Brokers and banks:who depends on the other

[hima]

Hi forum members we all know banks are also into Forex . Now my question is does bank open account with brokers to trade Forex or they can do that on their own or does brokers depend on banks and do brokers also trade. Please give answers you're sure about. Thanks

[anna_quen]

Hi forum members we all know banks are also into Forex . Now my question is does bank open account with brokers to trade Forex or they can do that on their own or does brokers depend on banks and do brokers also trade. Please give answers you're sure about. Thanks

in my view banker have accounts with forex and they also trade with forex,
and thy both depends on each other

[anna_quen]

Now some one told me that bankers are the main role in forex trading that they play the forex with brokers

[mayengbam]

well friends, its the brokers who are depending on banks for forex speculation. The national banks are the ones who does the real trading and we are just speculating on the price fixed by these banks, based on demand and supply, to make profits. The brokers quote the price fixed by these banks to operate their business.

These big banks intervene quite often in forex speculation to increase or decrease their currency values and the market may entirely change course sometimes due to the intervention.

[forexman]

i think inorder to trade for banks in forex they need a broker,broker is one who opens and closes a position on traders request

[vineet]

as far as i know, the smaller one always depend on the big one, so i guess the smaller bank will usually trade their funds in larger Forex Broker, and so the opposite. Now the next question is, how about the larger bank, and the larger broker, who's depend who? for this, absolutely no depending relation, cause each of them usually trader directly to the market. If you know the history of the forex, back a few decade ago, only the big institution with huge fund i.e banks, company, brokers, etc, that can trade the forex. That's still not change until now.

[sinaga]

I think the brokers and banks have been dealing in this trade. rules set a good broker will be processed that same view with the rules set by the bank. deposit and withdrawal process also through bank acc first before getting into our brokerage account.

[nurhidayah]

I think the brokers and banks have been dealing in this trade. rules set a good broker will be processed that same view with the rules set by the bank. deposit and withdrawal process also through bank acc first before getting into our brokerage account.

if observed closely as it is a rule that the relationship between the broker with the bank very closely, for example:

trader - a local bank - money changer - a means of payment - broker (deposit)

trader - broker - a means of payment - money changer - a local bank (withdrawal)
sorry if wrong in this process I have described this

[ahmedlinkers]

Hi forum members we all know banks are also into Forex . Now my question is does bank open account with brokers to trade Forex or they can do that on their own or does brokers depend on banks and do brokers also trade. Please give answers you're sure about. Thanks

Actually in the forex trading, bankers are the liquidity providers and brokers introduce clients to the trading markets. Thats how both supplement each other in this process.

[jab we met]

actually many broker attach their account with the bank to satisfied their customer so actually according to me broker depend on the bank for save the money of different trader many broker may have some shares with the bank

[andhwrey]

i think both are depending each others,they delivering money as person needs to trades,and get commisions agains using their service
that are misiions in brokers,to get profit when we are using their service

[cozard007]

As far as i am concerned, both depends on eachother, broker will depend on the bank transactions and service, while broker will depends on the bank for transactions and storage.

[nurhidayah]

Brokers and Banks depends with each other because it's all about money transaction. Because a broker needs a bank where they can send the money to the traders and for the bank, it is vice versa :)

the way we have understood each transaction process in which we live is indeed derived from our conviction to better understand the condition of our trade to be able to see the relationship between banks and brokers so that we can better understand our procedures we want to take advantage

[ishvara]

The banks that exists around the world and the big companies that trade forex markets are not brokers of forex so they will still have to depend on forex exchange brokers to have forex accounts and then trade forex markets as well.

[essam1985]

i think that brokers is depending on banks

because bank is the one who give the broker the price feed

and the the trades excuted in thier liquidity pool

[shankar_saha]

ok friends, its the brokers who are reckoning on banks for forex speculation. The national banks are those who will the $64000 trading and that we are simply speculating on the value fastened by these banks, primarily based on demand and provide, to form profits. The brokers quote the value fastened by these banks to control their business.

These huge banks intervene very often in forex speculation to extend or decrease their currency values and also the market could entirely amendment course typically attributable to the intervention.

[forech]

i think brokers are depend on other ,buz broker earn money from there clients deposit,broker profit will depend on traders deposit and trade.but bank not depend on traders and broker,traders and brokers are depend on bank.

[khaled6969]

Trading by banks are more secure on condition that Astaal margin so as not to go as the money that the bank guarantees the operations of the

[nurhidayah]

Trading by banks are more secure on condition that Astaal margin so as not to go as the money that the bank guarantees the operations of the



operations that it can be applied with some things that will be used as a guide and guide traders can adjust itself to the rules of how we look at the relationship between the broker and the bank when we were in the forex market

[rana157]

mere khayal main broker banks per depnd karte han keun ke in ke sara inhsar apne trader pe hota ha
jin ke acounts hote han.or banker ka be broker pe he depnd hota ha jis se dono aik dosre ke leye ahm han.

