Short term forex trading or Long term forex trading?

[voogoo]

true, I feel its also. Short term trading is better than the long term. I use scalping techniques, when it has reached a daily profit target then I decided no longer trading on that day.

I am also the same as you, conduct short-term trading makes me feel happy because I can take advantage of many opportunities that exist so that I can get more profit even though comparable to the risks faced.

[nitintripathi]

maine zyaadatar trader dekhe hai jo long term forex trading karte hain and usi mein believe karte hai but mai personally short term trading mai believe karta hoon
kyunki maine reason yehi hai ki capital kam hai to usse mujhe short term trading karni padti hai and kam risky rehta hai

[bestlooser]

well you are right people like me will always prefer long term trading after some real defeats in the short term trading. so I find that long term is easier for me and every one has his/her own ways and method of trading so short or long success is important and so people who are successful in short term should do short term where as people who finds long term is better can do long term.

[bhanu]

well said bhai
jo log regular forex kop monitor kar sakte hai unkel iye long term aur short term dono tyarah ki tarding shai rehti hai
jo log kam time de paet hai unke liye long term acha rehta hai

[bhanu]

aapki ye strategy mujhe achi lagi
small traders ke liye short term trading hi safe rehti hai
lekin sath sath uneh sl aur tp ko bhi use karna chahaiye

[aryan]

I do both long and short and its depend on market movement . actually i like short because it may give quick profit but here risk also . anyway its better to trade long and short after watching the market movement i think.

[chintan]

short term and long term tradings has its own pros and cons. some believe that short term is more profitable than long term and some believe long term to be more profitable.

but it is not as they think so, both can be profitable if we have the right techniques and follow the market closely.

so the important thing is the right technique/strategy, whether one does long term or short term trading doesnt matter

[Anand]

agar aapke pas jyada money hai aur aap bade loss ko zel sakte ho to hi long term jyada munafa kamaneke liye kar sakte ho.agar aap k pass paise kam ho to jaruri hai ki kam profit le k baha aa jao.long term me aap apne favour k trade me khade raho tabhi accha hota hai.

[gosians]

Mery khyal sy tu short term he best hy kiun k long term main kisi b wkt agr koi big news aa jaye tu market ki direction he change ho jati hy jb k short term main ap profit ko jald he apny account main add kr lyty hen.

[shah.zoor]

aaj kal kay fast door may aik trader ko forex market ki fluctuations kay sath sath tabdeel hona perta hay, isi liay aik trader ko versatile trader hona cheay, jab zarorat paray to short term trading ker lay or jab moqa milay to long term order bhi ker lia karay, ye aik plus factor hoga aap ki trading ki kamae may.

[vicky]

short term and long term tradings has its own pros and cons. some believe that short term is more profitable than long term and some believe long term to be more profitable.

but it is not as they think so, both can be profitable if we have the right techniques and follow the market closely.

so the important thing is the right technique/strategy, whether one does long term or short term trading doesnt matter
I am fully agree with you . its totally depend on traders and on his understanding . i also think both are profitable if we have proper knowledge and if not then forex is dangerous . i think we can open long as well short for quick profit and long for handsome pips but all is need to good experience and skill in forex.

[gosians]

I do both long and short and its depend on market movement . actually i like short because it may give quick profit but here risk also . anyway its better to trade long and short after watching the market movement i think.

Apki bat theek hy, short term trading main profit ya loss ka jldi he pta chl jata hy aur jahan tak risk ki bat hy tu risk tu long term trading main b hy but mery khyal sy short term trading he best hy.

[bestlooser]

basically forex is all about movement of prices up and down and some trends it always will not move in one direction as some time in one direction and some time in other direction. so we have to take advantage of that so in long term it is easier to hold your positions for longer if you have good money so you need to have big amount for long term.

[indra1991]

this kind of thing is a type of each. as only the traders who choose a system with scalping and traders who choose to longterm, and I think that choosing scalping traders are traders who have a lot of time so that it can always monitor the chart, in contrast with longterm traders because of time constraints

[realfun07]

I do both long and short and its depend on market movement . actually i like short because it may give quick profit but here risk also . anyway its better to trade long and short after watching the market movement i think.

Although both short term and long term trading are profitable depending on the trading strategy of a trader and market conditions but it is long term trading that brings most of the profits.

[indra1991]

I always target long term trading but my emotions make me to close running trade which i planned for long term,
so it becomes short term trading, One should have lot of patience to go for long term.

patience is not just my opinion. but the analysis is good and sufficient capital to withstand a long trend. so when we get a hit or a bullish trading bearish.akun we stay safe:)

[chintan]

main to hamesha long term prefer karta hu kyunki jitna kam position open ho utna hi tension aur loss kam hota hai, long term me hume zyada pips bhi milta hai

[chintan]

bhaijaan aapne sahi baat bolu hume 2 account used karna chahiye pehle account me long term wala strategy aur dusre account me short term wal strategy jiske hume faidya ho sakta hai

[hetal]

ya patience is the main factor which is required for long term trading which most of the trader lacks. so most of the trader prefer short term trading than long term trading

[hetal]

ya patience is very important in long term trading but i dont have that much patience so i always prefer for short term trading.Another reason is that i dont have enough balance in my account so i can afford to trade for long term

[popatji]

since my capital is low, i always prefer to trade as short trading...in short trade,maximum we can get profit..but we should not feel greedy while trading,if it is so we ll be a looser...

[indra1991]

since my capital is low, i always prefer to trade as short trading...in short trade,maximum we can get profit..but we should not feel greedy while trading,if it is so we ll be a looser...

I'm just like you, I am more inclined to play scalping in forex trading. because the capital that I have too little, in my opinion is a bold play longterm traders who have large capital. capital so that they can withstand the movement of prices. although I made a little but I feel happy.

[newentry]

ya patience is the main factor which is required for long term trading which most of the trader lacks. so most of the trader prefer short term trading than long term trading

me too, i prefer used short time than long term because i just have a little funds on my balance and also i really like short term, i can get the profit with fast and as long as i do with careful there is nothing problem with long term or short term
the conclusion is it depends to the trader what strategies will they choose

[SG Trader]

I'm just like you, I am more inclined to play scalping in forex trading. because the capital that I have too little, in my opinion is a bold play longterm traders who have large capital. capital so that they can withstand the movement of prices. although I made a little but I feel happy.

I also think like that. long term trading requires a lot of capital because they will hold up to hundreds of pips if you have the wrong position. whereas if we are short term trader such as scalping using small capital is not a problem

[indra1991]

I also think like that. long term trading requires a lot of capital because they will hold up to hundreds of pips if you have the wrong position. whereas if we are short term trader such as scalping using small capital is not a problem

and the obvious use of the lot shall be in accordance equity, because the use of lots in scalping still need to be noticed. like just a better use of small lots is safe, with an open position many times. than using a large lot but dangerous to our capital,

[bestlooser]

I also think like that. long term trading requires a lot of capital because they will hold up to hundreds of pips if you have the wrong position. whereas if we are short term trader such as scalping using small capital is not a problem

well yes you right money is required but do not you think you would also required big amount for scalping because you can lose in many short positions and in this case you were always better to have some long term positions and earn as much in longer time period but same sort of result can be achieved but ways are different.

[zoomfire]

me too, i prefer used short time than long term because i just have a little funds on my balance and also i really like short term, i can get the profit with fast and as long as i do with careful there is nothing problem with long term or short term
the conclusion is it depends to the trader what strategies will they choose

yes short term trading is more preferable than long term for people who want to make profits in short time and want forex money as a little income or a side income.long term trading is for people who want to make forex as full time job and earn profits in big amounts.

[SG Trader]

and the obvious use of the lot shall be in accordance equity, because the use of lots in scalping still need to be noticed. like just a better use of small lots is safe, with an open position many times. than using a large lot but dangerous to our capital,

I think in scalping strategy, we must have money management table in which there is a lot that accordance with the capital and our profit target. we can use a averaging transaction but the maximum is only 4 positions averaging if the initial decision was wrong. such as with $100 of capital we can use 0.1 of lot size in first trade and we can compound the lot size suits by our equity or balance. maybe will be better if we have money management and compounding table, usually the format is excell

[indra1991]

I think in scalping strategy, we must have money management table in which there is a lot that accordance with the capital and our profit target. we can use a averaging transaction but the maximum is only 4 positions averaging if the initial decision was wrong. such as with $100 of capital we can use 0.1 of lot size in first trade and we can compound the lot size suits by our equity or balance. maybe will be better if we have money management and compounding table, usually the format is excell

function of Excel itself whether to count our points every day. to make our account in accordance with good management. so as to achieve the target that is expected. and 4 positions that you say is take 4 open every day in accordance with what we expect. What do you mean that?

[bhanu]

for me its long term forex trading bcoz it gives good handsome profit to get it i alway trade with lowest risk forex is alway a long business thats y every trader should go for long term

[bhanu]

same with me, i like short-term trading. because i can't see my position floating till 1 week or more than....
my type is day trader. after closing all position daily, i can sleep soundly...

