Why some brokers don't allow scalping?

[Anytime]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

[Victoryindia]

some brokers dont allow scalping bcoz the chances of loss is high during scalping since we take only 5 pips or 10 pips. so once u loss many times u will dont have the hope of trading in forex and u will leave forex permanently and then broker cannot make money from u in spreads. so they dont allow u for scalping.this is the main reasons

[nilu]

Normally brokers don't send order to the inter bank regularly so if some one make profit from the trade then broker pay from his pocket, Broker think that all traders will loose amount so he collect that amount without sending information to interbank, so they don't allow scalping

[soumen]

hey there is already a thread same name and the link is.
https://indian-forex.com/showthread.php?1211-Kuch-broker-scalping-allowed-kyu-nahi-karte-hain
the answer i posted there is
broker sayad server problem ke wajahse scalping allowed nehi karte. par mujhe ye bhi lagta he ki scalping ek accha method he trade ko samajh ne ka. . most of broker ise allow karte he. aur hum logo ko iska subhidha lene chahiye. agar koi broker isse allow nehi karte to mere khayal se us broker me join karna nehi chahiye.:good:

[andry777]

I think that broker must be non-dealing desk broker because this kind of broker didn't take advantages from spreads only but they used our funds (trader's fund) to trade by theirself. It means, if you did scalping then the chances of winning will be higher and if traders won, brokers must pay but if traders lost then brokers will get profit because they didn't need to pay.

[rajuonline]

agar koi broker scalping allow nehi karte to aap log ku us broker ke sath he. trading me scaling karnese trader ko fyda milte he. main jitna janta hoon ki sabhi broker scalping allow karte hoge. agar koi broker scalping allow nehi karte to us broker ka naam yaha de. main janna chate hon.

[arjun]

scalpingwill make the server broker becomes busy, so it will be detrimental to the broker as it is likely many of the complaints by the slow server broker.

[andry777]

scalpingwill make the server broker becomes busy, so it will be detrimental to the broker as it is likely many of the complaints by the slow server broker.

Maybe you're right but brokers could give rules to prevent that actions happened like if traders used scalping method,
so they must wait at least 2 minutes before they could close position or other rules to limit it. IFX used that rules to
limit action of scalpers.

[Victoryindia]

Maybe you're right but brokers could give rules to prevent that actions happened like if traders used scalping method,
so they must wait at least 2 minutes before they could close position or other rules to limit it. IFX used that rules to
limit action of scalpers.

nahi bhai, instaforex me aisa kuch nahi hai, hum kitne der me bhi close kar sakte hai, koi limit nahi hai isliye instaforex best broker hain.

[siberian]

Maybe you're right but brokers could give rules to prevent that actions happened like if traders used scalping method,
so they must wait at least 2 minutes before they could close position or other rules to limit it. IFX used that rules to
limit action of scalpers.

Yes, it is not good reason not allowing traders to use scalping only because server of broker couldn't
handled transaction. Maybe it happened in small brokers which used worse server than commonly brokers.
Actually for dealing-desk broker, it is more profitable when there is scalper because the brokers will
get more earning from many open positions.

[arjun]

Maybe you're right but brokers could give rules to prevent that actions happened like if traders used scalping method,
so they must wait at least 2 minutes before they could close position or other rules to limit it. IFX used that rules to
limit action of scalpers.

IFX really have a rule like that? where can I read it, because I just know it now. but fortunately I was not a scalper, but sometimes I also make scalping.

[denira]

IFX really have a rule like that? where can I read it, because I just know it now. but fortunately I was not a scalper, but sometimes I also make scalping.

if you understand the techniques scapling well I think you will not hesitate to use this technique especially when kondsisi sidway happens to the market you are trading currencies

[Nikhil]

Yes i also dont know why some broker dont allow scalping when if we trade more then thier more profit . before i trade in uwcfx but they dont allow trade close within two mites and also there is some broker also dont allow . actually i dont do scalping most of the time but if there is opportunity then sure do which is really great way to earn some green pips quick.

[pivot-trader]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

in my opinion scalping trading just make the server work harder, because it some brokers don't alllowed us to scalping.

[blackprince4u]

in my opinion scalping trading just make the server work harder, because it some brokers don't alllowed us to scalping.

Yes this is the main reason that brokers don't allow scalping.In news time when we use big lot sizes and open order and close it in a minute or two it puts a great load on servers and they become slow and some time they say requote

[siberian]

Yes this is the main reason that brokers don't allow scalping.In news time when we use big lot sizes and open order and close it in a minute or two it puts a great load on servers and they become slow and some time they say requote

There is no one who trade scalping when there is news. So I think that is not good reason which is used by broker because
in all brokers will experience same thing when high impact new is arriving. Server worked harder when traders used scalping
is not done in news time.

[denira]

There is no one who trade scalping when there is news. So I think that is not good reason which is used by broker because
in all brokers will experience same thing when high impact new is arriving. Server worked harder when traders used scalping
is not done in news time.

wow for me may be dangerous to conduct trade in this news release scpling because it could be too big so the movement of the wrong placement of this position will be very dangerous

[blackprince4u]

wow for me may be dangerous to conduct trade in this news release scpling because it could be too big so the movement of the wrong placement of this position will be very dangerous

You are right. but i use a hedging kind of strategy to trade news like i open two orders at almost same price one buy and one sell i put sl value but don't enter tp and when the price moves in any direction one order is closed by hitting sl and other goes in profit. and the net outcome is always profit.

[pivot-trader]

Yes this is the main reason that brokers don't allow scalping.In news time when we use big lot sizes and open order and close it in a minute or two it puts a great load on servers and they become slow and some time they say requote

thank for completing my explanation. in the news trading, trader ussualy just trading in short time. because price movement also move wildy in short time too.

[daniel]

thank for completing my explanation. in the news trading, trader ussualy just trading in short time. because price movement also move wildy in short time too.

yes,,, and they usually put up trapping pending order strategy, in order to be able to touch one of these two pending orders. but be carefull about some broker terms of rule which prohibit us to do that

[andry777]

thank for completing my explanation. in the news trading, trader ussualy just trading in short time. because price movement also move wildy in short time too.

Yes, news trader will trade in few times. They will take advantages of fast movement in short time which happened when high impact news is appearing. But if we wanted to take advantages for long-term trading, it is still possible because usually high impact news will give long-term impact too.

[pivot-trader]

Yes, news trader will trade in few times. They will take advantages of fast movement in short time which happened when high impact news is appearing. But if we wanted to take advantages for long-term trading, it is still possible because usually high impact news will give long-term impact too.

yeah i agree with you. like non farm payroll. just not in short time but can effect for long time too. like 2 month ago.

[denira]

Yes, news trader will trade in few times. They will take advantages of fast movement in short time which happened when high impact news is appearing. But if we wanted to take advantages for long-term trading, it is still possible because usually high impact news will give long-term impact too.

I support your opinion that no news is also slightly change the direction trend happened before because the news is one of this part of the economic state of our currency trading

[pivot-trader]

I support your opinion that no news is also slightly change the direction trend happened before because the news is one of this part of the economic state of our currency trading

yeah, some times high impact news can make a new trend. but not all time. just for several, and this is fo far i know.

[arjun]

yeah, some times high impact news can make a new trend. but not all time. just for several, and this is fo far i know.
This often makes me stuck. I am often one open position, because usually the price will go up astray and turn direction,
so when news form the new trend I often affected floting loss.

