Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?

[ity]

Well my dear I personally think it is not the business of the broker that he know about the position ,they just follow our instruction if we will give the instruction to buy ,then it will buy and charge the commission and place our order it is really the simple thing.

[Uhuru]

yes they know. there was a case just the other day when banks were fined for manipulating the market see they know when,people have bought,overbought so they sell to push the prices down so that they can make money out of it.

[vite]

well dear I personally believe they can know because they can monitoring our account. however, we trade in the broker, then the broker will have full access to our account and they will know all our position in our trading.

[fxmoney]

No one know about the forex pair movement and there are large traders in the forex market as you can understand chf crash which was just happened 2-3 months before most of the brokers dont know.

[mujahidirshad60]

dear main ye nahi smjhta k broker ko pta hota hay k market ks traf jaegi or kitna move karegi broker sirfv trade karne k liay hoita hay baaki market forex market k mutabik automatic move karti hay brokers ko nahi pta hota.

[fxkol]

It is not possible to know the market or to control market in this forex, So it is not possible to know by the forex broker but yes if they have good trader or analysist then they can assume the market.

[widia]

Brokers, banks, pro traders all follow it and execute their trades accordingly. where the market will move and even the market operator will not know where the market will move. they also don't know what testament occur either the marketplace will go up or trailing.if they know suchlike that they start into the marketplace with big money

[neil92]

Nahi yasa to nahi ho sakta hai koi broker yah janta ho ki koi postion kab up hogi aur kab down ho sakti hai ager yasa hota to broker apne hi bahut big lot me trading karke bahut hi huge profit earn kar sakte hai but yasa hota nahi hai.


Ji sahi kaha koi bhi broker ye nahi jaanta hai ke position kab up jaayegi aur kab down ye koi nahi jaanta hai sab bas predition karte hai aur analysis ke base par ye estimate karte hai ke market kaisa move karega aur usi base par trading ki jaati hai.

[PANKAJMEHRA]

yes no one knows the future of the forex that is why it is one of the most excited trading market present at the time and 3 trillion trades takes place in a day if it would have known by the broker earlier than forex have not been present today.just one can predict the market but no one knows the exact future.

[voipkolkata]

I think no one can control the market and we should know that brokers can not know when to go up or down and it is not possible here in forex trading but if they have good forex analysist then they can help them.

[promoneyfx]

I think no one can control the market and we should know that brokers can not know when to go up or down and it is not possible here in forex trading but if they have good forex analysist then they can help them.

Forex trading ka business kisi ke bhi control me nahi clahta hai aur hame dekhna hoga ki ham log jo bhi trading kar rahe hain us se hame kis tarah ki income mil payegi aur ham logon ko apni trading ki analysis ko bhi sahi tarah se samajhne ki jaroorat hoti hai.

[fsr333]

Kuch kuch broker hain jisko market maker keh te hain and kuch broker hain jo normal hain. So market mover broker janta hain kab move hota hain aur wo log bhi chahe to move kara sakte hain. Lekin sab broker hi thori bohot janta hain moving ke badimain. Key they wo log news ki upar depend karta hain.

[ranafx972]

markete movers main broker kaa naam ni aata hay balakay is main buhat say countries kay baray baray banks shamil hain jin ki exchange say markete move karti hay brokers markete ko move ni kara sktay hain lakin is main acha analysis zrur nikla sktay hain jiskay istamal say ham loss say bach sktay hain

[Talhazz]

yes unhen sab pata ha aur unhen positions kuch aise nazar ati hen k 1 jaga pe bht zada sell lage hote hen 1 jaga pe bht zada buy lage hote hen wo un positions k sl ko hit karne ki koshish karta ha aur agey ki taraf nikalen hum

[soniailyas]

yes broker ko sary situation ka mahloom hota ha kuke internaional broker koi ham ham broker tu nahoi hoty ab tu sary local broker ke pass bhi trader ki all situation show ho rahi hpoti ha.

[zuhaib shakeel]

Yes brokers have their own analyst to predict about market but at news timing specially on live speak no one knows about the market's next move may be it goes up may be down and may be up and down both in a jiffy so its very predictable most of the time for everyone.

[fxjais]

Nahi forex brokers ko bhi ye malum nahi hota hai, actually ye kisi ko malum nahi hota hai ki market me price kab up aur kab down hogi, jiske paas analysis karne ka experience hota hai sirf wo hi analysis karte trend ka pata laga sakte hai.

[M.USMAN]

I think yes, Brokers apny hand per pata hota hai.Kay ous kay brokers me overall trading result kia ja raha hai.Our brokers loss me ja rhay hai ya phir profit me.I think brokers bohat ziada hotay hai.Jis ki waja say all brokers ko closely check karna possible nhi hai.

[wonggo]

Yes, of course they know. but dont worry. if you trade in a good broker, not matter if they know when a position goes up or down, they will not interrupt your trading account except you dont have enough margin to hold your positions anymore, and give you margin call or stop out

[sehar1]

Dear brokers don't know about market trend what will b buy or sell because its depend on buyers or sellers and trades while broker can good judge and can get good analysis result from mt4 against others trades

[PRAYOGO]

the broker can know exactly about the price direction if will goes up or goes down but the broker may has a analyzer just have the good knowledge and they have an experienced eye on the the current market

[voipkolkata]

I am sure no, because forex trading is a market based trading business and it is a world wide trading business, if they can know then they will earn money and they do not need clients for trading, no one can know what will happen in the market.

[wonggo]

Of course they will know, because we trade in the broker, so they will know when a position goes up or down. but i think it is not a problem at all. they will not do anything as long as we trade with honest. dont worry, you still able to trade without any problem despite they know about your real trading

[gremori]

Brokers do not know when the price will rise or when the price will go down, even traders also do not know, it all happened because the psychology is in the forex market, if we can read the psychology of the market which would terjad, even the possibility we will determine the movement of the price first.

[fxbirati]

I do not think so they could know when the positions goes up or when the positions go down, it is totally impossible because no one can control the forex market, they can just assume that with good analyst.

[xaxi]

well dear I really consider brokers are just an intermediary and helps you in trading. they cannot do anything on their own. they give us the medium to work and they don't do and know anything.it is very necessary to select a reliable broker.

[dafi]

well my dear actually I consider cause i am a beginner in the Forex market but as I know that, the maximum brokers are also trade in the Forex market and they have many specialists on Forex trading. So, they should easily and correctly make prediction on the market.

[Medo.Forex]

It is actually in our Brokers platform that we open trades, Thus i guess that they have ability to see our trades. But in real sense, It does not actually make any difference, Our Brokers do not have any single right to obstruct without the trades, If they do it, We will know.

[moamen khaled]

*yes they can know that , but not exactly , and he can know that from two things
the first is the tecnical anlysys and the scound is the news

[pakpa]

Of course they know about it, because they we trade with their company, of course they will know when a positions goes up or down. but i think it will not become a matter as long as we trade with trusted broker. they will not disturb us

[Naughty_Guy401]

Dear broker just hum ko trading ke liye platform provide kerta hai broker ko nahi pata hota ke price ab up jayegi ya down but unke pass professional analyser traders hote hain jin ki zyada prediction successful hoti hai just bank ko pata hota hai ke price kab down hogi aur kab up hogi jub koi curruncy ke pair mein related country mein koi import ya export ho ya phir construction ho tub bhi price up down hoti hai...

[rajukarmakar]

I think it is impossible in forex trading and I think if a broker knows that then they will only make money and not other broker can make money, I think no one can control or know what will happen in the market and billions of traders are trading in forex market.