[bhanu]

if your target only 10-20 pips every day, you can choose short-term...
if you like fundamental news, you can choose long-term...

[bhanu]

yes it was good ... but remember, the amount that we put no more than 3% of capital that we have ... just to watch if you have a floating ...

[bhanu]

be careful, usually accompanied by a quick profit with the same risk of loss ...
you must be prepared to receive between them ...

[bhanu]

It probably caused you too often see price chart ...
if we want long-term trading, it's better when open positions using the TP and SL ... then do not be too often open the chart...

[aryan]

a scalper could produce the same amount with a long term trader in just minutes ...
because the scalper used lot bigger than the longterm trader ...

[aryan]

a trader who has a daily target usually do intraday trading ... because they want to achieve the target that's why he's doing intraday trading ...

[indra1991]

a trader who has a daily target usually do intraday trading ... because they want to achieve the target that's why he's doing intraday trading ...

acquisition target can be achieved by any means,. use of open positions sooner or later is the tradition of each trader. they are free to do scalping or longterm. fare because their objective is profit

[newentry]

acquisition target can be achieved by any means,. use of open positions sooner or later is the tradition of each trader. they are free to do scalping or longterm. fare because their objective is profit

you are right, no matters what's strategies we use for scalping, intra day or long term , as long as we can get profit as target so we can achieve our purpose and the important thing how we make it consistent,,,that's the problem

[indra1991]

you are right, no matters what's strategies we use for scalping, intra day or long term , as long as we can get profit as target so we can achieve our purpose and the important thing how we make it consistent,,,that's the problem

learning consistent 10 points every day I think it is difficult, although it can be by using a scalping, sometimes we are greedy and do open the transaction again, but what's in the can, we have MC

[dmambi]

acquisition target can be achieved by any means,. use of open positions sooner or later is the tradition of each trader. they are free to do scalping or longterm. fare because their objective is profit

Yes i agree with you here the main target is to get profit, whatever the methods we adopt. So if one is comfortable with Long term or short term they should continue what they find profitable, and no need to change for the sake of change.

[realfun07]

a trader who has a daily target usually do intraday trading ... because they want to achieve the target that's why he's doing intraday trading ...

There are different types of traders who have different strategy and use different style and methods for trading. So even short term trading is good like scalping and even long term trading like day trading or position trading.

[bestlooser]

@realfunn07 yes this is the beauty of forex that we can do in long and short terms and every trader has its own choice and we see some traders who successful in short term and some in long term. but yes they are different to each other long term is easier and short is more risky.

[s19]

@realfunn07 yes this is the beauty of forex that we can do in long and short terms and every trader has its own choice and we see some traders who successful in short term and some in long term. but yes they are different to each other long term is easier and short is more risky.
in long term trading the risk is less compare to short term trading. in short term trading need accurat analyses and update to market events also. if you miss one of them the result is not in your direction. while in long term trading no need hard analyses. new effect also less.

[indra1991]

Yes i agree with you here the main target is to get profit, whatever the methods we adopt. So if one is comfortable with Long term or short term they should continue what they find profitable, and no need to change for the sake of change.

true, the change in my opinion is just to make our time is up, because with the transaction strategy changes we make that time wasted. do you think traders who use longterm trading system is a trader who only trades with long-term monitoring as well. whether they use TF ranging from TF1H, TF4H until TF1day

[voogoo]

There are different types of traders who have different strategy and use different style and methods for trading. So even short term trading is good like scalping and even long term trading like day trading or position trading.

yes, I agree with you, every trader has a different way of trading, they will choose how and strategy that they find most comfortable thing to do

[bestlooser]

in shot term market can be so quick that you have to make quick and instant decisions and margin or error is very less so in long term as we see there will be more time and money required and easy to make decision in longer term so I think long term is far more better

[100c�]

in shot term market can be so quick that you have to make quick and instant decisions and margin or error is very less so in long term as we see there will be more time and money required and easy to make decision in longer term so I think long term is far more better

yes you are right if we want to go for long term then we can easily analysis the forex market and but in this situation we must have big money in our account in the other way if trade for short term then you have to keen interest on the current picture of the pair.

[narendra]

Well to be honest i don't use a sl.
I just do an in depth analysis and than open a trade.Which hits tp in 1-2 hrs and than i become free to enjoy.

[indra1991]

Well to be honest i don't use a sl.
I just do an in depth analysis and than open a trade.Which hits tp in 1-2 hrs and than i become free to enjoy.

but is not dangerous for your account. when prices move suddenly. I think better use the SL. just in case. because it is all to create success with good management. but if your analysis is really good. if you think SL does not become an obstacle, I think it does not matter.

[narendra]

Thats very nice.I am also a student and i want to earn via forex to make it my full time job so i am trying hard to learn it and one day i will be able to earn a good money consistently with forex trading.

[s19]

Well to be honest i don't use a sl.
I just do an in depth analysis and than open a trade.Which hits tp in 1-2 hrs and than i become free to enjoy.

may be its good analyses that your trade hit tp in 1-2 hrs. sl not depend on type of trader. trading short term ho ya long term ho sl use krna chahiye..
but its not batter to avoide sl. you should use sl it may be your maximum limit but use. there are many trader who lost their account due to only one reason dont using sl. once i am also.

[speedy]

I don't like long term trading because we have to wait for long to take profit. The world economic conditions are so much volatile and long term trading may not be so beneficial as compared to short term trading. I like to trade for short term as we get small profits daily to build our account gradually.

[realfun07]

in shot term market can be so quick that you have to make quick and instant decisions and margin or error is very less so in long term as we see there will be more time and money required and easy to make decision in longer term so I think long term is far more better

Both short term and long term trading have their own advantages and since different traders have different strategy and different trading styles , I would say both are good but long term traders make more money as compared to short term traders.

[aryan]

Every system that gives us consistent profits is good.It doesn't matters either it is short term or long term.every trader should choose his own trading style according to his capital,strategy and money management.

[bestlooser]

yeh to sahi hai k profit importnat hai but hum yehi baat kar rahe hain k profit kis tarah easily zyada profit liya ja sakta hai aur knosa in dono mein se behtat hai. you know both are good for diffirent kind of people but I like both but using long term nowadays as I think I can handle it easily.

[SG Trader]

Both short term and long term trading have their own advantages and since different traders have different strategy and different trading styles , I would say both are good but long term traders make more money as compared to short term traders.

i also think like that. a long term trader need more capital than short term traders, because when we as long term trader, we need a large resilience of capital, this happen when we getting floating minus too much, so the resilience of capital is large too. the profit target and stop loss is very large, so i cant follow this strategy.

[shah.zoor]

in shot term market can be so quick that you have to make quick and instant decisions and margin or error is very less so in long term as we see there will be more time and money required and easy to make decision in longer term so I think long term is far more better

Long tern is fairly easy than short term trading. aap short term trading kay liay bht sharp honay chaey keuun kay aksar market achanak bhi fast move kerti hay to os time agr aap proper entry na ker paeen gay to aik acha moqa zaya ker daingay.

[newentry]

Long tern is fairly easy than short term trading. aap short term trading kay liay bht sharp honay chaey keuun kay aksar market achanak bhi fast move kerti hay to os time agr aap proper entry na ker paeen gay to aik acha moqa zaya ker daingay.

you are right, but i think large margin is very needed by this strategies and how if the trader only have a little funds for it?i used scalping, intra day and also long term and i used them depended to the condition...
i hope that we get profit with consistent...good luck my friend

[SG Trader]

you are right, but i think large margin is very needed by this strategies and how if the trader only have a little funds for it?i used scalping, intra day and also long term and i used them depended to the condition...
i hope that we get profit with consistent...good luck my friend

you are good trader friend, because you can do both for any strategies in there. i want to know how about your amount do you have? because i think to be long term trader we need a large capital.
i only used scalping in my strategy because i dont have enough money. the take profit target are too small and the lot size also..

[narendra]

Actually long term trading and Short term trading both can give profit. It depend on market movement, history and economic calendar that which term did you pick. But long term trading is safer then short term but short term can make 2x profit but probability of high losses.

[realfun07]

i also think like that. a long term trader need more capital than short term traders, because when we as long term trader, we need a large resilience of capital, this happen when we getting floating minus too much, so the resilience of capital is large too. the profit target and stop loss is very large, so i cant follow this strategy.

Since long term trading or position trading is done based on fundamentals , larger capital is required so the trader does not have to even bother about 50 pip - 100 pip movement in reverse direction and has to continue with his trade.It has to be done properly with good analysis.

[dmambi]

Since long term trading or position trading is done based on fundamentals , larger capital is required so the trader does not have to even bother about 50 pip - 100 pip movement in reverse direction and has to continue with his trade.It has to be done properly with good analysis.