[blackprince4u]

This often makes me stuck. I am often one open position, because usually the price will go up astray and turn direction,
so when news form the new trend I often affected floting loss.
In case of news that have medium impact you can open any order because the price will move in one direction for a short time than return to original if the trend is not reversed.Real thing is the entry point if you entered at a good price you can get good profit.

[denira]

In case of news that have medium impact you can open any order because the price will move in one direction for a short time than return to original if the trend is not reversed.Real thing is the entry point if you entered at a good price you can get good profit.

sometimes the news is true only in diverting the trend is only temporary course but we should also note the news that has the power to change the direction of the trend that occurred during the

[anubhavsingh]

ye baat maien bhi botice kari hai
kayi brokers complain karte hai ki unke server me kayi baar dikkat ho jati hai because of scalping jisse ki kafi confusion ho jatyi hai..
Is wajah se scalping avoid karte hai

[denira]

if you are brokers who do not allow scapling I'm still confused why brokers are prohibited to do scpling,, anyone know why?

[alwi]

if you are brokers who do not allow scapling I'm still confused why brokers are prohibited to do scpling,, anyone know why?

perhaps because this makes the server performance scapling broker so disturbed scpling friend because this is not usually open and close within a very fast

[arjun]

In case of news that have medium impact you can open any order because the price will move in one direction for a short time than return to original if the trend is not reversed.Real thing is the entry point if you entered at a good price you can get good profit.

really like that? I believe the answer is not always that way. so there is a condition that prices will move against the trend just before the price reverses direction. The second movement could be 200 pips, and my margins are not strong enough to withstand floting far.

[dead]

really like that? I believe the answer is not always that way. so there is a condition that prices will move against the trend just before the price reverses direction. The second movement could be 200 pips, and my margins are not strong enough to withstand floting far.

this is where we do have better money management melakuka friends to be able to withstand the price moves with unforeseen margin not served until unable to resist the price and make the MC

[anubhavsingh]

Jab koi bhi high impact news market me aati hai to trend ko change hone me time nahi lagta..
with in few minutes market ka trend change ho jata hai...news ka market pe abhut asar padta hai.isliye technical studies ke alawa news ke hisab se bhi trade karna chahaiye

[soumen]

Yes, news trader will trade in few times. They will take advantages of fast movement in short time which happened when high impact news is appearing. But if we wanted to take advantages for long-term trading, it is still possible because usually high impact news will give long-term impact too.
ha baria khabar se hum long trade pe ja sakte he.par short time is best agar aapke paas kam balance ho. aur instaforex me sabhi tarah ke subhida hei. to aap log instaforex use kare to sab payenge.

[arjun]

this is where we do have better money management melakuka friends to be able to withstand the price moves with unforeseen margin not served until unable to resist the price and make the MC

using the MM or not trading when news, I choose to avoid it.
but if I want to open a position I usually use the smallest lots.
I did just for fun

[denira]

using the MM or not trading when news, I choose to avoid it.
but if I want to open a position I usually use the smallest lots.
I did just for fun

I also like that my friend is sometimes more to avoid news of the need to open a position when the news was released and more to see how the market response to news of the

[anubhavsingh]

I also like that my friend is sometimes more to avoid news of the need to open a position when the news was released and more to see how the market response to news of the
market respond very quickyly after the effect of news
Experianced tradres earn huge sum of money at the time of news because they have good experiance in this market and there analysis aur very accurate
But usually small tradres should not trade at the time of news or any other big event in fiorex market

[alwi]

market respond very quickyly after the effect of news
Experianced tradres earn huge sum of money at the time of news because they have good experiance in this market and there analysis aur very accurate
But usually small tradres should not trade at the time of news or any other big event in fiorex market
if we can not control the market with good news would be much better indeed we only see it from that asked of the losing

[medhat4forex]

I think that some brokers do not accept and scalping due to the slow implementation of the transactions as the most reliable third party intermediaries do not have them in the implementation of the speed of transactions with banks

[dead]

I think that some brokers do not accept and scalping due to the slow implementation of the transactions as the most reliable third party intermediaries do not have them in the implementation of the speed of transactions with banks

maybe that's the one that makes the brokers not to give permission on a lot of traders to do because the order is fast scapling

[denira]

I think that some brokers do not accept and scalping due to the slow implementation of the transactions as the most reliable third party intermediaries do not have them in the implementation of the speed of transactions with banks

could be the reason that way but I have a peculiarity in me should be banned why this scpling technique but also there that allow me to wonder whether this technique is too good for brokers as agents rather than brokers who actually

[arjun]

could be the reason that way but I have a peculiarity in me should be banned why this scpling technique but also there that allow me to wonder whether this technique is too good for brokers as agents rather than brokers who actually

seems to have explained before, if this technique also makes a server becomes busier.
so that will make requotes becoming more frequent. and interfere with other traders.

[pinpin]

scalpingwill make the server broker becomes busy, so it will be detrimental to the broker as it is likely many of the complaints by the slow server broker.
Your opinion may be true
servers will be busy if many orders come in, so that the service is slow
or brokers fear bankruptcy if we do scalping

[soumen]

seems to have explained before, if this technique also makes a server becomes busier.
so that will make requotes becoming more frequent. and interfere with other traders.
ya you are right. and your reason is right. par kya aap bata sakte he ki konsi broker scalping allow nehi karte? give a list.

[ganguly]

some brokers dont allow scalping bcoz the chances of loss is high during scalping since we take only 5 pips or 10 pips. so once u loss many times u will dont have the hope of trading in forex and u will leave forex permanently and then broker cannot make money from u in spreads. so they dont allow u for scalping.this is the main reasons

[vicky]

You have explained very well why the brokers do not allow scalping. Infact traders are like honey bees for brokers and brokers like to protect these honey bees. Scalping is not a safe way of trading that's why brokers do not allow scalping.

ya its true when i trade in one broker than they set trade time minimum 2 minutes and send me a mal informing me that most of my trade going to scalping and its not good and its very risky . but i think when some traders really earning good from scalping and risk is fully traders then broker prevent us probably for server issue.

[anubhavsingh]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

maine ab tak jitne brokers se sath trade kiya hai sabne scalping ko allow kiya hai
mere khayal se ye trader ki apni choice hoti hai ki trade ko 10 pip me close kare ya fir 50 pip me
isme broker ka koi matlab nahi hota

[denira]

No there is no server issue for scalping but it is only for the safety of the trader. Most of the newbies think forex a very profitable style of trading but in fact it is trader killing trading style.

can be as long as you have a good internet connection you might not be a problem with the server for this scpling style but you must first set SL and TP to keep the server issues

[anubhavsingh]

agar koi broker scalping allow nehi karte to aap log ku us broker ke sath he. trading me scaling karnese trader ko fyda milte he. main jitna janta hoon ki sabhi broker scalping allow karte hoge. agar koi broker scalping allow nehi karte to us broker ka naam yaha de. main janna chate hon.

me aapek sath ekldum sehmat hon
brokers ko scalping se koi dikkat nahi honi chahaiye...mostly brokers scalping allow karte hai..
aapko apne broker ko bolna chahiye ki aapko bhi scalping allow kare

[venkiaries61]

Why some brokers don't allow scalping?

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

But, instaforex provides all features including scalping. So, don't worry about that and enjoy trading with instaforex. scalping is supported by instaforex. Dont go for non scalping one.

