but for me the best system for trading is a manual system is the best of the best
Yes auto trade is a kind of short form for automatic trading. It means that we would relax and a trading software would take all the trading decisions for us. This is not too good since it does not allow us to learn.Quote:
Originally Posted by mhchomsi
I prefer trading manually, because it involves common sense and instincts of man. all it is clear that the market is driven by humans not machines so the market pattern is the pattern of human desire. for that auto trading is never used by big succes tradersQuote:
Originally Posted by adil.iub
Auto Trade in my opinion is a positive thing, if done by a trader who has matured in the understanding of Forex Trading. Before he runs a program of Auto Trade, he should have considered the conditions or requirements that are different from Auto Trade conditions he has. Money management, especially in terms of durability of capital, and the decision of when to exit. And all that he put on the setting of Auto Trade will he run.