Yes long term trading needs a good amount of capital, also it needs good amount of patience to stay in the market for long time without any profit.
But still this type of trading is good for the people who don't have much time to spend in front of the Terminal.

[james]

Short term forex trading or Long ter forex trading? which trading do u prefer.aapke hisab se hame short term trading karni chaye ya long term kismai hame jada faida ho sakta hai??

it depends from person to person those who are into full tym buisness will do long term and those who do other jobs will do short term ....so profits wil vary from person to person ie traders.....and it will depends on you impliment your strategy with it

[bestlooser]

@Victoryindia
pehle bhi kisi ne yeh baat ki thi but aap ne yehi to batana hai k konsi trading aap ko pasand hai aur kyon but aap to comment hi kar rahe ho ke dono hi theek. koi sahi answer do ta k aur log bhi aap se kuch sikh sakain aur log confuse na ho , baqi bhi thek hai k logo ko dono hi akrni chahyie aur log kuch seekhne k baad khud faisla kar sakte hain

[cumil]

Yes long term trading needs a good amount of capital, also it needs good amount of patience to stay in the market for long time without any profit.
But still this type of trading is good for the people who don't have much time to spend in front of the Terminal.

if i have a lot money then I will do for longterm investment of gold, because for me gold is very good for the future, for now I do trade with the method possible short term, because it fit with my capital,

I will wait to be able to get a lot of money in this business so one day I was in the long term

[100c�]

if i have a lot money then I will do for longterm investment of gold, because for me gold is very good for the future, for now I do trade with the method possible short term, because it fit with my capital,

I will wait to be able to get a lot of money in this business so one day I was in the long term
Yes I also love to trade in gold but trading in gold for long term it is not better because if you manage your profit for short term then you can earn more other then long turn. Daily gold move minimum 30$ to 40$ and better to enter in reasonable point and exit on good profit.

[SG Trader]

if i have a lot money then I will do for longterm investment of gold, because for me gold is very good for the future, for now I do trade with the method possible short term, because it fit with my capital,

I will wait to be able to get a lot of money in this business so one day I was in the long term

but if you get a lot of money in forex it means you has been mastering of forex, i think will be better for you to stay in forex, but its depends by you.
altough gold is very good for the future, is too risky if we dont have enough experience to trades on that.

[gosians]

Yes I also love to trade in gold but trading in gold for long term it is not better because if you manage your profit for short term then you can earn more other then long turn. Daily gold move minimum 30$ to 40$ and better to enter in reasonable point and exit on good profit.

Ma apki bat nahi smajh saka k gold $30 to $40 ki movement krta hy. Ye dollars tu hmari lot size pe depend krty hen agr ap movement ko pips main btao tu jyada behtr ho ga aur ye k gold ki long term trading b boht fiada mand hy.

[anubhavsingh]

Ma apki bat nahi smajh saka k gold $30 to $40 ki movement krta hy. Ye dollars tu hmari lot size pe depend krty hen agr ap movement ko pips main btao tu jyada behtr ho ga aur ye k gold ki long term trading b boht fiada mand hy.

long term trading ke liye gold ko buy me rakha ja sakta hai
gold ki overall movement upar ki taarf hi rehti hai..isliye gold me long term trading karke paisa kamaya ja sakta hai

[Mr. Tukul]

but if you get a lot of money in forex it means you has been mastering of forex, i think will be better for you to stay in forex, but its depends by you.
altough gold is very good for the future, is too risky if we dont have enough experience to trades on that.

not about how much money is generated from forex, but about the consistency of money that we produce it continuously ...
if it is successful like that, then we think to stay in forex ...

[s19]

long term trading ke liye gold ko buy me rakha ja sakta hai
gold ki overall movement upar ki taarf hi rehti hai..isliye gold me long term trading karke paisa kamaya ja sakta hai
yes i agree with you..if we are investing in metal like gold & silver its give good profit for long term..becasue these pair has up movement. but in my view if we do proper analyses then we can go currency pair also.

[SG Trader]

not about how much money is generated from forex, but about the consistency of money that we produce it continuously ...
if it is successful like that, then we think to stay in forex ...

yes, if we has been like that with short term trading and then we have think change into the long term. what your opinion in this case?
or we has been success in forex and can get profit consistently but we are want to trading in the gold commodity. if me i just stay what i has been success on that. maybe i just learn for the other beside forex.

[vicky]

yes i agree with you..if we are investing in metal like gold & silver its give good profit for long term..becasue these pair has up movement. but in my view if we do proper analyses then we can go currency pair also.

I think its also have great movement when its go down. personally i dont trade gold and silver but watch both price which have great movement when uptrend and downtrend . so its really risky with low capital if we wish for long.

[newentry]

i agree with you, but the things is when we get profit, we will think to stay in forex, but when we got loss, we also might think that forex is not the best way to get some money. so for me, i try to get profit and withdraw it bit by bit.

so when you got profit every day and you make withdraw...hmmm good idea, i made withdraw once a week and sometimes i lost my profit too..so i do not made withdraw...alright...i will take my profit every day...this is very good idea

[anubhavsingh]

so when you got profit every day and you make withdraw...hmmm good idea, i made withdraw once a week and sometimes i lost my profit too..so i do not made withdraw...alright...i will take my profit every day...this is very good idea

profit ko withdraw karna bahut zaruri hota hai
jab tak aapka profit forex account me hi pada rahega aap usko looose kar sakte ho..isliye traders ko time to time apna profit withdraw klar lena chahiye...forex me ye bahut zaruri hota hai

[dmambi]

so when you got profit every day and you make withdraw...hmmm good idea, i made withdraw once a week and sometimes i lost my profit too..so i do not made withdraw...alright...i will take my profit every day...this is very good idea
Withdrawing the profit daily is not a good idea, you can do it on weekly or monthly basis. This helps you to trade long term with good amount of capital in th e account.

[SG Trader]

i agree with you, but the things is when we get profit, we will think to stay in forex, but when we got loss, we also might think that forex is not the best way to get some money. so for me, i try to get profit and withdraw it bit by bit.

good, we must routinely to make withdraw so it make me fresh.
if you can make withdraw for weekly or monthly i think is really good.
beside to make withdraw we are also must coompound our capital balance, so altough we make withdraw, our capital is grow too.

[simbagi123]

Short term forex trading or Long ter forex trading? which trading do u prefer.aapke hisab se hame short term trading karni chaye ya long term kismai hame jada faida ho sakta hai??

shourt time trading or long time trading dono ki apni apni ahmiyat ha app forex market k mutabiq he decide kar saktey hane k app ne long ya sort trading karni ha main to long term trading ko prefer karta hn

[shibilyt]

i used to do short trade before a few months but nowadays my time doesn't allows me to do it so i'm currently doing the long term trading , its really good and i find it working better than short term for me .

[s19]

i used to do short trade before a few months but nowadays my time doesn't allows me to do it so i'm currently doing the long term trading , its really good and i find it working better than short term for me .
its the most advantage of forex..if we dont have enough time we can go for long term...
In long term trading no need to do hard analyses...for long term trading success depend on only good money management.

[SG Trader]

i used to do short trade before a few months but nowadays my time doesn't allows me to do it so i'm currently doing the long term trading , its really good and i find it working better than short term for me .

do you always busy in your activity?
i think you can be able stay on short term if you can manage your time, so time management is usefull to not just a money management..
for me, i prefer short term and i just spend 1 until 2 hours per day.

[shah.zoor]

i agree with you, but the things is when we get profit, we will think to stay in forex, but when we got loss, we also might think that forex is not the best way to get some money. so for me, i try to get profit and withdraw it bit by bit.

ye achi baat hay kay aap apna profit withdraw ker lay tay hain , mjhe bhi aik trader nay aesa hi kaha tha kay jab bhi kch profit hoon to withdraw ker liay karo laykin may nay aesa nae kia or result ye hua kay sab ka sab loss ker liay, jab ap ko profit hota hay to phir ap ki equity barh jati hay or phir bari lot may trade kernay ko dil kerta hay or phir agr loss ho jaey to sab loss ho jaata hay.

[SG Trader]

you are saying good my friend and i think as you said that weekly or monthly basis is the good option to trade well and i think the good option is to withdraw the money on weekly basis

yes i agree with you, we must withdraw the money on weekly basis because in my opinion we must growing our capital with compounding.
while, i not yet to make withdraw routinely because sometime i became loss. i hope i will not get margin call again in the next trade because i has been tired of it. i will try the best in this business

[realfun07]

you are saying good my friend and i think as you said that weekly or monthly basis is the good option to trade well and i think the good option is to withdraw the money on weekly basis

It is good to do short term trading or achieve short term targets and withdraw your money on weekly basis after leaving some funds for trading.Do not trade with profits you earn and always withdraw them on weekly basis.

[dmambi]

It is good to do short term trading or achieve short term targets and withdraw your money on weekly basis after leaving some funds for trading.Do not trade with profits you earn and always withdraw them on weekly basis.