[yasiraziz]

brokes apne account bank main open karte hain costmer ko satsified karne k liye
Broker bank par deeand karta hai

[ripon4x]

Banks do both action in the forex market. They bank supply exchange rates to the broker. Broker depends on the bank for that. On the other hand, Bank also trade through the broker to make money.

[eslam]

According to my point of view banks also trade with Forex because we are all known that all banks are attached with Forex exchange and they strongly depend on each other.

i agree with you

[mehedi315]

Yah forex is spared over the world day by day. Someone said to me that banks are included into forex trading as if brokers.
Thanks !

[Borhan107]

Yes, you are right. Banks are the main role thats play all forex broker. The broker are plyed by banks which releated in forex market. But all bank are not releated with forex market.

[Maaz]

broker banks par depand karta hai kyn usy apne costmer ko mutamen karna hota hai is liye aur wo apna paisa bank main rakhta hai
brokers banks par depand karte hain

[cfxsignals]

I am sure that brokers have accounts with banks. Some brokers have segregated accounts for their clients. Basically this means the accounts are seperate from the brokers funds. Some brokers mix them together. I think that all brokers trade low risk and make money on the markets.

[wavestraders]

of course all the broker are relaying on the bank because forex is one of the bank money game so whatever the data and source will came from the bank before it can be channel out to us

[irfi mp]

As iam new here but i think it depends each other.and bankers are the main main and important role in forex trader.in my view banker have accounts with forex and they also trade with forex,and thy both depends on each other. brokers who depend on banking for forex speculation.

[gkintl]

Banks are market participants. They need not open account with forex brokers. Only forex brokers depend on banks for quotes. This is how it works:-
The banks trade with each other and with multinational corporations, hedge funds etc., These rates are passed on by companies like integral(who are connected to top layer banks) to forex brokers who then send it to clients like us using the quote servers, after creating a spread.

[Hiron]

I am not fully aware about the interrelation between banker and forex. Can anyone help me about this.

[Amitpaul]

Yes,bank can open accounts with brokers to trade forex or they can do that on their own and they are dependable on each other.

[budado]

I guess broker is more dependent to the bank than the bank to the broker site. First and foremost you need bank to have an exchange of money. If you are a broker site how will you going to transfer money to the investors and the investors the the broker site? You need bank right? That's why its very important that theirs a bank. A bank can trade in forex but a broker site can't act as a bank. So in short bank has more function than a broker site. Even a big financial institution need a bank to function.

[monsterzz]

when asked which requires more between banks and brokers, then the answer is jelals that desperately need a bank broker. Party broker requires the bank to be able to resolve regulatory issues and all the things that had to do with the government.

[even89]

sure banks will be the generator for forex price. bank transactions always be the leader for bigboss, bigplayers and brokers to take any positions. once banks take position, price could to move in large movement. and to know when the bank enter the market i use a paramater of size candle. if the size candle more then 30 in h1. i believe banks was in the market! :)

[nasim39]

yaa The national banks are the ones who does the real trading and we are just speculating on the price fixed by these banks, based on demand and supply, to make profits.

[agitiga]

Hi forum members we all know banks are also into Forex . Now my question is does bank open account with brokers to trade Forex or they can do that on their own or does brokers depend on banks and do brokers also trade. Please give answers you're sure about. Thanks

most broker brokers are banks and the big banks are brokers, that is the way it works

[3etman]

banks benefit more from forex brokers , because the brokers represent an adequate way for supplying them with a rolling flow of funds not only every day but every hour in the day.
in the same time brokers benefit from the banks through having more consultancy opportunities and higher abilities to go on safer mutual fund investments.

[forexlearn]

Bank are most % trade of the world. Broker is also doing it. But they are always depend on each other. I think they have huge invest and huge money they are always gain from Forex Market. If you have hug capital then you never lose from this market. Gain % must always 99.99% what you think.

[ripon4x]

Banks plays the main role here. They provide the instant rates to the broker and broker collect individual traders and make the environment to trade with the bank. Broker takes his commission as a link builder between banks and traders. its the bank and traders who either win or lose money

[Adaja92]

From me broker and bank are the one and another side of a coin. They depend one another to satisfied their clients and service provider. broker trade their business by the providing money from bank or their deposited money, one the other hand bank trade their business by the money which was collected from that broker.

[ladoali]

Mara khail ma bank trade ma main role ada karta ha is lea brpker bank per depend karta ha na ka bank broker pa depenen d kary.
kio ka tamam broker ki mony bnk ka pas safe hoti ha kio ka bank ka pas many broker ki mony safe hoti ha .

