Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

[forexman]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

[mayengbam]

News and events are big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others. Brokers, banks, pro traders all follow it and execute their trades accordingly.

[barmanitrade]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

nahe mere khiyal main to bhi ye nahi janta ha sirf andaza he laga saktey hane k ab values up houn gi ya down lekin bilkul sahi koi bhi nahi bata sakta ha ager kisi ko pata hota to woh sab se ziyada he ameer hota forex trading main

[yogesh]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[dweet]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

brokers are just like us, they don't know whether market is gonna go up or down. if they know whether market is going up or down, they won't be forex broker business. instead they will use all their capital for trading where they can make tons of money.

[hardworks]

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

Yes, Instaforex also don't know the future movements. They are just to manage our investments link with the market. Instaforex is non dealing desk brokers. So, they support for us by giving some analysis by some experts. We can able to get that in free of cost. Instaforex analysis. (https://instaforex.com/forex_analysis/)

[bigearners]

yeah, IFX also don't have any idea about market movement.. they are just predict from big news came into market... Even, if they know movement of market..then, they no need to open broker just apne hi paise laga karke kaafi kama lete..par somebody told me that movement shown over mt4 platform is managed by some person..is it true.. Mujhe nahi lagta ki ye sah hoga par bhi kissi aur ne aisa hi suna hai kya meri tarah.

[kanwaljit]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

i agree with yogesh here a very good observation hats off to you yogesh, brokers earn money regardless of whether someone earns or looses money trading and no they are not gods to predict the future market movements

[dmambi]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

I feel Forex brokers also don't know for sure whether the price of a given currency pair goes low or high at a given instant. Since the market is very vast it is hardly possible for them to know where the market heads. i think they too are predicting the price based on there own analysis.

[sabbir20]

I not sure that if the Forex broker in a particular money pair is less or more than the cost of at a given instant do not know. Since the market is very vast, it is hardly possible to for them to know where the market headed. I think they are very cost forecasts on are based on our own analyzing.

[atif58]

Brokers are unaware of market movement. They do follow the market same as we do. They only earn from the spreads that they have given. If there would be any thing like that they could now about future then they can trade much more then traders. News , fundamentals are the factors on which the market is moving.

[muhammadatif]

I think any broker no know about up and down of the market because it is an international matter. I think brokers can guess properly future market position with the help of financial instruments.

[sinjiku]

in my personnel opinion brokers are most experience traders and they know when the price will move up or down and also they do the tradings against their clients so the price moves artificially up or down.
some brokers also provide their analysis, and it makes it easier in the prediction of the price because we are given a reference from a broker, maybe we can use as reinforcing the results of our analysis so that we can be certain when open positions

[Warrior]

Kisi bhi broker ko nahi pata hota hai market k future k bare me. Woh bhi hamari tarha hote hai jo sirf predict karte he aur woh prediction galat bhi hosakti hai. Magar un ko faida yeh hota hai k un k links banks k sath hote hai jo brokers ko rate bhejti hai jin k apne expert analyst aur traders hote hai.Woh broker ko general direction bata sakte hai jo k ziada tar sahi sabit hoti hai magar woh log bhi predict kar k batate hai.

[forexprophet]

No, the brokers do not know where the market is heading to and to be precise nobody knows. The chart what we see in the forex trading is the pictorial representation of the sentiments of all the traders around the world and it shows the whole demand and supply for the currency at the specific time. So, it is impossible for anyone to know the exact direction of the market all the time.

[ali1011]

Broker are not aware from this act of trading reactions and price movement they also do trading same like me and you i think so it not fear that traders know rate movement and when a position goes up and when it go down.

[venkiaries61]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

No, broker is just for ECN. But, they also help us by their analyzing team. The market movement is not pre decided, the movement is according to the deals placed by the traders. If anyone knows the accurate future movement by any chance, then they put huge lot size with huge fund, this will affect market movement and should end in stop out.

[manoj]

aesa nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading volume.

[manoj]

Brokers ko pata to nae hota laykin on kay pass kafi ziada capital hota hay iss liay wo achi trade ker saktay hain. phir mayray khyaal say on ko apnay traders may say best trader ki trades ka bhi pata hota hoga, to kya pata wo oss ko hi follow ker laytay hoon

[mini]

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion
no the breokers does not know when the price will move up or move down even banks do not know that all of traders and banks just analysys the market and predict the next price.

[ishvara]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

Everyone is going to know when a forex pair is going up or down because the forex trading market is a universal and open one to deal. But do not worry about such a question, just concentrate on getting a good trading strategy for yourself.

[tinku9832]

Definitely not, they don't have any link with market directly. But they can have good experts in analysis portion, But there's no option to get 100% trend before signal change.

[alam]

broker ko bi parta ni rhata hai ki kab hamari possition up move hogi or kab down hogi.
lekin broker ke apne khud ke analysis hote hai.
wo apne analysis se aane wale market ka movement ka andaja laga sakte hai.

[dmambi]

May be the brokers know the price movement before us, but not always. Since the market is not controlled by a single broker or traded through the single broker it is impossible to know the exact way the price is heading at a given time.

[dog]

brokers are just like us, they don't know whether market is gonna go up or down. if they know whether market is going up or down, they won't be forex broker business. instead they will use all their capital for trading where they can make tons of money.
yes brother i really agree with you.from my view the broker are like us.they also don't know what will happen either the market will go up or down.if they know like that they enter into the market with big money and they earn lot of profits.

[alam]

Broker are not aware from this act of trading reactions and price movement they also do trading same like me and you i think so it not fear that traders know rate movement and when a position goes up and when it go down.

[nilesh]

Brokers are unaware of market movement. They do follow the market same as we do. They only earn from the spreads that they have given. If there would be any thing like that they could now about future then they can trade much more then traders. News , fundamentals are the factors on which the market is moving.

[kameeelforex]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

nahi mere khiyal main to aese koi baat he nahi ha k brokers ko pata ho k kis time position up ho gi or kis time down ho gi sirf indecators k zariye he app aandaza lagate ho es k elawa koi bhi es k bare main nahi bata sakta k kab market up jani ha or kab down brokers ko bhi es ka pata nahi hota ha

[nilesh]

I think any broker no know about up and down of the market because it is an international matter. I think brokers can guess properly future market position with the help of financial instruments.

[lgarhboularbah]

hmm good question it is as i know that they interdit to trade for the Officers that they work at the broker because i think that they can make the price change like they want so for this we cant find a Officer trade with his personal money and we should always trade at the trust and the famous broker to avoid this case

[forexprophet]

The brokers always have the information of the entered volumes of positions on sell and buy as well. They know the volumes of stop loss and take profit set on a specific price and they can track any informations needed using their advanced softwares. So, it is always better to trade with good reputed brokerage firm.

