Technical Analysis ya Fundamental Analysis par trading?

[malik]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........

[medhat4forex]

Technical analysis is best for me in Forex and I see that most of the traders in the forex rely upon in their analysis of the Forex
There is no doubt that the basic analysis greatly affect the market

[pipsdragon]

i prefer to combine it, because my strategy is combine pivot point with fundamental analysis and i have got good result.

[anubhavsingh]

Aaj kal market me fundamentals ka bahut zada asar ho ra hai..technical studies last kuch weeks se fail hoti ja rahi haoi aur fundamental studies apna asar dikha rahi hai
ye haal kafi pairs ke sath ho raha hai jaha pe usd base currency hai...like aud/usd nzd/usd xau/usd etc

[mayengbam]

Understanding of both the analysis is a necessity to succeed. A good trader relies on both technical and fundamental analysis. And both the analysis compliment each other. besides these sentiments of the traders is also a very important factor to consider before trading

[pipsdragon]

Understanding of both the analysis is a necessity to succeed. A good trader relies on both technical and fundamental analysis. And both the analysis compliment each other. besides these sentiments of the traders is also a very important factor to consider before trading

that is right, both of analysis is very important. if we can combine both analysis i think we will have best strategy.

[dead]

Understanding of both the analysis is a necessity to succeed. A good trader relies on both technical and fundamental analysis. And both the analysis compliment each other. besides these sentiments of the traders is also a very important factor to consider before trading

I agree with your opinion and when we can control both the analysis of this market then we will understand when working technical analysis and fundamental analysis when working

[soumen]

waise dono analysis ka ek alag hi maine he. agar koi dono analysis se trade kare to wo jyada profit karega. waise main abhi technical analysis karta hoon par abhi fundamental analysis sikh raha hoon.

[Mr. Tukul]

I much prefer to use technical analysis, because I do not really know about the fundamental news ...
Sometimes the price moves do not correspond with the news that came out, so that makes me confused ...

[pipsdragon]

I much prefer to use technical analysis, because I do not really know about the fundamental news ...
Sometimes the price moves do not correspond with the news that came out, so that makes me confused ...

in the fact fundamental analysis is very important like technical analysis, both of analysis is very important to learn.

[zoomfire]

I much prefer to use technical analysis, because I do not really know about the fundamental news ...
Sometimes the price moves do not correspond with the news that came out, so that makes me confused ...

yes,fundamental news will be little confusing,you cant figure out how much the news will have impact,so i feel that we should not have fundamental as primary one.
the impact can be less or high than the predicted one.

[pipsdragon]

yes,fundamental news will be little confusing,you cant figure out how much the news will have impact,so i feel that we should not have fundamental as primary one.
the impact can be less or high than the predicted one.

if we fell confused by news trading or fundamental analysis we can use trap trading strategy as the alternative.. :)

[shibilyt]

if we fell confused by news trading or fundamental analysis we can use trap trading strategy as the alternative.. :)

hm trap trading strategy :doubt: what's that ? i would surely love to learn that . i used to trade mainly on the news when i was learning forex. now i would love to get back to it again . so please tell me more about this strategy.

[zoomfire]

if we fell confused by news trading or fundamental analysis we can use trap trading strategy as the alternative.. :)

trap trading strategy?? well what is that? i have never heard of it. do you mean trading with news correctly and trapping the trend?? something like that?

[vicky]

if we fell confused by news trading or fundamental analysis we can use trap trading strategy as the alternative.. :)

I also dont know your mention strategy but i think its not hard to trade depending on news actually and if anyone find hard then they may atleast uptodate from news which is really help us to understand of that particular currencies economic situation . anyway with technical if we mixed this news then its really better.

[anubhavsingh]

if we fell confused by news trading or fundamental analysis we can use trap trading strategy as the alternative.. :)

fundamental analysis aur technical analysis- dono ki apni importance hoti hai aur dono aopni tarah se market ko effect karte hai..lekin jaha tak maien notice kiya hai, us hisab se fundamentals ke aage technicals fail ho jate hai..so i think fundamental studies are more powerful then technical studies

[Mr. Tukul]

now America and Europe are in a state of economic crisis ...
which should have both the Euro and the USD weakened ...
I'm confused, why USD participate weakened against the euro ... anyone can explain ...

[blackprince4u]

now America and Europe are in a state of economic crisis ...
which should have both the Euro and the USD weakened ...
I'm confused, why USD participate weakened against the euro ... anyone can explain ...

I think USD is weekened due to continuously increasing unemployment rate and the debts on US economy are really great.But its the same situation all over the world and the world's economy is in worst condition.So a wave of optimism takes the currency up and than again it comes down due to continuous bad economy reports.

[fravash]

in the past, i used to be a technical trader, but time after time, i followed fundamental more, i fount its easier to learn fundamental since we dont have too look many indicator in the screen, and market movement is dominantly from fundamental news

[vicky]

I also start forex depending on technical and also spend many time to understand to indicator but after few time i understood the impact of news and now trying more depending on news . actually where there is no news and if news far then depending technical analysis and entering market.

[cumil]

please note the news, news is very important ... even if you master the techniques of analysis, but if you do not notice news I am sure your trading will regret, because many traders loss often regret about news, I hope you guys could be be aware if there is important news ..

[vicky]

please note the news, news is very important ... even if you master the techniques of analysis, but if you do not notice news I am sure your trading will regret, because many traders loss often regret about news, I hope you guys could be be aware if there is important news ..

I am fully agree with you because i also think when there is very first impact of news in market then when it released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails , so i think its always good to check atleast important news .

[zoomfire]

please note the news, news is very important ... even if you master the techniques of analysis, but if you do not notice news I am sure your trading will regret, because many traders loss often regret about news, I hope you guys could be be aware if there is important news ..

yes what you say is correct ,because when the news is released,it will have a wild impact and no one can guess where the price will go to.even sometimes tech analyzes can not make out what news will tell.
so just have a mere look at news will help us a lot.

[ganguly]

Aaj kal market me fundamentals ka bahut zada asar ho ra hai..technical studies last kuch weeks se fail hoti ja rahi haoi aur fundamental studies apna asar dikha rahi hai
ye haal kafi pairs ke sath ho raha hai jaha pe usd base currency hai...like aud/usd nzd/usd xau/usd etc

[soumen]

yes what you say is correct ,because when the news is released,it will have a wild impact and no one can guess where the price will go to.even sometimes tech analyzes can not make out what news will tell.
so just have a mere look at news will help us a lot.
bro if you read the news and if u have fundamental knowledge then you may say that where the market will go. currently main fundamental analysis sikh raha hoon. agar fundamental aur technical analysis mil jaye to trading me ek bariya profit hoga. isliye dono analysis jaruri he.

[arjun]

I am fully agree with you because i also think when there is very first impact of news in market then when it released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails , so i think its always good to check atleast important news .

this is we must do every morning, and always install an alarm at the news with high impact will occur.
but if we always open a position with a good SL, I think even though there is news will not make us confused.

[vicky]

this is we must do every morning, and always install an alarm at the news with high impact will occur.
but if we always open a position with a good SL, I think even though there is news will not make us confused.

ya its great if we install that but i think if we see th economic calender each day of incoming news of that have or not than also better and i always do it and when see there is news not so far than sure wait for news and if see its still far time then start to short trade.

[anubhavsingh]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........

mere khayal se fundamental ke hisab se trade karna zada safe rehta hai
fundamental aur news ke aage koi bhi technical study nahi tik sakti
fundamenatl market ko zada control karte hai techncial ke comparison me

[denira]

short the trade all the time before the news ? what will happened if the actual news are better than the forecast ? i think its risky to just short our trade right before the news, if you are a fundamentalist the you have to wait until the news out and open your position based on your analysis

yeah that's really the style of a merchant or a fundamentalist in making trade at the time the news will be released they will wait for the news come out and see how the market response

[Mr. Tukul]

short the trade all the time before the news ? what will happened if the actual news are better than the forecast ? i think its risky to just short our trade right before the news, if you are a fundamentalist the you have to wait until the news out and open your position based on your analysis

fundamental news is more difficult to predict long-term ...
I prefer to use technical analysis ...
but if there is news I choose not to trade ...

[venkiaries61]

I don't know the name of analyze which i follow. I analyze through charts and time frames. Can anyone categories this type. This analyze helps me a lot. I also use some indicators to know the trend.