[fravash]

it happened because some broker still use desk dealing, and when their client do a scalping, the execution order could be closed just before it through the market, the profit that their client earn would be a loss to the broker

but mostly that happened with B rated broker, an A rated broker like insta allow their client to scalping

[Victoryindia]

some broker trading platform get hang if many people open or close many order, so they dont allow scalping so there will be less order at the same time, so it will not get hang

[Victoryindia]

If brokers are not allowed to trade scpling I think a lot of which can not be traded on the brokers because many of my friends also use the technique in their trading scpling

ha wo to sahi hai bahut new log to scalping hi karte hai aur thoda thoda pips kamate apna positon close kar dete hai. isliye broker jo scalping allow nah karte hai flop hi hota hai

[carimas888]

some of the brokers dont allow scalping because if the traders win then the brokers loss.probability chance to win is high when we use scalping strategy.

[denira]

some of the brokers dont allow scalping because if the traders win then the brokers loss.probability chance to win is high when we use scalping strategy.

I do not think there is any problem with our profits, but this is only their server problems that will be disturbed if we use scpling and somehow scpling too quick to close the transaction so that the server service brokers may be in really big trouble

[siddesh]

I do not know why most forex brokers do not allow scalping in their trading platform. For me, i think scalping has some advantages for the broker since scalpers open several trades per day and this in-turn leads to the broker making more money through spreads.

[Ronak]

I do not know why most forex brokers do not allow scalping in their trading platform. For me, i think scalping has some advantages for the broker since scalpers open several trades per day and this in-turn leads to the broker making more money through spreads.

nahi bhaai..scalping se broker ko advantage milta toh who scalping kyun banned karte..scalping karne se hamara fayda badh jayegaa aur broker ko kuch nahi milta..aur some provide scalping but there is more restriction

[diesel1984]

it happened because some broker still use desk dealing, and when their client do a scalping, the execution order could be closed just before it through the market, the profit that their client earn would be a loss to the broker

but mostly that happened with B rated broker, an A rated broker like insta allow their client to scalping


Most of the traders favor of this type, only a 5-10 point to take profits and close the transaction.
To increase profit, the transaction must often be done, but unfortunately with the growing number of transactions, the risk of losing money is also getting bigger.
Technical analysis should be done by extending the forex signal as a guide.
Traders need to avoid this type of fundamental news ..
and does not make a deal when "High impact" will be released...
In addition pairs traded pairs preferably with a small spread.

[carimas888]

some brokers dont allow scalping because they dont connect us to real market so they will get loss if we earn more.and some brokers get load of work when many people doing scalping so sometimes they cant closed any people position at the particular time and they can get loss.

[Ronak]

some brokers dont allow scalping because they dont connect us to real market so they will get loss if we earn more.and some brokers get load of work when many people doing scalping so sometimes they cant closed any people position at the particular time and they can get loss.

sahi kahaa..if we earn more than they earn less..they earn from which we loose spread ..but some broker like instaforex alllow scalping but thre is more restriction

[Ganesh]

:doubt: i had read in a post somewhere i remember tht the cause to this scalping being avoided was said to be problems in the system which are caused due to it so they avoid scalping:doubt:

[jai]

Scalping is one of major trading style and it widely use by trader's.
So broker should check server capacity to hold the load of many trader activity.

[gosians]

some brokers dont allow scalping bcoz the chances of loss is high during scalping since we take only 5 pips or 10 pips. so once u loss many times u will dont have the hope of trading in forex and u will leave forex permanently and then broker cannot make money from u in spreads. so they dont allow u for scalping.this is the main reasons

I think ye reason nhi hy, mery khyal main brokers work load ki waja sy scalping ko allow nhi krty. Reason chahye kuch b ho but ma aisy brokers ko like nhi krta jo scalping ko allow nhi krty. Jb b hum position open krty hen brokers spread ki waja sy profit bna lyty hen so un ko scalping ko allow krna chahye aisy unki income b increase ho gi.

[realfun07]

I do not know why some brokers do not allow scalping as I have not heard or come across any such broker but if it is the case then it must be with small time brokers as they do not have enough capital and can not keep track of many open positions.With reputed and big brokers like Instaforex this is not the case and they do allow scalping.

[nsawork]

perhaps because this makes the server performance scapling broker so disturbed scpling friend because this is not usually open and close within a very fast

Many brokers are also concerned about the sharp fluctuations in the prices and thus their own margins are effected if this is being done to often. This is so because the earnings of the brokers do come from the difference of the BUY and the SELL prices.

[swallow2000]

I think some brokers do not allow scalping because if we will open and close our positions so frequently then their trading servers will effect severly

[Rohail]

Some people thought that Scalping is easy and profitable strategy. Scalping involves a trader to trade frequently and make many trades in a day so at times there are small brokers who are unable to cover the position of many traders at the same time and it is difficult for them to assess the exact situation so that is why they do not allow scalping.
As we know that Forex trading is a risky business so some brokers try to keep safeguard the traders from this risk.
Scalpers work like honey bees for a brokers and they pay the cost of spread again and again that is beneficial for the brokers. However i think the brokers who do not allow scalping are the best friends of the traders and they tend to safeguard their customers.

[Jazpa]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

There is almost no role for the brokers in scalping. In scalping traders hold their trading position just for few minutes and the profits are also very less. In that case, brokers don't get commission that they hope to get. There is low spread during scalping and we all know that low spread is definitely not good for the brokers to make money.

[sanjeev]

Pressure is wrong word for expressing. We can say to much load of user activity on server causes server low problems which rise another problem like long opening browsing activity,reduce of activity on main site.

[sachin]

instaforex broker trading all kinds of ways are allowed, possibly at another broker should not be scalping, because too much pressure on the server, also should not be hedging the same reasons, to burden the server, I do not know why they like do not have a solution

[anubhavsingh]

yeah, some times high impact news can make a new trend. but not all time. just for several, and this is fo far i know.

mere khayal se news kabhi bhi market ka trend change nahi karti..thodi der ke liye zarur move kar deti hai lekin trend change nahi kar pati hogi
jab tak koi bahut major news me bahut zada changes na ho..tb tak koi normal news market ka trend chaneg nahi kar sakti..thodi der move karayegi lekin fir market apne trend me aa jayeag

[netra]

When a trader make a trade with his broker, the broker has to cover the position in the market to protect him against exchange rate risk. Scalpers trade frequently sometimes making hundreds of transaction in a short span. Though the broker is getting income from the spread in these transactions, the frequent trades makes it difficult for the broker to correctly assess his position and cover it in the market. Moreover, the broker has to make frequent covering. Because of this many brokers are not preferring scalpers.

[akshayfuriya]

Yes, news trader will trade in few times. They will take advantages of fast movement in short time which happened when high impact news is appearing. But if we wanted to take advantages for long-term trading, it is still possible because usually high impact news will give long-term impact too.

[Victoryindia]

Yes, news trader will trade in few times. They will take advantages of fast movement in short time which happened when high impact news is appearing. But if we wanted to take advantages for long-term trading, it is still possible because usually high impact news will give long-term impact too.

high impact news jitna short term mai fayda dete hai utna long trtm mai mere hisab se nahi deta. so mere hisab se better ha short term mai khelna

[sunil]

some brokers dont allow scalping bcoz the chances of loss is high during scalping since we take only 5 pips or 10 pips. so once u loss many times u will dont have the hope of trading in forex and u will leave forex permanently and then broker cannot make money from u in spreads. so they dont allow u for scalping.this is the main reasons

[sunil]

perhaps because this makes the server performance scapling broker so disturbed scpling friend because this is not usually open and close within a very fast

[akshayfuriya]

Pressure is wrong word for expressing. We can say to much load of user activity on server causes server low problems which rise another problem like long opening browsing activity,reduce of activity on main site.