[Efat2rh]

I don't know everthing correctly. But i know that there is no person or broker or company that can give a guarantee when market goes down or up.If anyone knows it he become rich. And if a broker knows it broker do trade of their own accustom. Broker not help any trader this time.

[dafi]

well to me i personally think news and events are big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others,the only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread if brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[jara]

can have the godo doalr jobs . they are just predict from big news came into market... Even, if they know movement of market..then, they no need to open broker just apne hi paise laga karke kaafi kama lete..par somebody told me that movement shown over mt4 platform is managed by some person..is it true.. Mujhe nahi lagta ki ye sah hoga par bhi kissi aur ne aisa hi suna hai kya meri tarah.

[medthebigboss]

forex brokers didnot know the ups and downs of market.
they can trade with or against big positions in the market. :)

[rocks123]

mere khayal se forex broker ko nahi pata hota hai ki market konsi side moves karenga aur wo bhi market ko apne knowledge se analysis karte hai aur wo apne loss se profit earn karte hai.Forex broker bhi apne jaise hote hai.

[vite]

Well in fact I personally believe the brokers also make analysis and predictions as a trader. so he can not be sure about the price movement. because the price movement was formed by the law of demand and supply.

[mix]

well dear I personally believe that broker know that when the trend is going up and when it is going down in the trade of forum but if you are not able to know that then you are not able to compete the market

[mix]

in fact I always think that our broker have all information about our positions and also our take profit and stop losses so forex broker can also close our positions and they also watch when a position goes up or down.

[mix]

dear actually I can say that a professional broker certainly know about it. This is because they continue to learn and find info about Forex is as detailed as possible. Therefore, we must continue to learn in order to make a profit in Forex.

[voipkolkata]

i want to ask that will forex brokers know when a position goes up and down? or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion

My friend no one can control the forex market and it is tough to understand the market sentiment before the market react and we need to know that all traders from the different world are involved in trading and billions of traders are engaged in this trading. so no broker knows the position before the market reaction.

[kelv]

I don't think so because I have seen a lot of brokers that give signal to traders instaforex give signal too, some times I follow this signal I won most time but some times lose which to say the broker donot no when exactly the market will be up or down too.

[kamranqureshi]

bhai broker k haath main kuch nahi hota sb market pr depend krta hai agar main zyada seller ho to market down jati hai or agar market main zyada buyer ho to market up jati hai borker to sirf hame trading krne ka platfarm use krne k lye apni site dete hai baki sara kaam market ka hota hai

[Pisces07]

g han iss baat main koi shak nahi ha ke aik broker iss baat ka pata laga sakta ha ke kab trend high jaata ha aur kab low iss liye iss kaam ko achey se samajhney aur krney ke liye aap ko chahiye ke iss kaam main pori mehnat karen to hi aap ko fayda ho sakta ha aur iss ke liye aik acah broker choose karen jese instaforex

[ayan2453]

ni bhai jaan mera ni khyaal k un ko pata ho k markit ab dwn jaey gi ya up bus un ko bhi andaza hota hy k markit next time kis side per ja sakti hy q k markit ka kisi ko bhi ni pata hota k nconferm kis side per ja sakti hy koi ni bta sakta

[ghantoot]

nahe broker bilkul nahe janty kay market nay kab oper aur kab nehcya ana hay broker ka kaam to app kay paisay forex trading main ap ki merzi kay mutabiq invest kerna hota hay forex trading main invest kerna hota hay market ki movement to international affairs per hoti hay agr aik currency ki price barhay gi to her sort dosri currency ki price kam hogi aur issi base per movement kerti hay

[mukas]

dear actually I can say that no one knows the price will move in the direction where, although only 5 minutes ahead. broker can only take advantage of the spread that has been determined. because, that move the market consists of various market participants, with diverse interests.

[pakpa]

Broker will know everythings which happened in our account. But i think it is not a matter at all, despite they know when a possition goes up or down, they will not intterupt our trading at all, they still works well for us

[fakit]

dear actually there is no doubt that the broker just copy quote price from the central bank, so maybe they know about it and also there will be no difference in price a few pips of real prices in the central bank, then to the rise or fall of prices is the influence of the market.

[Tselim]

Totally I agree with this reply. Brokers don't know about market up down strategic appropriately. If that then they don't become forex broker instead they used their all capital to invest and make a gig profit. Actually anyone don't know where will go market tomorrow but we can make some similar idea about market movement.

[mukas]

dear broker ko markeet ki movement k baray main sab maloom hota ha k ab markeet up ho rahe ha ya ab down ho rahe ha woh sab janta hota ha lakin woh markeet ko move nhe kar sakta bus woh yeh dakh sakta ha k markket up ho rahe ha ya pher down usay yeh zaroor pata hota ha

yes to me i personally think broker can only deliver orders that we make the trade. broker will not know where the price the market will move next. broker may only make a market analysis that we can use as a reference position of trade

[wajid.ali788]

traders ko kam kar kar k experience ho jata hai is lehaz say is bat ki samjh rakhna parti hai aur dekhna parta hai k humaray business baray kesa sub kuch ho ga.hume acha broker dekhna parta hai.

[moneytalkgood]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case

[eurofab]

nahe broker nahe jantay kay market kab oper aur kab nechay jaey gi broker to bas hamara paisa market main dal daity hian aur pher hamare merzi kay mutabiq trading ko chalaty hian forex main hamain khud market ka andaza kerna perta hay aur ye andaza news say technical analyses aur market kay behavior say pta chal jata hay

[Ali Rizwan Nasir]

No brokers also don't know about the market positions they also use singles and analysis to execute their trading . So the traders must follow daily market analysis to trade better .

[jamila chahed]

Dear brother
Unfortunately I did not pick up today because the account margin
And good luck and success to another in Forex

---------- Post added at 06:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:49 PM ----------

Frankly, my good brother I do not have balance in Account
And wait for the bonus and wish to have all the brothers have made profits from their trading during today's deal
and all the days, and God bless

[mukas]

Yes dear I actually think that in forex trading Forex Broker does not have any business to know the direction of our trades or any commodity. no one can still know the concepts of a market move i think,

[fxjais]

Nahi, forex brokers ko market ki movement up hogi yaa down hogi ye pata nahi rahta hai, actually ye kisi ko pata nahi hota hai, sabhi market ki analysis karke hi guess karte hai ki market ki trend kya hai.

[dafi]

well of course I actually consider that no one would be able to find the market will move in this business to know when the market will go up and down because it is difficult to know all of that even though the broker itself

[ity]

well of course I actually consider that no one know about prices movement but we can analyses about our pair where it will move up and down. Fundamental technical analysis are use for long term trading. In forex these are all expectations not accurate.

[fxbirati]

I think it not possible to know the market before and we have to analyse the market and have to trade with proper discipline and a broker may have good analyst but no one can control the market at all.

[dafi]

dear of course I also think that brokers cannot predict where the market will move and even the market operator will not know where the market will move. No one will know where the market will move. it all happens according to the buyers and sellers and trades.

[ity]

well my dear I personally consider brokers do not know about the direction of the pair that where the trade will go. they just supply the platform and get the spread when we trade. If they know then why they will provide such service they can trade and make huge amount of money easily.

[Medo.Forex]

It is in the Forex brokers Platform that we open trade so it is fair to say that they even have the right to check and Monitor our trades in the market, When they finish doing this and we are clean, We will still be trading in the market and have no problems.