[makjon]

I agree with your opinion and when we can control both the analysis of this market then we will understand when working technical analysis and fundamental analysis when working

please share about how to combine between analysis and fundamental,so we can understand how to combine both on trading

[fravash]

yeah that's really the style of a merchant or a fundamentalist in making trade at the time the news will be released they will wait for the news come out and see how the market response
you re correct brother:)

fundamental news is more difficult to predict long-term ...
I prefer to use technical analysis ...
but if there is news I choose not to trade ...

i think the opposite, most of the longer term trend are created from cumulative of news impact, the example were 2008 recession when the market fall because of many bad news about credit default

[fravash]

maybe my lack of patience waiting for the effects of news in the long run ... because I always see the chart every day to cover daily position ...

its almost invisible brother, you perhaps notice it on your chart, but if you put a pin on every time huge impact news out then you will realize that news have many impact to the pair on the long run

[vicky]

Not all news has a long-term impact because you have some news that long-term and there were not a lot but can make the transfer to long-term trends such as the NFP

its true not all the news have great impact which we can see in economic calender of high impact and low impact but before i see high impact news have no doubt big impact on market but sometime low impact news also play great rule and for this if we trade with news then we need always careful.

[fravash]

yeah I agree with you because there is some news that has an adverse impact if it is bad news such as interest rates, the NFP and the like, and how we understand the news was not to get caught up in trade

and CPI, those 3 are killer(NFP is the main killer since it will make a pair jump of fall easily), to understand those news we have to put our self as the one who affected directly by it, like when NFP news out, we have to put our self as american people

[anubhavsingh]

that is right, both of analysis is very important. if we can combine both analysis i think we will have best strategy.

jis trader ne fundamenatl aur techncial studies ko combine karke trade kiya, wo hamesha market ko jeet ke niklega
forex market techncia laur fundamenatl studies pe hi depend rehta hai

[SG Trader]

Not all news has a long-term impact because you have some news that long-term and there were not a lot but can make the transfer to long-term trends such as the NFP

yeah, NFP have a short term impact, like today you can see your MT4 chart. besides NFP i think Halifax HPI, Services PMI news in gbp pairs have a same impact too.
maybe news has a long term impact happen because circumstances in a country, such crisis in europe recently

[cumil]

and CPI, those 3 are killer(NFP is the main killer since it will make a pair jump of fall easily), to understand those news we have to put our self as the one who affected directly by it, like when NFP news out, we have to put our self as american people

if there is news NFP, CPI and PMI I will wait until stopped, because thats news all my analysis technical does not work, thats news for me is news has a high impact
for NFP range of price movements :100-150
for CPI and PMI range of price movements 50-80

[bestlooser]

for me it is all about technical analysis and I have my own way of these technical analysis and it works and I just do not follow any kind of news too. I just believe that we can be stronger by depositing more and more money into our trading account. more money we have more power we have and we can play more safely without taking much of risk.

[anubhavsingh]

in the past, i used to be a technical trader, but time after time, i followed fundamental more, i fount its easier to learn fundamental since we dont have too look many indicator in the screen, and market movement is dominantly from fundamental news

fundamenatls to study karna kafi easy hota hai techncial ke comparison me
fundamenatkl news market ko bahut zada affect kartio hai..
techncial studies zadatar fudnamenatls ke saamne bekar ho jati hai

[cumil]

I was like-minded with you that we will not know where markets respond after news was released, and indeed the data are hard to observe separately at much better and will wait until the extent of the impact of the news

yes, that's the case, where prices will move we don't know, I had a trauma at the time the news was Realease, I'm trading with a relaxed and I think not considered that the effects of the NFP news could kill my account, and turns in an instant I lost my money and all mySL was touched , this is a bad experience, and I will never repeat again

[Mr. Tukul]

yes, that's the case, where prices will move we don't know, I had a trauma at the time the news was Realease, I'm trading with a relaxed and I think not considered that the effects of the NFP news could kill my account, and turns in an instant I lost my money and all mySL was touched , this is a bad experience, and I will never repeat again

I do not advise on trading there NFP news release ...
usually by the time the news was released the market moves very fast ...
if you keep trading on the news release, it is better to use pending orders ...
because if you try to order manually, normally it would be difficult to enter the market ...

[SG Trader]

I do not advise on trading there NFP news release ...
usually by the time the news was released the market moves very fast ...
if you keep trading on the news release, it is better to use pending orders ...
because if you try to order manually, normally it would be difficult to enter the market ...

we must focus on market 30 minutes - 5 minutes before news release
trapping or do a pending order in two position is the best solution to trade in NFP
i have best result in last news with this technic

[SG Trader]

I trade using both analysis as technical analysis tells how to do with price buy or sell .Fundamental analysis with Forex news is much effect in price movemment Yo can make profits in short time when forex news has arrived.

yeah both strategy it will work well, but if we are could focus with our strategy.
if me, i use both strategy but in different real account. i still fear with fundamental

[siddesh]

Technical analysis is all about speculation, which is actually the main reason why it is not 100% efficient.
The forex exchange trading is also the same way. All depends on speculation. But if technicals are used
well, it works and brings us profits.

[Ganesh]

i will say a combination of both technocal and fundamental analysis can bring up good results coz technical analysis is important but even the smallest change in market coz of news can make you regret a lot

[diesel1984]

Fundamental analysis :
- It takes time to obtain information.
- Characteristically subjective because it involves a lot of people's opinions.
- Difficult to apply on an inefficient market.

Technical analysis :
- Requires lots of data to support accurate prediction.
- Requires proficiency (read chart)
- More suitable to be applied on a long term trading period.

[realfun07]

Both technical and fundamental analysis are important and they both should be considered before the trades.Technical analysis should be considered before short term trades and fundamental analysis before day trade or long term trades.

[nsawork]

It really depends on the trader what type of analysis he wants to use so that the profits from the markets are there to stay with him.

When there is a major correction in the markets it is due to a Fundamental change which he needs to be aware of and when the market is moving in small or trading range of 50 pips then technical analysis will be the best bet for him.

[Ronak]

fundmental and technical analysis have its own value....forex trading is incomplete without fundamental and technical..most of trading analysis is based on technical while fundamental is the study of individual region economic stdyy..so both are important for perfect trading

[waheedpcc]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........
is sawal ka jawab dena although kafi mushkil ho ga, aik example deta hon ager cycle key do tires na hoon to nehe chel sekti hain na? to isi terhan hum ko technical analysis or fundamentals anaylsis done per rely kerna perta ha, lekan technical analysis kafi powerfull hota ha

[cumil]

Technical analysis should be considered before short term trades and fundamental analysis before day trade or long term trades.

is it true? trading with the fundamental techniques used for long term trades? can you tell what news do you mean? so I can more considered the news

[james]

bro in baby pips they say if u remove one anaylsis from the list you will fall down in to losses of from my point of view all are important

[Ganesh]

Fundamental analysis :
- It takes time to obtain information.
- Characteristically subjective because it involves a lot of people's opinions.
- Difficult to apply on an inefficient market.

Technical analysis :
- Requires lots of data to support accurate prediction.
- Requires proficiency (read chart)
- More suitable to be applied on a long term trading period.
very accurately and exactly explained yaar, yes technical analysis will be needed for long term trade coz it will be the perfect thing to do to know when to exit with the profit's of a long term trade

[anubhavsingh]

fundmental and technical analysis have its own value....forex trading is incomplete without fundamental and technical..most of trading analysis is based on technical while fundamental is the study of individual region economic stdyy..so both are important for perfect trading

well said bhai
fundamental aur technical dono analysis ki apni apni value hioti hai
inme se kisi ko bhi ignore nahi kiya ja sakta
lekin fundamental analysis zada zaruri hote hai market ke liye

[carimas888]

technical analysis may be complicated for some but once we get used to our trading strategy this tends to get a whole lot simpler compared to fundamental analysis.here we would just have to analyze the charts and make a decision from it.

[venkiaries61]

technical analysis may be complicated for some but once we get used to our trading strategy this tends to get a whole lot simpler compared to fundamental analysis.here we would just have to analyze the charts and make a decision from it.

I am not get you. Analyze the charts and decision is associated with technical or fundamental. I usually analyze with charts only. And 1h timeframe and with some indicators.

[anubhavsingh]

is it true? trading with the fundamental techniques used for long term trades? can you tell what news do you mean? so I can more considered the news

long term tarduing me news ka bahut role hota hai
jo tarder long term tarding karte hai wo lagatar news pe nazar rakhte hai aur long term trading wale traders profit bhi acha khasa kamaet hai kyunki long term tradinmg karke thdoa paisa kamana use less hai kyunki thdoa paisa to aap daily trading me bhi kama hi sakte ho

[rakesh]

Fundamental Analysis is all about speculation, which is actually the main reason why it is not 100% efficient.
The forex exchange trading is also the same way. All depends on speculation. But if technicals are used
well, it works and brings us profits.