I think this way trading will not be useful in the long run, since in Forex trading the risk of loosing money is always there, we never know when we need the margin money to hold our loosing positions. So i feel it is better to have some money in the account for back up purpose. So we should do partial withdrawal of the profit we get.

[Ronak]

It is good to do short term trading or achieve short term targets and withdraw your money on weekly basis after leaving some funds for trading.Do not trade with profits you earn and always withdraw them on weekly basis.
for those who has less knowledge and experience can trade in short term...long time trading needs more knolwedge and experience and all trader could not ready for this ..so better to start live trading with short term .,

[jai]

If you have enough time to sit in front of your P.C and charts then you need to do short term trading because because short term trading can bring more pips for us but if we have not enough time then long term is best but long term trading is some difficult.

[amit]

Weekly target i think that it`s good because it`s allow me to remain in good mood and we have plenty of time to get a good opportunity whereas ager hum daily target main jaen to humhein force k sath trader kerni perthi or loss ho kata ha , well main compundng ko prefer kerta hun at least achi equity he se achi earning ho sekti ha

[amit]

Well it`s on just like a greediness factor involve there then because i think that if you want to make a good amount of money then it`s necessary for you to do trade in the right way what`s my exactly mean to say that don`t make a short trade all the time if you use big time frame then you can easily achieve what`s you want

[jai]

Apki bat bilkul theek hy. Long term trading k lye boht sy analysis krny prty hen jis k lye boht sa knowledge and experience hona zarori hy. Long term trading is not suitable for newbies they should do short term.

[jai]

Ma tu short term trader hon aur short term trading ko he like krta hon. Ap daily apni sari positions close kr k apna profit or loss calculate kr skty hen aur next day ak new plan k sath market main aa skty hen. Long term trading krny k lye boht experience ki zarorat hy.

[krishan]

यह व्यापारी व्यापारी पर निर्भर करता है ..
विभिन्न व्यापारी के लिए खुला है और दैनिक आधार पर सौदों को बंद जबकि कई व्यापारियों कई सप्ताह या महीनों के लिए प्रतीक्षा क्रम में बड़ा लाभ मिल का मानना ​​है ..
व्यापार के दोनों तरीकों समान रूप से अच्छे हैं और यह व्यापारी द्वारा स्वयं निर्णय लिया है ..

[amit]

ya better make such choices, I was do not know about trading with the long term,
if the longterm how much should require funds ?

[s19]

ya better make such choices, I was do not know about trading with the long term,
if the longterm how much should require funds ?
Well in my view thinking about fund after analyses the trade...
fund problem you can solved with using high leverage...you analyses according to you stop loss pips..
In my view this the minimum balance that your trade have sufficient balance for touching your stop loss...

[jai]

why would you say that the long term has a less risk? give me a reason? I think about the big or small the risk not on longterm or short term, but lies in money management, if you have good money management, then there is no problem with the risk of longterm or short term
if about longterm can get huge profits must be in capital used, and usually longterm must have big fund

[tristia]

short trading is only using when i don't have many times in market
but when i have many times to trading in market i'm prefer to trading in long term
because i can make more profit in long term almost more than 100 pips

[goodthought4]

Experience people says " IF YOU WANT MORE PROFIT THEN INVEST MORE MONEY" and if you are investing more money then you have to be long term trader,but right now i am short term trader as i am not having more money to invest but i am planning for long term trader ship in future.

[sithara]

I'm still a beginner .So I'd like to trade in the short term.In fact i'd like day trading.But i have read most of the professional traders (rather investors) uses long term trading.They look at the fundamentals and trading with the long term trend targeting large profits. But for beginners like myself i think it is better to go for short term trading. Because then we will be able to survive in this high volatility market. And I'm comfortable with Shot term trading

[s19]

ye to trader par depend karta hai ki uska risk factor kya hai. mere hisab se long term trading jyada acha hai usme profit jyada hota hai.
i dont think that long term me jyda profit hota hai..
ya its true that we will close trde in profit. here i see many trader they got good number of pips in a scalping trading..some trader got more then 20-30% per months.
in short term traidng we got more chance for traidng but in long term we got only one chance.

[sasa0220]

I'd like short term trading. In fact most of the time i'm trading in the H1 and H4 chart. It is easy to trade because we don't have to wait for a long time to collect the profit.I have put daily targets and trying to achieve them. It also give me the opportunity to trade on many trend of a single currency pair.

[sunil]

i agree with you and i choose short term as my strategies because with this i can get profit with safe
no need longer time to wait for profit and of course it is so simple and easy to predict...
but we have to be careful for this strategies when we think that we need to double our volume to get big profit...we have to know what we do and the market condition

[sunil]

i do not like to open position for long term, i have no big margin to hold floating minus...so i take scalping or short time and i think this is easy and simple to do, no need much time to get profit and also with just a little money, we can start to get profit...
happy trading...and keep profit

[cumil]

i do not like to open position for long term, i have no big margin to hold floating minus...so i take scalping or short time and i think this is easy and simple to do, no need much time to get profit and also with just a little money, we can start to get profit...
happy trading...and keep profit

its good for beginners to trade short-time, with consideration of:
- The limited funds
- Lack of experience
- increase the balance
- To improve the analysis capability

[eddis]

for me trading with short term is more profitable, because can make more transaction
we can get rabate and also get profit from transaction in forex market
trading with big system is very good if using short term

[SG Trader]

i do not like to open position for long term, i have no big margin to hold floating minus...so i take scalping or short time and i think this is easy and simple to do, no need much time to get profit and also with just a little money, we can start to get profit...
happy trading...and keep profit

good, iam also using scalping techinique in my trade,
i think is very good strategy and its very simple, because we are only make or take a few pips in a day. you should not greed when do scalping. because this is always done by trader.

[krishan]

मुझे लगता है कि लंबी अवधि के व्यापार आप भी लंबे समय के लिए व्यापार कर सकते हैं छोटी राशि के साथ बड़ा संतुलन की आवश्यकता होती है, लेकिन वहाँ एक शर्त है कि आप कम मात्रा का उपयोग करें और हमेशा की प्रवृत्ति के साथ व्यापार की जगह है.

[krishan]

हाँ, तुम ठीक कह रहे हैं.लोगों को समय के सबसे अधिक के लिए अल्पावधि व्यापार के साथ नहीं जाना है, लेकिन वे दीर्घकालिक व्यापार भी करना है. क्योंकि अगर मुद्रा की आर्थिक हालत कमजोर है या इस से अच्छा है कि हम प्रवृत्ति का फैसला है और लंबे समय के लिए हमारी स्थिति को बनाये रखने के. मुझे लगता है कि लंबे समय में हम अल्पावधि से अधिक वापस मिल जाएगा.

[sanjeev]

अल्पावधि व्यापार अच्छा coz हम वहाँ कुछ pips का आनंद लें बैठने के लिए और फिर बंद कर सकते हैं ले लेकिन लंबी अवधि के व्यापार में हम बाजार और समाचार बुनियादी बातों पर बहुत अधिक ध्यान आकर्षित किया है और दीर्घकालिक व्यापार भी कुछ अच्छे हाथ कुछ राशि का पुल रणनीति requeires की जरूरत हैइसे से लाभ.

[krishan]

मैं भी लंबे समय तक ट्रेडों जो मैं सप्ताह या दिनों की जोड़ी के अंत तक खत्म, और H4 चार्ट में भी कभी कभी उझकना करने के लिए एक पूर्वावलोकन मिलता है अगर इतनी लेकिन जाने चार्ट्स coz के किसी भी और कभी नहीं यह सिर्फ increses लिए D1 चार्ट का उपयोग करेंभ्रम और भी लंबी अवधि के व्यापार के लिए एक बहुत बुरा

[chirayu]

not necessarily short term trading is that scary buddy coz in short term trade you need to keep focus on the trend and also incoming news updates, you can even gain with short term trade yes but not how much you can on a long term trade but you can benefit

[chirayu]

according to me short term trading gives small profits and long term trades give more profits so its very simple then which you want to select .......but some guys even meke large profits from least time.......i still gotta learn tht

[shibilyt]

not necessarily short term trading is that scary buddy coz in short term trade you need to keep focus on the trend and also incoming news updates, you can even gain with short term trade yes but not how much you can on a long term trade but you can benefit

Long term trading is pretty good but we can't just ignore the short term trading it's also a good way to trade. It's just that you need to know the shit about how to make it really work for you ., It's the decision of the trader which one of these shall be adopted by them.

[zoomfire]

according to me short term trading gives small profits and long term trades give more profits so its very simple then which you want to select .......but some guys even meke large profits from least time.......i still gotta learn tht
well it is not like that some times some people earn big profits from short term trading. and some people take long time to make small profits.So the question is you like to trade in forex for long time or short time.