[fxbirati]

I think it is not possible to know the market trends previously by anyone including any brokers, if possible then every brokers will earn money and they do not need any clients, I believe forex has no controller except the market. that means markets control the forex market.

[neil92]

Nahi, forex brokers ko market ki movement up hogi yaa down hogi ye pata nahi rahta hai, actually ye kisi ko pata nahi hota hai, sabhi market ki analysis karke hi guess karte hai ki market ki trend kya hai.

Ji haan sahi kaha aap ne kisi ko bhi ye pata nahi hota hai ke postion kab up hogi aur kab down aur ye broker ko bhi pata nahi hota hai sab bas predication skartey hai exactly koi nahi jaanta ke market kaise move karega bhai ji humein apni analysis ko strong karna hoga tabhi hum yaha achcha profit bana saktey hai.

[dailyforex]

no one knows the future of currency movement but only few knows where the currency may go in next few months cause they set the monetary policies of the economy of that currencies and i am talking about the central banks like federal bank , they played a huge role in directing the movement of the currencies by injecting and withdrawing money from the market.

[tanu003]

We general people are not known the future of the market movement like us traders are also they do not know the market movement. But they follow the market news and issues, after that they trade lost of money in the market and earn good money from the market.

[indiantiger]

bhai mujhe lagta hai ki brokers ko iske baare mein kuch nahi hpata hota hai kyunki iss field mein market ko predict koi nahi kar sakta hai mein toh yeh kahunga ki forex trading mein jo karna hai aapko hi karna hota hia bhai aur koi kuch nahi karta hai ismein.

[jakefc7528]

If your question is your can a broker , see if the position that opened this win or lose, probably yes, but then to think that they will move the market to miss , it is impossible , it is very common to think that when you're and new position is opened and it seems strangely the market moves in the opposite direction , but that is why we entered the market later and change

[fxmoney]

brokers do not know about the volatility of the forex market as you will understand that in the past due to the volatility in chf pairs most of the brokers gone in the loss so they do not know movement so we just have to follow proper money management and trade

[goodtrider]

Most Forex traders use different strategies during the Forex currency trading,
these strategies do not necessarily come in the same results if we work with, because they put by the nature of the balance of trader

[fx4somethin]

I guess they do. If you are the trader who trades with a software the one people called robot. They simply monitor your trades and the worse is when it is hosted on VPN. you know very well that if it is hosted on VPN you can forget about it and allow to run for like a month. Well, it depend for how long you subscribe with the VPN provider. These broker will just go and distort the history of the robot and before you know it , you will be getting a negative result. Your lose will pile up like sack of wheat and thus might led to the wiping of the account.

[zani]

well dear in forex actually I consider brokers and we traders I think in the same position, only able to read market trends through indicators. So no one knows for sure 100% position up or down. We can only analyze, and those who got the profit, of course have the better.

[bhattipak]

Forex brokers also don't know for sure whether the price of a given currency pair goes low or high at a given instant. Since the market is very vast it is hardly possible for them to know where the market heads. i think they too are predicting the price based on there own.

[Rehman12]

no dear i have no idea about this and in my observation its not possible for also broker to control the market trend and if there is some involved of instaforex then its may be for betterment of forex market

[voipkolkata]

No way, now one could know what will happen in the market but we can assume that but not surely and we have to understand that if we can trade with proper knowledge only then we can make money here.

[minok]

well actually I strongly consider even the broker did not know when and where the price will move up or down this also the reason if you ever hear about broker that colapse and got broke because they made wrong prediction and their customer or their trader make much huge loss so they the broker have to cover the loss because broker use leverage for trader.

[zego ze]

nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading

[voipkolkata]

I think no one can know when the market goes up or goes down and it is not possible to control the forex market and we should know that forex brokers can get the spread and we should know that we are doing trade with our own trading strategy only, no one can stop us.

[goodboye]

Broker ko position k about kuch b ilm nahi hota agar asy broker ko pata chal jae position up ya down ka tu broker khud bohat earning kar jae khud trade na b kary kisi ko bta kar profit bna sakta.

[Decent]

ye broker is know a postion and gose up it is down forex trading aik risky aur acha profitable business hai aur ye just luck par he nahe depend rehna cahye hamye real knowledge bhe use karna cahye.

[dd super]

nae ho sakta. aik time may aik broker may hazaroon ki tadaad may traders trade open kertay hongay abb aik broker kiss kiss trader kay against trade open kerta hoga. its not possible for any broker to do that or simply change the market direction because of that little trading

[sayinifx]

Forex me movement hoti hai to broker ko pata nahi hota hai market up jayenga ya down jayenga ess ke baare me broker ko kuch bhi pata nahi hota hai market em sabhi analysis kar ke trade ke baare me pata karte hai ess ke baare me kisi ko pata nahi hoti hai.

[Medo.Forex]

A Forex broker will have to know the places where our trades are, But they have no business touching it, They will not even have the time to check all trading accounts as InstaForex has over 2 Million customers, Who can check all that.

[Mubariz]

i think no bro broker ko nai pata hota hai k market kub up dwn hoge but un k pass info achi hoti hai market k about aur wo har time fx market say update hoty hai ...baqi brokers b humre tarha hoty hai is market ko kuch big traders and bank move karti hai jo big invstr hoty hai ...............

[ity]

Well my dear of course I do believe no one can control the forex trading it is tough to assume that what the market behaviour would be by any one. so I think it is not possible to know the ups and downs of the market by any body..

[fxearner]

hanji forex broker ko har trader ke position ke baarein me pata rehta hai lekin wo apne aapse position me kuch nahi kar sakta,yahan trader achha sirf tabhi kar sakta hai agar wo apne position ko open karne se pehle analysis karle..

[fabu]

can see the good broekr forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[mix]

well dear actually it is no doubt that broker doesnt knows about it. as trading varies person to person and each person set it with his owns point of view.how could broker knows about each person mantality. I donnot think so. if you believe then it might be possible.

[sino]

actually my dear for me I consider that its not matter for broker,the main income of broker is when trader do place trade they got the income through spread,to understand the trend of the market,trader must needs to analyze the market chart properly and that helps trader to made good income

[minok]

Well my dear of course I do believe brokers doesn't know that when and where the market goes. if they knows then the they must share this into their clients because successful clients are helpful for brokers..

[ity]

of course to me I find it is obvious that brokers cannot predict where the market will move and even the market operator will not know where the market will move. No one will know where the market will move. it all happens according to the buyers and sellers and trades

[eshaa]

Jii han brokers ko pata hota hai ka jab kisi pair ne oper jana hpota hai ya nichy ana hota hai kun ke wo is bary main sab janty hain. jin ka pass experince hota hai un ko iss bary main pata hota hai ka kab pair ne opr jana hai aur kab nichy ana hai. is liye hi wo itni earning karty hain aur kamyabhi hasi karty hain

[zani]

dear to me in forex I always believe they know. but dont worry. if you trade in a good broker, not matter if they know when a position goes up or down, they will not interrupt your trading account except you dont have enough margin to hold your positions anymore, and give you margin call or stop out your real trading

[seahawks90]

bhai mujhe aisalagta hai ki broker ko nahi pata hota hai mein toh yeh kahunga ki forex trading mein aapko sab karna hota hai apne pe bharosa karna sabse zyada zarori hota hai uske bina iss field mein kuch nahi hasil kar sakte hain aap bhai isliye iss field mein dhayan de ke kaam karein bhai.

[dafi]

well my dear, actually I strongly consider broker who have a stand alone platform and they is market maker type, they will easy to profile our trade include know how our position now. But it is only done by machine of back office. That is why many broker now purchase trading platform to reduce this point and make their work more transparent.