[venkiaries61]

perhaps because this makes the server performance scapling broker so disturbed scpling friend because this is not usually open and close within a very fast

Yes, thats correct. Server will get too slow while in true trends. because, all scalpers trade at a time opening and closing their positions. by this, brokers may get disturbed. So only, they dont allow scalping. Let us discuss.

[ketan]

I do not know why some brokers do not allow scalping as I have not heard or come across any such broker but if it is the case then it must be with small time brokers as they do not have enough capital and can not keep track of many open positions.With reputed and big brokers like Instaforex this is not the case and they do allow scalping.

[vikas]

With scalping its possible to make the most from forex market. But it requires to spend a lots of time daily after monitoring the market and the problem here is, you have to spend a lot after spreads and one loss can cut the profit of many trades.

[aniket]

i had read in a post somewhere i remember tht the cause to this scalping being avoided was said to be problems in the system which are caused due to it so they avoid scalping

[sachin]

Many brokers are also concerned about the sharp fluctuations in the prices and thus their own margins are effected if this is being done to often. This is so because the earnings of the brokers do come from the difference of the BUY and the SELL prices.

[vikas]

maine ab tak jitne brokers se sath trade kiya hai sabne scalping ko allow kiya hai
mere khayal se ye trader ki apni choice hoti hai ki trade ko 10 pip me close kare ya fir 50 pip me
isme broker ka koi matlab nahi hota
ya its true when i trade in one broker than they set trade time minimum 2 minutes and send me a mal informing me that most of my trade going to scalping and its not good and its very risky . but i think when some traders really earning good from scalping and risk is fully traders then broker prevent us probably for server issue.

[anubhavsingh]

In case of news that have medium impact you can open any order because the price will move in one direction for a short time than return to original if the trend is not reversed.Real thing is the entry point if you entered at a good price you can get good profit.

medium impact ki enws ke waqt aapko amrket me bahut zada movement nahi dikhegi
lekin kuch news aisi hoti hai jo ki amrket ka naksha hi badal deti hai
Inme FOMNC report aur US Jobles claims etc ki news market me bahut volatility le aati hai

[ketan]

it happened because some broker still use desk dealing, and when their client do a scalping, the execution order could be closed just before it through the market, the profit that their client earn would be a loss to the broker

but mostly that happened with B rated broker, an A rated broker like insta allow their client to scalping

[arihant]

Normally brokers don't send order to the inter bank regularly so if some one make profit from the trade then broker pay from his pocket, Broker think that all traders will loose amount so he collect that amount without sending information to interbank, so they don't allow scalping

[nikhil]

ya you are right. and your reason is right. par kya aap bata sakte he ki konsi broker scalping allow nehi karte? give a list.

[patil]

कुछ दलालों scalping bcoz की अनुमति न हानि की संभावना scalping के दौरान अधिक है क्योंकि हम केवल 5 pips या 10 pips के ले. इसलिए एक बार यू हानि कई बार यू न विदेशी मुद्रा में व्यापार की आशा है और यू विदेशी मुद्रा स्थायी रूप से छोड़ दो और तो दलाल पैसे फैलता में u से नहीं कर सकते हैं. ताकि वे न की अनुमति यू scalping.this के लिए मुख्य कारणों

[patil]

IFX सच है कि जैसे एक नियम है? जहाँ मैं इसे पढ़ सकते हैं, क्योंकि मैं सिर्फ यह अब पता. लेकिन सौभाग्य से मैं एक scalper नहीं था, लेकिन कभी कभी मैं भी scalping बनाने.

[vineet]

There is almost no role for the brokers in scalping. In scalping traders hold their trading position just for few minutes and the profits are also very less. In that case, brokers don't get commission that they hope to get. There is low spread during scalping and we all know that low spread is definitely not good for the brokers to make money.

[popatji]

I think that broker must be non-dealing desk broker because this kind of broker didn't take advantages from spreads only but they used our funds (trader's fund) to trade by theirself. It means, if you did scalping then the chances of winning will be higher and if traders won, brokers must pay but if traders lost then brokers will get profit because they didn't need to pay.

[popatji]

Maybe you're right but brokers could give rules to prevent that actions happened like if traders used scalping method,
so they must wait at least 2 minutes before they could close position or other rules to limit it. IFX used that rules to
limit action of scalpers.

[popatji]

Yes, news trader will trade in few times. They will take advantages of fast movement in short time which happened when high impact news is appearing. But if we wanted to take advantages for long-term trading, it is still possible because usually high impact news will give long-term impact too.

[vineet]

I think some brokers do not allow scalping because if we will open and close our positions so frequently then their trading servers will effect severly

[bhanu]

medium impact ki enws ke waqt aapko amrket me bahut zada movement nahi dikhegi
lekin kuch news aisi hoti hai jo ki amrket ka naksha hi badal deti hai
Inme FOMNC report aur US Jobles claims etc ki news market me bahut volatility le aati hai

[aryan]

Yes i also dont know why some broker dont allow scalping when if we trade more then thier more profit . before i trade in uwcfx but they dont allow trade close within two mites and also there is some broker also dont allow . actually i dont do scalping most of the time but if there is opportunity then sure do which is really great way to earn some green pips quick.

[chintan]

ha wo to sahi hai bahut new log to scalping hi karte hai aur thoda thoda pips kamate apna positon close kar dete hai. isliye broker jo scalping allow nah karte hai flop hi hota hai

[speedy]

It is quite amazing that some brokers do not allow scalping. I think from scalping they should get more commission because in scalping traders open many positions in very less time so broker will earn more and it is beneficial for a broker.

[nitintripathi]

main reason mujhe nahi pata ki brokers scalpin allow kyun nahi karte unke trading platform ke liye mere hisab scalping ke fayde hai ek broker ke liye kyunki scalpere kai trades kholte hai har din and uska unko fayda milta hai jiske badle woh spread se kaafi amount bi banate hain but scalper broker ke network ko kafi busy bi bana deta hai

[anubhavsingh]

main reason mujhe nahi pata ki brokers scalpin allow kyun nahi karte unke trading platform ke liye mere hisab scalping ke fayde hai ek broker ke liye kyunki scalpere kai trades kholte hai har din and uska unko fayda milta hai jiske badle woh spread se kaafi amount bi banate hain but scalper broker ke network ko kafi busy bi bana deta hai

scalping se brokres ko fayda hota hai kyunki scalping me aap chote time me zada se zada trade karte ho
maine aisa koi broketr nahi dekha jo ki scalping ke liye mana karta ho..mere khaya lse har broker scalping allow karta hoga

[donofforex]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.
mere mtabiq to ziyada tar brokers es liye bhi scalping allowed nahi kartey kioun k es k zariye newbies aksar loss main jatey hane or phr fear ka shikar ho kar forex trading ko churr detey hane esi liye us broker ko nuqsan hota ha or woh broker scalping allowed nahikartey