[Ronak]

technical and fundamental has own value in forex..but since technical has more importance than the fundamental ..coz fundamental has limit ..it depends only on economy review while technical is based on many technic and strategies..so its widelyy used and accepted..than fundamental

[loserbynature]

I like Technical Analysis because for me it is easy to learn it rather than fundamental analysis. In TA I am learning 2-3 indicators so that I can earn a reasonable amount of profit. Once I become good in TA then I will think about learning the FA.

[BojanHajdinjak]

Trader have to know that fundamentals cant change direction few times a day.
Some less important events can produce "intraday noise" but fundamentals are changing slowly.
In such case technicals will always follow fundamentals. Of course not for scalper on minute chart.

[sanjeev]

You really have to monitor the trades while trading with news as the market becomes so volatile and it may go against you quickly. A newbie should avoid trading with news and keep on moving with technical analysis.

[Mr. Tukul]

You really have to monitor the trades while trading with news as the market becomes so volatile and it may go against you quickly. A newbie should avoid trading with news and keep on moving with technical analysis.

yes, because if we do a trade when there is a news release, all technical analysis can become useless ... so it is better at that point we do not do trades ...

[waheedpcc]

yes, because if we do a trade when there is a news release, all technical analysis can become useless ... so it is better at that point we do not do trades ...

what if an trader know news is coming and h know it`s impact and also he have knowledge to trade with technical terms and technical so it`s become use less and how i`m really surprised please let me know how

[Ronak]

You really have to monitor the trades while trading with news as the market becomes so volatile and it may go against you quickly. A newbie should avoid trading with news and keep on moving with technical analysis.

right bro....technical analysis has more accuracy than the fundamental....newbie dont know how trade with news since he is new to forex..so technical analysis good for whom who want to trade with certainity.

[denira]

Technical analysis really becomes useless during news hours and we should only look at the fundamentals at that time. Price moves very quickly during these hours and a trader depending on technical analysis can not earn any thing during these hours.

if you want to do technical analysis works well then you should avoid when the market there will be news released because when news releases are usually technical analysis will be a little disturbed and will work after the news was released that there are far

[Jazpa]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........

I think technical and fundamental both analysis are important for better career in forex trade. It is because only if we are great in both aspects, we will be able to make good fortune out of the trade. Most of the traders think technical analysis is more important because it deals mostly about how to make money. But it is also very important for us to know about factors affecting forex before thinking of how to make money in forex.

[Ronak]

I think technical and fundamental both analysis are important for better career in forex trade. It is because only if we are great in both aspects, we will be able to make good fortune out of the trade. Most of the traders think technical analysis is more important because it deals mostly about how to make money. But it is also very important for us to know about factors affecting forex before thinking of how to make money in forex.
yeah.......right.....most of trader prefer for technical ..coz it has more accuracy than fundamental..technical has technique to use of indicator and other theories of elliot and fibonacci...

[anubhavsingh]

yeah.......right.....most of trader prefer for technical ..coz it has more accuracy than fundamental..technical has technique to use of indicator and other theories of elliot and fibonacci...

aapki baat ekdum thik hai bhai
zadatar tarder techncials pe hi dhayan deke trading karte hai
me bhi zada dhayan techncials pe hi deta hon..lekin fudnamenatls pe bhi dhyaan dena bahut zaruri hai..sirf techncials pe depend rehke trading karna safe nahi hai

[sachin]

yeah what you say is true but I personally would use a trade that is safe to have a target of trade that has good results and that I think is the best way of trade

[akshayfuriya]

in the past, i used to be a technical trader, but time after time, i followed fundamental more, i fount its easier to learn fundamental since we dont have too look many indicator in the screen, and market movement is dominantly from fundamental news

[netra]

if we fell confused by news trading or fundamental analysis we can use trap trading strategy as the alternative.. :)

trap trading strategy?? well what is that? i have never heard of it. do you mean trading with news correctly and trapping the trend?? something like that?

[Ronak]

It is good if you are able to understand fundamentals easily. Most of the traders think fundamentals are difficult to understand. I think you will very successful trader in near future.

fundamental and technical both are important in ther forex..while most of the forex strategy depends on technical....coz it has accuracy..while in the fundamental there is only studies on economy..as i am newbies so i m weak in making analysis through economy..so i use indicators and some technics

[akshayfuriya]

I am fully agree with you because i also think when there is very first impact of news in market then when it released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails , so i think its always good to check atleast important news .

[Victoryindia]

I am fully agree with you because i also think when there is very first impact of news in market then when it released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails , so i think its always good to check atleast important news .

ya i also agree that when sometime news is released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails but for long term mai techinical analysis ko hi prefer karuga

[anubhavsingh]

ya i also agree that when sometime news is released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails but for long term mai techinical analysis ko hi prefer karuga

technical analysis fail ho jate hai news ke samne
kuch news ka bahut zada impact padtah ai market me aur market saare support aur resistance tod deta hai news ke waqt
isliye chote traders ko news ke samay trading se bach ke rehna chahaiye

[denira]

ya i also agree that when sometime news is released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails but for long term mai techinical analysis ko hi prefer karuga

technical analysis you can use to see how far prices will move and you can use fundamental analysis to identify the capacity price would be pressured to show directions in technical analysis

[gosians]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........

Mery khyaal sy dono analysis he boht zarori hen. Ap kisi ak pe pori trah rely nhi kr skty. Kbi kbi technical zyada importent lagty hen aur kbi fundamental but trading main pori trah kamyab hony k lye dono he zarori hen.

[waheedpcc]

technical analysis fail ho jate hai news ke samne
kuch news ka bahut zada impact padtah ai market me aur market saare support aur resistance tod deta hai news ke waqt
isliye chote traders ko news ke samay trading se bach ke rehna chahaiye
jiada ter log yehe sumjhte hain technical analysis fail ho jata ager news break out ho jae lekan aik good or effective trader janta ha keb trade ki jay jeb ne releasing k chnaces kum hoon, or support and resistance sehe terhan kam kareen,news ka koi pata nehe hota isi st jaroor use kerna chahaye

[ishvara]

I prefer to use the technical analysis in my trading, this is because it is easier for me to understand when i am trading. But i know for a fact that it is better that a trader uses both of the analysis methods and make their trading decisions for better market results.

[Mr. Tukul]

technical analysis you can use to see how far prices will move and you can use fundamental analysis to identify the capacity price would be pressured to show directions in technical analysis

between technical and fundamental analysis often opposed both ...
fundamental analysis is more powerful than the technical ...
if technical analysis provides a signal to buy but at the news does not support it, then technical analysis could be wrong ...

[SG Trader]

between technical and fundamental analysis often opposed both ...
fundamental analysis is more powerful than the technical ...
if technical analysis provides a signal to buy but at the news does not support it, then technical analysis could be wrong ...

you are true, sometimes fundamental news will changed everything
so we sholud to use both. technical are good if we are trade avoid the news

[mayengbam]

Both should go hand in hand. we should use both in our trading. fundamental analysis are the drivers and the technical analysis corrects the trade for us. If we are able to harness the powers of these analysis effectively we can make a good gain

[Ronak]

you are true, sometimes fundamental news will changed everything
so we sholud to use both. technical are good if we are trade avoid the news

both fundamental and technical is necessary in forex...fundamental is only related to news while technical is related to analysis on some indicators techniques . but both same importance in forex

[waheedpcc]

i think that technical analsyis is really better as compared to others but still we should combinationof boh analysis because market demand bth , like an man can`t feet on one leg for long time same the way we need both analysis

[chirayu]

Yes, fundamental analysis and technical analysis both have their significant importance in forex forecast. Most of the new traders depend on technical analysis because it is easy to understand and work out. Fundamental analysis is difficult to understand and follow because of its wide range of factors involved in it.

[SG Trader]

both fundamental and technical is necessary in forex...fundamental is only related to news while technical is related to analysis on some indicators techniques . but both same importance in forex

yes, if we combine the analyisis certainly the result is very good than use only one analysis. but is very difficult to do.
need more knowledge and experience to do it.

[greenmedia]

It's like two sides of same coin.
How can we separate them?
How well can we leave them?
So, the best thing is to master both at the same time and make decisions quickly and accurately.