[bestlooser]

according to me short term trading gives small profits and long term trades give more profits so its very simple then which you want to select .......but some guys even meke large profits from least time.......i still gotta learn tht

in long term yes we may get big profits and we need to give some time but we may have to make less effort and as short term trading can be tense and this is why i am big fan of long trading right from start and trying different strategies for long term. and yes results can be achieved there as good as short term and even bette.r

[arihant]

are otherwise accustomed to trading with long time then we will never open a position in more than one day because I do not ever open a position in one day however the results

[arihant]

with profit 20 pips per day I think it was enough to make you rich from your forex and manage money just waiting there to be larger by the day

[arihant]

yeah if you use a lot size greater then meets these demands can maximize your profits even in a small number of pips but must be careful to balance the margin

[amit]

I think its also have great movement when its go down. personally i dont trade gold and silver but watch both price which have great movement when uptrend and downtrend . so its really risky with low capital if we wish for long.

[amit]

I am fully agree with you . its totally depend on traders and on his understanding . i also think both are profitable if we have proper knowledge and if not then forex is dangerous . i think we can open long as well short for quick profit and long for handsome pips but all is need to good experience and skill in forex.

[sanjeev]

फिर धैर्य मुख्य कारक है जो दीर्घकालिक व्यापार जो व्यापारी की सबसे अभाव के लिए आवश्यक है है. तो व्यापारी का सबसे लंबी अवधि के व्यापार की तुलना में अल्पावधि व्यापार पसंद करते हैं

[sanjeev]

फिर सभी व्यापारियों चाहे वह अल्पावधि व्यापार या दीर्घकालिक व्यापार करना चाहता है पर निर्भर अपनी. अगर वह छोटे पूंजी निवेश करके अच्छा ज्ञान और अनुभव है तो केवल वह अल्पावधि का उपयोग करके अच्छा लाभ कमा लेकिन लंबे समय के लिए वह बड़ा पूंजी निवेश की आवश्यकता होगी कर सकते हैं

[bhanu]

Even when using the short term trading we have to remain focused on the long term trends in the markets. I have been trading using the H1 charts and the trends but to tell you the truth it is only the Long term trading that is the most profitable trading option provided you have the required margins for doing so.

[sanjeev]

फिर मैं आप के साथ सहमत हैं कि दोनों अल्पकालिक और दीर्घकालिक व्यापार ही knolwedge और experinece लाभ कमाने की जरूरत है. यह कहना गलत है कि केवल लंबे trem व्यापारी experinece की आवश्यकता

[sanjeev]

फिर अगर आप समय है, तो आप लंबी अवधि के व्यापार करते हैं क्योंकि दीर्घकालिक व्यापार द्वारा आप अल्पावधि व्यापार के अधिक से अधिक लाभ कमा सकते हैं चाहिए, लेकिन अगर आप छोटे से समय मिलता है तो आप शॉट अवधि के व्यापार के लिए जा सकते हैं

[sanjeev]

फिर अपने अच्छे विचार के लिए हर दिन लाभ वापस लेने क्योंकि अगर हम न वापस लेने का तो वहाँ है कि लाभ लाभ रखने also.but lossing की संभावना भी फायदेमंद है क्योंकि यह आप निवेश बढ़ाने के लिए और आप बड़ा बहुत आकार के साथ व्यापार करने में मदद

[weekager]

Short term forex trading or Long ter forex trading? which trading do u prefer.aapke hisab se hame short term trading karni chaye ya long term kismai hame jada faida ho sakta hai??

yara ye app k apne style par he depend karta ha or dosra or dosra jese app ko sahulat hoti ha app wese he trading karo lekin main ziyada long term trading karta hnn kioun k es main app ko profit ziyada milta ha

[sanjeev]

फिर व्यापार सोने और चांदी के बहुत ही जोखिम भरा हो सकता है क्योंकि हमारे सरल संकेतकों और संकेत का कोई फायदा नहीं हो सकता है. यह अच्छा विश्लेषण तो व्यापार करने के लिए केवल यह संभव है के लिए सोने और चांदी के साथ लाभ कमाने की आवश्यकता

[s19]

yara ye app k apne style par he depend karta ha or dosra or dosra jese app ko sahulat hoti ha app wese he trading karo lekin main ziyada long term trading karta hnn kioun k es main app ko profit ziyada milta ha
i am not agree with you that in long term we make a hug profit compare to short term trading.
In my view if any one have a good scalping trading strategy then he make more profit comparing to long term trading.

[Anand]

Aapko jis me sabse jyada se jyada munafa or Accuracy mile wohi aapke liye accha hota hai.koi Long term position banake kamata hai to koi short term.

[aryan]

Every system that gives us consistent profits is good.It doesn't matters either it is short term or long term.every trader should choose his own trading style according to his capital,strategy and money management.

[cumil]

i am not agree with you that in long term we make a hug profit compare to short term trading.
In my view if any one have a good scalping trading strategy then he make more profit comparing to long term trading.

sometimes I fell really good doing scalp in a demo account, but if in real account is too difficult to get profit, in the demo I was able to produce many green pips whereas if the real truly disappointing result may be in a demo account was loose and there is no responsibility in managing the accounts so emotions influence decision of transactions,

I do not know if I am trading using scalping technique full of ambition and emotion, then I strongly prefer to deal with long term

[blackprince4u]

sometimes I fell really good doing scalp in a demo account, but if in real account is too difficult to get profit, in the demo I was able to produce many green pips whereas if the real truly disappointing result may be in a demo account was loose and there is no responsibility in managing the accounts so emotions influence decision of transactions,

I do not know if I am trading using scalping technique full of ambition and emotion, then I strongly prefer to deal with long term

Yes there is a difference in demo and real. In demo we do not care about money but in real we have fear of losing money and that fear is the main cause of our losses. Also we got emotional when we see our account floating in negative.But its a natural thing and to succeed we have to overcome our emotions and fear.

[chirayu]

But long term is best if have large margin to to stop call of .Its make large profits ranging from 100-1000 pips if open trade for 4-10 months.But its possible to earn even in short time.

[raja]

when determining the exit strategy is sometimes we are wrong in terms of its placement position and when out of the market we often late with the time that we use ..
to that required discipline and habits we are in a set position when going out of the strategy that we use in the Forex market

[bestlooser]

Yes there is a difference in demo and real. In demo we do not care about money but in real we have fear of losing money and that fear is the main cause of our losses. Also we got emotional when we see our account floating in negative.But its a natural thing and to succeed we have to overcome our emotions and fear.
yes live and demo can not be same because live money will test your emotions so to test emotions you may have to do with live and you may lose some money in process of gaining experience. it is all about patience and why do not you go for long term there you would only require patience and your patience will earn you money

[arihant]

ye aik misconception ha k long term trade mein jiada experience k need hoti ha instead short mein hoti ha kuin ap ko fastly decision lene perte hain or long term me jiada stress nehe hota bus ager apko pata ho ga keb buy kareen or keb sell

[arihant]

Well i think that novice trader should select an reliable style on which he or she can do trade easily, in short term trading to handle your position is too much hard because i`m facing tis problem as newbie
One thing that i want to tell you that there is no consistent profit in this market

[kanwaljit]

forex markets move so rapidly and change directions so fast that it is best to go for short term scalping trade, because then you move in and out real fast and are able to collect more money, of course you need to make a long term analysis also to be good in short term trading

[s19]

ye aik misconception ha k long term trade mein jiada experience k need hoti ha instead short mein hoti ha kuin ap ko fastly decision lene perte hain or long term me jiada stress nehe hota bus ager apko pata ho ga keb buy kareen or keb sell
friend i am not agree with you long term me kam experience or short term me jyda experience ki jarurat hoti hai.
trading long term ho ya short term both need a good trading experience.
In my view first newbie start their trading for long term after gotting some experience they learn short term trading..

[jabrik1991]

But long term is best if have large margin to to stop call of .Its make large profits ranging from 100-1000 pips if open trade for 4-10 months.But its possible to earn even in short time.

actually to earn 100 points. within a week I think can,. we do not wait until a month already. it's just a waste of time wasted, and we lose a very significant movement. such as the maxim time is money. and the point also is money. so do not waste a time.

[mirror]

From my little experience long term trading is safer then short term but short term can make much profit but probability of high losses. So I will suggest you If you cannot give your time and concentration properly. So just handle short term trading if you are part time worker:) good luck

[bestlooser]

short term forex trading can be highly stressful if done over a long period of time, as we have probably discovered if we have any experience of forex trading. we need quick fingers to trade in and out of positions and we need to make decisions quickly regarding entries and exits.

in long term success may not come instantly but if you will compare a long term trader to a short term trader after 6 months or so you may find long term and short term trader can be equal or long term can be better more than short term traders. so must try long term for sure it can benefiting more.

[realfun07]

in long term success may not come instantly but if you will compare a long term trader to a short term trader after 6 months or so you may find long term and short term trader can be equal or long term can be better more than short term traders. so must try long term for sure it can benefiting more.