[nilesh]

No, broker is just for ECN. But, they also help us by their analyzing team. The market movement is not pre decided, the movement is according to the deals placed by the traders. If anyone knows the accurate future movement by any chance, then they put huge lot size with huge fund, this will affect market movement and should end in stop out.

[forexbroker123]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

nahi yar aesi to baat nahi ha ager aesa hota to brokers hhe khud se trade kartey rehte or profit kamtey rehtey mere khiyal main to kisi ko bhi nahi pata hota k ab market kis rukh jaye gi ye bahot risky ha or es main kisi bhi wqt up down chalta rehta ha esi liye main to app ko yahi kahoun ga k es main apna knowledge increase karain or profit kamaien

[twinkling star]

I donnot think so that broker knows about it. as trading varies person to person and each person set it with his owns point of view.how could broker knows about each person mantality. I donnot think so. if you believe then it might be possible.

[donofforex]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion
nahi yarr mere khiyal main to un ko pata nahi ho sakta kioun k ager aese koi baat hoti to her koi broker he banta na k trader hota kiun k app ko pata ha jab ek bandey ko pata chal jay e k kabb values up honi hane or kab down to phr us ne to kafi profit kamana ha esi liye main nahi samghta k brokers ko pata hota ha k values up honi hane ya down

[wolfkamikaz]

this is not luck it's the market analysis must always see what's new and Thus to learn the analyzes because the news has an impact on the market and that there's never a broker who may know what is up or down is about the analysis

[kaji]

I would argue that the broker is a company 'which provides services to connect with a market trader, so I think they are just like us because forex is a business that incorporates a large capital of the world then no one can know where prices will move

[100c�]

I would argue that the broker is a company 'which provides services to connect with a market trader, so I think they are just like us because forex is a business that incorporates a large capital of the world then no one can know where prices will move

Yes it is right no one know about prices movement but we can analyses about our pair where it will move up and down. Fundamental technical analysis are use for long term trading. In forex these are all expectations not accurate.

[niteshforex]

aesa nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading volume.

[niteshforex]

Brokers ko pata to nae hota laykin on kay pass kafi ziada capital hota hay iss liay wo achi trade ker saktay hain. phir mayray khyaal say on ko apnay traders may say best trader ki trades ka bhi pata hota hoga, to kya pata wo oss ko hi follow ker laytay hoon

[fxquest]

Main bhi nahi samajhta ki brokers ko pata hoga ki market kis disha me jayega aur vo bhi hamari tarah hi anbhigya hote hain future move se. Lekin traders ke pending traders data se vo andaja laga sakte hain ki unke clients jyada kis disha ki aur market ko le jane me interested hain.

[siddesh]

brokers consist of human beings too just like we. so there's no way they can predict the price movement. remember the first rule in forex, no one can control forex, it's too big even for the bigest broker. But usually brokers hire the experiences traders and analyst to help them predict the price movement, that's why sometimes their predict is better than us who learn by ourself.

[maryosa]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

broker can not know when a position will go up or down because nobody in forex market know exactly where price go next. Everybody in market including broker predict price movement that is why some broker give slippage if news come up.

[xiaotanghao]

As far as I am concerned,I think the brokers will not know when a position goes up and when it go down.You see,if the brokers can know it,I think you can trade in forex with that much money in their companies,which I think can help them earn more money rather tahn just help the traders there.

[raka999]

As far as I am concerned,I think the brokers will not know when a position goes up and when it go down.You see,if the brokers can know it,I think you can trade in forex with that much money in their companies,which I think can help them earn more money rather tahn just help the traders there.
You are right. broker will never know the market's movement. they only distribute our funds. but, there are many types of forex broker. There are indeed deliver our capital into the forex market, there is also acting as a dealers. These brokers that we need to beware. because we are going against the broker. the more we lose, then the broker is getting profits. These brokers often commit fraud against the trader.

[amit]

kuch log mind mein ghelt baat bitha detay hien k broker jaan bhuj ker stop loss legwaatey hien, ek trader k loss honay mein broker ka bhi haath hota hey lekin yeh ek ghelt concept hey, broker wahan jaye ga jahan market us ko ley ker jaye gi or na hi broker ko humary position ka peta hota hey

[krishan]

Brokers are unaware of market movement. They do follow the market same as we do. They only earn from the spreads that they have given. If there would be any thing like that they could now about future then they can trade much more then traders. News , fundamentals are the factors on which the market is moving.

[netra]

Mere hisab se broker ko in sbaka koi bhi andaza nahi hota kyunki market ke bare me koi kuch nahi keh sakta bas apne analysis ke hisab se predict kar sakta hai..amrket ki koi bhi sure shot move nahi hoti chahe jitna bada trader kyu na ho ya broker kyu na ho..market ke bare me 100% kuch bhi nahi keh sakta

[tajdarbet]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

nahi es k barey main koi bhi nahi janta ha k ye kab down ho gi or kab up ho gi main ne khud es ko kafi samghne ki koshish ki ha or kafi guess lagaye hane par phr bhimain forex trading k mode ko nahi samgh paya ye bahot mushkil ha guess karne main

[netra]

aesa nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading volume.

[netra]

Brokers ko pata to nae hota laykin on kay pass kafi ziada capital hota hay iss liay wo achi trade ker saktay hain. phir mayray khyaal say on ko apnay traders may say best trader ki trades ka bhi pata hota hoga, to kya pata wo oss ko hi follow ker laytay hoon

[sachin]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[dmambi]

Brokers are also like us humans who are placing orders on international banks on behalf of small traders like us and they don't have any clue about the market movement but they have access to the news sources which are more reliable than ours.

[vineet]

mere khayal se aap sahi kah rahe broker ko kuch pata nahi hota hai broker humari prediction ka pata rahta hai nahi bhai aisa kuch nahi hota hai hum jo bhi kaam karte hai wo online hota hai aur mere khayal se online ke bare mein koi bhi pahle andaza nahi laga sakta hai

[waqtitrader]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

nahi yaar aesi koi baat bhi nhi ho gi kioun k main ne dekha ha k ager kisi bhi broker ko es ka ager pata hota na to woh apne traders bitha k khud he profit kamata rehta yehni k neechey us ne bandey rakhey hovey hotey or un ko woh batata rheta k ab sell karo ab buy karo or profit kamata rehta par mere khiyal main es ka kisi ko bhi nahi pata hota ha k kaya hone wala ha market main

[zahidrock]

I think its not possible to know when position goes up and down. But broker can easily catch this situation because they have expert analyzer who can easily analysis about market. If you have good knowledge about analysis then you can also know about this.

[adahidayat]

i think that no one knows about going up or down of forex currencies....because it depends on many factors....many brokers has experts and they make a plan and analysis about forex trading and then they will predict on the basis of economic news, and other related things which affect forex trading...

[jai]

Broker are not aware from this act of trading reactions and price movement they also do trading same like me and you i think so it not fear that traders know rate movement and when a position goes up and when it go down.