[mix]

well actually my dear, we know that its not for sure that we can say.they are smart and yes they handle the most of the market deals so it is obvious that they will more knowledge about.they have enough knowledge but still they cannot accurately predict it,nobody can.

[zani]

actually my dear for me I consider that I dont think they can know in advance which way the prices shall move, but they sure have upper hand as by the data of their clients they can get some idea about traders sentiments e.g. their pending orders stop and target.

[dafi]

dear in trading forex I also do think no one knows at all when the price will rise or fall. the broker will not know when the market price will move up or down. market prices are subject to change at any time. but we can analyze to determine where the next direction of the market price.

[Medo.Forex]

Yes my friend, a Forex market Broker can actually know where the Forex trades of their customers are headed for, But they have no need nor time for that, Forex Brokers make big Money and as such do not need to steal from their customers.

[dafi]

dear in trading forex I also do think the broker did not know for sure where the direction of price movement, up or down, as did their analysis can only predict the possibility of price movements in the next session. many factors that influence the price movement of a currency pair or market such as economic or political policies of a country or a country's income growth rate.

[sino]

well actually my dear in forex do I consider broker will never know the market's movement. they only distribute our funds. but, there are many types of forex broker. There are indeed deliver our capital into the forex market, there is also acting as a dealers. These brokers that we need to beware. because we are going against the broker. the more we lose, then the broker is getting profits.

[Medo.Forex]

Forex brokers just have the good knowledge and they have an experienced eye on the the current market, so most broker know those Forex trader that are very good and those that always make deposit into their trading account after margin call.

[Blast]

All brokers have top analysts and brokers who work for them and follow the markets strictly so much more than the individual traders do. Have you ever heard about stop loss hunting? This is allegedly done by brokers based on open positions.

[alvarez4exer]

Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?
frequently used is called either historical or statistical volatility, typically
abbreviated as HV or SV. I prefer the term statistical volatility and that�s what
we�ll use throughout the text. This is a simple if mildly tedious calculation.

[monica]

Of course they know, it makes us need to trade and invest our money to trusted broker. There are many scam broker out there which will take our money. then we must choose the best broker for us

[sayinifx]

Forex market me kab up market jaata hai aur kab down market jaata hai ess ke baare me broker ko pata nahi hota hai market up jaat aur down jaat hai he kisi ko ess ka knowledge nahi hota hai yaha par trader ko khud such samjhkar Kaam karni hogi.

[KASHIF]

dear all friends around my read Forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The ultimate advantage they will have is they will earn regard less of traders win or lose in kind of spread. If brokers new the long run they'll merely enter big trades and win large amount of cash however that isn't the case...... thanks

[boda be]

sure that if the Forex broker in a particular money pair is less or more than the cost of at a given instant do not know. Since the market is very vast, it is hardly possible to for them to know where the market headed. I think they are very cost forecasts on are based on our own

[sayinifx]

forex market me kab position up aur down hotaha i ye kisi ko nahi pata hota hai aur nahi borker ko bhi esske baare me pata nahi rahta hai lekin markte me up trade ho ya down ess ko fark nahi parta hai broker ko market me dono condition me broker ko profit hoti hai.

[forex45]

aesa nae ho sakta. aik occasion may aik specialist may hazaroon ki tadaad may dealers business wide open kertay hongay abb aik specialist kiss kiss broker kay against business wide open kerta hoga. it's not possible for any specialist to achieve that or perhaps adjust the market route as a consequence of that small buying and selling level.

[BADAR]

yeah my dear friendssssssssss.........If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case. So, they support for us by giving some analysis by some experts. We can able to get that in free of cost. Instaforex analysis.they no need to open broker just apne hi paise laga karke kaafi kama lete..par somebody told me that movement shown over mt4 platform is managed by some person..is it true.. Mujhe nahi lagta ki ye sah hoga par bhi kissi aur ne aisa hi suna hai kya meri tarah.

[Gamabunta]

There is no one can be sure 100% from the direction of the market, brokers cannot know it, the next direction you can predict according to your analysis only, that is the only way to do that.

[mubshar iqbal]

nah forex main broker ko ya nahe pta hota kay market up jay ge ya down ho ge agar brokr ko ya pta hota to wo khud trade karta hum sy invest kar kay trade na karwata aur forex ki market chot marketnahe ha is ka kisi ko pta anh hota .

[monica]

Of course they know, but they will do nothing as long as we dont break their trading rules, and still have enough margin to maintain our open positions. so dont worry, whether they know, it will not be dangerous at all

[neil92]

Ji nahi broker ko ye pata nahi hota hai ke market kab up jaayega ya kab don jaayega ye kisi ko pata nahi hota hai kyunki market ko koi control nahi karta hai bahi ji agar aisa hota toh broker broker nahi hota woh bhi tarder hota aur duniya ka sabse rich person hota.

[fxjais]

Mere khyaal se forex brokers ko market ke movement ke baare me utna hi pata rahta hai jitna ki forex traders ko, forex market ko koi bhi predict nahi kar sakta hai chahe wo koi forex brokers hi kyu na ho, technical aur fundamental analysis ki help se traders achchi trading kar sakte hai.

[Medo.Forex]

I think no one can control the market, and we should know that brokers can not know when to go up or down and it is not possible here in Forex trading business but if they have good Forex analysist then they can help them.

[farqan khaled]

forex trading aik world wide online business hay iss main loss bhe hay or profit bhe yeh aik highly risky business haygee haan bilkul usko sab pata hoota hay..

[ASHOK]

no, aisa nhi hai broker ko bhi is bar eme koi knowledge nhi hoti hai ki kb market upr jayegi or kb niche, broker ka sirf kaam hota hai spreads se profit earn krna or withdraw ke time pe commistion lena or jb koi trader rule break kre ot usse block krna.

[P-K]

aysa bilkul nahi hota hai yaha per sirf andaza hota hai matlb k ak proper idea esi ko experince kahtay hai dear bro forex business ma jo trader y ideas rakhta hai wohi successfull hota hai dear bro forex business ak properly learning per hi succesfull hota hai.

[mustafa4242]

can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down we can not say any thing because we have no awairness about this it seems that news and sellers buyers are main mover of market may be brokers know or not

[spider]

aysa bilkul nahi hota hai yaha per sirf andaza hota hai matlb k ak proper idea esi ko experince kahtay hai dear bro forex business ma jo trader y ideas rakhta hai wohi successfull hota hai dear bro forex business ak properly learning per hi succesfull hota hai.

experince ke bina to koi bbi kuch nhi kar sakta hai experince to trader kel iy bahut hi importent hai experince hota ha iwork karna easy hota hai hum sab kuch bahut hi easily kar leten hain koi bhi dikkt nhi hoti hai . ;)

[Nawaj hussain]

Mai smjhta hu broker ko nahi mallum ki market kaha jaane wali hai ya fir kis tarh move karne wali hai wo bus apna compony ko chalte hai or humy trading karwate hai.. broker sirf aapne company ko dhayan deta hai ki hum jo trade karwte hai us se trade kaffi santus ho..

[badro20]

the broker estimates only know just the same as us, but brokers are more experienced and more precise in analyzing, so he is more perfect than we are.