[anubhavsingh]

mere mtabiq to ziyada tar brokers es liye bhi scalping allowed nahi kartey kioun k es k zariye newbies aksar loss main jatey hane or phr fear ka shikar ho kar forex trading ko churr detey hane esi liye us broker ko nuqsan hota ha or woh broker scalping allowed nahikartey

me is baat se bilkul bhi sehmat nahi hon
scalping karna ya na karna tarder pe depend karta hai..uski personal marzi hoti hai ki wo kaise trade kare..iske liye broker ko beech me nahi aana chahaiye
lekin jaha tak maien dekah hai..saare ache aur reputed brokers scalping allow karte hai

[lax]

scalping ma risk factor buhat jiada hota ha i think iss liye some brokers nai chahte ke koi b person scalping kr ke apna loss karwa le aur osska account nill ho jaye unki policy ye hoti ha ke long time relation kaim ho aur trader long time trading kr ke onke liye profit generate karta rahe

[anubhavsingh]

scalping ma risk factor buhat jiada hota ha i think iss liye some brokers nai chahte ke koi b person scalping kr ke apna loss karwa le aur osska account nill ho jaye unki policy ye hoti ha ke long time relation kaim ho aur trader long time trading kr ke onke liye profit generate karta rahe

me brokers ki is bat se sehmat nahi hon..kyunki mere hisab se scalping karna ya na karna tarder ki marzi hoti hai..isme broker ko beech me nahi padna chahaiey kynki trader apne analyse ke hisab se hi tarding karta hai..agar koi aur reason hota hai brokers ke pas scalping allow na karne ka to wo yaha zarur bataye..

[forexman]

i think scalping is risky one and sometimes money may lost even in a hour when there is a various of 500pips in a day and trader will lose all his money and broker cant get much comission if traders lose

[anubhavsingh]

hello traders, broker ka is mein koi role nehi, scalping allow ya disallow kernay ka, her broker wohi cheezien deta hey jo sab detay hien difference trader per hota hey. ab trader per depend kerta hey k woh kis broker k saath scalping keray

nahi bhai aisa nahi hai..kuch brokers aise hote hai jo ki scalping allow nahi karte..waise to ye fair nahi hai traders kel iye kyunki unki marzi hoti hai ki unhe scalping karni hai ya lambe trade rakhen hai...lekin kuch chite brokers scalping ko leke jkayi rules nikal dete hai jise traders ko bahut taklif hoti hai...isliye traders ko apne broker ke sare terms padne chahiey usko join karne se pehle

[muhammadatif]

Those brokers do not allow scalping method they want to facilitate traders because scalping is too more risky. If you will face loss daily you will leave forex market then brokers can earn commission from traders so those brokers want to save your and won business with this policy.

[Mehak]

main reason jo mjhay samajh ati ha k jis tarhan scalping ma profit hota ha isi tarhan sa lose k bhi chances parh jaatay hain jis sa trader bohat disheart ho jata ha...becoz usay kuch pips pehlay stop kerna hota ha...and broker ko phir faida nhi pohnchta if trader leave his trade...

[twinkling star]

mjhay to yeh lagta hai k broker isliya bhi allow nhi kertay k is say humain zyada loss honay ka khatra hota hai. and I also think k broker ko bhi loss hota ho ga humaray loss say. another thing is k brokers agar scalping allow kerain to phir zyada log scalping kerain ga.

[asingh601]

Scalping karke kai log hazaron dollars kama lete hain kam balance pe aur isse brokers ke brokerage par asar padta hai isliye ho sakta hai ki kai brokers scalping allow nahi karte hon.

[ermaniso2011]

the biggest reason is the liquidity problem.that is why some of the broker permitting scalping only for mini or micro accounts. actually broker can earn more if allow scalping couse they will get commission from all the trades.

[wolfkamikaz]

because of scalping many times, the number of transactions keep on increasing making it difficult for the brokers to examine each of them and to actually calculate the amount of profit and loss.

[shinde]

Many brokers are also concerned about the sharp fluctuations in the prices and thus their own margins are effected if this is being done to often. This is so because the earnings of the brokers do come from the difference of the BUY and the SELL prices.

[ali1011]

meray kheyla sy main ney to aik he broker use kia hy instaforex yeh to scalping allowed karta hy ap sab ko chaiye k is me a jain yeh acha trading setup hy is me scalping allow hy apko change karna chiye apna trading terminal jo apko scaling allow nhi karta kya kheyal hy apka?

[prem]

it is not good reason not allowing traders to use scalping only because server of broker could not handled transactions.may be it happened in small brokers which used worse server than commonly brokers.actually for dealing desk broker,it is more profitable when there is scalper because the brokers will get more earning from many open positions.

[hsngs14]

it is really there is a brokers that do not accept scalping trading , i think that there is no strong reason to banne this kind of trading at the end scalping is risk as like profitable.

[manoj]

i think by scalping trader can earn very fast and can earn large amount of money in less amount of time and this is the reason some of the brokers dont allow scalping because they will not make money from this traders

[kastur]

I do not think there is any problem with our profits, but this is only their server problems that will be disturbed if we use scpling and somehow scpling too quick to close the transaction so that the server service brokers may be in really big trouble

[kastur]

can be as long as you have a good internet connection you might not be a problem with the server for this scpling style but you must first set SL and TP to keep the server issues

[sid]

seems to have explained before, if this technique also makes a server becomes busier.
so that will make requotes becoming more frequent. and interfere with other traders.

[fxquest]

Perhaps scalping will slow down their server because of too many traders coming in at the same time and getting filled and more opened again almost immediately. This is the main reason I think that it will slow down the trading server of the broker.

This can be one reason because scalper enter and close many trades in short time and so brokers may have more load on their server, but i dont find it sufficient as the main purpose of brokers is to earn thru spread and scalpers are those who pay big amount in spread due to many trades.

[ashwini]

broker kiun allow nahi karte ..yeh to wohi jane.. main details main nahi jaunga..
bass yeh ki scalping karo par ek targt lee kar 1-2 baar karna hain.. aur long trade 1bar.. to sayad yeh hamare financial health ke liye accha hoyega..lekin agar hum bhi wohi kare jo scalper karte hain.. to natiza wohi hoga jo sab 90% beginer ke sath hota hain..

[prem]

it is not good reason not allowing traders to use scalping only because server of broker couldn't handled transaction.maybe it happened in small brokers which used worse server than commonly brokers.actually for dealing desk broker,it is more profitable when there is scalper because the broker will get more earning from many open position.

[forexman]

i think brokers wont allow as peoples may lose their more money by scalping but may be it is wrong and i dont know exact reason but i think only due to scalping traders may lose so they wont like as when traders lose they also wont get much comission,i mean if trader earn more they trade more and brokers earn more

[sonia]

i don't know why some broker don't allow scalping. i am not a scalper.but, i am supporting it, for some trader it seems successful. at least for that trader, broker should allow it.happy trading

[adahidayat]

i think that different brokers are regulated and registered with different bodies...so those bodies will ask give them rules and regulations and ask them to do now allow scalping....and also some brokers think that scalping needs more staff to handle transaction and trades...because scalpers will close alot of positions every day...so they cannot handle it ...so they will not allow scalping according to their broker rules....

[motiurbd]

I probably sure that the reason most traders don't allow scalping is because they dont want their platform to be congested and secondly they want good profit.

Scalpers opened too much trade in a single day.. And this is why brokers platform gets crowded to fulfill order of the customers.. To provide better performance to all some brokers restricted scalping in their platform.. But brokers like Insta-forex frequently add new servers... to handle those pressure.. this is why we get fastest execution here:yahoo:

[sio]

instaforex allow scalping and this is enough for me many brokers do not allow scalping may be cause of they loss pip when you enter on late point or they are trade opposit of trader.