[anitagala124]

Main bhi nahi samajhta ki brokers ko pata hoga ki market kis disha me jayega aur vo bhi hamari tarah hi anbhigya hote hain future move se. Lekin traders ke pending traders data se vo andaja laga sakte hain ki unke clients jyada kis disha ki aur market ko le jane me interested hain.

[anchitkole]

You are right. broker will never know the market's movement. they only distribute our funds. but, there are many types of forex broker. There are indeed deliver our capital into the forex market, there is also acting as a dealers. These brokers that we need to beware. because we are going against the broker. the more we lose, then the broker is getting profits. These brokers often commit fraud against the trader.

[gava]

I think any broker no know about up and down of the market because it is an international matter. I think brokers can guess properly future market position with the help of financial instruments.

[girish]

i agree with yogesh here a very good observation hats off to you yogesh, brokers earn money regardless of whether someone earns or looses money trading and no they are not gods to predict the future market movements

[Abdomhadi]

Yes this is an obvious thing that no one knows where the market will move in 1 second or 1 minute or more of this time, even the dealers do not know, because the market moves from a wide range of so it will be very volatile and because it includes a very large capital.

[zahidrock]

Its not possible to know any idea about future market. Broker is same like us. If broker can know about market movement then we can also know about this from that broker. because broker also can make some profit from us.

[sabutkelaparasaduren]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

I'm not sure it will happen. because the broker is just a small part of market players in the world. would not be possible to determine the direction of the market because the market itself consists of many actors.

[tervarto]

I think the broker does not interfere in the deal that you open, it is utilized only difference from you or the so-called currency (spreads), but it can not the broker to know what you do in your position open , the biggest broker such as insta don't do that , but a little market maker maybe knows that cause they want to loose your money , so you have to choose the honest broker

[barkiman]

Its not possible to know any idea about future market. Broker is same like us. If broker can know about market movement then we can also know about this from that broker. because broker also can make some profit from us.
well, the broker will never know the price movement. because the forex market, there are various institutions concerned. and they have a different perspective in responding to price movements. Ultimately, that has the greatest power that can control the market. whether it's big traders, central banks, or else ... broker, just as a trader and market intermediaries.

[ritesh]

I think no one will know where the market will move to 1 second, 1 minute later, even the brokers also do not know, because the market moves from a wide range so it will be very volatile..

[gava]

yes brother i really agree with you.from my view the broker are like us.they also don't know what will happen either the market will go up or down.if they know like that they enter into the market with big money and they earn lot of profits.

[vikalpverma]

mujhe nahi lagta ki broker ke pas aisi ko jaankari hoti hogi
brokers bhi hamaeri tarah hi forex ke jaankaar hote hai..wo log apni study se bata sakte hai ki pair kis tarafa ja sakta hai aur kis taraf jane ke zada chances haui
lekin hum aisan ahi keh sakte ki unko pata hoga ki pair upar jayega ya neeche..wo bas apni study karke hume bata sakte hai

[darksaimon]

In my content Forex brokers are quite unaware of early moves suchlike we do. The only asset they bonk is they earn heart lower of traders win or regress in change of propagate. If brokers new the next they give simply save big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[babu]

aesa nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading volume.

[babu]

Brokers ko pata to nae hota laykin on kay pass kafi ziada capital hota hay iss liay wo achi trade ker saktay hain. phir mayray khyaal say on ko apnay traders may say best trader ki trades ka bhi pata hota hoga, to kya pata wo oss ko hi follow ker laytay hoon

[iwan]

to my knowledge, only as an intermediary broker of trade we do, they take advantage of the existing spread of each pair. and may never know when that moment occurs.

[ishvara]

I believe that this is a ridiculous question in forex currency trading business. A broker might have 500,000 customers, how can they be checking all those accounts in order to know what they are trading.

[Maham Gill]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down
mara bahi asa koi borker nahi ha jo market main apni position bana or phar kharab kar day as koi borker nahi ha sirf bat ya ha k starting min jub naaya kam hota ha log ya member kam ko shai tara injam data han is k bad farad karata hon is lyia koi be broker phar action lata ha to log kahat han k borker kharab ha ,

[wazwaz]

They can not move because the price is not an indication of them, but act according to economic news that come down every day, which belong to a group of countries and this is affecting the large price moves because the Forex is not a machine controlled by men, but it is something related and consistent with the economics

[dadaa]

-I think, no one in this world including their own broker who can predict up to exactly 100%, where prices will move. Perhaps that could do it, just large speculators such as the state central bank. They are big speculators, has a large and capable of moving the capital market and affect other traders.

[Forexboy]

For me it is so difficult to know where the market will move to 1 second, 1 minute, 1 hour or more, even brokers do not know this thing, because the market moves from a wide range so it will be very volatile and difficult to predict.

[rahool]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

I believe every broker to its analyzers that give their best decisions of the market, they are still attached to the computer 24/24 hours, and here we are talking about large analyzers, and walked the Novella is controlled by economic and major central bank.

[ishvara]

I believe every broker to its analyzers that give their best decisions of the market, they are still attached to the computer 24/24 hours, and here we are talking about large analyzers, and walked the Novella is controlled by economic and major central bank.

Not all brokers trade forex markets since they are actually very busy with their work as a broker. Besides they are making a lot of profits through the trades of the thousands of traders that they have under them.

[ishvara]

this question of yours is what really beats my imagination ever since i started trading forex, but most dealing desk brokers do.

This is an improper topic/answers about forex trading and its brokers. If a broker knows what our trades are doing or the direction that our trades are going, what are they going to do with such a useless informations.

[rock]

Forex trader can predict the position if he go for the trdaing with the indicators and also we have to go for the trading with the news and also technical analysis is important.

[got2luvyou25]

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down
mara bahi asa koi borker nahi ha jo market main apni position bana or phar kharab kar day as koi borker nahi ha sirf bat ya ha k starting min jub naaya kam hota ha log ya member kam ko shai tara injam data han is k bad farad karata hon is lyia koi be broker phar action lata ha to log kahat han k borker kharab ha ,

But the reality is different now days , makret ki ups down to apni jaga per ha , may be novice trader ko is se malsa ho because wo loss ker jate hain against of the trend ja ker , but the thing i want to tell wo ye ha k scam broker a chuke hain market main jo apko cheat kerte hain or humhein aisa brokeers se door rehna chahaye jo unbelieveable features deen

[dineshji]

I donnot think so that broker knows about it. as trading varies person to person and each person set it with his owns point of view.how could broker knows about each person mantality. I donnot think so. if you believe then it might be possible.

[+8801711444442]

can broker know when a position goes up or down ? im interested to know about this.i heard that broker use a software.by this software they know which trader open trade with big lots. they also know where traders setup stop loss and take profit !! i trust it , because nothing isnt impossible for at this time.