[alphatrader]

If a broker knows that the poll position will go up and down then he will definitely make millions money in a few seconds and the forex will not exist. Forex is one of the top business and it is unpredictable also that is why it is growing if it can be speculated that much easily than it won't have a future

[kashif0]

dear friends according to my knowledge and information forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The ultimate advantage they will have is they will earn regard less of traders win or lose in kind of spread. If brokers new the long run they'll merely enter big trades and win large amount of cash however that isn't the case.......thanks

[king.hnd]

Forex market main risk zaroori hai.koi bhi broker or trader ye nahin janta kay ab market 100% kisi direction main move kary gi.iss main to experience he hota hai or traders up to 90% accuracy tak market ko predict kar leety hain.

[dafi]

well dear personally in my oppinion I believe forex brokers know when a position goes up and down or thay are just like us who predicts.please share your opinion Brokers banks pro traders all follow it and execute their trades accordingly.

[ity]

well of course, my dear In my view brokers can't know when a position goes up and when it go down. Because trading software is placed by the authority and a fixed system.So it is impossible to known for them.Brokers can not know that whether the market will uptrend or downtrend as well.

[Alkin]

hi guy, brokers dnt predict and can't to know position or futur position. maybe analysist can have a little idea for futur but not of all time they can have right. I just think to be able to make trades with the best ability, and the not too concerned about much else ..

[sino]

yes, of course I think its very true that brokers do not know about the volatility of the forex market as you will understand that in the past due to the volatility in chf pairs most of the brokers gone in the loss so they do not know movement so we just have to follow proper money management and trade

[sino]

well bro, for me I personally believe that brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case. brokers earn money regardless of whether someone earns or looses money trading and no they are not gods to predict the future market movements

[opn003]

yeah, IFX also don't have any idea about market movement.. they are just predict from big news came into market... Even, if they know movement of market..then, they no need to open broker just apne hi paise laga karke kaafi kama lete..par somebody told me that movement shown over mt4 platform is managed by some person..is it true.. Mujhe nahi lagta ki ye sah hoga par bhi kissi aur ne aisa hi suna hai kya meri tarah.

[fadel123]

hello message_87201News and events are big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others. Brokers, banks, pro traders all follow it and execute their trades accordingly thanks.

[gmail003]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[pentkor]

in fact I personally think market movement is not predeclared, the movement is according to the deals placed by the traders. If anyone knows the accurate future movement by any chance, then they put huge lot size with huge fund, this will affect market movement.

I agree with you, no one knows where the market price will move, because of market price movements are determined from the number of transactions. certainly will not be able to know that the whole transaction is in the market, so it will not know where the price can be bergera. so the forex market is a market that is fair.

[Muskan]

big market movers and those who follows it well can surely have an edge over the others brokers If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case

[Ikhtiar999]

Well if it were possible not everyone knows, when prices will rise or prices will drop, perhaps even broker also does not know the price will rise or fall. All of them are only predictions, it could go up or get down. But according to an analysis of all existing teknikan pattern and usually we learn in forex it is just a movement pattern only. So all in all there is no certainty, apkaha price or fall also no one knows, there is only a prediction only.

[gmail003]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[Nawaj hussain]

jaha tak maine dekha hai mujhe nahi lagta ki forex broker ko acchi trah se mallum ho ki market ka agala move kia hogga wo vi humre tarah hi he forex ko view karte hai apni technical anylsis fundamental anylsis ka accha use karke market ka ik anuman lagte hai ki maket ka agla movement kia hogga.. broker sirf humy trading karne k lia platfrom dete jis ki waja se hum forex mai trade karte hai

[ASIM]

dear friend i think....No they need to analysis like we do they dont know about this that when it will go up and when it will go down but if they will put lots of money than can certainly move the market the banks can also move the market ......thanks

[alphatrader]

No one knows about the Forex price in the advance , if someone knows that price will go up in down then he will be rich in a single day by trading with a very high lot size. Forex market is very uncertain and you can predict by just gaining skills and by just giving experience otherwise it is not possible

[Hamz1]

Mere khyal se unhen kuch idea xaror hota ha k kab market ne up jana ha aur kab market ne down ana ha so mere khyaal se hume chaiye k trading ki dunya me hamesha agey se agaye jane k liye brokers koi acha hi choose karne jisse hume faida ho

[gin]

my dear in forex trading actually I consider that market movement is not predeclared, the movement is according to the deals placed by the traders. If anyone knows the accurate future movement by any chance, then they put huge lot size with huge fund, this will affect market movement.

[sino]

well actually my dear i strongly think that brokers have access to the financial market and they can know how the price is acting unlike us within fraction of seconds.the advantage that they have that they know where the stops are placed by traders.

[minok]

well in fact in forex trading I do think the broker just copy quote price from the central bank, so maybe they know about it and also there will be no difference in price a few pips of real prices in the central bank, then to the rise or fall of prices is the influence of the market.

[pentkor]

No one no about this not even the broker, the market can go up and down @ anytime no one can really predict that we must do good analysis before we can no when the market will be up or down, and some times our analysis skills can still be wrong.

yes no one knows where prices will move, the broker does not know because the price moves based transactions are entered into the world market, and brokers only mediates between the trader at the market. even broker also does not have the power to intervene in the movement of the market.

[safeer38403]

No one knows 100% exact what the market will do. Market depends on different situations in the concerned countries. So the broker and traders are completely unaware about the market future movement. They can only predict by analysis.

[gin]

personally my dear for me I also do consider that broker can only deliver orders that we make the trade. broker will not know where the price the market will move next. broker may only make a market analysis that we can use as a reference position of trade i think.

[neil92]

Bhai ji aisa possible nahi hai broker nahi jaanta hai agar aisa hota toh broker brokering nahi karta woh bhi trading karta aur sabse rich hota world mein forex mein koi nahi jaanta hai ke market kaha aur kitna move karega sab prediction par hi hota hai bhai ji.

[badar.munir]

yeah my dear friends/...........No they need to analysis like we do they dont know about this that when it will go up and when it will go down but if they will put lots of money than can certainly move the market the banks can also move the market .

[eniolaforex]

Brokers in the forex market do trade them self too so they did not know where the forex market trend is moving toward.know one knows were the forex market trading business is moving towards so the broker did not know

[pakpa]

Broker will know our open positions, because we make open position through them. But i think we dont need to be afraid about it. we can use hidden TP or SL, then it will not become a problem anymore. I dont use any hidden TP or SL, because i think broker will not cheat with the trader who trades with small capital like me

[rabia500]

Brokers hires many experts related to forex business. Experts analyze all the points and data that release today that may affect the dollor value so in this way brokers come to know about forex market

[sayinifx]

Forex market ke baare me kisi brokers ko pata nahi hota hai ye kisi ko pata nahi hota hai position ke baare me kab up hoga aur kab down hoga , yaha par trade ke baare me pata karne ke liye market me technical analysis se trend ko pata kar sakte hai.

[Salufx]

yeah, IFX also don't have any idea about market movement.. they are just predict from big news came into market... Even, if they know movement of market..then, they no need to open broker just apne hi paise laga karke kaafi kama lete..par somebody told me that movement shown over mt4 platform is managed by some person..is it true.. Mujhe nahi lagta ki ye sah hoga par bhi kissi aur ne aisa hi suna hai kya meri tarah.

[pentkor]

I think the brokers also make analysis and predictions as a trader. so he can not be sure about the price movement. because the price movement was formed by the law of demand and supply.

it is true, the broker will also never know where prices will move, because it is formed from the transaction price in the market. price moves because of the buy and sell transactions. so naturally broker also only able to analyze and predict market movements.

[umair121]

haan yar broker woh hota hai jis ki hum posting karty hain so agar to hum news ko follow karain to acha munafa bhi kama sakty hain or ziada kamai bhi kar sakty hain so is kaam main mehnat ziada karni ho gi.