[zeghbadrahem]

well i think that you mean the ECN account its true that in the past when there are not a lot of broker you read in the condition of the trading at the broker that the scalping not aloowad but now i think i guess that all the broker alowed it jsut the ECN account

[ishvara]

Truly, i personally do not know why they do not allow scalping in their trading platforms, i have never even asked them that question in that support section. Scalping in my opinion and experience will even help brokers to make more money through spreads.

[dmambi]

Scalpers opened too much trade in a single day.. And this is why brokers platform gets crowded to fulfill order of the customers.. To provide better performance to all some brokers restricted scalping in their platform.. But brokers like Insta-forex frequently add new servers... to handle those pressure.. this is why we get fastest execution here:yahoo:

But when a trader is opening more orders per day then the broker will get more profit in terms of spreads and they should very much happy to allow the traders to do the scalping. I think there may be other strong reasons for not allowing scalping.

[arihant]

it happened because some broker still use desk dealing, and when their client do a scalping, the execution order could be closed just before it through the market, the profit that their client earn would be a loss to the broker

but mostly that happened with B rated broker, an A rated broker like insta allow their client to scalping

[gala]

yeah this usually because they're the market maker type, which trades against us. So there's no way they will be allowing their traders to do a scalping, it's just the same like they're giving their money to us freely.

[lgarhboularbah]

Normally brokers don't send order to the inter bank regularly so if some one make profit from the trade then broker pay from his pocket, Broker think that all traders will loose amount so he collect that amount without sending information to interbank, so they don't allow scalping

yes you are right we can find this kind of broker and i think that we shoumld avoid it they dont send our order exprie till the change of the price but when they change with lost they open it i think that they send the order at the new price and open our deal at the old one

[nilesh]

Those brokers do not allow scalping method they want to facilitate traders because scalping is too more risky. If you will face loss daily you will leave forex market then brokers can earn commission from traders so those brokers want to save your and won business with this policy.

[pooja]

seems to have explained before, if this technique also makes a server becomes busier.
so that will make requotes becoming more frequent. and interfere with other traders.

[vikas]

i had read in a post somewhere i remember tht the cause to this scalping being avoided was said to be problems in the system which are caused due to it so they avoid scalping

[kameeelforex]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

main ne akser dekha ha k kuch brokerssca lping allowednahi karetpehely main bhi kafi sochta tha k kioun woh allowedna hi kartey to es ka jawaab mugh ko ye mila k ye salping ye us broker ka server buzy ho jata ha or es se us broker ki repotion down hoti ha esi liye main samghta houn k brokers scalping allowednahik arte y hane

[forexbroker123]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.
han scalping ackser brokers allowed nahi kartey kioun k es se traders kafi loss main bhi jatey hane or jo trader jo k newbie hota ha or us ko loss ho to woh forex trading ko churrr jata ha fear ka shiakr ho kar kioun k us ko kafi loss hota ha es ki waja se or eis liye brokers apme custumers ko jane nahi detey or woh scalping allowed nahi kartey or dosri barri waja ye ha k es se broker ka server bhi down ho jata ha or es ki waja se woh scalping allowed nahi kartey hane

[niteshforex]

Many brokers are also concerned about the sharp fluctuations in the prices and thus their own margins are effected if this is being done to often. This is so because the earnings of the brokers do come from the difference of the BUY and the SELL prices.

[jai]

I think server is one of the problem broker dont allow scalping. It is very first entry and exit trade. Server may problem other trader to trade. Some broker have many server.
It can help trader to trade smoothly.

[lgarhboularbah]

i have 2 yers old in the forex market and i see broker like this in the past because you can read in thr condition that you can close your deal when you open it till pass 3 min and t deffrent from broker to an other one but now all the broker accept the scalping but the ECN's account

[siddesh]

yeah this usually because they're the market maker type, which trades against us. So there's no way they will be allowing their traders to do a scalping, it's just the same like they're giving their money to us freely.

[krishan]

कुछ दलालों scalping bcoz की अनुमति न हानि की संभावना scalping के दौरान अधिक है क्योंकि हम केवल 5 pips या 10 pips के ले. इसलिए एक बार यू हानि कई बार यू न विदेशी मुद्रा में व्यापार की आशा है और यू विदेशी मुद्रा स्थायी रूप से छोड़ दो और तो दलाल पैसे फैलता में u से नहीं कर सकते हैं. ताकि वे न की अनुमति यू scalping.this के लिए मुख्य कारणों

[amit]

it's not always about the profit, but some brokers do have their own reason why they don't allow their traders to do scalping. as far as i know, scalping involve short time TF, and this mean that the platform will pull the recent data continuously to guarantee that the chart represent the real data. Such action will need a lot of bandwith that effect the broker server. more over if the number of traders that doing the scalping is in large scale. it can make the server down.

[amit]

hello traders, broker ka is mein koi role nehi, scalping allow ya disallow kernay ka, her broker wohi cheezien deta hey jo sab detay hien difference trader per hota hey. ab trader per depend kerta hey k woh kis broker k saath scalping keray

[siddesh]

Isnta forex kay pass bohot ziada servers hain aur un ko server par pressuer ka koi problem naheen hay. Traders apny man pasand broker kay pass apnee man pasand ki trading kar sakty hain yahan koi bann naheen hay kisi kisam ki bhi trading par.

[krishan]

There is almost no role for the brokers in scalping. In scalping traders hold their trading position just for few minutes and the profits are also very less. In that case, brokers don't get commission that they hope to get. There is low spread during scalping and we all know that low spread is definitely not good for the brokers to make money.

[krishan]

It is quite amazing that some brokers do not allow scalping. I think from scalping they should get more commission because in scalping traders open many positions in very less time so broker will earn more and it is beneficial for a broker.

[chetan]

instaforex me har tarah ki trading ki facility hai kyunki iska server bahut hi fast hai aur traders ko kabhi koi dikkat nahi hui
instaforex ke stah me long term trading bhi karta hon short term trading bhi karta hon aur daily basis pe scalping bhi akrta hon

[netra]

i don't know why some broker don't allow scalping. i am not a scalper.but, i am supporting it, for some trader it seems successful. at least for that trader, broker should allow it.happy trading

[sachin]

i think by scalping trader can earn very fast and can earn large amount of money in less amount of time and this is the reason some of the brokers dont allow scalping because they will not make money from this traders

[andhwrey]

Maybe brokers see thats are more risk to practice scalp method,we know not all scalpers succeed,more risk if we play like that
and brokers look for long term in patnership to us

[newentry]

there are many reason for it and i heard that scalping will make low their server and i do not know is it true or not and because there are many brokers allowed scalping too, so where is the problem here, and for this condition will build many reason...and for me, i just joined with broker who allowed scalping

[tajdarbet]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

han akser broker jo hane scalping allowed nahi kartey hane kioun k es se ek to trader ko loss bhi ziyada hota ha or phr woh fear ka shikar ho k trading churr deteyn hane or jo sab se barri bat ha woh ye ha k es se broker ka server bhi bzy ho jata ha es liye woh allowed nahi kartey haen

[tiar]

maybe too many position was made by trader, it makes they have to work hard to serve every trader.
or maybe the broker is non dealing broker desk, the broker have to pay every trader by themself. that's why the broker not allow scalping

[sunil]

It is quite amazing that some brokers do not allow scalping. I think from scalping they should get more commission because in scalping traders open many positions in very less time so broker will earn more and it is beneficial for a broker.