[joget]

I think the broker did not know for sure where the direction of price movement, up or down, as did their analysis can only predict the possibility of price movements in the next session. many factors that influence the price movement of a currency pair or market such as economic or political policies of a country or a country's income growth rate, etc.

[kaji]

I think the broker did not know for sure where the direction of price movement, up or down, as did their analysis can only predict the possibility of price movements in the next session. many factors that influence the price movement of a currency pair or market such as economic or political policies of a country or a country's income growth rate, etc.

I agree with your opinion. the only broker forex trading work as an intermediary between the trader with the market and they take advantage of the spread. so in fact they did not know which direction the graph will move ...

[maurya]

News and events are big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others. Brokers, banks, pro traders all follow it and execute their trades accordingly.

[newentry]

i think they have good analizer for the market trend and i think they have good source for it, so they can make predicition and send to us via email at mt4 and else...
but all back to the trader itself for make decision...broker only get from advantages from the spread

[cac4a26]

broker just want to secure their interests . you should listen to them and go for real facts and then make your decision by yourself.
Some times broker can also provide you some sort of just rumors which can lead to further losses, so i think just keep your mind on facts and real news.

[tashnotashi]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

nahi nahi aesi koi bhi baat nahi ha k koi broker ye janta hota kioun k es se us k members he profit main rehtey or us ko bhi profit hota es liye main to sahi baat ha k ye nahi manta k broker ko pata hota ha k kab values up honi hane or kab down honi hane

[wendhrie]

Maybe, that could do it, just large speculators such as the state central bank.
They are big speculators, has a large and capable of moving the capital market and affect other traders.

[jmsblack18]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

The broker same like us. they didn't know how market will moves, except your broker is type of market maker who manipulate the price for their advantages. But in real interbank market no one can know what will happen in minute later. They all same like us to wait and analysis when and where the price will moves.

[sinaga]

I think the broker will not know when the market price will move up or down. market prices are subject to change at any time. but we can analyze to determine where the next direction of the market price.

[taufiqbd]

Basically forex market is fully automated and main factor of market movement is changes of supply and demand. Broker have no power to control this market movement. A expert trader as same a broker just analysis the market and they only predict the market only their analysis it may be right or wrong. Market is always right.

[anoha]

No one knows at all when the price will rise or fall it is very confidential information being sent between central banks and each other through the chart in the form of blades are only able to decode these codes so as not to leak out the next trend ....

[lights]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

I think the broker would know whether the market goes up or down. they must monitor their traders. brokers, especially with the kind of non-dealing desk. they make a profit if their traders lose, and lose if their trader profitable

[playfx]

i don't think any broker could do that. forex is so independent that not even a central banks could interfere it's movement. so broker is just like us they need to analyze the market so they can predict where it will headed.

[sachin]

broker can not know when a position will go up or down because nobody in forex market know exactly where price go next. Everybody in market including broker predict price movement that is why some broker give slippage if news come up.

[sinaga]

not all brokers are market makers, the majority of them have analysis team
who predict the market just like we do and they make positions upon that analysis
it may be right or wrong, they are not moving the market at all
very true friend. broker can only deliver orders that we make the trade. broker will not know where the price the market will move next. broker may only make a market analysis that we can use as a reference position of trade

[bdboy]

no. broker dont know about the market up or down. its just show u the present price. The up down of the currency depends on the news and other things. Its depends on one countries economical issue.

[coba]

possible for a broker with experience are able to know, and some do not know ..
because these days there are so many new brokers popping up, and to offer all things ..

[tarun2305]

brokers keval predict karte hai apne expereince se ki market kis direction me jayegi aisa koi confirm nahi hai ki jidhar wo log bolenge usi direction me hi market move kargegi

[fajar]

possible for a broker will know about it, but still requires the analysis ..
and analysis that is sent to us to be more alert to the market ..

[yogesh]

I dont think they can know in advance which way the prices shall move, but they sure have upper hand as by the data of their clients they can get some idea about traders sentiments e.g. their pending orders stop and target.

[Nabi Ahmed Gill]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

mara kahal main broker apna position up ,down nahi karta hoon ga balka trading main market up down hote ha or es sa hama fadia hota ha mara kaala main to yahi bat ha aga ap ko bather pata ho ga q k ap mara sa senior member ho or mauaja lagata ha ap boht achi trading karta ho ga.

[najaf12345]

hi
i agree with yogesh here a very good obvservation hats off to you yogesh brokers earn money regardlessl of whether someone earn or
losses money trading and no they are not good to predict the future market movements.

[sudsind]

brokers don't know the price in advance, but market maker brokers can manipulate the price a little bit from their softwares to hunt sl, also they have real values of volume and transaction happening in the market and they can trade with or against big positions in the market. they have many good resources than us but they don't know the future move in advance like us

[taqiniazi]

no i don't think that any broker knows about the movement of market. but because of thier experience hey have almost 80% perfect ideas about market

[Malay Lady]

From my opinion, I don't think that any broker know 100 percentage when a position will go up or down. Like us, all broker also doing technical analysis and fundamental analysis and they can predict the movement of price from the result of their analysis.

[wendhrie]

I don't think if the Forex broker in a particular money pair is less or more than the cost of at a given instant do not know. Since the market is very vast, it is hardly possible to for them to know where the market headed.

[taqiniazi]

brokers don't know the price in advance, but market maker brokers can manipulate the price a little bit from their softwares to hunt sl, also they have real values of volume and transaction happening in the market and they can trade with or against big positions in the market. they have many good resources than us but they don't know the future move in advance like us

Yes , you are absolutely right that the broker hunting with pips. but almost 80% of brokers spreed are fixed and the remaining are trying to hunt the price rate. exness is one of them

[riya]

i say that brokers cannot venture where the market testament locomote and flatbottom the market manipulator module not live where the market give advise. No one present bed where the market testament change. it all happens according to the buyers and histrion and trades

[forexgain]

it is the same for the broker as well as it is for us. the broker is just an interface between the forex market and the client. the only edge that they have is that they have the best traders and analysts working with them

[+8801711444442]

yes , the broker might know it. its not difficult at this time. but i think that broker doesnt control forex market. its not possible to do. but sometimes , they might know where market will go by forecast.

[najaf12345]

hi
i think any broker do not know about up and down of the market because it is an international matter. i think broker can guess properly future market
position with the help of financial instruments.

[waleedkhan]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

may tu yahi janta hun kay market kay bara may koi sayi tarah nhi janta hai sab jo hain sirf aik andaza laga sakta hain kion kay koi nhi janta hai kay market kab up ho ge aur kab down ho ge

[warnisw]

i dont think they know, they can only predict, because if they would know, they will trade by them self and make huge money from other banks
broker dont need it anyways, they are getting spread from us

[eoneadit]

if the brokers don't have conflct of interest, i believe they don't care about the price movement and so they don't predict, it's exhausting to do. it's better the give their resource to do some marketing, supporting and accounting, so that their company can attract more customer.