[jefricha]

i'm positive that brokers have accounts with banks. a few brokers have segregated accounts for the shoppers. basically this suggests that the accounts are seperate due to brokers funds. a few brokers combine them along. i believe that brokers trade low risk and earn cash inside the markets.

[forexgame1]

as far as i know, the smaller one always depend on the big one, so i guess the smaller bank will usually trade their funds in larger Forex Broker, and so the opposite. Now the next question is, how about the larger bank, and the larger broker, who's depend who? for this, absolutely no depending relation, cause each of them usually trader directly to the market. If you know the history of the forex, back a few decade ago, only the big institution with huge fund i.e banks, company, brokers, etc, that can trade the forex. That's still not change until now.

[samsuddin.bepari]

I am convinced that intermediaries are the account with the banks, a few brokers have segregated decommissioning funds accounts customers mainly indicates that accounts are a separate broker fund, it, a few intermediaries to, because I believe that intermediaries low risk trade and earn money on the market.

[nodidesign]

There are brokers, who work as middlemen between banks lenders and borrowers on the wholesale end to secure financing for homeowners. And there are banks and lenders, that work directly with the Currency Owner to provide financing on the retail level.There are pros and cons to both, and sometimes you will have little choice between the two if you have poor credit or a tricky loan scenario.

[barikahalah]

At this point the query: the particular launching of your bank-account within Forex trading broker agents as well as professionally as they can independently, as well as many people count on financial institutions and broker agents conduct business. Intermediaries running within financial institutions will be cost deals. For those who have additional monetary information about alforksmrh a couple of years in the past, merely large companies with large financial institutions, companies and agents, for example, that may, you already know, deals within foreign currencies, that's not yet changed.

[Roddexx]

I guess each interdependent because they are interaction to each other. clearly, their orientation was profit. So, for making a profit then they can just depend on other.

[vallen]

Hi forum members we all know banks are also into Forex . Now my question is does bank open account with brokers to trade Forex or they can do that on their own or does brokers depend on banks and do brokers also trade. Please give answers you're sure about. Thanks

I think the only broker that will be able to keep us going in investing so that I will be able to easily obtain a secure way of doing this trafficking
this way then I will always be able to get the benefit that I can take anytime and anywhere with safe once if I was going to withdraw funds

[WonderWoman]

Banks accomplish the two activity with the foreign exchange market. These people financial institution provide exchange prices on the dealer. Dealer depends on the lending company for your. In contrast, Standard bank also trade through the dealer to make funds.

[peewmilon]

I'm sure to be able to business with regard to banks within foreign exchange needed a brokerage, brokerage can be person who opens along with shuts a situation on dealers demand.

[shoaib786]

mere khyal sy dono he aik dosre py depend rehty hain kyun k choty bank bhi aik bary broker k sath kam krty hain es liye mere khyal sy dono he

[naija]

It is believed that banks do have direct access to the market and most of them are liquidity providers to the brokers. Though some banks too acts as brokers as well as banks, so both we always need each other.

[ijazsony]

meary khiyal main tmam banks brokers p depend nahi kraty kuch banks aisay hon gay jo apnay funds ki trade kraty ho gay.i think brokers depend on banks.

[shanu]

I think banks have accounts with forex both depends on each other Rules set a good broker will be processed that same view with the rules set by bank

[naija]

Both the banks and the brokers work together in the forex business. Most big banks are liquidity providers for the brokers, and most banks also are forex brokers providing brokage services as well.

[tayia157]

Brokers are depend on banks because all countries economy are save in banks and banks are invest in forex market, all brokers assets are save in banks, so we can say that all broker companies are dependent on any centrals banks and investment of all client of the broker is save in that bank.

[shahzad yousaf]

i think bankers have accounts with broker,s and also forex traaders and a broker depends on the bank for save the money and both are depend,s on each other

[ghulam88]

Broker ko bank pa he depond karna parta ha na ka bank broker pa depond karta kio ka broker ki her chez bank ka pas hoti ha a/c wagara sub kaush agar broker bahata b ha to
broker ki sari amount to bank ka pas hoti so is lea broker apna a/c open karny ka apny assets wagara show karta ha bank ko na ka bank ko sub kush show karwana parta
ha broker ko.

[sohailsk]

I must say that i am very much clear about it, banks are also participating in this business and the brokers depends upon them, they need to open the account in the banks and safe thier comission in it and to use thier money as desired in the forex business.