[sachin]

Well if a trader losses money from scalping, that should not be the brokers problem. After the trader has already been informed of the risks involved in forex trading before he became involved. If the broker wants to protect trader, then they can remove spreads and comissions

[narendra]

i have 2 yers old in the forex market and i see broker like this in the past because you can read in thr condition that you can close your deal when you open it till pass 3 min and t deffrent from broker to an other one but now all the broker accept the scalping but the ECN's account

[narendra]

Some brokers do not allow scalping because they have fear that their inexperienced clients will blow their accounts and brokers will not get regular commission from those clients. Because broker will not be benefited in the forum of commission if his clients will blow their accounts.

[vineet]

yeah this usually because they're the market maker type, which trades against us. So there's no way they will be allowing their traders to do a scalping, it's just the same like they're giving their money to us freely.

[rakesh]

ya its true when i trade in one broker than they set trade time minimum 2 minutes and send me a mal informing me that most of my trade going to scalping and its not good and its very risky . but i think when some traders really earning good from scalping and risk is fully traders then broker prevent us probably for server issue.

[deathzz]

some brokers might prohibit scalping because it was feared there will be traders who put up with a very large lot with a very small target, it is actually very detrimental to the broker. But only some are banning scalping broker, so read the rules before you place trades before signing up.

[waqtitrader]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.
meri hobby ha k main brokers join karta rehta houn or es taranse main brokers k mutaliq janta bhi houn kafi ziyada mere khiyal mian to es liye bhi broker scalping allowed nahi kartey kioun k bar bar scalping karne se us broker ka server bzy ho jata h or dosrey customer ko apne trade open ya close karne main mushkil hoti ha es liye baaz brokers scalping allowed nahi kartey haen

[sinaga]

I think every broker has different rules. scalping by the broker may be able to merugiakan him. by using a scalping strategy, we can make a tremendous keuntunan. but I think if we are lucky, the broker will also be more profitable. because the percentage of profit that we get will also be taken by the broker.

[jai]

meray kheyla sy main ney to aik he broker use kia hy instaforex yeh to scalping allowed karta hy ap sab ko chaiye k is me a jain yeh acha trading setup hy is me scalping allow hy apko change karna chiye apna trading terminal jo apko scaling allow nhi karta kya kheyal hy apka?

[lode]

i have not good information about it but i think that those brokers trade against the traders DD brokers but what i can not understand is the most of traders who use scalping lose in forex too.

[jai]

i have 2 yers old in the forex market and i see broker like this in the past because you can read in thr condition that you can close your deal when you open it till pass 3 min and t deffrent from broker to an other one but now all the broker accept the scalping but the ECN's account

[anitagala124]

there are many reason for it and i heard that scalping will make low their server and i do not know is it true or not and because there are many brokers allowed scalping too, so where is the problem here, and for this condition will build many reason...and for me, i just joined with broker who allowed scalping

[rano53]

Haar aik broker kie apanie apanie kavayd or zavbaat hotie hai....iss layee baaz broker scalping allow nahee kartie ..iss kie aik woja ye be hai scalper
bohot zayda hotie hai iss layee haar aik broker itanie jaldi itanie logo ko handle nahee kaar saktie...That why they do not allow scalping....

[kaji]

I see that some brokers are not allowed to trade with scalping strategy, because this strategy will make the traders often open and close a position that will not overload theer server......

[norix]

there are many reason for it and i heard that scalping will make low their server and i do not know is it true or not and because there are many brokers allowed scalping too, so where is the problem here, and for this condition will build many reason...and for me, i just joined with broker who allowed scalping

maybe if someone trading scalping system of profit he can complete very quickly, hence enabling some brokers refused to use a scalping system
but I myself prefer scalping hopefully on my broker there is no prohibition in the future

[Marcs]

i think that some brokers dont allow scalping because the chances of loss is high during scalping since we take only 5 pips or 10 pips. so once u loss many times u will dont have the hope of trading in forex and u will leave forex permanently and then broker cannot make money from u in spreads....

[ShoSho]

those brokers that do not allow scalping are market makers , they do not allow it because it is so profitable for the trader but the market makers don't want you to earn but they want you to lose your account and deposit it again so i prefer to open an ECN account to avoid that problem
Really i do not know why i think as you said the main problem that most of brokers do not want it is fast earnings method but i do not know why they do not like that also they will take the spread that they want in all cases.

[forexman]

Yes, it is not good reason not allowing traders to use scalping only because server of broker couldn't
handled transaction. Maybe it happened in small brokers which used worse server than commonly brokers.
Actually for dealing-desk broker, it is more profitable when there is scalper because the brokers will
get more earning from many open positions.

yes you are right and only some brokers will allow and also when brokers allow they only get more earnings when people open more positions so athts why so many brokers even allowing scalping but i did not came across scalping not allowed brokers upto now

[Amitab]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

Some brokers do not allow scalping strategy by what he is very dangerous for the accounts, by the scalping is used jackpot with a target of 5 or 6 pips profit per trade, so to win is good but there is a big loss if the market goes in one direction against what you expect, so watch out when you use this strategy.

[jai]

This can be one reason because scalper enter and close many trades in short time and so brokers may have more load on their server, but i dont find it sufficient as the main purpose of brokers is to earn thru spread and scalpers are those who pay big amount in spread due to many trades.

[jmsblack18]

Some broker who doesn't allow scalping sometimes had 2 reason when we ask them. Th first reason ussually because they are market maker and need hold your fund to hedging it with other broker. And the other reason is they have small server and cannot hold scalping technique because it is hard for their server.

[girish]

i think by scalping trader can earn very fast and can earn large amount of money in less amount of time and this is the reason some of the brokers dont allow scalping because they will not make money from this traders

[gava]

It is quite amazing that some brokers do not allow scalping. I think from scalping they should get more commission because in scalping traders open many positions in very less time so broker will earn more and it is beneficial for a broker.

[mita]

It's really surprising for me to listen that some brokers do not allow scalping because till now I was thinking that the more we trade the more commission goes to a broker but if they don't allow scalping then I think they are not doing well for themselves.

[gava]

Those brokers do not allow scalping method they want to facilitate traders because scalping is too more risky. If you will face loss daily you will leave forex market then brokers can earn commission from traders so those brokers want to save your and won business with this policy.

[darksaimon]

Usually brokers don't displace arrangement to the inter side regularly so if few one hit clear from the trade then broker pay from his innervation, Broker consider that all traders instrument infirm assets so he acquire that become without sending accumulation to interbank, so they don't portion scalping

[avi]

Normally brokers don't send order to the inter bank regularly so if some one make profit from the trade then broker pay from his pocket, Broker think that all traders will loose amount so he collect that amount without sending information to interbank, so they don't allow scalping

[yaar]

i have not good information about it but i think that those brokers trade against the traders DD brokers but what i can not understand is the most of traders who use scalping lose in forex too.

[Nabi Ahmed Gill]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

nahi bahi insta forex trading main asa ko chakcer nahi ha ya scapling ka mara jub dil karta ha min apana order closed karta hoo or mara jab dil kara main apn order open karta hon mian na abi tak yahe borker use ka ha is ka alwa min na koi or borker use nahi ka ,..

[waqarme2]

majority of the brokers don't allow the scalping its just because of that through this method the chances of earning money becomes low and i think that lot of the traders work here to win not to lose.