[traderapes]

In my opinion, they also do not know when it will go up or down position as the market is fully controlled by the shareholders and the market reaction. However, forex brokers usually have great analyzers to analyze the market.

[sumonmia0526]

sometimes i think this is preset the daily range ad all the brokers are know that previously but this is completely my guess ..but i don't think there is no way to know the economic condition in advance ..this based on fundamental actually

[jab we met]

actually no one know when the market go up or down every one work on the basis of trend and indicators signals and news about the economics also market movement depend on the political situation

[raka999]

actually no one know when the market go up or down every one work on the basis of trend and indicators signals and news about the economics also market movement depend on the political situation
Your right, I do not think anyone knows the price will move in the direction where, although only 5 minutes ahead. broker can only take advantage of the spread that has been determined. because, that move the market consists of various market participants, with diverse interests.

[sanvol]

sir wese to me forex market ke bare me zayada secrets nahi janta magar mere dost ne mujhe bataya tha ke forex brokers ko market trends ka pehle se hi andaza ho jata hai kyun ke un ke pass bohot sa experience hota hai.

[jmsblack18]

Broker who have a stand alone platform and they is market maker type, they will easy to profile our trade include know how our position now. But it is only done by machine of back office. That is why many broker now purchase trading platform to reduce this point and make their work more transparent.

[seahawks90]

i don't think so because it always depends upon the market so i am not agree with this thing that broker always knows that when market will go up and when it will come down.

[cruzzero]

You are right. broker will never know the market's movement. they only distribute our funds. but, there are many types of forex broker. There are indeed deliver our capital into the forex market, there is also acting as a dealers. These brokers that we need to beware. because we are going against the broker. the more we lose, then the broker is getting profits. These brokers often commit fraud against the trader.

[kapil_chemical_07]

It is impossible to know the actual position of the forex market.But,after analysis the news and other analysis,you can get an idea about the market trend.But,the broker or any other do not know the exact situation of the current market.

[taqiniazi]

No brokers doesn't know that when and where the market goes. if they knows then the they must share this into their clients because successful clients are helpful for brokers

[zeshan]

the brokers are jot now clear the movement of market they just predict and tell us if they now they tell to their clients but the predict on the bases of previous e situation of the market

[deep]

Yes it is right no one know about prices movement but we can analyses about our pair where it will move up and down. Fundamental technical analysis are use for long term trading. In forex these are all expectations not accurate.

[spread]

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?
i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion
I do not agree with you I think that the broker can not know the position of the market, but they know the impact of the news to currency and can correctly predict the trend of the in future market, just my thoughts because I do not know much about this

[boniez]

I guess, the broker just copy quote price from the central bank, so maybe they know about it and also there will be no difference in price a few pips of real prices in the central bank, then to the rise or fall of prices is the influence of the market.

[saviour196]

there are some factors which give a rise or fall to the market , like news or related these type of factors which have direct impact on the market.if these things dont affect the market you can have a sure idea about the market trend.brokers knoiw where the market is going just like us traders from news and analysis.

[ryodan]

the brokers are jot now clear the movement of market they just predict and tell us if they now they tell to their clients but the predict on the bases of previous e situation of the market, sometimes i think this is preset the daily range ad all the brokers are know that previously but this is completely my guess ..but i don't think there is no way to know the economic condition in advance ..this based on fundamental actually.

[ryodan]

It is impossible to know the actual position of the forex market.But,after analysis the news and other analysis,you can get an idea about the market trend.But,the broker or any other do not know the exact situation of the current market.

[puri]

Main bhi nahi samajhta ki brokers ko pata hoga ki market kis disha me jayega aur vo bhi hamari tarah hi anbhigya hote hain future move se. Lekin traders ke pending traders data se vo andaja laga sakte hain ki unke clients jyada kis disha ki aur market ko le jane me interested hain.

[yulianto470]

It is impossible to know the actual position of the forex market.But,after analysis the news and other analysis,you can get an idea about the market trend.But,the broker or any other do not know the exact situation of the current market.
well yes sir, because everyone can not predict the market can only predict it. It was predicted that only 15% depending on the market that berjalan.o ..
yes I am questioning the call market but it is what it is,,

[incredibleindia]

Usually, the broker cannot say for certain what will happen to the position because even the market is out of his control, even for ECN brokers. There are bigger influences from the big fishes of the forex market.

[zahidrock]

Main bhi nahi samajhta ki brokers ko pata hoga ki market kis disha me jayega aur vo bhi hamari tarah hi anbhigya hote hain future move se. Lekin traders ke pending traders data se vo andaja laga sakte hain ki unke clients jyada kis disha ki aur market ko le jane me interested hain.

yes you are right broker don't know about market movement. But they can idea from analysis. Because they have best analyzer then us. So i think they can easily catch right trend on this market.

[puri]

i think they have good analizer for the market trend and i think they have good source for it, so they can make predicition and send to us via email at mt4 and else...
but all back to the trader itself for make decision...broker only get from advantages from the spread

[Zubaed]

Forex is a big market range in worldwide and this is qite impossible to predict not only to the person but also to the any institutions or broker and even to the government.If so happen then we would find imbalance market character which never occured.

[brutu]

To predict every broker has a very experienced person in a very good observation, regardless of their movement from the market in the future to make money, lots of money to lose, someone will not get a cent was

[alvabra2010]

No! Brokers don't know where the market is going. They are also traders like us and even they trade in the forex market. If they knew where the market would go, then wouldn't be brokering because they would have earned billions by just trading in forex. The market is moved by news, sentiments, trends, etc., which are really unpredictable because of which its really difficult for anyone to know where the market is going.

[ernestina]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

Brokers do not know where the price is going to go to, they just speculate the same way that the retail traders speculate. The forex prices come from a price feed known as interbank so the prices are almost all the same, save broker interference. However, the direction of the market cannot be tampered with by anybody.

[digger_jim]

I guess there would be very unlikely that any broker can know in advance whether price will go up or down. They probably know a few second earlier and some pips ahead (depend on how fast the price moves) due to the price data sourcefeed system. Most brokers rely on the fact that very few traders, especially small timers like us, who make the right trading decision most of the time. The majority would tend to make mistake and loose money, a fact which is time-proven already.

[joru]

Broker are not aware from this act of trading reactions and price movement they also do trading same like me and you i think so it not fear that traders know rate movement and when a position goes up and when it go down.

[mehedi islam]

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion
it is difficult to predict the next five minute's market movement for an expert economist. may be the broker have some idea. but they can't ever say that the market will follow a particular trend in next 5/10/30 minutes.

[nabila]

yeah, IFX also don't bang any purpose nearly industry laxation.. they are righteous hazard from big broadcast came into market... Equal, if they cognise change of activity..then, they no require to unsealed broker just apne hi paise laga karke kaafi kama lete..par somebody told me that movement shown over mt4 level is managed by both being..is it harmonious.. Mujhe nahi lagta ki ye sah hoga par bhi kissi aur ne aisa hi suna hai kya meri tarah.