[sweetypk2016]

bankers ti depend nhi karta hai broker pa jab ka mare knowledge ka mutabiq broker ,bankers ka oper depend karta hai. kiyo ka broker apna account bank ka sath attach karta hai jo ka bhot save hai. isi waja sa customer bhi satisfy hota hai or broker pa trust karta hai

[hafi1199]

mery khyal main tu banks jo hoty hain wo sirf account he mange karty haain aur wo forex kay sath be trader karty hoan gay aur is bat say ya andzaha hay kay donoon aik dkosty kay lay bohat zoori ahin aur ahmeet rakhty hain is lay donon aik dosry kay lay aham hain

[saqibazmat908]

dear______ ye forex internation banks or market mey rakhey howey baki sarey currecies k combination sey he to bani howi hy... barey barey bank trades or share mey hisa laitey hain or en sab ka apas mey buhat bara combination chalta rehta hy... banks or proffesional traders ki waja sey he to market chal rahi hoti hy... but kuch broker alag b hain jo market k sath he chaltey hain but alag hotey hain...

[m.asifali]

in the my mind the broker and the bank are deppend on the each others because the treder gave her money on the bank and bank also gave her money to back the broker.

[umairmalik]

yes you can say brokers are banks because most of the brokers attach them selves to the banks so that you can trust them but actuallt they do it to save money so you can say brokers are banks in my opinion in trading.

[davi]

The two that is the brokers and the bank they are the biggest trader are in the makert that reason i say that is because the amount of the the fundamental that are used when tradeing they depending on each other in that there can not be any one else have to depend on each for the work that they do

[irshad]

Now my question is does bank open account with brokers to trade Forex or they
can do that on their own or does brokers depend on banks.

[Mqasim]

the brokers contingent on the banks to satisfy traders according to my point of view brokers mostly depend on bank in order to protect their income. some brokers have stipulation with the banks.

[BOOM]

According to my knowledge and experience i think these both are depend on one an other because banks offer leverage facilities to forex traders and forex traders are open is accounts in forex market and invest is money in banks.So i think these both are not separate.

[sobuj85]

I know, small sized one always rely on the big one, so i think small sized financial organization will usually business their resources in bigger Currency trading Agent, and so the other. Now the next query is, how about the bigger financial organization, and the bigger broker, who's rely who? for this, definitely no based upon regards, cause each of them usually investor straight to the industry. If you know the record of the forex, returning a few several years ago, only the big organization with large finance i.e financial institutions, organization, agents, etc, that can business the forex. That's still not modify until now.

[earnprofit]

In my opinion,I find the banker will still trade in forex,which can help them to keep the currency value.While,the broker still need to have a bank account to deposit their money.

[marshad]

broker can help you a lot to open a acount and banks is use for withdrawl a money. brokers and bank are depend on each other in trading market.

[forex_adviser]

in my view banks not completely depends on broker but broker completely depend on banks for his transactions.This is my thinking that bank is independent.
Because banks have many other options but brker don/t have.

[mar1990]

