Spread Discrimination For Chinese and Indian Traders

[sura]

It is not a secret anymore that some brokers that offers metatrader 4/5 discriminate spread for Chinese and Indian traders. We all know and understand that something like this should not happen because traders are the same no matter where they reside.

Here's some questions for you:
Why does something like this happen?
What is the real reason behind this act?
Do you have an account with this kind of broker?
Are you thankful that in Instaforex there is no price discrimination?


Let's start a great discussion about this matter...

[DiF0r]

I would say the same for brokers that offer swap free accounts ONLY to Muslim traders. Every trader should be treated the same. So if a Muslim trader can get a swap free account every other trader should have this option too.

[sura]

I think you should never trade with a broker who discriminate against their clients, stay away from this broker

I would say the same for brokers that offer swap free accounts ONLY to Muslim traders. Every trader should be treated the same. So if a Muslim https://secure.instaforex.com/en/open-account.aspx?x=monitoringhttp://www.getforexrebate.com/?id=411226trader can get a swap free account every other trader should have this option too.

[sura]

i just opened a live account with other broker (i don't think it's a good idea to mention the name of the broker here) to see their live price feed and i see that in their small print they mentioned that they don't allow traders from India to open a live account with them.

[nurhidayah]

i just opened a live account with other broker (i don't think it's a good idea to mention the name of the broker here) to see their live price feed and i see that in their small print they mentioned that they don't allow traders from India to open a live account with them.


when there are brokers that we do not allow trading of a particular country, I think the broker is not so attractive to many traders because of state restrictions that they mentioned, that's better for trading with a broker who can receive all countries provided that can connect to the internet I think it is more sense

[ahmedlinkers]

It is not a secret anymore that some brokers that offers metatrader 4/5 discriminate spread for Chinese and Indian traders. We all know and understand that something like this should not happen because traders are the same no matter where they reside.

Here's some questions for you:
Why does something like this happen?
What is the real reason behind this act?
Do you have an account with this kind of broker?
Are you thankful that in Instaforex there is no price discrimination?


Let's start a great discussion about this matter...

I think this happens because of the lesser strict or in some cases absence of laws in this respect in some countries lead to such a situation. Regulation and their proper implementation leads to transparent trading.

[yogesh]

Brokers should treat traders equally and any discrimination not only hurts to traders of some countries but does not help brorkers too. India and chinas are growing economies and there is going to be huge participation in forex from these counries in coming time.

[forexman]

Brokers should treat traders equally and any discrimination not only hurts to traders of some countries but does not help brorkers too. India and chinas are growing economies and there is going to be huge participation in forex from these counries in coming time.

yes india and china is biggest country with huge population in world and there should not be spread discrimination but i think the brokers will do like that as most people are trading from india they might reduce the spread i think

[jab we met]

actually i am thankful to instaforex who remove all problem and treat every trader with same spread and provide same feature to all trader so i think instaforex is the best choice in the forex market

[moonletter]

I do not like all the acts of discrimination. That is not fair and we are having the same degree. Especially if there are brokers who discriminate based on the country in terms of forex trading, I do not like it. Surely we should be grateful to the insta forex very friendly in all respects.:respect:

[andhwrey]

is this are real?thats are really unprofesionall brokers,i will recomended all traders i know to vote bad things about that brokers,we are same as bussiness
activities who are trading with right ways,so brokers must makes same proportions as same as they offered service to us as good brokers

[cozard007]

I don`t think there is discrimination any where, well, i will not argue this much, if you are working with a very good broker, this should never be a problem at all.

[nurhidayah]

Spread Discrimination For Chinese and Indian Traders from the above we see that needs move from lower level to the higher level. therefore to motivate the employees a manager must give more emphasize on lower level needs then on higher level needs.but this hierarchy is not always maintained.

discrimination in terms of spreads in the forex world, I think no because all the traders in the eyes of the same broker, it's just that there may be special rules that make the separation between the trader and the trader india china, but very rarely encountered a problem like this, which is often found that trader from the USA should not be joined with a broker

[phi]

is that true? its the first time I heard about discrimination in forex...