[didikebenaran]

brokers cannot predict where the market will move and even the market operator will not know where the market will move. No one will know where the market will move. it all happens according to the buyers and sellers and tradesI agree with you that no one would be able to find the market will move in this business to know when the market will go up and down because it is difficult to know all of that even though the broker itself

[Fahad]

i don't think so because forex is related to international market and no one can know the exact trend of the market they just can predict the market on their experience basis

[zeshan]

i think the brokers don t now about that if they now they tell to the traders and give the profit to their traders i think they don t now about the trend of market but they can predict the market

[shoeib]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion
no not exactly but news set some idea in the brokers mind and by using that idea and his long experience in trading a broker can detremine the cndition of market very much...

[awaccoo]

I agree with you that no one would be able to find the market will move in this business to know when the market will go up and down because it is difficult to know all of that even though the broker itself

Indeed, no one knows exactly when the market will go up and when it will down, but the instruments are in demand to a trader can analyze the market and study the causes of the causes of rising market moves and causes of the causes of decline in the market, than it was usually a trader can estimate what will happen when the cause occurs, up or down, though not guarantee 100% correct

[shamimuiu9]

absolutely no,brokers don't know about future movement. but it can be guess depends on different financial information.

[yoryo]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion
in my personnel opinion brokers are most experience traders and they know when the price will move up or down and also they do the tradings against their clients so the price moves artificially up or down.

[khanforex]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

brokers cannot predict where the market will move and even the market operator will not know where the market will move. No one will know where the market will move. it all happens according to the buyers and sellers and trades

[MIMIH]

The scholarship can save you money, a lot, but if a stock drops 50%, it will not regain it as a pretext that rises or falls, the risk of getting fleeced

[Lia]

brokers cannot predict where the market will move and even the market operator will not know where the market will move. No one will know where the market will move. it all happens according to the buyers and sellers and trades

very well indeed function only menjebati broker between buyers and sellers so that he can not possibly know the future market movement

[truegoa]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

From what I heard about some brokers, some broker did the best things to get profit againts us with entering market by their hugh capital. Some of them did server managing to involve our trading. But some broker do nice to just take profit from spread. But, after all, I agree that thay actually cant read the movement of future chart.

[milan]

broker is meet for ENC. But, they also provide us by their analyzing squad. The marketplace motility is not per definite, the movement is according to the deals settled by the traders. If anyone knows the exact future motion by any possibles, then they put Brobdingnagian lot filler with huge fund, this instrument strike industry change and should end in preclude out.

[macblanc474]

In my appearance forex brokers are absolutely blind of approaching moves like we do. The alone advantage they accept is they acquire attention beneath of traders win or lose in anatomy of spread.

[aamu]

very true friend. broker can only deliver orders that we make the trade. broker will not know where the price the market will move next. broker may only make a market analysis that we can use as a reference position of trade

[puri]

I think the broker will not know when the market price will move up or down. market prices are subject to change at any time. but we can analyze to determine where the next direction of the market price.

[aarti]

not all brokers are market makers, the majority of them have analysis team
who predict the market just like we do and they make positions upon that analysis
it may be right or wrong, they are not moving the market at all

[aina]

I have this concept very clear. There are a few very big brokers in the market. And the movement of the market is partially controlled by the brokers. Thus the effect is still not for sure for the brokers.

[mdfarid]

It is a fantastic question to me,you know every trader is so expert in business and they flow the news and realize the news after that they think what they do so there position go down o up they know eery moment i think.

[ishvara]

brokers are like all other traders, they have their own analyzers who give signals
and enter the market upon these signals, also they trade in intermarket in a way which is related to their clients
other brokers only depend on the banks commissions and spreads in making profits

Yes i believe that brokers mainly gain their profit using spreads that they collect each time we open our trades. Now many think that brokers trade and some how use it to scam traders. I think that is false.

[jab we met]

i think no one know about the exact movement of the market most of the time they only predict the market according to the history because most of the history repeat in the forex market

[sufanw1]

I think the broker did not know it because the broker will also need to analyze in determining price movements in the forex market. We need to remember is in the forex market price is not driven by one person or a broker but is driven by the thousands and even millions of traders in the world resulting in a moving sale and purchase prices.

[antosco]

Yes, Instaforex also don't know the future movements. They are just to manage our investments link with the market. Instaforex is non dealing desk brokers. So, they support for us by giving some analysis by some experts. We can able to get that in free of cost. Instaforex analysis.

I don't think they can accurately predict the market not all the time. But it is okay if we check their analysis we can also check other sites that are offering their analysis just in case we are not good in knowing whether or not the market trend will change.

[moonlight]

i think no one know about the exact movement of the market most of the time they only predict the market according to the history because most of the history repeat in the forex market

Right that no one can tell or prejudge the actual movement, they can make only guess. Brokers are only middle links between traders. They are not controling the market. We, traders are controlling the market so brokers cannot predict that how many pips it will go up or down.

[grabbani]

I think the brokers can know when a position is going up again when a position is going down because all the time they remain close to the trading and that is why broker can very easily know that which position is going up and which position is going down here in Forex trading.

[rudy]

I think the brokers can know when a position is going up again when a position is going down because all the time they remain close to the trading and that is why broker can very easily know that which position is going up and which position is going down here in Forex trading.

no i do not agree with your opinion..broker can not know too market will going up or going down..no one can know where exactly the market will go in a minute later..the one who can know is only GOD....

[chirag111222]

dude there are mny indicators and chrtz and forex graphss to study abt in which these forex masters and expertzz use their tradin skills and get some idea of future condition frm graphics and thus they trade in well planned manner nt by guessin dude
there are times to guess as well as think but totally dependz upon situation !

[terajana]

I do not know whether the broker will know every movement of the market place, but when there is a strong movement has been able to anticipate broker seems properly .. I just think to be able to make trades with the best ability, and the not too concerned about much else ..

[tamanna]

Forex trading is one kind of fluctuated market. So sometimes broker decision has been wrong as well as broker can not knows that the position goes up or not.

[wahidaaa]

The broker are just using the same system like we are using and its universal for all the users online so i dont think so that the brokers know the insider information.The beauty of the forex is that being a universal market it is very difficult to predict.It is also not possible to control the market so its a fair market and gives equal chances to all of us,and the brokers are also some times the traders like us and get the loss and profit in the same way.

[faria]

During my see forex trading agents may be unaware of foreseeable future movements just like many of us accomplish. The only real benefit they've can be they gain regard less connected with merchants win as well as get rid of throughout type of spread. In the event agents fresh the future they may purely type in massive positions and win fortune nevertheless that isn't the way it is.