a.o.a
~~~!!@@ trading mmain jb koi trader apni investment py kamm krr rha hota hay to wo apni daily ki zrroriyat k ly any profit mmain sy kuch rakam withdraw b krwana chahta hay jis ko wo bank kk throw he withdraw krwata hayy is ly kha jata hay k trader ka bank pr depond hota hay ......in other worlds trading bank mmain hony wala kam hay jis ki wjha sy brooker ka bank k sath link rahta hayyy many brookers have shares in the bank and keep their money save ;;;;; i say brookker ko bank kk baghair too benifit km he rah jay ga ~~~~@@@@:yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo:

[sakibmiakob]

genuinely a large number of brokering service install his or her's profile aided by the commercial lender towards thrilled his or her's customers which means genuinely as reported by everybody brokering service could depend on the particular for the purpose of protect the dollars from completely different buyer a large number of brokering service regularly have numerous stocks and shares aided by the commercial lender.

[nayeem01715]

I am certain that brokers possess accounts with banking companies. Several brokers possess segregated makes up about his or her consumers. Essentially it indicates your accounts usually are separate through the brokers finances. Several brokers mix them together. I'm sure that all brokers industry reduced chance and also generate income for the areas.

[51fctn]

mary khyal say bank or broke dono ak dusary pay inshar kerty hai.........
broker ko apny customer ko satisfied kerny kay lea apna paisa bank main rekhna parta gai. bank ka bi broker pay depend hota hai as lea dono he ak dusary kay lea aham hai.

[kalulu]

While tradeing there are they both need each other for there customer ronga make sure that have made all the money and they have maximiced all the opportunity they can get but when they are tradeing The cam all do there tradeing through the markets direct

[osim71]

I think the banks need to shop for a necessary broker in forex, broker is the one that opens and closes the position at the request of traders.

[keroso1]

actually the broker depend on the bank and there is no doubt about that so for me i think that the banks have a lot of money and much more than the broker which make them the leader in the forex market

[raazi]

mara idea ka mutabk banker ka account attched hota ha forex ka trader ka sth and tradrs to phle hi sa forex ja sth attched hota han or ye sa is dono ma hi depand karta ha

[hsp1]

Meray khiyal main dono hi kisi had tak aik dosray pe depend krtay hain,banks apnay paisay say forex market main trade krtay hain or is tarah say wo profit bi earn krtay hain or brokers apnay accounts ko bi banks k sath attach main rakhtay hain jo forex market k customers k liay easy ho jata hai.

[smsobuj]

Forex and banks are the both side of a coin. We can not differentiate the difference. Banks do Forex and Forex relay on Bank in many way. So it is not easy to think two different picture like Forex and bank. banks invest large scale of money in Forex. It is very much normal calculation for extra liquidity. Thats how bank's business runs.

[mub5455]

dear sir ap ney buhat achi post ki hai mai ap ko sush btaon to mujey is kay barey mey bilkul pata nahi ntha ap ki is post ki waja sey mujey kafi malomaat mili hai ap ka thanks mery khial mey ap ak dam teak baat ki hai k bankes brokers per depend kerty hain or brokers traders per depand kerty hain

[indianpk01]

karobaar jo b hota ha wo trust ki bunyad pa tareeqi kr skta ha banks b register hota han aur forex business b register ha is lia wo dono easily ak dosra pa yaqeen kr skta han aur apna karobaars ko aaga tk la kr jaa skta han ..

[aug14]

i do not think so because bank has their own business of money so bank prefer its customers and broker can not depend on bank because they are main customers and big also,and brokers also make trades in forex trading online market because this is its business and broker make many profits from it.

[fulltry]

main banks per zyada depend krta hu isi liye main trading indirect bank acount k throw krta hu isi trah mera mera paisa bank main safe rehty hain

[fxrafi4]

i think so as to trade for banks in Forex they have a broker,broker is one World Health Organization opens and closes an edge on traders request.............

[qaisercolonel]

I think the trade is not depend on the banks. Because a lot of people work on forex that are not employ of the bank. But bank is depend on the forex market. Because banks invest their money into forex to make good money on it.

[Ramlan Fs]

of course in this case make use of the advantages and benefits that attract both to generate profits with either to use a good profit and therefore do well to create profits

[beamsteam]

Mere khyal main broker or bank dono hi ak dosre k ly zarori hn because broker apni investment ko trade main invest krne ka bad jo profit hasil krta he wo usy apne bank account main transfer krta he or wohi amount/profit usy cash ki surat main mil jta he so both are need for eachother

[a555]

both depends on each other in this sense that all the system of the broker run by the bank and all the transaction is happen through the bank and on the other side if the broker does not keep their money in the bank then the bank cannot make his routes strong

[monirhasan]

You think Forex trading broker Bank in order, one edge of the opening question traders

[c13]

broker aur bank dono he aik dosray kay zarori hain ager broker paisa rakhnay kay liay bank ka he istamaal kartay hain aur sari transaction bank kay zareay se he karwatay hain aur ager bank hamesha wohi kamyab rahtay hain jin main zeada say zeada amount ho aur broker kay pas to bohat paisa hota hai

[sahilbutt]

is platforum ma jita bhi traders kam kar rha han un sab ka account hota han bank account or un ki attchment broker work ki un ka account ma krta ha or un ka pasa un ko trancfer online hota ha

[habibur25]

I'm definitely a particular company, the Bank leads the agents in this solution. A number of principles are a good trader will be processed similar reservations when they use policy of Standard Bank. In addition to handling the resistance on the use of standard bank Ac first before coming to our account at the broker's agent.