As it says with the name the long term trading with take long time for success and short time will take comparatively less time but long term trading is done with aim at more number of pips so the result is same.I think long term trading is always better than short term.

[arihant]

it depends from person to person those who are into full tym buisness will do long term and those who do other jobs will do short term ....so profits wil vary from person to person ie traders.....and it will depends on you impliment your strategy with it

[bhanu]

I think long term trading is more preferable because in short term trading you have to take more tension and sit on the computer all the time. But if you are trading with long term trading you are relatively more relaxed and you need not to focus your attention on the trading all the time

[jabrik1991]

I think long term trading is more preferable because in short term trading you have to take more tension and sit on the computer all the time. But if you are trading with long term trading you are relatively more relaxed and you need not to focus your attention on the trading all the time

but the risk of long trade itself is also relatively very dangerous. need for analysis that is really good in a long trade, but trade in the short makes it easy to saturate a person, so the analysis is not accurate,

[arihant]

Traders who does not have much money in their account they trade on short term basis and for newbies also go on short term because they don't have much knowledge about money management and discipline trading.

[jabrik1991]

yes you are right if we want to go for long term then we can easily analysis the forex market and but in this situation we must have big money in our account in the other way if trade for short term then you have to keen interest on the current picture of the pair.

large capital or not all depends on how we conduct the transaction. as only a large capital but lots of our great mouseover, it's also very dangerous if we use a long trend, albeit with large capital we still have to adjust the equity we have,

[bestlooser]

Traders who does not have much money in their account they trade on short term basis and for newbies also go on short term because they don't have much knowledge about money management and discipline trading.

yes and after some experience you may reach to this conclusion long term is better but some people just do not change and they keep on doing in short term anyway long term or short but success is the thing that matters. so do not change if you are getting success and if you are not getting success in short term than try long term and it can be easy

[dmambi]

yes and after some experience you may reach to this conclusion long term is better but some people just do not change and they keep on doing in short term anyway long term or short but success is the thing that matters. so do not change if you are getting success and if you are not getting success in short term than try long term and it can be easy

That is right one should not change there profitable strategy now and then. We should stick to the strategy in which we are conversant and have confidence. For me long term trading is the best suitable since i am not able to keep watching the charts all the time.

[tibasingh]

Short term forex trading or Long ter forex trading? which trading do u prefer.aapke hisab se hame short term trading karni chaye ya long term kismai hame jada faida ho sakta hai??

main abhi new houn forex main or wese bhi main posting bonus se he guzara kar raha hnn es liye main to short term trading karta hnn kioun long term trading k liye app ko kafi balance chiye es liye

[MTEBESSI]

When I open a position I fill in the comment failed. Its the best way to keep a position for long term running to its target price. And trading for long term is not the same as trading short term even on lot size or stop lose amount. I may place 15 or 20 pips as stops in short term but In long term at least 70 pips.

[arihant]

function of Excel itself whether to count our points every day. to make our account in accordance with good management. so as to achieve the target that is expected. and 4 positions that you say is take 4 open every day in accordance with what we expect. What do you mean that?

[arihant]

and the obvious use of the lot shall be in accordance equity, because the use of lots in scalping still need to be noticed. like just a better use of small lots is safe, with an open position many times. than using a large lot but dangerous to our capital,

[arihant]

I'm just like you, I am more inclined to play scalping in forex trading. because the capital that I have too little, in my opinion is a bold play longterm traders who have large capital. capital so that they can withstand the movement of prices. although I made a little but I feel happy.

[arihant]

patience is not just my opinion. but the analysis is good and sufficient capital to withstand a long trend. so when we get a hit or a bullish trading bearish.akun we stay safe

[jabrik1991]

patience is not just my opinion. but the analysis is good and sufficient capital to withstand a long trend. so when we get a hit or a bullish trading bearish.akun we stay safe

by holding a big move. very dangerous. a bullish or bearish should have a resistance above 1000 points. otherwise our account does not allow safe, longterm trading style is a very powerful analysis and profit that is remarkable.

[waqasma]

It depend to your account margin. If you have enough money in your account you can do long term trading, but if you do not have that much amount then you can do short term trading which is carry out in hours or in a day.

[burayak]

learning consistent 10 points every day I think it is difficult, although it can be by using a scalping, sometimes we are greedy and do open the transaction again, but what's in the can, we have MC

to get the target points, although only 10 pips actually really hard to do if we have not been able to analyze price movements properly so that we have to practice and learn to improve our ability to run this business properly.

[arihant]

this kind of thing is a type of each. as only the traders who choose a system with scalping and traders who choose to longterm, and I think that choosing scalping traders are traders who have a lot of time so that it can always monitor the chart, in contrast with longterm traders because of time constraints

[aryan]

that depends on differnet style of trading ;
some trader likes to trade shorts by busy hour and other prefers to trade long terms (intraday for longer TP)
that need different strategies / analysis..

[aryan]

depends on the chart profile ; system gives signal by the price movement..
chart profile comes in different looks by each trading sessions...

[hiren]

yeah..agree with you..if u r doing good with the short term then u should not taking risk of long term trading...a trader has difffernt trading style...so u should use which suits best to ur trading strategy

[jabrik1991]

depends on the chart profile ; system gives signal by the price movement..
chart profile comes in different looks by each trading sessions...

each time frame does have a different candle time changes, it all depends on the time that we piih frae. but traders who play who play longterm certainly use the time frame above the h1.

[s19]

depends on the chart profile ; system gives signal by the price movement..
chart profile comes in different looks by each trading sessions...

i dont understanding that how a chart profile select short term or long term trading.
every one trade with their own trading system. soem trader made their system for long term and some made for short term trading. they open and clsoe their trade on base singnal of trading system not base on chart profile.

[kanwaljit]

short term is good for day traders who wish to keep collecting profits daily even if it is small profits, long term is for those in job who can sit on a trade for months to let it hatch into profits, even if they miss several hundred pips in between

[jabrik1991]

short term is good for day traders who wish to keep collecting profits daily even if it is small profits, long term is for those in job who can sit on a trade for months to let it hatch into profits, even if they miss several hundred pips in between

but the long trade always produce a big profit. you think the profit generated from the short play or large. which is better, because I wanted to finalize a short trade. and passion I love to see the graph for a long time.

[alvabra2010]

I would always go for short term forex trading because of my small capital. Long term trading is ideally for traders who have large capital and are generally professional traders. Short term forex trading helps me to make profitable trades in most of the market moves.

[dmambi]

I prefer doing long term trading , but still when opportunities exist for short term trading i do enter in market and try to exit with tp hit. In short term trading i always aim for around 10 to 20 pips profit only.

[SG Trader]

I would always go for short term forex trading because of my small capital. Long term trading is ideally for traders who have large capital and are generally professional traders. Short term forex trading helps me to make profitable trades in most of the market moves.

yeah good opinion. iam also prefer short term than long term trading.
short term is bring more advantage for the trader who have less capital to start trade in forex, so long term is suits with large capital because we will be able to hold a lot of pips when get floating minus position.

[jabrik1991]

I have planned my self for long term profit but i could not i always do the trade for short time and when i see any opportunity for short term then i have to choose it whether i got small profit or not.

advantages to playing in the short term all depends on our transaction. and the acquisition point, if you can make repeated transactions or one-time transaction. and when you play long, the advantage in a single transaction is very much at all.,

[kamla]

i think short term trading is good enough to whom who really new and want to learn from real trading...long term trading mein jyada anubhav chahiye aur newbie ko long term trading ke stage pe pahochne se pehle short term trading ka anubhav jaruri hai.

[nikhil]

most of newbies scalping se apni trading start karte hai kyu ki knowledge na hone ki wajah se woh log jyadatar short term trading choose karte hai..aur newbies ko time by time apni trading style aur strategy change karte rehna chahiye jisse jyada anubhav ka fayda ho

[nikhil]

Yeah....thats the big advantage of short term trading....so since i joined forex i prefer short term trading ..like scalping......besides long term forex trading has advantage on the basis of big profit but neeeds more knowledge nd experience,,,,

[nikhil]

u r right..i also prefer scalping but i usually take less time for chart and i mostly depended on the indiacators and usually trade on seeing them ....and scalping is proved good for my trading ..

[dimdim]

whether you are a short-term or long-term trader, setting a stop loss is a good strategy to check the amount of loss, its very important to limit the losses for we a seeking good profits at the end so unless we minimize the loss we cant have good profits

[yogesh]

Those expert traders and know well about trading strategies ... and who are good in finding up recent support and stop loss for short term, short term or day trading can help, but for newbies i think long term trading is more helpful.

[aryan]

In my opinion to sustain your self for long term in forex always invest small capital in forex trading and increased your capital gradually, so lot size is also make small to get profit, but forex always in profit.