[dafi]

yes dear in fact I obviously find that it is not possible to know the market or to control market in this forex, So it is not possible to know by the forex broker but yes if they have good trader or analysist then they can assume the market.

[minok]

well in fact, generally I do think that no one knows the future of currency movement but only few knows where the currency may go in next few months cause they set the monetary policies of the economy of that currencies and i am talking about the central banks like federal bank , they played a huge role in directing the movement of the currencies by injecting and withdrawing money from the market.

[fx4life]

yes dear in fact I obviously find that there is no person or broker or company that can give a guarantee when market goes down or up.If anyone knows it he become rich. And if a broker knows it broker do trade of their own accustom. Broker not help any trader this time.

[manmeet143]

sir mare accroding market kaa up down to kise ko pata nahi hota hai but ham jo postion lagte hai un postion kaa hmare broker ko pata hota hai kee ham nee kha par apne postion ko laga rakhe hai means hamre broker ko pata hota hai kee ham nee kis postion ko kis prize par laga rakha hai

[ninofx]

well dear I clearly think there is no double that brokers do not know about the movements they only allow investor to enter in market and trade there and broker get commission from the both side the market and investor.

[mix]

well dear, absolutelly I can say that in forex brokers know the price movement before us, but not always. Since the market is not controlled by a single broker or traded through the single broker it is impossible to know the exact way the price is heading at a given time.

[ity]

no dear, to me I personally do consider that brokers can not know that whether the market will uptrend or downtrend. The market moves as per the buyers and the sellers. So when the buyers are more, it moves upward and the same as when the sellers are more it moves downward. So, no one knows where the market will move.

[ninofx]

my dear, I clearly think there is no double that brokers cannot predict the market movement of pips in the current position. so even though the market operator will not know the where the market will move . no one will know the market moves it depends on the price level increase or decrease in the markets.

[fx4life]

no, I definitely do not agree with you and I also think all brokers have top analysts and brokers who work for them and follow the markets strictly so much more than the individual traders do. Have you ever heard about stop loss hunting? This is allegedly done by brokers based on open positions.

[mahi218]

jee nahi is bat ka kissi ko b maloom nahi hota hai k kiss tarha say market me kam karna hai aur kiss tarha say us ko samjhna hai ku k jb tak market move karti hai us k pechay sub brokers ka hath hota hai aur wohi is ko chala rahay hoty hain.kissi ko b maloom nahi hota hai k market kiss taraf move kare ge.

[reham1122]

i thing k we need to talk on this topic kiu k bro to khod hm se profit earn krty hain jab k wo ye ni maloom kr skty k market kis traf jane wali hain broker ko kbi be ye pta ni hota market ki movement k bary my or na he pta chal skta hy.

[minok]

My dear, for me I absolutelly do find that the brokers also make analysis and predictions as a trader. so he can not be sure about the price movement. because the price movement was formed by the law of demand and supply.

[erlangga]

Of course they know, because we trade in forex market through them. Broker will know when a position goes up or down. It is not matter if they know about it. i think it is not a problem at all. We still can make good profit however, we just need to be smart to do this business only

[Power]

Han brother eisa hota he k broker bhi ye andaza kar skate hin k market ki price buhat up jaei gi ya buhat down jaei gi wo khud bhi buhat tajurbar trader hote hin es market k ups and down ko samjhte hin es lei to es business min eitni bari investment kar k eitne zidya waqat se beithe aur phir unhon ne apni bari investment bhi ki he.

[ity]

well dear, generally in forex trading I do think that mostly brokers don't know what to happen next.The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.if they know what to happen next they should do trade himself.

[zani]

yes dear, absolutelly in trading forex, i strongly can say brokers are unaware of market movement. They do follow the market same as we do. They only earn from the spreads that they have given. If there would be any thing like that they could now about future then they can trade much more then traders. News , fundamentals are the factors on which the market is moving.

[WaheedRana]

G ni broker markete movers ni hain ye sirf hamain markete main enter honay kay liye rasta daiatay hain or is main inka koi kirdar ni hay ye bhi asiay hi daikhatay hain jasay ham markete ka analysis kartay hain . Bas wo pasiay walay log hain or ham is main tarder hain jo kay poors hain

[mix]

of course, strongly I think it is very true that no one can control the market, and we should know that brokers can not know when to go up or down and it is not possible here in Forex trading business but if they have good Forex analysist then they can help them my dear.

[M.USMAN]

Brokers ko pata ho ga kay traders ups hai ya downs hai.Meray khyal say brokers all traders kay account nhi dekhty ho gay.Wo over all position ko watch karty ho gay.Brokers bhi trading say earning karty hai our traders bhi karty hai.

[imtrader]

Most trusted brokers had nothing to do with market orders as they directly send orders to Interbank exchange which provide liquidation to the market and earn lump sump commission per lot but some market makers really screw traders and run after stops knows as stop hunting and that often happens in range bound markets and we have seen lot of complaints from traders that orders did not get executed or stops was taken out before or after price reached and that is really a responsibility of a trader to select the trusted and responsible broker not market makers.

[atulkumar2k0014]

Ha bahi forex to ek achha bussness hai par yah market ke anusar up down kar rahta hai . Kabhi yah up karta hai to kabhji yah down me rahta hai . Iski jankari jo achhe broker hai unko jarur se haoti hai

[ninofx]

well, I actually do think in forex trading business the brokers cannot predict the market movement of pips in the current position. so even though the market operator will not know the where the market will move . no one will know the market moves it depends on the price level increase or decrease in the markets.

[fx4life]

well dear personally in my opinion I believe they can not know in advance which way the prices shall move, but they sure have upper hand as by the data of their clients they can get some idea about traders sentiments e.g. their pending orders stop and target.

[mix]

yes, of course I think its much true that I know that the brokers can not know when the forex market movie up or down, because if they can know that they can invest money to trade, they don't need be a broker. I know that no one can control the international online trading market.

[Medo.Forex]

No way, now one could know what will happen in the market but we can assume that but not surely and we have to understand that well if we can trade in the market with correct knowledge only then we can make money from this trading business.

[m.shahid]

Ni broker ko is bare myn ni malom hota k kb values down ho gi ya kb up. Q brokers market ko deal ni kr rahe hote. internation market ko handle hr country ki currency kr rahi hoti ha. kisi bhi country ki currency us country k economic situation k hisaab se market main up and down hoti ha. broker ko ye nai malom hota. han jo professional trader hota ha wo economic news pr nzr rakhta ha jis k matabiq traders order place krte hain.

[AnsaGee]

No brother, Brokers does not know when the market will up or low, it depends upon the country's success rate, employment and a lot of other factors affect the market. Even buy and sell orders made by the Forex trader's help the market come down. This is not easy to understand.

[chokaxx]

Brokers are nit Gods that they can know anything about the market behavior. . They predict just like us by analysis, news & events. .

[anwarali1122]

jha tak mje maloom hy k unko kuch be pta ni hota hy market ab kdr jani hy agr aisa hota to wo he pori world my rich person hoty jo k khod ek broker hain wo logo ko apna broker introduce ni krwaty or na he is ko join krwaty.

[sangam]

nai bhai broker b humre tarha hoty hai un ko b maloom nai hota hai market to all world news par work karti hai achank move say soem time broker b apn afund loss karrty hai so is main broker ka koi b work nai hota hai market world wide work karti he,.......