[sura]

Yeah, it could be. Some brokers need different threat for some cuntry with different forex policy. But I think broker also give other compensation for this kind of "discrimination" for their traders on those country, don't you think so?


discrimination in terms of spreads in the forex world, I think no because all the traders in the eyes of the same broker, it's just that there may be special rules that make the separhttps://instaforex.com/?x=indobrokeration between the trader and the trader india china, but very rarely encountered a problem like this, which is often found that trader from the USA should not be joined with a broker

[nurhidayah]

Yeah, it could be. Some brokers need different threat for some cuntry with different forex policy. But I think broker also give other compensation for this kind of "discrimination" for their traders on those country, don't you think so?

discrimination against traders who came from a particular country is carried out by several brokers usually have its own reasons inherent understanding of how to broker any trade process to be used as eligibility for the broker's own trading process that equalizes every stage undertaken with a clear and in accordance with the directions market itself

[darkrider]

If this is true then it is really frustrating about mt4 and the brokers to discriminate among the traders based on region.

[ripon4x]

I have traded with many different brokers so far but I wasn't aware of this ever. If this thing happen intentionally then we should not trade with those brokers and should ask them why is that discrimination..!!! Can anyone name the brokers plz !!

[hichamoiv]

Brokers should also deal with traders and discrimination not only hurt retailers in some countries, but does not help too brorkers. India and china are growing economies and it will be very strong participation in Forex from these counries in time to come.

[hmbelal]

we all know and understand that something like this should not happen bcause traders art the same no matter wherw they eside seres some questions for you

[Borhan107]

Spread descrimination chines and indian are not any matter. The broker offer the muslim broker to open a swap free account. But it account can open all trader. So it is not any descrimination.

[goldenmember]

Yes, I have noticed that many of the asian brokers offer massive spreads. There is no need for this, because many brokers I have seen offer 1-2 pips. Having 3-4 pips is just too much, even with rebate.

[ESSADRY]

India and chinas are growing economies and there is going to be huge participation in forex from these counries in coming time,So if a Muslim trader can get a swap free account every other trader should have this option too.

[gkintl]

I don't think that there is any price discrimination between Chinese and Indian traders. This is the first time I am hearing about such an issue. Do you have any proof of that? If so, pls., post the same here so that we can discuss the same with the concerned broker. Also, swap free accounts for muslims come at a price. You need to pay a hefty monthly charge to get those kind of accounts. In that way misuse of the account is prevented.

[kashifrehman]

Brokers should treat traders equally and any discrimination not only hurts to traders of some countries but does not help brorkers too. India and chinas are growing economies and there is going to be huge participation in forex from these counries in coming time.

They treat equaly but on the basis of account types, When we select swap free account at that time all trader are treated in same manner and also in similar manner in other account we cannot say that a broker treat all the account holders in equal so don't make it serios issue just understand the logic behind.

[jowaljawil]

I would say the same for brokers that offer swap free accounts ONLY to Muslim traders. Every trader should be treated the same. So if a Muslim trader can get a swap free account every other trader should have this option too.

i am moslem i use freeswap account. but i think free swap acount is not discrimination any trader may aplly for it, not only moslem traders

[agitiga]

It is not a secret anymore that some brokers that offers metatrader 4/5 discriminate spread for Chinese and Indian traders. We all know and understand that something like this should not happen because traders are the same no matter where they reside.

Here's some questions for you:
Why does something like this happen?
What is the real reason behind this act?
Do you have an account with this kind of broker?
Are you thankful that in Instaforex there is no price discrimination?


Let's start a great discussion about this matter...

I do not think that this should be a good thing for a broker to do. If any broker does that it is not a good brokerage practice and the traders should avoid it

[sura]

I'm not sure abouyt this but swap free is not for moslem only.
It's just another option from brokers for anyone who don't want to use swap on their account

Sometimes swap is good for trading purpose


I wouldhttp://www.getforexrebate.com/?id=411226 say the same for brokers that offer swap free accounts ONLY to Muslim traders. Every trader should be treated the same. So if a Muslim https://secure.instaforex.com/en/open-account.aspx?x=monitoringtrader can get a swap free account every other trader should have this option too.

[robiul alam]

It is not a secret anymore that some brokers that offers4/5 discriminate spread for Chinese and Indian traders. We all know and understand that something like good friends fast work thank

[raihan8212]

Making this more of a software/platform discussion then. Which is fine, that's basically the gist of what they offer (other than being an IB).