[Ronak]

It's like two sides of same coin.
How can we separate them?
How well can we leave them?
So, the best thing is to master both at the same time and make decisions quickly and accurately.

yeah both are vital part of the forex trading..as anyone of them cant be ignored..both analysis makes our trading easy to perform..so technical and fundamental has own importance

[sunil]

Aaj kal market me fundamentals ka bahut zada asar ho ra hai..technical studies last kuch weeks se fail hoti ja rahi haoi aur fundamental studies apna asar dikha rahi hai
ye haal kafi pairs ke sath ho raha hai jaha pe usd base currency hai...like aud/usd nzd/usd xau/usd etc

[sunil]

i prefer to combine it, because my strategy is combine pivot point with fundamental analysis and i have got good result.

[gosians]

yes, if we combine the analyisis certainly the result is very good than use only one analysis. but is very difficult to do.
need more knowledge and experience to do it.

Surely agr hum dono ko combine kr k chalen tu hmari trading boht achi ho gi aur loss k chances boht km rah jaen gy. Kuch traders aisy b hen jo sirf fundamental ko use krty hen aur kuch sirf technical ko but mery khyal sy both are important.

[shahzad0able]

mayray khayaal say dono analysis ko use kerna behtar hota hay, agr hum sirf technical analysis ki bunyaad per kisi trade may enter hotay hain to ho sakta hay kay fundamental ko nazar andaaz kernay ki waja say hamay loss ho jaey, iss liay behtar yehi hoga kay dono ko use kia jaey, ye best method hoga.

[Mr. Tukul]

yes, if we combine the analyisis certainly the result is very good than use only one analysis. but is very difficult to do.
need more knowledge and experience to do it.

but better still are not trading, if there is a news release that has a huge impact as NFP ...
because at the time it usually does not play a lot of technical analysis, even less likely to be useful ...

[SG Trader]

but better still are not trading, if there is a news release that has a huge impact as NFP ...
because at the time it usually does not play a lot of technical analysis, even less likely to be useful ...

yup, i think nfp not related with technical analysis. a technical indicator usually give a wrong signal and unpredictable when nfp is release. i think NFP is the great news for fundamental trader

[Ronak]

Surely agr hum dono ko combine kr k chalen tu hmari trading boht achi ho gi aur loss k chances boht km rah jaen gy. Kuch traders aisy b hen jo sirf fundamental ko use krty hen aur kuch sirf technical ko but mery khyal sy both are important.

yeah..u r absoulately right....both has importance in the forex..for example. fundamental analysis says that price will be high of individual pair ..but how much will be high ..is not said by fundamental??...technical helps to determine level of price..so both are vital part of forex

[akshayfuriya]

we may be differences of opinion, because the trading systems that use a trader can vary, it makes forex even more attractive for the try and learn

[netra]

Technical analysis and fundamental analysis are the two main schools of thought in the financial markets. As we've mentioned, technical analysis looks at the price movement of a security and uses this data to predict its future price movements.

[ketan]

Both technical and fundamental analysis are important and they both should be considered before the trades.Technical analysis should be considered before short term trades and fundamental analysis before day trade or long term trades.

[vikas]

As a beginner i had been depending only on technical analysis, but now i also concentrate on fundamental analysis. Fundamental analysis has improved my results and i have better understanding of market movements now.

[aniket]

Fundamental analysis :
- It takes time to obtain information.
- Characteristically subjective because it involves a lot of people's opinions.
- Difficult to apply on an inefficient market.

Technical analysis :
- Requires lots of data to support accurate prediction.
- Requires proficiency (read chart)
- More suitable to be applied on a long term trading period.

i will say a combination of both technocal and fundamental analysis can bring up good results coz technical analysis is important but even the smallest change in market coz of news can make you regret a lot

[aniket]

well said bhai
fundamental aur technical dono analysis ki apni apni value hioti hai
inme se kisi ko bhi ignore nahi kiya ja sakta
lekin fundamental analysis zada zaruri hote hai market ke liye

very accurately and exactly explained yaar, yes technical analysis will be needed for long term trade coz it will be the perfect thing to do to know when to exit with the profit's of a long term trade

[sachin]

It really depends on the trader what type of analysis he wants to use so that the profits from the markets are there to stay with him.

When there is a major correction in the markets it is due to a Fundamental change which he needs to be aware of and when the market is moving in small or trading range of 50 pips then technical analysis will be the best bet for him

[Ronak]

very accurately and exactly explained yaar, yes technical analysis will be needed for long term trade coz it will be the perfect thing to do to know when to exit with the profit's of a long term trade

both analysis is needed for agreesive trading..because both has own importance in trading..while do u trade..technical help for forecasting future movement while fundamental stands for which way movement will be in future ???

[netra]

yeah, NFP have a short term impact, like today you can see your MT4 chart. besides NFP i think Halifax HPI, Services PMI news in gbp pairs have a same impact too.
maybe news has a long term impact happen because circumstances in a country, such crisis in europe recently

[netra]

we must focus on market 30 minutes - 5 minutes before news release
trapping or do a pending order in two position is the best solution to trade in NFP
i have best result in last news with this technic

[netra]

yeah both strategy it will work well, but if we are could focus with our strategy.
if me, i use both strategy but in different real account. i still fear with fundamental

[Mr. Tukul]

yeah both strategy it will work well, but if we are could focus with our strategy.
if me, i use both strategy but in different real account. i still fear with fundamental

I recently read a book, the book said that as a trader, an analysis that we must master the technical ...
whereas the fundamental only as an adjunct to analyze ...

[rajesh]

is sawal ka jawab dena although kafi mushkil ho ga, aik example deta hon ager cycle key do tires na hoon to nehe chel sekti hain na? to isi terhan hum ko technical analysis or fundamentals anaylsis done per rely kerna perta ha, lekan technical analysis kafi powerfull hota ha

[shahzad0able]

is sawal ka jawab dena although kafi mushkil ho ga, aik example deta hon ager cycle key do tires na hoon to nehe chel sekti hain na? to isi terhan hum ko technical analysis or fundamentals anaylsis done per rely kerna perta ha, lekan technical analysis kafi powerfull hota ha

ye aap nay zabardast misaal di. hamay bhi trading may dono fundamental of technical use kernay cheay, tabhi hum aik achay trader kehla saktay hain. kabhi kabhi aesa hota hay kay technical base per aik achi trade fundamental ki waja say loss bhi kerwa sakti hay.

[lovefx]

Both are essential for getting the right momentum.

[vikas]

fundamental analysis aur technical analysis- dono ki apni importance hoti hai aur dono aopni tarah se market ko effect karte hai..lekin jaha tak maien notice kiya hai, us hisab se fundamentals ke aage technicals fail ho jate hai..so i think fundamental studies are more powerful then technical studies

I also dont know your mention strategy but i think its not hard to trade depending on news actually and if anyone find hard then they may atleast uptodate from news which is really help us to understand of that particular currencies economic situation . anyway with technical if we mixed this news then its really better.

[vikas]

please note the news, news is very important ... even if you master the techniques of analysis, but if you do not notice news I am sure your trading will regret, because many traders loss often regret about news, I hope you guys could be be aware if there is important news ..I also start forex depending on technical and also spend many time to understand to indicator but after few time i understood the impact of news and now trying more depending on news . actually where there is no news and if news far then depending technical analysis and entering market.

[vikas]

yes what you say is correct ,because when the news is released,it will have a wild impact and no one can guess where the price will go to.even sometimes tech analyzes can not make out what news will tell.
so just have a mere look at news will help us a lot.

I am fully agree with you because i also think when there is very first impact of news in market then when it released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails , so i think its always good to check atleast important news .

[vikas]

ya its great if we install that but i think if we see th economic calender each day of incoming news of that have or not than also better and i always do it and when see there is news not so far than sure wait for news and if see its still far time then start to short trade.