Ham log jo bhi trading karte hain wo trades markets me chali jaati hai. Ham log Forex brokers ke thru Banks se connected ho jaate hain jis se hamari trades direct Inter Bank markets me hoti hai aur brokers ko sirf hamari trading se comission hi mil paata hai. Is wajah se broker ko nahi pata hota hai ki ham log kis tarah ki trades ko kar rahe hain.

[zahid2016]

and the brokers are the part of forex market ... they knew what is going on the forex market and . they also know the future of market except the news factor..

[anwarali1122]

Dear sir broker to khod apne ek shop ko run kr rhy hain wo khod trading walo to perment ko buy krty hain or bad my ham logo ko introduce krwaty hain taa kham is my join ho k broker or ham trading se paise bna sky... they don't know about market moves..

[Hana]

ahan , Can brokers know when a position goes up and when it go down?, well yeah i think ke broker ko pataw hotaw hai andazaw tu hotaw hai ;)

[pipshunt]

I do not believe that forex broker know the position goes up or down and it is impossible to know the market and we have to trade with the proper analysis of the market and if we can trade with proper way then only we can get money and no one can control the market at all.

[Fxwin]

Mere khyaal se traders aur forex brokers dono me se kisi ko ye pata nahi hota hai ki market price kahan jaane wali hai, forex brokers ko to kya kisi bhi person ko ye pata nahi rahta hai, haan kuch forex analyst apni analysis se market ki movement ko guess karte hai par sure wo bhi nahi hote hai.

[mazprofx]

Mujhe nahi lagta hai ki forex brokers ko ye malum rahta hai ki forex market me price kab up aur kab down hone wali hai, agar unhe ye pata hota to unka team khud hi forex trading karke big money bana sakte hai aur unhe broker banane ki jarurat bhi nahi hai.

[Medo.Forex]

I think no one can know when the market goes up or goes down and it is not possible to control the Forex trading market and we should know that Forex brokers can get the spread and we should know that we are doing trade in the market with our own strategy only, no one can stop us.

[arshad4433]

Many times mein ne suna hai brokers bhi bohat ziada fraud kertay hain aur hamein apna broker choose kernay se pehle lazmi unn k bare mein information gain kerni chahye. Aur Insta forex broker sab se best broker hai . Aur I think koi bhi broker yeh nahi janta k kab market up ja rahi hai aur kab down. market movement sirf demand and supply pe hi depend kerti hai.

[shaad1122]

ni agr aisa hota hy to market ka online trading ka koi be faida ni hy log is my brokers ko he paise dy k market ki move ka pta lga lain or har koi is my winner hota ye ga trading my or ye achi bat ni hy traders k liye.

[Uhuru]

sometimes yes they have the full information that they can use to trade forex with and so when we are able to work well in these market we are all able to develop some of the best trading institution that is able to work well for all of us to the right direction as we may call them. forex has its own process of intervening in the right direction and we should approve it to make it easy

[pentkor]

no one knows where the market price will move, even the brokers do not know. because the broker is only an intermediary trader in the market, so the broker will not know about the market movements or even broker can not intervene in the market. so the forex market is a market fair in my opinion.

[mmmahabur]

In MY watch forex brokers are quite unaware connected with future moves including we do. your own sole advantage It offers will be they earn regard less regarding traders win or maybe lose within application associated with spread. no matter whether brokers new the future they will probably quickly enter big trades AS WELL AS win lot involving money but This really is not your own case.

[impexo27]

Nobody in the world knows that where the market will go next not even warren buffet. Everybody make money with edge they have. Nobody is sure about the market movement and it is impossible to guess that way. If you want to make money you must use probability to make money otherwise you will lose plenty of money here and there. Dont waste your time like that rather take some serious dedication to learn to trade.

[bogelfx]

I think the broker does not know, when the position of the market going up or going down, if they know, they can trade with large capital on brokerl ain, and I think there is no person or broker who is able to perform an accurate analysis of the market with 100%

[Uhuru]

Yes they can and sometimes it becomes rough that they cannot be able to help some of these people they must know because they are the main link between interbank and final traders and so they must know. the right ruling of any one trader is the role of good channels that we have developed and we are all know to understand what are the values we can heed

[pipshunt]

Actually it is tough to know the market condition in forex trading and we all know that no one can control the market and no one know the market before it reacts and we can only assume the market but it is tough to get understand the market easily.

[Uhuru]

They always know the problem is they can do nothing , they never advice, they are the link between the right and we have the same trading and we have to work the same tradign the same trading forum is that we have to work and develop the right well in certain channels that can develop and we have. the same trading channels we have to rule the working and we have

[a_for_apple]

according to the definition of a broker, the broker will not know when prices go up / down
the pure movement of the global market
and the global market is a collection of psychological trader, indeed they will not know when the market will move, but at least we can do a good analysis to get an overview of the direction of the next market

[Medo.Forex]

Yes, a Forex market Broker can actually know where the Forex market trades of their customers are headed for but they have no need nor time for that, Forex market Brokers make huge Money and as such do not need to steal from their customers.

[fxlife2015]

My friend I do not believe that forex broker can know when a position goes up or goes down and we all need to learn this trading business and no one can know the market trends previously and no one can control the market easily.

[blsingh33]

ji nai bhae log esa nai hoata hai koe bhi jan ni skata hai ki kya hone wala h hamko bhut jayad hi en bato ko dhyan dene ki bhut jyaad hi jaroort hoti hai hamko bhut jayad hi mza ata hai hamko bhut jayad hi ache se dhyan dene chahiye jisse ki hamko bhut jyada hi fyada ho skat hai hamra dhyan yha hona chahiye jisse ki hamko acha lage

[raufqazi]

brokers are also like us they don't know that whats going on in future the brokers can not know about future and if they keep skill a good skill and if they work honestly and understandingly then they can hope that whats going on in the future the brokers can earn very much if they work honestly and understandingly it is the best way to earn if you are not mature then you can loose so you also needs maturity in this business and you need hard working i think the brokers can not know whats going on in future

[zidab]

In OUR look at forex brokers usually are quite unaware of future moves including we do. your singular advantage It offers will be they earn regard less of traders win or even lose in application form of spread. if brokers new your current future they may easily enter big trades ALONG WITH win lot involving funds but This can be not ones case.

[Uhuru]

yes they do and so they are ableot understand certain dynamics and so sometimes there is a lot of good work that can be borught to some reasons of other information whave to see that when a borkers starts business, he/she becomes the link between the investor and the inter bank so we have to rule out the right process of trading working principles that we all think of

[vexedebe]

If the should know , one day it will be expose to others,the market is controlled by forces of demand and supply. no body determines the market and no body regulate the movement of the market

[pentkor]

Yes dear I actually think that in forex trading Forex Broker does not have any business to know the direction of our trades or any commodity. no one can still know the concepts of a market move i think,

it is true, no one knows where prices will move, in fact I'm sure no one can intervene in the price movement, because too much money is there in the market. so the forex market is a market that is fair. so forex is good business for us, and we have to focus on learning more about the market.

[ciocio]

The interesting thing that we should know that we earn regular profits will dicancel by the broker. This is because they do not want to bear keruhgian large, therefore sometimes some brokers will change or shift our OP with us will be losers. That way he will make us less profit or even we will loss.

[pentkor]

If the should know , one day it will be expose to others,the market is controlled by forces of demand and supply. no body determines the market and no body regulate the movement of the market

and the forex market is indeed a market that is fair, because it is controlled by supply and demand. no one can intervene in the movement of the market, and no one knows where prices will move. which can be done by anyone forex businesses, just to analyze and predict the movement. That's why the forex market is said to be a fair market.