Sounds like a great platform. It's good to have a worthy MT4 alternative what with MetaQuotes so heavily dominating the FX platform space.

Odd that they don't list which US brokers they work with for US retail clients (who unfortunately can't use LMAX). I presume they must work with at least one of the US retail shops. I'm guessing ILQ perhaps.

[anupomks]

It is not a secret anymore that some brokers that offers metatrader 4/5 discriminate spread for Chinese and Indian traders. We all know and understand that something like this should not happen because traders are the same no matter where they reside.

Here's some questions for you:
Why does something like this happen?
What is the real reason behind this act?
Do you have an account with this kind of broker?
Are you thankful that in Instaforex there is no price discrimination?


Let's start a great discussion about this matter...
yes , i think so that the article describes a tool that provides strong repetition of order openings that allows us to maintain a mathematically correct platform to compare the results of different algorithms for trailing stops and for exiting the market. If you are debugging a complex EA that is supposed to independently calculate the time to enter the market, trailing stops, and exiting the market, then it is practically impossible to get a repeatable pattern to be compared to other ones. Imagine a situation where there is a rather long signal for opening an order. Ideally, the order will be opened.

[jefricha]

i dont assume that there's any price discrimination between chinese and indian traders. this is that the 1st time i'm hearing regarding such a difficulty. do you have got any proof of your ? if thus, pls., post the exact here to make sure that we are able to discuss the exact along with the involved broker. conjointly, swap free accounts for muslims return on a price. you have to be compelled to pay a hefty monthly charge to find those more than a little accounts. for the reason that manner misuse as to the account is prevented.

[suhermanto]

I don't think that there is any price discrimination between Chinese and Indian traders. This is the first time I am hearing about such an issue. Do you have any proof of that? If so, pls., post the same here so that we can discuss the same with the concerned broker. Also, swap free accounts for muslims come at a price. You need to pay a hefty monthly charge to get those kind of accounts. In that way misuse of the account is prevented.

[nimohit]

Yes, I have noticed that many of the asian brokers offer massive spreads. There is no need for this, because many brokers I have seen offer 1-2 pips. Having 3-4 pips is just too much, even with rebate.

[peewmilon]

Stockbrokers ought to deal with traders just as along with almost any discrimination not simply damages for you to traders involving some countries but won't aid stockbrokers far too. The indian subcontinent along with china's tend to be growing financial systems along with presently there is going to be enormous involvement inside forex trading coming from most of these counties inside on its way moment.

[syahir]

Brokers should treat traders equally and any discrimination not only hurts to traders of some countries but does not help brorkers too. India and chinas are growing economies and there is going to be huge participation in forex from these counries in coming time.

yes india and china is biggest country with huge population in world and there shouldn't be spread discrimination however i believe the brokers can do of that sort as most many people are trading from india they will may lessen the spread i believe

[fxrafi4]

Brokers ought to treat traders equally and any discrimination not solely hurts to traders of some countries however doesn't facilitate brokers too. India and china are growing economies and there's aiming to be immense participation in Forex from these counties in coming back time..............

[indianpk01]

isi wja sa kuch log un brokers ko chod deta ha jo her trader ko equil right ni deta insta broker na ya farq khtam kr dia ha jis sa ya sab sa acha broker asia k ban gya ha ya broker trader k lia tips aur facilities zyada frahim krta ha .aur sb ko equil rights deta ha for exampla fix spread aur low spread

[buxpir]

Spreed discrimination for chinesse and indian trader kay baray me ap nay posha he to me ye kahon ga kay jo china ke market he who bohat badi he likin india be bad raha he.

[awais123]

je han main is baat sey igree karta hon keh forex forem aik aysa bussnis hai yeh pory word main hota hai kisi beh contry main yeh bussnis kar saktey hain yeh online ka bohut accha bussnis hai

[mole]

I just opened a live account with an alternative broker (I don't think it's wise to plan to say the name of the arbitrator here) to visualize their life worth of feed and that I can see, that they called in their fine print, that do not have an option for traders from India to open a real account with them.

[Merabnoor123]

exness is very good broker yahan bohot saray brokers hay but mein zyada acha exness ko samajhta hu kyou k is ka deposit bohot kaam hai aur bohot bounus b humay milta hai is sy hum is ka automatic withdraw b ho jata hai