[lion8414]

in my knowledge is that,the smaller one always depends on the huge ones, so i guess that, the little bank will usually trade their funds in bigger Forex Broker, and so the opposite...... and as far me ,actually according to me broker depends on the bank, for saving the money of different traders, many broker may have some shares with the bank.......

[extraordinaryboy]

i think the brokers are depend on the banks because all of money is available in the banks there are many of brokers make profit from this money,brokers make many of profits from the money which is invest the traders in the market.

[vakas.9011]

i think that banker have accounts with Forex and they also trade with Forex. they both depends on each other but i think that brokers depend more on banks for en-cashing their payments. their is important relationship between brokers and banks.

[@missodekanmi]

brokers and traders together with banks are depending on each other in my opinion of trading forex. the banks are the ones that help the transactions of brokers and transders after and during when they have used it for withdrawing and transfering of money all over the world

[creative]

In fact, different broker accounts to make your client happy and actually hangs in accordance with the agent, who so to save money off the Bank's beginner that a number of different providers may be something with the world bank

[amssalcity]

the international banks and brokers and both who depend on each other because for money transfer brokers use banks and for getting money in market banks need brokers. so i think both are totally dependent on each other. both help each other in many ways in forex trading business market.

[jazy]

yes it think the broker and bankers are depend one and other,broker sells the goods and the banker gave the payment and send money to other country,so i think both are very important.

[bloch.bhai]

my opinion brokers have account in forex and they also trading with the forex so they depends each other.many brokers attach there account with bank to satisfied customer and some brokers have share in the bank.

[7544]

I think i agree with you but how do the broker now do the physical cash transaction with banks when we now place our orders.

[awais123]

ge han man is baat say igree karta hon keh forex forem aik bohut accha bussnis hai brokar ka is man kam yehi hota hai keh woh informtion dey ta keh logon ko is sey fiada ho aur un ko jkoi pareshni na ho

[buxpir]

broket and bonad who depends on the other is lay kay in ka sara ka sara karobar dosray logon par depand karta he agar who apni market ko banana chahtay hin ya who earn karna chahtay hin to in ko dosran par depend karna padta he.

[saaad042]

brkes apne acount bank main opon karte hain costmer koo satsified karne k lya brokers har mumkan kosish karty ha,,
Broker bank par deeand karta hai

[irbaz.000005]

i think both brokers and banks are depend on each other. banks also want to invest money on this profitable trading platform and for investing their money, they need brokers. brokers need banks for deposits and withdrawal of money. i think, they both are depending on each other.

[Zee133]

I think dear banks and brokers have depend both of each other becouse banks have account in trading market and do also trading with brokers and brokers also so both of depen on each other.

[kamrun7142]

Banks will be depended than brokers,Bank can't bankrupt very easily.Most of the people know about bank,but most of the people can't know about brokers.

[juneer]

i think well friends, its the brokers who are depending on banks for forex speculation. The national banks are the ones who does the real trading and we are just speculating on the price fixed by these banks, based on demand and supply, to make profits. The brokers quote the price fixed by these banks to operate their business.

[amjid222]

broker our bank ak dosre per depend karte hian kuon ke broker ko bank ki zroret hoti hi kunke us ne lgon ko payment karne hoti hian or bank ko broker ki kuo k bank broker ke begar kush bi ni kar skta us k lia broker zrorey hia.

[moon dk]

well friends, its the brokers who are depending on banks for forex speculation. The national banks are the ones who does the real trading and we are just speculating on the price fixed by these banks, based on demand and supply, to make profits. The brokers quote the price fixed by these banks to operate their business. if observed closely as it is a rule that the relationship between the broker with the bank very closely, for example:

trader - a local bank - money changer - a means of payment - broker (deposit)

[fariyalshah04]

jhan tak main janati ho broker our bank dono he ek duara ka oper depend hai . but jahan tak our mazid knowledge ka bad hai ti broker mujhe bank ka oper depend lagta hai kiyo with drow our deposit bahi bank ka throw hi hota hai.

[iolkujy]

I think it is necessary for the banks to trade in Forex, broker has a broker is a World Health Organization opens and closes a foothold at the request of the trader

[indianpk01]

we depend on both things because dono cheez register hoti han banks national bank sa aur broker exchange sa aur dono k leen deen hot rahta ha aur trader apna profit withdraw krwana k lia banks ko use krta han aur investing k lia b trader bank ma invest krta han jis sa ya business mukamal hota ha ...

[frijhyg]

I think in order to act on behalf of the Bank in their broker, Forex broker is an organ of the UNITED NATIONS opens and closes a foothold at the request of dealers

[naija]

Banks are liquidity brokers, though the big banks. So the forex brokers would always depend on the banks for their trading and executions operations on behalf of their clients

[princeua]

This depends on the company you work with them there is a company that operates as an intermediary between you and the bank directly and there is a company that does not work this thing that you want to work with the bank you have to open an investment portfolio in this bank in order to trade in Forex.