[lovereurusd]

Short term forex trading or Long ter forex trading? which trading do u prefer.aapke hisab se hame short term trading karni chaye ya long term kismai hame jada faida ho sakta hai??

main to long term trading nahi karta kioun es k liye app ko kafi large balance ki zarorat parti ha main shurt term trading karta houn es se app kafi kam balance se bhi achi trading kar saktey ho

[kampung]

In my opinion to sustain your self for long term in forex always invest small capital in forex trading and increased your capital gradually, so lot size is also make small to get profit, but forex always in profit.

I agree with your opinion that the atu way to survive in this business is to save our trading capital budget for the capital budget menghmat then we still have a long time to survive in this business and learn to succeed

[dimdim]

Everyone sets his target according to his own strategy for me 10 pips daily are enough with 1 standard lot size.If i get 10 pips i close my terminal and do not trade more and when my equity will increase i'll increase my lot size to get more profit.

[realfun07]

Everyone sets his target according to his own strategy for me 10 pips daily are enough with 1 standard lot size.If i get 10 pips i close my terminal and do not trade more and when my equity will increase i'll increase my lot size to get more profit.

This is the best strategy you have used and best way to trade.Initially you must aim at making number of pips on regular basis and once you are successful in doing that you can always increase your profits by increasing the lot size.

[hiren]

Since long term trading or position trading is done based on fundamentals , larger capital is required so the trader does not have to even bother about 50 pip - 100 pip movement in reverse direction and has to continue with his trade.It has to be done properly with good analysis.

[SG Trader]

Both short term and long term trading have their own advantages and since different traders have different strategy and different trading styles , I would say both are good but long term traders make more money as compared to short term traders.

yes, so i think it depend by each trader.
what the strategy that suitable with their. for me, i choose short term altough i do analysis for long term. i just take a few pips and i dont want to wait for long time see my open position.

[hiren]

It is good to do short term trading or achieve short term targets and withdraw your money on weekly basis after leaving some funds for trading.Do not trade with profits you earn and always withdraw them on weekly basis.

[SG Trader]

It is good to do short term trading or achieve short term targets and withdraw your money on weekly basis after leaving some funds for trading.Do not trade with profits you earn and always withdraw them on weekly basis.

that is good idea, i think you have good thinking to save our profit so when we get a loss, our profit is not affected because we has been withdraw it.
so make a routinely withdraw is very important to do. as you say do in weekly basis, but for me better to make withdraw in monthly basis, and we must confident with ownself that we can withstand your own account for long time.

[gosians]

It is good to do short term trading or achieve short term targets and withdraw your money on weekly basis after leaving some funds for trading.Do not trade with profits you earn and always withdraw them on weekly basis.

Its good advice from you that we should withdraw our profit continuously, in my opinion long term trading is more complicated than short term trading so we should focus on short term trading as you said.

[cumil]

It is good to do short term trading or achieve short term targets and withdraw your money on weekly basis after leaving some funds for trading.Do not trade with profits you earn and always withdraw them on weekly basis.

hmm. a very good habit, I would like to withdraw each week, but unfourtunely I just withdraw each month, I just WD $ 50 because my capital was only $ 100,

one time when my capital up to $ 1000 then I will make it a habit WD $ 500 per month , .. hopefully can be accumulated up to that amount, and I will be long-term investment

[sameerjazba]

Short term forex trading or Long ter forex trading? which trading do u prefer.aapke hisab se hame short term trading karni chaye ya long term kismai hame jada faida ho sakta hai??

short term or long term dono traders k liye faida mand hane short time trade ka ye faida ha k app jaldi jaldi profit kama saktey hane or kam balance kioun na ho app k account main par long term main app ko large capital or ziyada time ki zarorat hoti ha per es ki ek dafa ki trade he app ko kafi profit de jati ha es liye ye dono app k liye achi hane

[kamla]

I like long term forex trading, I trade on 4h and daily chart. I want to do swing trading as it is easier than short term trading. In long term trading you don't have to sit in front of the terminal to view every movement of the market. Patience is required to do long term trading but once you get use to it, its very profitable than other types of trading.

[kamla]

I prefer long time forex trading because in long terms you don't have to sit in front of the terminal watching each and every move of the pair and then you can make good profits from long time trading then short term. One great risk is that you have to place your stop loss at a fairly large margin to let price breath within that and if unluckily you SL got hit then it would be huge loss as well.

[nikhil]

I just can trade forex in part time, so I can not be a short time trader, but I always exit my trades soon and lost a lot of money. So I made a writen trading plan, and take it seriously, then I found I can control myself, I advise this method in some other thread also I think. Then I can make money this year.

[hiren]

I think its also have great movement when its go down. personally i dont trade gold and silver but watch both price which have great movement when uptrend and downtrend . so its really risky with low capital if we wish for long.

[hiren]

I am fully agree with you . its totally depend on traders and on his understanding . i also think both are profitable if we have proper knowledge and if not then forex is dangerous . i think we can open long as well short for quick profit and long for handsome pips but all is need to good experience and skill in forex.

[kamla]

yes i also believe short and long is not much important things but the important things is that in which method like trader and in which they feel comfortable . anyway both are need skill and if such have then both are opportunity to earn green pips.

[kamla]

its not true short time trade causes loss all time but its also great way to earn quick profit if our analysis is correct and take entry at the good time . anyway there is no doubt with long to follow the trend its low risk but short also not bad and scalping is another things i think.

[kamla]

agar tu aap ma sabar jiada ha tu aur aapki investment b jiada ha tu phr long trading karni chahiye iss ma jiada faida ha aur agar sabar aur investment kam han tu phr short time he jiada thaik ha.

[nikhil]

I prefer long time forex trading because in long terms you don't have to sit in front of the terminal watching each and every move of the pair and then you can make good profits from long time trading then short term. One great risk is that you have to place your stop loss at a fairly large margin to let price breath within that and if unluckily you SL got hit then it would be huge loss as well.

[rakesh]

I am not agreed with your statement, short term trading will cause looses for the traders because the chances of being over traded are always there for the traders. I personally like long term trades and i am not in the favor of scalping.

[anchitkole]

Bohot sary log short term trading par yaqeen rakhty hain aur wo forex market main short term trading ki wjha say kuch naheen kma paty. Ziada log na jany kion sochty hain kay thory pasoon say log trade naheen ki ja saktee. mary khayal main thorry pasoon say bhi aap apni profitable trade ko ziada der tak hold kar sakty hain.

[rakesh]

Mary khayaal main agar aap kay pass ziada time hay phir bhi aap ko long term trade hi karna chahiye konkay short time trade main aap ko ziada faida bhi naheen milta aur nuqsaan ka chance bhi ziada hota hay.

[anchitkole]

I usually do short term trading but also focus on long term because for short term trading we must know the long term direction of the market. For this purpose I use different charts from M5 to H1.

[anitagala124]

I was trying short term trading for years and now I decided I can not plan for 50 or 100 pips per trade and I have decided that I have to wait for longer and looking for long term trading now and I am sure I will get better result by the long term and there is going to be less risk and maybe more profit.

[anitagala124]

but yes long term trading can be hard work but it can also give you big profits too in longer term as you can earn more with your one trader where as in short term you have to do many trades and I just decided to do long term and I have long time experience and I HAVE DONE SHORT TRADING TOO.

[anitagala124]

well this is your opinion and I feel the same for short term what you feel for long term. so every trader has different thoughts. So I still prefer long term. what you said about economical crisis and in that case if would find it difficult for long term then how can we survive in short term?

[anitagala124]

but long term mein you can really control more and there are less chances of losing and you will have less pressure as well as easy to manage and it will be slow progress so you will have plenty of time to make decisions and analyse and if you do it quickly then you have to make quick decisions and and in hurry you can make decisions in hurry.

[anitagala124]

well for me now long term trading is really working and I can not think of going back to short term trading so I can give you advice that you people can think of doing long term trading too. it will be easier and for me results are coming but we just have to be a little patient in long term trading.

[lovefx]

Trading short term or trading long term are fully depends on the strategy and money management. There is no rules that we must need a specific term on trading. terms is very traders to traders and market positions.

[rakesh]

it is simple that whether you want to win or lose and if you go for long term and then you can have success easily but if you do not have time and you still thing I do not have time and just try it for long time then maybe that is risk that you are taking . for me short term trading is full time risky.

[rakesh]

for me I tried scalping and as well as long term but so far long term has given me better result so this is why i am just thinking to be perfect in long term trading it is really really easy for me.. as market is not same all the time so different strategies can work at different times.

[rakesh]

well you are right people like me will always prefer long term trading after some real defeats in the short term trading. so I find that long term is easier for me and every one has his/her own ways and method of trading so short or long success is important and so people who are successful in short term should do short term where as people who finds long term is better can do long term.

[rakesh]

basically forex is all about movement of prices up and down and some trends it always will not move in one direction as some time in one direction and some time in other direction. so we have to take advantage of that so in long term it is easier to hold your positions for longer if you have good money so you need to have big amount for long term.