[waheedpcc]

I recently read a book, the book said that as a trader, an analysis that we must master the technical ...
whereas the fundamental only as an adjunct to analyze ...

nehe ye sehe nehe ha dono ko proper importance dene cahaye dono h kam kerte hain ager ap technical analysis kia hua ho lekan fundematal nehe or news break ho jae to
like aik inssan two legs k bageer kam nehe ker sekta isi terhan trade mein ye dono analysis kafi bilkey compulsory hain

[vikas]

its true not all the news have great impact which we can see in economic calender of high impact and low impact but before i see high impact news have no doubt big impact on market but sometime low impact news also play great rule and for this if we trade with news then we need always careful

[ketan]

i think the opposite, most of the longer term trend are created from cumulative of news impact, the example were 2008 recession when the market fall because of many bad news about credit default

[ketan]

its almost invisible brother, you perhaps notice it on your chart, but if you put a pin on every time huge impact news out then you will realize that news have many impact to the pair on the long run

[ketan]

and CPI, those 3 are killer(NFP is the main killer since it will make a pair jump of fall easily), to understand those news we have to put our self as the one who affected directly by it, like when NFP news out, we have to put our self as american people

[aniket]

trap trading strategy?? well what is that? i have never heard of it. do you mean trading with news correctly and trapping the trend?? something like that?

[aniket]

yes,fundamental news will be little confusing,you cant figure out how much the news will have impact,so i feel that we should not have fundamental as primary one.
the impact can be less or high than the predicted one.

[aniket]

yes what you say is correct ,because when the news is released,it will have a wild impact and no one can guess where the price will go to.even sometimes tech analyzes can not make out what news will tell.
so just have a mere look at news will help us a lot.

[100c�]

No doubt news are very important for us but it is also right we don't know when news publishes and what will be the happened. One thing is very important what will be the react of the big eligators, who control all the market.

[nikhil_rrane]

No doubt news are very important for us but it is also right we don't know when news publishes and what will be the happened. One thing is very important what will be the react of the big eligators, who control all the market.
You should go to forexfactory.com for the great sort of knowledge of economic news as well as calander which help you to analye fundamentally. On that site you will get whole details of the news impact. Means if negative news come what happen and if positive news come what happen.

[newentry]

i prefer to combine it, because my strategy is combine pivot point with fundamental analysis and i have got good result.

it is good if you can combine your technique here...honestly, i want do that but till now i still in my old system, technical analysis and with this i got some profit and imaghine if we can combine them, that is a big bang

[shahzad0able]

dono strategies ko combine ker kay hi achi trade ho sakti hay. behtar or safe method yehi hay kay news kay qareeb ap trade mat karain, khaas ker aesi news jis ka kisi aik currency per kafi gehra asaar perta ho, keuun kay iss tarah ap ko loss bhi ziada ho sakta hay.

[Ronak]

No doubt news are very important for us but it is also right we don't know when news publishes and what will be the happened. One thing is very important what will be the react of the big eligators, who control all the market.

.new beginner cant trade with the news ..because less knowledge obstacle for trading with news..while technical has many indiacators and strategy so its easy to use...for beginner and newbbies

[sejun]

this all are impotent but Fundamental is so impotent i think. Because when i am analysis the market and your analysis is to easy when you analysis in fundamentally. you i choose this.

[hiren]

Technical analysis is best for me in Forex because mainly people and mere friends ko yehi use karte hue dekha hai.
because technically analysis karne se jyada deeply ja sakte hai understanding bhi easy se hoti hai.
my vote goes to Technical analysis.

[hiren]

yes u r right. future is uncertain so humko technical hi select karna cahiye.
humko pata nahi hai k next min. main proce increase hoga ya decrease hoga.
so ager technically dekha to hum assume kar sakte hai.

[kamla]

mayray khayaal say dono analysis ko use kerna behtar hota hay, agr hum sirf technical analysis ki bunyaad per kisi trade may enter hotay hain to ho sakta hay kay fundamental ko nazar andaaz kernay ki waja say hamay loss ho jaey, iss liay behtar yehi hoga kay dono ko use kia jaey, ye best method hoga.

[kamla]

ya combination of both fundamental and technical analysis will be better for you rather than using only one of them. this will help you earning more profit than by using only single

ye aap nay zabardast misaal di. hamay bhi trading may dono fundamental of technical use kernay cheay, tabhi hum aik achay trader kehla saktay hain. kabhi kabhi aesa hota hay kay technical base per aik achi trade fundamental ki waja say loss bhi kerwa sakti hay.

[kamla]

.new beginner cant trade with the news ..because less knowledge obstacle for trading with news..while technical has many indiacators and strategy so its easy to use...for beginner and newbbies

dono strategies ko combine ker kay hi achi trade ho sakti hay. behtar or safe method yehi hay kay news kay qareeb ap trade mat karain, khaas ker aesi news jis ka kisi aik currency per kafi gehra asaar perta ho, keuun kay iss tarah ap ko loss bhi ziada ho sakta hay.

[patil]

तकनीकी विश्लेषण विदेशी मुद्रा में मेरे लिए सबसे अच्छा है और मैं विदेशी मुद्रा में व्यापारियों की है कि ज्यादातर विदेशी मुद्रा के अपने विश्लेषण में पर भरोसा
इसमें कोई शक नहीं है कि बुनियादी विश्लेषण बहुत बाजार को प्रभावित है

[nikhil]

waise dono analysis ka ek alag hi maine he. agar koi dono analysis se trade kare to wo jyada profit karega. waise main abhi technical analysis karta hoon par abhi fundamental analysis sikh raha hoon.

[nikhil]

bro if you read the news and if u have fundamental knowledge then you may say that where the market will go. currently main fundamental analysis sikh raha hoon. agar fundamental aur technical analysis mil jaye to trading me ek bariya profit hoga. isliye dono analysis jaruri he.

[nikhil_rrane]

Fundamental analysis give you a brief view of the economy so that you can decide the trend of the forex pair according to that. After getting from fundamental analysis just keep your eye on the technical analysis, note down the pivot points so that you can place the trade at that points.

[patil]

तकनीकी विश्लेषण विदेशी मुद्रा में मेरे लिए सबसे अच्छा है और मैं विदेशी मुद्रा में व्यापारियों की है कि ज्यादातर विदेशी मुद्रा के अपने विश्लेषण में पर भरोसा
इसमें कोई शक नहीं है कि बुनियादी विश्लेषण बहुत बाजार को प्रभावित है

[patil]

आप आर्थिक रूप में अच्छी तरह के रूप में कैलेंडर जो आप मौलिक analye करने में मदद खबर के ज्ञान के महान प्रकार के लिए forexfactory.com जाना चाहिए. उस साइट पर आप खबर के प्रभाव के पूरे विवरण मिल जाएगा. मतलब अगर नकारात्मक खबर आने के क्या होगा और यदि सकारात्मक खबर आने के क्या होगा.

[SG Trader]

.new beginner cant trade with the news ..because less knowledge obstacle for trading with news..while technical has many indiacators and strategy so its easy to use...for beginner and newbbies

i think for newbie trader we should learn and do technical analysis firstly than fundamental, because fundamental is so dificult.
if we feel mastering about techincal we can learn fundamental and use the both

[rajid]

I think as a good trader should master both techniques. because if only one master to achieve the profit will be hard. loss if you do not give up and learn from mistakes loss and find out your weaknesses in technical or fundamental :good:

[realfun07]

i think for newbie trader we should learn and do technical analysis firstly than fundamental, because fundamental is so dificult.
if we feel mastering about techincal we can learn fundamental and use the both

It is totally the other way around as a newbie trader must first learn the fundamental analysis that form the shape of the market and then switch to technical analysis.Both are important and none should be ignored and both work hand in hand.

[vineet]

I think technical and fundamental both analysis are important for better career in forex trade. It is because only if we are great in both aspects, we will be able to make good fortune out of the trade. Most of the traders think technical analysis is more important because it deals mostly about how to make money. But it is also very important for us to know about factors affecting forex before thinking of how to make money in forex.

[zoomfire]

ya for fundamental analysis you must have enough time to work on it.and also i think fundamental analysis is somewhat difficult than technical analysis.so first try to do technical anaylsis and if possible do fundamental analysis.experiecne is also required for fundamental analysis

yes ,fundamental analyses wont be as accurate as tech analyses. fundamental gives over all idea but tech will be somewhat indepth. So a combination of both will give big results.

[kamla]

You should go to forexfactory.com for the great sort of knowledge of economic news as well as calander which help you to analye fundamentally. On that site you will get whole details of the news impact. Means if negative news come what happen and if positive news come what happen

[gosians]

yes ,fundamental analyses wont be as accurate as tech analyses. fundamental gives over all idea but tech will be somewhat indepth. So a combination of both will give big results.

I agree with your point, if we want to get more success then we must use them combine. Jb hum un dono ko ak sath use kr k koi position open krty hen tu hamen 80% yakeen hota hy k hmari position profit main jaye gi but agr ak use kren tu ye percentage reduce ho jati hy.