[janeg]

the relationship between brokers and banks is of primary nature. some time bank approach brokers to invest money and some time brokers need bank to carry trading transactions.

[zeeshan13g]

Bank k bagair koi bhi bisiness mushkil he isi liye Forex ur tradors mil k bank accounts se kaam karte hain Forex ka bhi bank mein account hai.

[muna1982]

the relationship between brokers and banks is of primary nature. some time bank approach brokers to invest money and some time brokers need bank to carry trading transactions.

bank is an individual organization so they did not need to depend on any one. but the dealer or the broker a bit related to the bank because all the trade we done must need to assign with a bank. if it did not happen then the transaction will not done and we have to requite it and need some time. the bank actually clear the transaction and the broker is just a via to do so.

[aidilburhan]

i think broker depends on the bank because most of the time bank is the one who has the asset, or liquidity and the broker if act as a market maker they only provide the place for trader to make their order

[ali.khan]

I think in order to industry for banks in forex they require a broker is person who opens and ends a position on traders request.

[siful003]

I love forex i think the brokers and banks have been dealing in this forex market trade. rules set a good broker will be processed that same view with the rules set by the bank. deposit and withdrawal process also through bank acc first before getting into our brokerage account.
thanks.................

[Muddasar CTN]

Brokers or bank dono he ek dosry py depend karty hen keun k bank barokers k sahary he kam karty hen or broker ko treader ke zarort hote hy treader jis qader money invest kary ga to use tarha he broker ko bhe comition mely ga so.....ye ek dosary py depend karty hen

[naija]

Brokers would depend on banks for many reasons, like the provision of liquidity which banks do, and also the safe keeping of clients deposits for the brokers.

[visioit001]

insta forex or bank aik dsre k bgar kam nai kar sakte hai q k brokr or bank ka apas m lyn dyn hota hai or yahe inke earning ka zriya hota hai

[aamishmehmood]

g haan ,brokers or banks aik dosere pr inhsar karte hain or aaps mein lan dan ka kam karte hain donon aik dosare ki aamdani ka zaria hain.

[aamish001]

yes banks plays a very important role in trading . foreign trade totally depend on banks to get foreign exchange . brokers are the source of income for banks and banks are the source of income for brokers

[visioit002]

g han koi b kam ya firm bank or broker k bagr mumkin nae ha q k broker ka link bank k sath hota ha or bank k broker k sath as liya ya aik 2sry par depand karty hain

[sweetkuri82]

in every business we have to open account in banks for many transactions because banks are very helpful for us to save our money so i want to tell you that many brokers registered there accounts in banks to satisfy there clients but some time banks depends on brokers to collect maximum reserve so in my point of view both are depends on each others

[markhoor]

If someone wants to do forex trading, he will have to join a broker or a make a brokerage of himself because forex trading is not possible with out a broker. Big banks and other financial institutions usually have their own brokers so that hey can avoid spread and other commissions charged by brokers and they can make the market shift because they make big investments.

[usmanijaz]

Basically from the forex currency trading, lenders will be the liquidity vendors and brokers create consumers on the buying and selling promotes. That's just how both product the other person on this course of action.

[ahmad33nadeem]

sir broker jo hai woh be trusted hota hai main tu broker per he depend karta ho koun kai muj ko broker releble lagte hain app kesee sahe broker jo hai tu trusted hain jaisa insta forex hai

[hasilpur]

broker and banks both are depend on one another for earning money because the main source of earning for banks are brokers and the main source of earning for brokers are banks by exchanging currency in domestic money money

[shahid1477]

mery khyaal say ye donon he ikk dosry pay depend karty hain.i mean that the bankers and brokers depends upon each other.

[naija]

The bank is usually liquidity provider in most cases, so with that, the brokers will definately depend on the banks for liquidity of their clients orders.

[shamshad21]

Banks Forex per depend kartay hain aur apna hisab kitab chalatay hain. Banks hi kay zariye hum apni money ko send aur receive kar saktay hain.

[mahk987]

mne forex trading business ko much din pekle join kmia he or mje is business k bare mein me abhi zeada andaza nahe he k kon kis pe depend karta he balke me to khud is bare me information lena chati hon

[beamsteam02]

mere khyal main dono hi ak dosre pay depnad krte hain bank ko deposit k ly broker ki service chy hoti he or broker deposit krwne or withdrew krwne main bank ki service required hoti hain so dono ak dosre pay depnad krte hain ye mere khyal he.

[shoaib546]

i have been join forex trading business a few months ago,and i think i have no much knowledge about this but i also want to know about this question and i want to increase my knowledge.

[monmon]

see every one depends on the other banks most are in to forex by forex companies or a lot of banks own forex companies it is a huge investement they move the market and eat the other money

[Omerhayat]

ak bank main boht se brokers kam kerty hain bank berokers par depend kerta hai ore boht se brokers jo hain wo ak bank par depend kerty hain.bank ore broker ka apas main boht depely relation hai agr bank na ho to broker useless hain ore agr broker na ho to bank useless hain.iic lya donun boht important hain.

[saime121]

Dear i think banks and brokers are depending on each others because the banks have their own accounts with brokers to do trading and the brokers have their account with banks to send and receive money.

[wicaksono]