[wolfkamikaz]

I am a sniper i like ShortTerm forex sometimes I like scalping because I am not a person who wants to become a millionaire a sudden I want to avoid longterm because if you have not a good strategy you can lose a lot

[popatji]

well yes you right money is required but do not you think you would also required big amount for scalping because you can lose in many short positions and in this case you were always better to have some long term positions and earn as much in longer time period but same sort of result can be achieved but ways are different.

[popatji]

in shot term market can be so quick that you have to make quick and instant decisions and margin or error is very less so in long term as we see there will be more time and money required and easy to make decision in longer term so I think long term is far more better

[popatji]

yes this is the beauty of forex that we can do in long and short terms and every trader has its own choice and we see some traders who successful in short term and some in long term. but yes they are different to each other long term is easier and short is more risky.

[popatji]

pehle bhi kisi ne yeh baat ki thi but aap ne yehi to batana hai k konsi trading aap ko pasand hai aur kyon but aap to comment hi kar rahe ho ke dono hi theek. koi sahi answer do ta k aur log bhi aap se kuch sikh sakain aur log confuse na ho , baqi bhi thek hai k logo ko dono hi akrni chahyie aur log kuch seekhne k baad khud faisla kar sakte hain

[popatji]

yeh to sahi hai k profit importnat hai but hum yehi baat kar rahe hain k profit kis tarah easily zyada profit liya ja sakta hai aur knosa in dono mein se behtat hai. you know both are good for diffirent kind of people but I like both but using long term nowadays as I think I can handle it easily.

[chintan]

Well in my view thinking about fund after analyses the trade...
fund problem you can solved with using high leverage...you analyses according to you stop loss pips..
In my view this the minimum balance that your trade have sufficient balance for touching your stop loss...

[chintan]

i dont think that long term me jyda profit hota hai..
ya its true that we will close trde in profit. here i see many trader they got good number of pips in a scalping trading..some trader got more then 20-30% per months.
in short term traidng we got more chance for traidng but in long term we got only one chance.

[hetal]

मुझे लगता है कि ज्यादातर newbies के अल्पावधि में व्यापार करने की कोशिश और वे डर है कि कीमत वापस नहीं कदम है और वे अपने पैसे नहीं खो सकते हो सकता है की वजह से ऐसा करते हैं. लेकिन मुझे लगता है कि वे छोटे बहुत आकार के साथ दीर्घकालिक व्यापार व्यापार क्षमताओं को बढ़ाने चाहिए.

[anitagala124]

I just can trade forex in part time, so I can not be a short time trader, but I always exit my trades soon and lost a lot of money. So I made a writen trading plan, and take it seriously, then I found I can control myself, I advise this method in some other thread also I think. Then I can make money this year.

[forexx]

Short term forex trading or Long ter forex trading? which trading do u prefer.aapke hisab se hame short term trading karni chaye ya long term kismai hame jada faida ho sakta hai??

app k account main large capital ha to phr app ko long term trading karni chiye or ager app k account main kaam capital ha to phr app shurt term trading karo wese kam balance wale scalping use karain woh un k liye bastha or long term wale ziyada account balance ki waja se bhi ziyada profit kama saktey hane woh tab tal apni open trade close nahi kartey jab tak un ko profit un ki demand k braber na mil raha ho

[anitagala124]

I agree with your opinion that the atu way to survive in this business is to save our trading capital budget for the capital budget menghmat then we still have a long time to survive in this business and learn to succeed

[forexman]

i usually trade short time only upto now butwhen a price of golkd falls to 1500 then i may go for longtrade until it reach 1700 again.but i wont go for longtrades in others accept gold and that too i think when price still move further

[anchitkole]

i am a short term trader.Mostly i will not have open trades more than a day.My target will not be higher than 100pips.My average TP will be 50pips.

[anchitkole]

i prefer short term trading only.Because i hate to hold the trade for long terms like 1week or 1month.Maybe only organizations will trade like that.
Almost the individual traders will do short term tradings only.Maybe very few individual traders wil do long term.

[rakesh]

yes,but i think they lose in many dollars and not in pips.
and mostly i think that long term traders wont get margin call easily as they will be more planned and their risk factor will be less.

[rakesh]

i think you are wrong.Even you can get big profits from short term trades also.But for that you need to take big risks.So it is wrong to say short term low profits and longterm big profits.

[Garry]

i do short term trading because i m a new trader , i m learning trading . we should have some experience to put our foot in the arena of long term trading . we should have a lot of patience and some huge capital .

[anubhavsingh]

I am always doing short trade. because My capital is very small. also in short time trade there is more chances to win. in long trade the time is taking too. so for me short trade.

small capital me short trading hi karni chahaiye
;lekin sath hi sath apko zada bade lots bhi nahi lene chahaiye
ye sab baatein bahut zaruri hoti hai chote traders ke liye

[rakesh]

no even forex will be suitable for long term also.If we trade for long time and execute perfectly,profit will be high.And trading currencies is easier than trading commodities like gold i feel.

[ACE]

Short term trading is good for beginners because it also includes learning analysis working , experiencing little losses and profits and the use of different pairs.
Long term trading is best for taders who are in the business from years , able to predict coming analysis, has a a lot to loss or gain .

[sinjiku]

Short term trading is good for beginners because it also includes learning analysis working , experiencing little losses and profits and the use of different pairs.
Long term trading is best for taders who are in the business from years , able to predict coming analysis, has a a lot to loss or gain .

learning is a matter that must wrestle with before we actually wrestle propesi sepagai trader. by learning that we will understand a little about the movement of the world economy. learn the system and analysis to predict price movement

[hardworks]

no even forex will be suitable for long term also.If we trade for long time and execute perfectly,profit will be high.And trading currencies is easier than trading commodities like gold i feel.

Yes, Forex is suitable for all types of trading style. In my opinion, the long term trading is better than short term trading. In long term trading, the analysis part is minimum. All we want to do is to have some patience till our target reached. The profit is reasonable, but very safe. We should always maintain money management even in very bottom and very top too.

[yogesh]

I consider long term trading have lesser risk but one should analyse for good fundamentals the instrument one want to go long with and ensure that use very low leverage in case the trade go opposite due to technical reasons in short term.

[nikhil_rrane]

I like to trade for the long term as the long term trading is very safe rather than the short term trading but most important thing we have to do while placing the trade for the long term that we have to track the trend of the pair so that we can take position according to that and make money.

[vikas]

its not true short time trade causes loss all time but its also great way to earn quick profit if our analysis is correct and take entry at the good time . anyway there is no doubt with long to follow the trend its low risk but short also not bad and scalping is another things i think.

[vikas]

yes i also believe short and long is not much important things but the important things is that in which method like trader and in which they feel comfortable . anyway both are need skill and if such have then both are opportunity to earn green pips.

[ketan]

I am fully agree with you . its totally depend on traders and on his understanding . i also think both are profitable if we have proper knowledge and if not then forex is dangerous . i think we can open long as well short for quick profit and long for handsome pips but all is need to good experience and skill in forex.

[ketan]

I think its also have great movement when its go down. personally i dont trade gold and silver but watch both price which have great movement when uptrend and downtrend . so its really risky with low capital if we wish for long.

[hetal]

waise main 1 day tak trading karna pasand karta hoon. par kabhi kabhi bahut din ka trading bhi kar leta hoon.
waise mujhe short trading accha lagta he. par scalping ekdam accha nhi lagta. agar aap ke paas balance accha ho to aap long trading me jaye.

[anubhavsingh]

I think its also have great movement when its go down. personally i dont trade gold and silver but watch both price which have great movement when uptrend and downtrend . so its really risky with low capital if we wish for long.

silver aur gold me kafi trader long term trading karte hai kyunki inki movement long term, me up trend hi rehti hai
aapne thik kaha bhai ki low capital me long term gtrading nahi kari ja sakti

[hetal]

I think longterm trader is a trader who has had a good psychology, so in any circumstances he would remain calm, and will not change strategy that is being run despite going through a floating minus

[hetal]

a trader who has a daily target usually do intraday trading ... because they want to achieve the target that's why he's doing intraday trading ...

[hetal]

a scalper could produce the same amount with a long term trader in just minutes ...
because the scalper used lot bigger than the longterm trader ...

[hetal]

short term is good, provided we can consistently run it and certainly produces a consistent profit also ...

[balakalimuthu]

I do prefer to go with short term, but daily research basis rather than scalping. As I have trading strategies which support only day long entry and exit levels. I believe long term positional trading could be done only by most experienced professional traders. Being a beginner I just dream about long term trading as now now, but preparing for it....

[bestlooser]

I think longterm trader is a trader who has had a good psychology, so in any circumstances he would remain calm, and will not change strategy that is being run despite going through a floating minus

yes if you are good enough trader that you can be patient than long term is best for you because there will be not a quick return but a guaranteed success after some time maybe after a week or after a month or even some people can wait for year to see a great outcome so forex can be easy in long term.