[Uhuru]

Yes they do know, their accounts and the main aim of any accoun trader is to make some good money and so they work as hard and prove that is bringing some go the best information to us and so we have torule the working principles that do develop the right paht to working forums and we have to rule what is right and what is not we can do it right for some reasons

[alibrothers775]

forex main koi bhe future k bare main confirm information nahe rekhta bus sab brokers oor traders ka idea hota hai laikin confidence ki c ko bhe nahe hota forex main trader ka apna knowledge oor exprience hota hai wo market direction ko dekh kar oor better planning se trading ki try karta hai forex main apna learning process ko continue rekhn oor better plane k sath trade karn

[shribalajimaharaj]

In my view forex brokers are quite unaware of future moves like we do. The only advantage they have is they earn regard less of traders win or lose in form of spread. If brokers new the future they will simply enter big trades and win lot of money but that is not the case.

[second2nun5]

Jaha tak mera knowledge hy k broker b market ki up down ka hundred percent idea nahi laga sakta k market up move kare gi ya down only wo ek acha analysis kar sakta he apni expertiese ki bina otherwise nahi

[Ghalib]

upto some extense forex broker know about trading that either it go up. or go down. mery heyal mie usko 97% lta huta hae. ka ajj market kua kay dekahe ga. aor ese trah wo trade kar kay lrofit krta hae.

[trader123]

ye hn bilkul asa hota ha brikerz asa kar skty han is liy to ye ik resky business ha is k liy he to is me expiemce zada zaruri hota ha tab ja k admi is me acha kama skta ha bht asanai se or is me acha trade b ban skta ha

[pentkor]

Forex is a market that is fair, no one knows where prices will move in the forex market. in fact no one can intervene in the price movement. because forex moves because of the transaction the buyer and seller. so brokers do not know where the direction of market movement. and all forex market participants could only be analyzed to predict.

[a_for_apple]

of course, most brokers certainly has a great market analysis so that they know at least 80% market movements
but that does not affect entry you created
because the broker will not do anything in your entry, they already benefit from the spread set before do order

[sumonmia0526]

i don't think so .if the broke will know the position of ups and down then they will make millions per hour everyone will lose their money .i think it's not a open secret that when and how does the market move . think there is some certain market range which can possible to predication but not the exact position .

[madhujella]

Its hard to relax when you money is at stake, and yes you are right by panicking we make silly mistake by taking decisions without thinking.It depends if you have a good strategy then Forex trading can be easy if not it is very hard. In this business is all about knowledge,strategy,money managing and discipline. And this you have it or you don't have it. If not then you will not profit.

[Marwan irshad]

forex me 100 percent koi sure ni ho skta broker sirf market ki situation ko dekhte hoe ek prediction kerte hai jo ke mostlly sai bi ho skti hai per uske galat hone ke bi chances hamesha hote hai,,ye sochna bilkul galat hai ke shahid brokers ko up and downs ka pta ho esa ni hai aur na kabi ho skta hai

[fxearner]

hanji forex broker ko har trade ke baarein me trader ka pata hota hai,yahan trader ko ess baat ke baarein me nahi sochna chahiye,trader yahan apni samajh sse market me kaam karenga to wo achha decision lekar kaam kar sakenga..

[watto]

nahi muja nahi lagata k kisi bi broker ko pata hota ha k marekt up hi ya down kuin k forex main market ka jo trend hota ha uc ko samjna k liya analysis ki zorrart hoti ha agar jo bi analysis karty hain sirf wohi janty hain k marekt up ho gi down in the near future icc liya ap ko chaia k ap apna mehnat karo aur kosish karo k ziyda sa ziyda knowladege gain karo forex k bary main :good:

[amind]

Of course the broker will know when our positions goes up or down. It makes we must know the type of the broker we trade with, a dealing desk broker or non dealing desk broker. The good broker is non dealing desk broker, they will profit if we get profit, so the broker will not be scam

[clclvox]

"

Forex is the most unpredictable market in the world. Nobody knows that when and how the market will be change. So dear any broker does not know that when the market will go down. But by analyzing the market we can be sure up to 86% about market`s probable way.

"

[flafio]

"

i think its must be good them as we prepare for the analysis if they were and knowledge measurement. If they give it advice from a financial analyst so good but there are analysts who just like us but with a higher level course they would only trade ney. As far as I know the broker or dealer has Plen managers handle their clients are just like us, we just shared my experience

"

[senose]

"

No , no body can know this thing in advance . In past time when central banks intervene in this market then only those people or brokerage houses who were aware that central bank is going to intervene they know it's consequences but that practice has ended now adays and with expansion in this market it is impossible for any one to know future movement of this market .

"

[cthart]

"

i don't think that broker know market position when market up or market down but they have just little-bit idea in market because they have good experience in trading market.

"

[agoogo]

"

I do not think they can know in advance which way prices will move, but they certainly have the upper hand as the data from their clients they can get some idea of ​​their orders as trader sentiment delayed stop and target.

"

[flafio]

"

i think its must be good them as we prepare for the analysis if they were and knowledge measurement. If they give it advice from a financial analyst so good but there are analysts who just like us but with a higher level course they would only trade ney. As far as I know the broker or dealer has Plen managers handle their clients are just like us, we just shared my experience

"

[xufxu]

"

News and occasions are great business movers and these who takes after it well can definitely have an edge over the others. Dealers, banks, master traders all take after it and execute their exchanges in like manner.

"

[czlfb]

"

From my opinion, I don't think that any broker know 100 percentage when a position will go up or down. Like us, all broker also doing technical analysis and fundamental analysis and they can predict the movement of price from the result of their analysis.

"

[xufxu]

"

News and occasions are great business movers and these who takes after it well can definitely have an edge over the others. Dealers, banks, master traders all take after it and execute their exchanges in like manner.

"

[czlfb]

"

News and occasions are great business movers and these who takes after it well can definitely have an edge over the others. Dealers, banks, master traders all take after it and execute their exchanges in like manner.

"

[czlfb]

"

News and occasions are great business movers and these who takes after it well can definitely have an edge over the others. Dealers, banks, master traders all take after it and execute their exchanges in like manner.

"

[pentkor]

Forex market is a market that is based on the existing transactions, so the price moves in the forex market is the number of transactions coming into the market. of course the broker does not know where prices will move, because the broker only be an intermediary between the market and traders. so for me the forex market is fair.

[ashrafsayd]

"

From my opinion, I don't think that any broker know 100 percentage when a position will go up or down. Like us, all broker also doing technical analysis and fundamental analysis and they can predict the movement of price from the result of their analysis.

"

[gehanfox]

"

News and occasions are great business movers and these who takes after it well can definitely have an edge over the others. Dealers, banks, master traders all take after it and execute their exchanges in like manner.

"

[emadeldin]

"

I do not think they can know in advance which way prices will move, but they certainly have the upper hand as the data from their clients they can get some idea of ​​their orders as trader sentiment delayed stop and target.

"

[aileid]

"

I wanna to say that no brokers can't really know about it because it will running by his owner powers if you really want to makes some profit from here then you will can't takes this places and in a days you will can make profit from here easily really !!

"

[a_for_apple]

The actual broker will always know what we are doing in metatrader possessed
because the broker is conveying our order to the global market, without our brokers can not trade in the global market
but the broker will not cheat with the transaction that you make, such as instaforex. I've been using instaforex but no cheating whatever I can get, even if sometimes account directly forum will be disabled if a violation of trading rules there :)