They were all connected, according what I know there are 4 player who use forex that is super bank - government - big company - brokers, and were include in brokers. They are need each other, and the broker or we can said all of the trader make profit from that connection and their activity, that was the price of pair were formed.

[ABUZAR]

I am sure that brokers have accounts with banks. Some brokers have segregated accounts for their clients. Basically this means the
accounts are seperate from the brokers funds. Some brokers mix them together. I think that all brokers trade low risk The banks trade with each other and with multinational corporations, hedge funds etc., These rates are passed on by companies like integral(who are connected to
top layer banks) to forex brokers who then send it to clients like us using the quote servers,

[Ali 123]

the way we have understood each transaction process in which we live is indeed derived from our conviction to better understand the
condition of our trade to be able to see the relationship between banks and brokers so that we can better understand our procedure ok friends, its the brokers who are reckoning on banks for forex speculation. The national banks are those who will the $64000 trading and that we are
simply speculating on the value fastened by these banks, primarily based on demand and provide, to form profits.

[@missodekanmi]

I am sure they both depend on each other. The banks needs brokers as customer: paying customers while the rockers needs the bans or their day ti dy transactions. The brokers need the bAnks the more because tithe banks have other customers that pay for services in my opinion. The banks can also lend the brokers money for their Buiness and I'm certain they too muse th feign exchange market

[Endeye]

I think the bank is a party that had a major influence on the market and being able to make a pattern from a bearish market become bullish market because the power of capital in the bank have not limited. it contrast to the broker as the party which accommodates all kinds of traders activities in forex trading. so, between brokers and banks there are different of principle and the broker and the bank could not be made as a comparison.

[Hina121]

i think both of depend on each others because some banks have account with brokers and do trading and some brokers have accounts with some banks and withdraw and deposit money easily.

[naija]

Banks are also brokers, because some brokers present themselves as banks, examples are Saxo banks, MIG, Citibank, they are brokers but are still financial institutions.

[seema121]

Dear i think the brokers and the bank are both of depend on each other because the brokers can get money from banks and it have accounts in banks and the banks do trading with the brokers and the banks have also accounts with the brokers in Forex trading business.

[naija]

Some banks have their own trading platforms as well. Like in the previous post which i made, i mentioned as few bank to have their own forex platforms for trading.

[Raja551]

Hmmm g haaan jnaab g aap nee saahi kahaa haai jnaab g aaj kaal bankers bhi online traading kaarte haain likaan meraa khyaal ye haain keh yee chizz wo stock exchange mee karte haain naa keeh brokerss forec mee kaarte haain g

[VikramSingh]

We got to be with broker that’s reliable and have some sort of reputation, as only then we will be able to gain and will be able to perform. I am with one of the best in OctaFX and they are awesome by all standards with been licensed by FCA while there is also ECN account that can be operated with as low as 20 dollars. There are no issues over slippage, re quote or such things, so keeps it all comfortable in every way.

[sidrazafar]

If you go it alone, you deal with the bank directly. If you're a regular customer and have a great relationship with your bank, you might receive better terms and interest rates.

If you don't have a good working relationship with a particular bank, you should shop around. Even if you do have a bank you've worked with, you should consider shopping around anyway�don�t trust your bank is automatically giving you the best deal.


Keep in mind that when you're on your own, comparing rates and terms can be time consuming and complicated. You may not know how to compare mortgage products correctly or be savvy enough to slice through all the financial jargon.

[Bajaj Vasu]

FreshForex jese broker duniya mai boht hi kam honge. Sirf in ki ya offer nahi balke aisi boht sari offers majood hain jis ki waja se ya log itne popular ha. Mujhe sab se achi cheez in ki 101% Tradable Deposit Bonus (https://freshforex.com/traders/promotion/tradable-forex-bonus.html) offer lagti ha!

[Doji]

Bank institutions do forex trading as well. Even those who directly related to that field.
The bank does indeed trade directly with the bank provider, and we do not know exactly how much they invest in the trading.
Of course they have teams or parties that manage the balance that they are staking in the market. I think so.

[chasif]

yes my all friends how are u
I think the ordr trader k ly lna baks in forex thy need a broker is one who opends and close a postion on tradrs request to thi friends and other we cant broker request with out broker u do not have trading .

[chasif]

dear friends miry khyal mn to brokers who are the deping on banks forex camishon forec speculaton . the natilon banks are the ones the real trading and we are just speculation on there =brokers aur do u your spered and give camishon on ur investment .

[Muhammad adnan]

both are depending on each others thats my thought..
are you agree with this view..

[sakigbest]

jii haan jab hum kise b broker ko join ker lty han toh humin is ka her rules ko aloow kerna hota hai jabn hum is ko fallow nhi kerty hain toh humain is main se kuch b ahsil nhi hota hai

[Merabnoor123]

Insta Forex ki high level verification kerna must hai withdraw k liye or high level verification k liye two steps hain first mein pic Identification or second mein address ki verification hoti hai to agar ap key me per home address ka koi utility bill nahi to Bank account ki statement se ho jaye ga.