[hetal]

Sab traders kay liye economic calender watch karna zaroori hay. Aap agar news hours main trade naheen bhi karna chahty to aap ko news hours ki information honi chahiye taky aap in hours main apni trading skip kar sakin.

[hetal]

bro in baby pips they say if u remove one anaylsis from the list you will fall down in to losses of from my point of view all are important

[popatji]

I prefer to use the technical analysis in my trading, this is because it is easier for me to understand when i am trading. But i know for a fact that it is better that a trader uses both of the analysis methods and make their trading decisions for better market results.

[vineet]

please share about how to combine between analysis and fundamental,so we can understand how to combine both on trading

[bhanu]

aapki baat ekdum thik hai bhai
zadatar tarder techncials pe hi dhayan deke trading karte hai
me bhi zada dhayan techncials pe hi deta hon..lekin fudnamenatls pe bhi dhyaan dena bahut zaruri hai..sirf techncials pe depend rehke trading karna safe nahi hai

[rohi]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........

ma fundamental aur technical both analysis use karta hon. dono pe working karne ke baad koi trade open karta hon iss se risk factor kam ho jata ha.

[SG Trader]

I always go and favor technical analysis because it is the best tool that aid my trading everyday. I cant depend much on fundamental analysis. It makes me confused. What I liked about technical trading is that it is always there in your chart and you dont have to go other site to look up to it.

i think would be better if we can rely on both of them.
but it is not easy to do, because technical and fundamental analysis is very different

[voogoo]

I always go and favor technical analysis because it is the best tool that aid my trading everyday. I cant depend much on fundamental analysis. It makes me confused. What I liked about technical trading is that it is always there in your chart and you dont have to go other site to look up to it.

for now I'm trading just by using technical analysis, because I still find it difficult to perform analysis of fundamentals, I still do not understand it.

[narendra]

Understanding of both the analysis is a necessity to succeed. A good trader relies on both technical and fundamental analysis. And both the analysis compliment each other. besides these sentiments of the traders is also a very important factor to consider before trading

[narendra]

ya i also agree that when sometime news is released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails but for long term mai techinical analysis ko hi prefer karuga

[hetal]

ya combination of both fundamental and technical analysis will be better for you rather than using only one of them. this will help you earning more profit than by using only single

[zoomfire]

I always go and favor technical analysis because it is the best tool that aid my trading everyday. I cant depend much on fundamental analysis. It makes me confused. What I liked about technical trading is that it is always there in your chart and you dont have to go other site to look up to it.

what you do is not wrong ,but i feel that you should learn fundamental analyses too.Although you can trade with tech as primary analyses and you can use fundamental for verifying the signals.This will boost up profits and also increase confidence level.

[newentry]

I always go and favor technical analysis because it is the best tool that aid my trading everyday. I cant depend much on fundamental analysis. It makes me confused. What I liked about technical trading is that it is always there in your chart and you dont have to go other site to look up to it.

fundamental depends to the news and it needs ability to read the news with correctly, and this strategies need to wait for news is released and waiting is bored for me
so i prefer choose technical analysis, no need to wit, just make analysis and open position but have to be careful when the neews is released because it can be big fluctuation and it will be bad if the fluctuation move immediately and fast and also against our orders..

[bhanu]

I much prefer to use technical analysis, because I do not really know about the fundamental news ...
Sometimes the price moves do not correspond with the news that came out, so that makes me confused ...

[bhanu]

now America and Europe are in a state of economic crisis ...
which should have both the Euro and the USD weakened ...
I'm confused, why USD participate weakened against the euro ... anyone can explain ...

[s19]

with the help of techanical we can not say market will go in which direction. we just entr accourding to our analyses..
but with the help of fundamental analyses we can say that now price will move in up/ down dierection. fundamental analyses give singnal before for enter in market.
but for batter result we mixed both of analyses...because techanical analyses fail due to fundament analyses.

[bhanu]

fundamental news is more difficult to predict long-term ...
I prefer to use technical analysis ...
but if there is news I choose not to trade ...

[shah.zoor]

may technicals or fundamentals ko aik sath lay ker chalta hoon, ziada importance fundamentals ki hoti hain agr news qareeb hoon to. agr news qareeb nae hain to phir aap totally technicals per depend ker saktay hain. iss kay liay aap ko candlestick formation or indicators ki study kerni cheay. price action say bhi aap achi trading ker saktay hain.

[aryan]

between technical and fundamental analysis often opposed both ...
fundamental analysis is more powerful than the technical ...
if technical analysis provides a signal to buy but at the news does not support it, then technical analysis could be wrong ...

[aryan]

yes, because if we do a trade when there is a news release, all technical analysis can become useless ... so it is better at that point we do not do trades ...

[aryan]

I do not advise on trading there NFP news release ...
usually by the time the news was released the market moves very fast ...
if you keep trading on the news release, it is better to use pending orders ...
because if you try to order manually, normally it would be difficult to enter the market ...

[aryan]

but better still are not trading, if there is a news release that has a huge impact as NFP ...
because at the time it usually does not play a lot of technical analysis, even less likely to be useful

[aryan]

I recently read a book, the book said that as a trader, an analysis that we must master the technical ...
whereas the fundamental only as an adjunct to analyze ...

[aryan]

I think USD is weekened due to continuously increasing unemployment rate and the debts on US economy are really great.But its the same situation all over the world and the world's economy is in worst condition.So a wave of optimism takes the currency up and than again it comes down due to continuous bad economy reports.

[Anand]

Technical analysis is best for me in Forex and I see that most of the traders.agar koi dono analysis se trade kare to wo jyada profit karega.

[realfun07]

I recently read a book, the book said that as a trader, an analysis that we must master the technical ...
whereas the fundamental only as an adjunct to analyze ...

In the long term markets function on fundamentals so it is very to do fundamental analysis.Short term operation is doe on technical analysis so both technical and fundamental analysis are important and you can not ignore any of them.

[s19]

you read good and i think if you are master in technical analysis then you can earn some good pips even there are no news
with the help ot techanical analysis we made a good profit...we can esily find where we enter & exit. but if we aslo see fundamental analyses that bring more profit. with the help of fundamental analyses we have an idea about aparticular pair...in wihich direction it will be go,

[motiurbd]

Fundamental are the only data which moves market.. And technicals only shows how much it moved... without fundamental none should call as a expert trader.. You have to know NFP, Retail Sales Data, Interest Rate, GDP etc before executing any trade.. without fundamentals none can make good profit from this market..

[cumil]

Technical analysis is best for me in Forex and I see that most of the traders.agar koi dono analysis se trade kare to wo jyada profit karega.

I am same as you, I am trading using Technical analysis, it is more convenient than using fundamental analysis because by using this analysis provides many opportunities , we can trade with intraday, scalp and many other technique
difference with using a fundamental , if using this analysis should be wait for the news release then make trades, ..

[amit]

Mery khyaal sy dono analysis he boht zarori hen. Ap kisi ak pe pori trah rely nhi kr skty. Kbi kbi technical zyada importent lagty hen aur kbi fundamental but trading main pori trah kamyab hony k lye dono he zarori hen.

[jai]

Surely agr hum dono ko combine kr k chalen tu hmari trading boht achi ho gi aur loss k chances boht km rah jaen gy. Kuch traders aisy b hen jo sirf fundamental ko use krty hen aur kuch sirf technical ko but mery khyal sy both are important.

[krishan]

तकनीकी विश्लेषण विदेशी मुद्रा में मेरे लिए सबसे अच्छा है और मैं विदेशी मुद्रा में व्यापारियों की है कि ज्यादातर विदेशी मुद्रा के अपने विश्लेषण में पर भरोसा
इसमें कोई शक नहीं है कि बुनियादी विश्लेषण बहुत बाजार को प्रभावित है

[amit]

please note the news, news is very important ... even if you master the techniques of analysis, but if you do not notice news I am sure your trading will regret, because many traders loss often regret about news, I hope you guys could be be aware if there is important news ..

[amit]

yes, that's the case, where prices will move we don't know, I had a trauma at the time the news was Realease, I'm trading with a relaxed and I think not considered that the effects of the NFP news could kill my account, and turns in an instant I lost my money and all mySL was touched , this is a bad experience, and I will never repeat again

[amit]

if there is news NFP, CPI and PMI I will wait until stopped, because thats news all my analysis technical does not work, thats news for me is news has a high impact
for NFP range of price movements :100-150
for CPI and PMI range of price movements 50-80

[s19]

please note the news, news is very important ... even if you master the techniques of analysis, but if you do not notice news I am sure your trading will regret, because many traders loss often regret about news, I hope you guys could be be aware if there is important news ..
i agree with you that news are also important..but techanical analyses is more important.
with the help of techanical analyses we assume upcoming market movement but with news we got exectally movement.
many time techanica analyses fail due to news and some time with the strong news we can see very good movement more then 400-500pips.
so both analyses are important.