[newentry]

Yes, Instaforex also don't know the future movements. They are just to manage our investments link with the market. Instaforex is non dealing desk brokers. So, they support for us by giving some analysis by some experts. We can able to get that in free of cost. Instaforex analysis. (https://instaforex.com/forex_analysis/)

yes but they have good analizer for it then they can make good calcualtion for the market movements and here is insta, they have good program with give us some analysis by their expert, i see that insta want to see their clients become a good trader ..

[ahsankhan]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

may samjhta hun kay is kay bara may har koi andaza he laga sakta hai kion kay market ki bilkul correct stretgy koi nahi jan sakta hai aur agar app is ko jan chata hain tu app ko bohut knowledge hasil karni ho ge forex kay bara may.

[solidperson]

i don't think anyone can know the future movement but brokers having financial annalist who are analysis every day and they can be confident about the range of movement ..if brokers are knowing the future movement then they will trade and make trillions every day ..am i wrong?

[safwan06]

yes. brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down by following news sites . all the traders can follow the sites . thank you.

[skboyra]

no the broker perception will not be always correct. but the old broker who is already involved in market a lot of years they can make assumption that where the market can run but not always correct. so before investment always think and take decision on your own thinking.

[forexboot]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion
sir mere khyaal se to broker ko pehle se hi pata hoota hai ke market positon kab up honi hai aur kab down hooni hai magar ye sirf aur sirf experience se pata lagta hai

[rasel]

brokers are just like us, they don't know whether market is gonna go up or down. if they know whether market is going up or down, they won't be forex broker business. instead they will use all their capital for trading where they can make tons of money.

[safayet39]

While we appreciate the advantages of the forex trade, it is also very important for us to realize that it is not just a highly and profitable paying job or trade, but it a kind of business, if properly mastered, gives the trader a very easy source of financial income. More so, the forex trade has beaten every other source of business, such that it has a way of making one's profit multiply exponentially.

I agree with you, we must also understand the disadvantages of forex trading because most times forex traders overlook the disadvantages, thereby focusing on just making money. We must all understand that those things in forex trading that makes it possible for us to earn like volatility also have disadvantages.

We must all first master the forex market movements before we are sure that we are ready for trading.

[polok499]

yes one can easily get information about it.

[Boss]

Yes of course we do trade here in Forex trading through the brokers and if any broker desires that they want to know which all the positions who all are going up they can do it very well and at the same time they can also monitor who all are going down here in Forex trading.

[farhannasir]

Agent are not conscious from this act of dealing side effects and cost activity they also do dealing same like me and you i think so it not worry that investors know amount activity and
when a place goes up and when it go down.

[safwan06]

maximum times they know about it. sometimes they scams. so traders will follow their own strategies. thank you.

[talebdpmg]

I think Forex brokers are as like as us regarding currency rate goes up and goes down. Because change of rate of currency is not controlled by the Forex brokers rather it is regulated automatically.

[razubd06]

The candle of the market when goes up and down, it depends on the fundamental news of the country, in the point of view and experience that all traders, all brokers and all Bank followed by the fundamental news and other techniques of their trade. if they know the candle up and down then the market could be a big loses.

[jui_222]

I think we can earn minimum of 1% daily with very low risks easily. But i have seen many traders 10% of their capital daily.the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[anuminam]

brokers cannot only know but can also control these positions towards certain aspects by the bulling effect.

[cuongmom]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

WEll, I don't think so. Every forex trader can predict the price will go up or go down, but in fact, their predict is not true, because the market can't be predicted, it depends on the supply, demand of money and the news affects a lot in this market, we must have experience to trade.

[deathzz]

seems the broker will not know for sure the price will go down or going up, and moreover there is no search for the broker to change the price trend is going to happen so that we do not need to worry. Moreover there is no influence prices will go up or down for a broker.

[galaxy]

broker did not know. but they can be analyzed as we do. and analysis is not 100% correct. be a broker or trader is the same. and they also do trading in real market

[kakuly]

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

May they know it. but i think new and event provide the market. also the can guess the market trend.

[zahidrock]

appears the agent is not going to realize for sure the purchase price go decrease or even becoming greater, and also additionally there isn't any try to find the agent to change the purchase price trend might take place to ensure we all need not be concerned. Additionally there isn't any affect rates go up or even decrease to get a agent.

[pakkar]

appears the agent is not going to realize for sure the purchase price go decrease or even becoming greater, and also additionally there isn't any try to find the agent to change the purchase price trend might take place to ensure we all need not be concerned. Additionally there isn't any affect rates go up or even decrease to get a agent.
broker is a role only as a service provider and trading only benefit from the spread, so he does not care about the price goes up or down, so he had no role for it, but the broker as well as forex traders and analysts to analyze and predict when prices will go up and down, but it's not necessarily 100% sure

[abdelmouman]

no i do not think so because the banks who control the price of the pair , as i know that the peron who work on the broker dont trade because the can change the price and cheat with the sending a wrong number and they dont have it

[cfxsignals]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

i don't think that your forex broker will have any more of an idea than you that a price is going up or going down than you do. They might have some information where people have their stops so they have slightly better idea where the market may stop hunt. However, they are using the same charts and indicators you are. The only people who know where the price is going are the big banks.

[syedraza]

Brokers are not aware of the business of trade and price formation in the reaction of movement makes me the same trading system and I fear that when traders and position to know whether the speed of thought and action goes down.

[isbhacker]

A single broker whatever amount or power they have cannot predict the market and also dont know what is next move if they knew next move they dont need any customers they can be millionaire in just one day.

[faisal89]

Information and events are big market movers and those who follows it source can sure possess an edge over the others. Brokers, botanist, pro traders all canvas it and execute their trades accordingly.

[andrian]

information can sometimes be misleading, and therefore we should be able to read information as well as possible, do not get us wrong use of information, because if we are wrong in this case, then we will get a lot of problems, perhaps excessive losses

[cozard007]

This is indeed the job of brokers to knowing that in real trading times, brokerage companies are not just there for figure head , they are alos their to protects the interest of their clients.

[mesbah]

Hi everyone ...i am a beginner and from my point of view forex brokers know when a position goes up and down and that's why they called brokers
and they know what time is best for trade ... but that doesn't mean they are right every time.
thanks

[computers]

not all brokers are market makers, the majority of them have analysis team
who predict the market just like we do and they make positions upon that analysis
it may be right or wrong, they are not moving the market at all

[aum]

brokers are like all other traders, they have their own analyzers who give signals
and enter the market upon these signals, also they trade in intermarket in a way which is related to their clients
other brokers only depend on the banks commissions and spreads in making profits

[computers]

-I think, no one in this world including their own broker who can predict up to exactly 100%, where prices will move. Perhaps that could do it, just large speculators such as the state central bank. They are big speculators, has a large and capable of moving the capital market and affect other traders.

[zahurulchd]

I am doing trade since January. I have a friend who do job in a broker in syprus. I talked with him about this. But broker does not know when it goes up or down.