[jai]

is it true? trading with the fundamental techniques used for long term trades? can you tell what news do you mean? so I can more considered the news

[sunil]

it is good if you can combine your technique here...honestly, i want do that but till now i still in my old system, technical analysis and with this i got some profit and imaghine if we can combine them, that is a big bang

[krishan]

मौलिक विश्लेषण अर्थव्यवस्था का एक संक्षिप्त विचार दे इतनी है कि आप विदेशी मुद्रा जोड़ी की प्रवृत्ति के अनुसार तय कर सकते हैं. मौलिक विश्लेषण से हो रही तकनीकी विश्लेषण पर अपनी नजर रख करने के बाद, धुरी अंक नीचे ध्यान दें इतनी है कि आप कि अंक पर व्यापार जगह कर सकते हैं.

[chirayu]

i will say a combination of both technocal and fundamental analysis can bring up good results coz technical analysis is important but even the smallest change in market coz of news can make you regret a lot

[chirayu]

very accurately and exactly explained yaar, yes technical analysis will be needed for long term trade coz it will be the perfect thing to do to know when to exit with the profit's of a long term trade

[arihant]

I agree with your opinion and when we can control both the analysis of this market then we will understand when working technical analysis and fundamental analysis when working

[miracle]

since i start doing trading in gold i chance become more to fundamental trader. before enter market i use to see current information from website and what news that will show that day. diligently read news papers and see news about what happen in the world.

[sanjeev]

फिर दोनों मौलिक और तकनीकी विश्लेषण के संयोजन के बजाय उनमें से केवल एक का उपयोग कर आप के लिए बेहतर होगा. यह आप और अधिक लाभ कमाने द्वारा की तुलना में केवल एक का उपयोग में मदद मिलेगी

[narendra]

in the past, i used to be a technical trader, but time after time, i followed fundamental more, i fount its easier to learn fundamental since we dont have too look many indicator in the screen, and market movement is dominantly from fundamental news

[aryan]

i think the opposite, most of the longer term trend are created from cumulative of news impact, the example were 2008 recession when the market fall because of many bad news about credit default

[aryan]

its almost invisible brother, you perhaps notice it on your chart, but if you put a pin on every time huge impact news out then you will realize that news have many impact to the pair on the long run

[aryan]

and CPI, those 3 are killer(NFP is the main killer since it will make a pair jump of fall easily), to understand those news we have to put our self as the one who affected directly by it, like when NFP news out, we have to put our self as american people

[sanjeev]

फिर मौलिक विश्लेषण के लिए आप it.and पर काम करने के लिए पर्याप्त समय भी मुझे लगता है कि मौलिक विश्लेषण कुछ हद तक कठिन है की तुलना में तकनीकी analysis.so पहले तकनीकी anaylsis करने की कोशिश है और यदि संभव हो तो मौलिक analysis.experiecne भी करते हैं मौलिक विश्लेषण के लिए आवश्यक है होना चाहिए

[sanjeev]

फिर मैं आपके साथ सहमत हूँ दोनों विश्लेषण में माहिर forex.If में सफलता के लिए बहुत महत्वपूर्ण है आप दोनों विश्लेषण में विशेषज्ञ हैं तो आप शीर्ष विदेशी मुद्रा पर किया जाएगा और लाभ के बहुत कमा जाएगा

[bhanu]

It really depends on the trader what type of analysis he wants to use so that the profits from the markets are there to stay with him.

[sanjeev]

फिर निश्चित रूप से दोनों विश्लेषण बराबर प्राथमिकता दी जानी चाहिए तो केवल यह संभव हो सकता है आप लगातार लाभ कमाने के लिए और एक सफल व्यापारी बनने

[aryan]

I think USD is weekened due to continuously increasing unemployment rate and the debts on US economy are really great.But its the same situation all over the world and the world's economy is in worst condition.So a wave of optimism takes the currency up and than again it comes down due to continuous bad economy reports.

[weekager]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........
yar main to dono ko chak karta hnn us k bad apne analysis bhi leta hnn or en sab ko dekh kar apni trade open karta hnn es taran se mugh ko trade open karne main aasani hoti ha or kafi had tak sahi trade open karta hnn

[cumil]

and CPI, those 3 are killer(NFP is the main killer since it will make a pair jump of fall easily), to understand those news we have to put our self as the one who affected directly by it, like when NFP news out, we have to put our self as american people

high-impact news making the prices to be volatile, I am very afraid that if the movement had a very extreme,

I prefer to trading without news, so I can focus on my technical analysis

[chirayu]

I trade using both analysis as technical analysis tells how to do with price buy or sell .Fundamental analysis with Forex news is much effect in price movemment Yo can make profits in short time when forex news has arrived.

[raja]

I use the moving average indicator, forex trading is the work of an intelligent, traders trading only at home, or outside the home using windows mobile, forex for beginners is a mystery, because it is difficult to understand forex, for a master trader, forex is a money machine

[s19]

i have some of the traders who like to only trade when the news release and when there is no news then they will not trade. if you know how to trade with news then try to trade at that time because some quick pips movement at that time.
that trader is called news trader.. they have a good experience of news trading. they know which new will move to market in which direction. news trading is hard for newbie.
this is fundamental trading. but in my view fundamental analyses is for short term and techanical analyses trade will be open for long time.

[arihant]

nehe ye sehe nehe ha dono ko proper importance dene cahaye dono h kam kerte hain ager ap technical analysis kia hua ho lekan fundematal nehe or news break ho jae to
like aik inssan two legs k bageer kam nehe ker sekta isi terhan trade mein ye dono analysis kafi bilkey compulsory hain

[arihant]

i think that technical analsyis is really better as compared to others but still we should combinationof boh analysis because market demand bth , like an man can`t feet on one leg for long time same the way we need both analysis

[nikhil]

jiada ter log yehe sumjhte hain technical analysis fail ho jata ager news break out ho jae lekan aik good or effective trader janta ha keb trade ki jay jeb ne releasing k chnaces kum hoon, or support and resistance sehe terhan kam kareen,news ka koi pata nehe hota isi st jaroor use kerna chahaye

[nikhil]

what if an trader know news is coming and h know it`s impact and also he have knowledge to trade with technical terms and technical so it`s become use less and how i`m really surprised please let me know how

[jabrik1991]

technical or fundamental all depends on the characteristics of each trader. use of both is also a very special thing that is expected, given the fundamentals, traders can understand when the movement., whether it be an important moment to open, whether a moment that should be avoided, as when prices move because of news, traders should be care,

[kamla]

is sawal ka jawab dena although kafi mushkil ho ga, aik example deta hon ager cycle key do tires na hoon to nehe chel sekti hain na? to isi terhan hum ko technical analysis or fundamentals anaylsis done per rely kerna perta ha, lekan technical analysis kafi powerfull hota ha

[jabrik1991]

technical analysis may be complicated for some but once we get used to our trading strategy this tends to get a whole lot simpler compared to fundamental analysis.here we would just have to analyze the charts and make a decision from it.

but the price movements caused by news of great help in the movement of the long and the acquisition of a large point, a signal of a strategy technique makes anyone think sometimes upside down,. confirmation sometimes do not correspond with what is expected., but for better analysis technique and not risk losing big. .

[arihant]

No doubt news are very important for us but it is also right we don't know when news publishes and what will be the happened. One thing is very important what will be the react of the big eligators, who control all the market.

[jabrik1991]

No doubt news are very important for us but it is also right we don't know when news publishes and what will be the happened. One thing is very important what will be the react of the big eligators, who control all the market.

actually with the use of pure analysis we can see the movement in which direction the market will not need to see the news when it happens. but the most important news is a antipasi for our financial security in forex

[aryan]

Fundamental analysis :
- It takes time to obtain information.
- Characteristically subjective because it involves a lot of people's opinions.
- Difficult to apply on an inefficient market.

[speedy]

I like the technical analysis because I think it is easy to learn technical analysis as compared to fundamental analysis.I have no sufficient knowledge about fundamental analysis but started to know about technical analysis. After I learn technical analysis, I will start learning fundamental analysis so that I can become a good trader.