[mmja2003]

I think forex calenedar is the great resources of identifying market trend. And technial analysis is a way understand the market trend. There is no other way to understand the market trend without the factor. Because forex market is so big as some big players cannot play with it. So I think brokers can predict about the trend anayzing fundamental and technical analysis, and there is no exceptional.

[sad]

the broker as well as traders, they certainly do not know where prices will move. I can say, that no one in this world that can accurately predict 100% where prices will move. Which determines completely the market and the strength of demand and supply.

[sad]

broker is an intermediary to assist us in foreign exchange trading. They do not know where prices will move. As for their own analysis of the experts, but it is usually limited to the analysis and prediction in general.

[khanam liza]

Yes i agreed with all no one can tall he know when market is up and down . It's quite difficult to say anything could be happens in one second.bcoz currency is a volatile market.

[ishvara]

The brokers do not ever need to know where our trades is going because it is non of our business. I believe that our brokers have love for us and they protect our trades since we are important to them. Our profits is equally their profits

[computers]

Brokers ko pata to nae hota laykin on kay pass kafi ziada capital hota hay iss liay wo achi trade ker saktay hain. phir mayray khyaal say on ko apnay traders may say best trader ki trades ka bhi pata hota hoga, to kya pata wo oss ko hi follow

---------- Post added at 01:17 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:11 PM ----------

aesa nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading volume.

[Saif]

No. Not only any broker anyone can not know markets position. It's a financial task. but an expert man can some assume when and how much up-down. I think forex is a full technical market and it's just drives by Technic. Not only instaforex any brokers unable to say it. they just assume by there own analysis.

[sajia]

Brokers are oblivious of activity taxation. They do follow the mart synoptic as we do. They only garner from the spreads that they score granted. If there would be any action like that they could now around proximal then they can interchange much many then traders. Program , fundamentals are the factors on which the mart is heaving.

[solidperson]

i don't think brokers knows about the market range ..it's completely secret things and if this can revealed then brokers can make millions per min ...i never think this secret will ever flash in anyone..but yes brokers annalist can guess the daily range

[want2brich]

Brokers base on news about the market, the world economic and the world politic to predict the market trend. They can predict better than us because they know more information and have expert analysis them.

[mokas]

i think that brokers don't know when a position goes up and when it go down because they are like other traders and some times they search to recrute big traders to help them

[victorforex]

Brokers not know when position will go up or down. Brokers like all traders like you and me and even make loss when doing trading. Broker that control maker on their server is bad broker and not do investment with them because they do scam.

[sharabela]

I do not think they exactly know what is going to happen next. But they can anticipate since most of the brokers officials are very experienced. This is what my belief is.

[kakatua]

I believe no one module jazz where the market testament displace to 1 secondment, 1 small subsequent, flat the brokers also do not cognize, because the market moves from a opened limit so it module be real volatilisable..

[VS89494899]

a broker may predict when it will go up or down. its completely based on its knowledge on trading and also analysis. broker mainly sneak peak these things through his assumptions.

[william88]

I think the brokers also dont know where the price may lead..
they are only a company that service us to buy and sell..they dont rely their profit on the capital gain..but by the transactions volume i think..

[qudsia123]

It is not that much possible, but traders can do estimates about knowing when the position can goes up and down. They need to do proper market analysis as no one can know how exact the market can move.

[Narr]

yes my friend they are expert that why they trader for other and make really good money too if brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[ishvara]

yes my friend they are expert that why they trader for other and make really good money too if brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

Yes no one knows the future in forex exchange trading business and the brokers do not know as well. Forex currency trading business is based on speculation and smart prediction by the trader.

[arju0011]

It depends, The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. They don't know whether market is gonna go up or down. if they know whether market is going up or down, they won't be forex broker business.They are just to manage our investments link with the market. Instaforex is non dealing desk brokers. So, they support for us by giving some analysis by some experts. Good Luck.

[lagarfeld]

Brokers can't predict future exactly but they have experts which have a good accuracy on top of that it doesn't matter for them they'll always be making money from investors.

[aalul]

I think the broker is the most familiar tentan forex trading and the use of indicators and analysis to predict price movements of a broker has the capacity to know better than tradernya, so the accuracy of the data of course he is more familiar

[nowsha]

My thinking is , Forex merchandiser can predict the function if he go for the trading with the indicators and also we have to go for the trading with the news and also analysis the strategic technique .

[gaga]

Is the most experienced traders in the opinion of the person in charge of my broker, or to move up and down as the price artificially when they conduct transactions for clients as well, the price to move up and down, those who know.

[vbalan]

broker is an intermediary to assist us in foreign exchange trading. They do not know where prices will move. As for their own analysis of the experts, but it is usually limited to the analysis and prediction in general.

---------- Post added at 10:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:17 PM ----------

the broker as well as traders, they certainly do not know where prices will move. I can say, that no one in this world that can accurately predict 100% where prices will move. Which determines completely the market and the strength of demand and supply.

[suresh]

aesa nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading volume.

[vbalan]

I think, no one in this world including their own broker who can predict up to exactly 100%, where prices will move. Perhaps that could do it, just large speculators such as the state central bank. They are big speculators, has a large and capable of moving the capital market and affect other traders.

[suresh]

I think any broker do not know about the market position before us and not only them i think no man perfectly can predict about price of currency, so broker also predict as like as us about the market after learning in several times.

[antosco]

I think, no one in this world including their own broker who can predict up to exactly 100%, where prices will move. Perhaps that could do it, just large speculators such as the state central bank. They are big speculators, has a large and capable of moving the capital market and affect other traders.

There is of course no body in the world who can say that they can predict the market 100% accurately it is only based on speculations, it is only the big players, such as the state central banks and financial institutions that can actually control the market to a great extent.

[vbalan]

no the broker perception will not be always correct. but the old broker who is already involved in market a lot of years they can make assumption that where the market can run but not always correct. so before investment always think and take decision on your own thinking.

[antosco]

I don't think that brokers would know when a position goes up and when it goes down because they are also traders like ourselves, but the only thing that will make a difference is if they have been trading for a long period of time and have enough experience, then they would be able to make good analysis.

[suresh]

I think any broker do not know about the market position before us and not only them i think no man perfectly can predict about price of currency, so broker also predict as like as us about the market after learning in several times.

[dharampal]

only those people or broker are predict about market are which professional in this business and anlayse news easily .what effect of news on market due to which they predict very easily market condition and earn huge amount of profit.

[marocsoldiers]

I think that no one knows where the market spent to 1 second, 1 minute later, even the dealers don't know also, because the market moves a wide range so it is very volatile...

[zakia]

I believe any broker no bed about up and down of the marketplace because it is an worldwide weigh. I reckon brokers can shot decent forthcoming activity function with the support of business instruments.

[kolpona]

I conceive brokers also have the similar become of aggregation as we have. but separate than that they are the fill who do have up to meeting facts on Forex intelligence and principle. they e'er save in sleepless some that.