[hiren]

both fundamental and technical is necessary in forex...fundamental is only related to news while technical is related to analysis on some indicators techniques . but both same importance in forex

[hiren]

yeah both are vital part of the forex trading..as anyone of them cant be ignored..both analysis makes our trading easy to perform..so technical and fundamental has own importance

[jabrik1991]

yeah both are vital part of the forex trading..as anyone of them cant be ignored..both analysis makes our trading easy to perform..so technical and fundamental has own importance

an analysis technique and fudamental mutually beneficial. each fill a market movement. suppose that before the news was released. the trader must use a systems engineering. and when the news was released trader must understand the effects of a news

[s19]

both fundamental and technical is necessary in forex...fundamental is only related to news while technical is related to analysis on some indicators techniques . but both same importance in forex
i agree with you that both analyses are very important in forex trading. we can not ignore anyone.
but i see if there is not too good or bad news, only normal news than market move only some pips and market become normal after some time..its again following its natural trend.
but there is any bad/good news then market 100% change their trend..

[tibasingh]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........

main to dono ko dekhta houn phr bhi apne tor par he trade open karta houn app sona to ho ga na k mashwera sab se lo par karo wahi jo app ka dil sahi samghey

[dmambi]

As per me both are important and should be kept in mind by the trader. Technical analysis helps us to identify and predict the price movement in the absence of news and it has become most important for traders around the world. Also fundamental analysis can not be ignored at any cost which can sometimes override the technical analysis.

[jabrik1991]

the most important thing is that you should know about the market sentiments about the news that where the movement of the price will go and now where will traders move the price? then according to that situation you should start a trade.

a very important role in the story itself is GDP, cpi and inflansi rising interest rates, in which case we should really be careful, capable of propelling the news daily price range hinga 300pips, and when we do not use the appropriate financial management. we will lose the whole

[kamla]

yeah..u r absoulately right....both has importance in the forex..for example. fundamental analysis says that price will be high of individual pair ..but how much will be high ..is not said by fundamental??...technical helps to determine level of price..so both are vital part of forex

[nikhil]

both analysis is needed for agreesive trading..because both has own importance in trading..while do u trade..technical help for forecasting future movement while fundamental stands for which way movement will be in future ???

[hiren]

In the long term markets function on fundamentals so it is very to do fundamental analysis.Short term operation is doe on technical analysis so both technical and fundamental analysis are important and you can not ignore any of them.

[SG Trader]

In the long term markets function on fundamentals so it is very to do fundamental analysis.Short term operation is doe on technical analysis so both technical and fundamental analysis are important and you can not ignore any of them.

of course, but to combine it, i think is very difficult to do,
even some trader only using one of it, and they still get well result in their trade, for me i just using technical, but i hope i can use the both so i can make extra profit in this business.

[gosians]

new beginner cant trade with the news ..because less knowledge obstacle for trading with news..while technical has many indiacators and strategy so its easy to use...for beginner and newbbies

Mery khyal st b technical analysis best hen aue ye newbies k lye he nhi bl k tama traders k lye best hen kuch traders tu sirf aur sirf technical k hisab sy he apni positions open krty hen aur phr fundamntl ko dykh kr tp aur sl ko modify krty hen.

[kamla]

mayray khayaal say dono analysis ko use kerna behtar hota hay, agr hum sirf technical analysis ki bunyaad per kisi trade may enter hotay hain to ho sakta hay kay fundamental ko nazar andaaz kernay ki waja say hamay loss ho jaey, iss liay behtar yehi hoga kay dono ko use kia jaey, ye best method hoga.

[kamla]

ye aap nay zabardast misaal di. hamay bhi trading may dono fundamental of technical use kernay cheay, tabhi hum aik achay trader kehla saktay hain. kabhi kabhi aesa hota hay kay technical base per aik achi trade fundamental ki waja say loss bhi kerwa sakti hay.

[kamla]

dono strategies ko combine ker kay hi achi trade ho sakti hay. behtar or safe method yehi hay kay news kay qareeb ap trade mat karain, khaas ker aesi news jis ka kisi aik currency per kafi gehra asaar perta ho, keuun kay iss tarah ap ko loss bhi ziada ho sakta hay.

[nikhil]

its true not all the news have great impact which we can see in economic calender of high impact and low impact but before i see high impact news have no doubt big impact on market but sometime low impact news also play great rule and for this if we trade with news then we need always careful.

[hiren]

ya its great if we install that but i think if we see th economic calender each day of incoming news of that have or not than also better and i always do it and when see there is news not so far than sure wait for news and if see its still far time then start to short trade.

[hiren]

I am fully agree with you because i also think when there is very first impact of news in market then when it released it may break everythings and then technical analysis go fails , so i think its always good to check atleast important news .

[kamla]

I also start forex depending on technical and also spend many time to understand to indicator but after few time i understood the impact of news and now trying more depending on news . actually where there is no news and if news far then depending technical analysis and entering market.

[safeerforex]

Kuch traders technical analysis use karty hain aur kuch fundamental analysis. Aap kay khiyaal main kon sa analysis forex trading main kamyaab honay kay liye ziada behtar hay. Aur aap kon say analysis par bharosa karty hain ?

Please let me know...........
main to dono he analysis yeni k technical anaysis or fundamental analysis use karta houn kioun k en se mugh ko kafi help milty ha en dono ko dekh kar he mugh ko trade ki position ka andaza hota ha k sell ya buy karna ha ya hr ahi saber karna ha

[kamla]

ma fundamental aur technical both analysis use karta hon. dono pe working karne ke baad koi trade open karta hon iss se risk factor kam ho jata ha.

[SG Trader]

I also start forex depending on technical and also spend many time to understand to indicator but after few time i understood the impact of news and now trying more depending on news . actually where there is no news and if news far then depending technical analysis and entering market.

you are really good trader because you can use the both analysis which suitable market condition.
for me, i just use technical and iam so fear with news, some time i will leave the chart if there is important news in pair which i trade. better to me to avoid the news.

[atif58]

Basically i am a technical analysit. But i found it sometimes that this analysis fail , so often i require Fundamental analysis for successful trades. Means both of analysis are important, you should have command in atleast one and little bit of other.

[nikhil]

technical analysis you can use to see how far prices will move and you can use fundamental analysis to identify the capacity price would be pressured to show directions in technical analysis

[atif58]

technical analysis you can use to see how far prices will move and you can use fundamental analysis to identify the capacity price would be pressured to show directions in technical analysis
Exactly , i am agree with you. But one thing that i thought during my trading is market is based on fundamentals. All changes took place in prices are due to fundamentals. And technicals (chats etc.) are the record of these changings.

[nikhil]

if you want to do technical analysis works well then you should avoid when the market there will be news released because when news releases are usually technical analysis will be a little disturbed and will work after the news was released that there are far

[nikhil]

dono strategies ko combine ker kay hi achi trade ho sakti hay. behtar or safe method yehi hay kay news kay qareeb ap trade mat karain, khaas ker aesi news jis ka kisi aik currency per kafi gehra asaar perta ho, keuun kay iss tarah ap ko loss bhi ziada ho sakta hay.

[nikhil]

ye aap nay zabardast misaal di. hamay bhi trading may dono fundamental of technical use kernay cheay, tabhi hum aik achay trader kehla saktay hain. kabhi kabhi aesa hota hay kay technical base per aik achi trade fundamental ki waja say loss bhi kerwa sakti hay.

[yogesh]

Some time technical anlaysis can give very good returns in short term, but that is not 100% of time, though if we stick to good fundamental analysis it will sure give profit though may be in mid to long term.

[nikhil]

mayray khayaal say dono analysis ko use kerna behtar hota hay, agr hum sirf technical analysis ki bunyaad per kisi trade may enter hotay hain to ho sakta hay kay fundamental ko nazar andaaz kernay ki waja say hamay loss ho jaey, iss liay behtar yehi hoga kay dono ko use kia jaey, ye best method hoga.

[alvabra2010]

I would suggest using both because each of it has its own unique purpose. Technical are set on the basis of closing price and other factors, and fundamentals are set on the basis of news releases. I use both of them for my trading purposes.

[cumil]

I would suggest using both because each of it has its own unique purpose. Technical are set on the basis of closing price and other factors, and fundamentals are set on the basis of news releases. I use both of them for my trading purposes.

if in my opinion, I only use technical analysis trading course, I can not use fundamental techniques, cause im not master it, so I would avoid the news release rather than my trade messed up, i think if there is a high-impact news the price movements more wild uncertainty