[ishvara]

majority of the brokers don't allow the scalping its just because of that through this method the chances of earning money becomes low and i think that lot of the traders work here to win not to lose.

The reverse is the case in forex trading. It is most brokers that support scalping in their forex trading terminal/platform. I personally do not know why it is that way, i think i would make some investigations about it.

[bhai]

han akser broker jo hane scalping allowed nahi kartey hane kioun k es se ek to trader ko loss bhi ziyada hota ha or phr woh fear ka shikar ho k trading churr deteyn hane or jo sab se barri bat ha woh ye ha k es se broker ka server bhi bzy ho jata ha es liye woh allowed nahi kartey haen

[Maham Gill]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

Main na to trading ke starting esi forum sa ke ha es laaya muaj to ya pata ha k ya forum sub sa acah forum ha ya forum apna members ko boht sara information or facility data ha mujaha ya nahi pata tha k kuch forum take profit and stop loss mara matalab ha scalping ke ajzat nahi data han to phar u forum main trading karana kafi dangerous ho sakta ha.

[waleedkhan]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

woh sirf is liya allow nhi karta hain kion kay kafi banda us ka galat istamal karta hain wasa tu mujh is kay bara may zayda kuch pata nhi hai woh sirf is liya kion kay may yahan par new hun is waja say may kuch zayda app ko is kay bara may zayda nhi bata sakta hun.

[Forexboy]

In time can have new scalping because these latter have an impact in the medium that you can open any order because the price moves in one direction for a short time back to the original if the trend thing is not reversed. And the entry point if you entered at a good price, you can get good profits.

[cac4a26]

I anticipate that agent have to be non-dealing board agent because this affectionate of agent didn't yield advantages from spreads alone but they acclimated our funds (trader's fund) to barter by their self.

[nizamitrading]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

han gi app ki baat sahi ha k akser broker scalping nahi allowed nahi kartey hane kioun k es se us broker k server down ho jata ha or es se un ko kafi loss hota ha es liye mere khiyam main na brokers scalping allowed nahi kartey hane

[maurya]

I see that some brokers are not allowed to trade with scalping strategy, because this strategy will make the traders often open and close a position that will not overload theer server......

[ishvara]

I see that some brokers are not allowed to trade with scalping strategy, because this strategy will make the traders often open and close a position that will not overload theer server......

I have also thought about this thing that you have said now, closing thousands of trades by traders might be causing network problem for the servers of our brokers. That might be why they are not allowing it.

[taufiqbd]

Some brokers have do not allow scalping because if broker allow scalping then need very high power trading platform. To develop scalping trading platform, need huge money but scalping trading is less profitable than long trading for broker.

[wendhrie]

I think scalping trading just make the server work harder,
because it some brokers don't alllowed us to scalping.

[netra]

well I still do not understand why some traders do not allow scalping but it can be that the broker does not have sufficient funds or infrastructure to keep a tab on many trades from different clients and that can give him sufficient reason not to allow scalping to their clients .

[dweet]

Nowadays most of the brokers allow scalping, almost all the ECN or STP brokers allow scalping, it is only few market makers do not allow scalping, the reason could be because they do not have a direct dealing desk so no direct execution and makes them work a lot for that particular transaction.

[asama]

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aaaaaaa

[kapil_chemical_07]

I do not know the foolish broker,who do not allow scalping.It is really stupidity.Why the broker do not allow scalping?It is my right to scalping. Is it possible?Do you know any broker who does such kind of work?

[traderapes]

In my opinion, most brokers do not allow scalping forex scalping due to server work harder for scalpers typically execute trades in a fairly short time. But some brokers allow it to attract clients to their broker.

[sumonmia0526]

some brokers dont allow scalping bcoz the chances of loss is high during scalping since we take only 5 pips or 10 pips. so once u loss many times u will dont have the hope of trading in forex and u will leave forex permanently and then broker cannot make money from u in spreads. so they dont allow u for scalping.this is the main reasons

yes possibly they don't allow for the reason u said but i heard some brokers are running dealing desk or something like that .but the tropic in not the dealing desk ..as i think most of the regulated brokers are allow scalping technique .scalping is very risky for trader and it can destroy anyone's trading career in short time .

[warnisw]

brokers server cant handle so many requests at same time, for second there are many brokers with dealing desk, scalping is not possible with them. some brokers just dont like scalpers because they charge commission and want earn more. and some brokers has web-trading where it wouldn't be possible

[budado]

Those who don't allows scalping want to have a long term trader as an investors. As most scalpers does not last a month. In fact I read an article that 90% of new accounts that use scalping they loss their account in less than three months. So those who don't allow scalping in fact help those newbies to stay a float for a while. As you can see its even good for broker site to have scalpers since they can earn per trade.

[kaia]

Perhaps many of the traders who like scalping, because they think this technique is easier and takes a short time but can produce a fairly decent profit. And that makes the brokers do not like, so that these regulations.

[rahulsagar]

maybe if someone trading scalping system of profit he can complete very quickly, hence enabling some brokers refused to use a scalping system
but I myself prefer scalping hopefully on my broker there is no prohibition in the future

[forextrader38]

Some brokers bcoz scalping scalping opportunity when the damage is high because we are only 5 points or 10 points may be. So when I lost a lot of times I have left a permanent foreign currency trading and foreign currency no hope in me, and then pay a broker can u openings. So the main reason I do not scalping.this

[digger_jim]

One of the simplest reason is because their infrastructure couldn't afford it. Remember, scalping means opening and closing many trades in a very short time. And for every order (either opening or closing a position) is treated singularly by the broker's infrastructure. Too many orders in a short time make it overload.

[ayusri]

Normally brokers don't send order to the inter bank regularly so if some one make profit from the trade then broker pay from his pocket, Broker think that all traders will loose amount so he collect that amount without sending information to interbank, so they don't allow scalping

prohibiting broker broker usually several ways and methods of trading is a brokerage that deserves to be suspected, a broker that too many rules we better leave, now hundreds and hundreds of brokers diinternet strewn with all sorts of facilities provided if today there are brokers that prohibits one form only of trading means the broker is not a professional broker, most likely to cheat is very large, a broker like this mock-maker is to be shunned and You do not want all once trading in broker like this, you must have lost money because of the jahati by a broker, a good broker is that allow all forms of trading, trading and all means whatever we want to do with trading, all forms of trading should not be a problem for the broker, the broker juhilah limiting our trading way.

[zeshan]

dear u write about the scalping it is the helpful for the new traders and the traders who don t now about that the now and can trade and earn the money by using the forex

[barn]

because if trading scalping is usually quick and fast open position closed position, so if more people are trading scalping it will make the path to be busy (requotes). to limit that there is usually a policy to prohibit trading with scalping method.

[purohit]

i think by scalping trader can earn very fast and can earn large amount of money in less amount of time and this is the reason some of the brokers dont allow scalping because they will not make money from this traders

[brutu]

in Some brokers do not allow scalping, scalping is where we only take 5 pips or 10 pips, so high a chance as possible peel losses, do not let the peeling. So, in the hope of foreign exchange trading that you do not earn a few times after a loss now and forever if you leave the foreign exchange, make money from your broker to deploy is not possible. So, rather than allow it to flake off.

[joru]

meray kheyla sy main ney to aik he broker use kia hy instaforex yeh to scalping allowed karta hy ap sab ko chaiye k is me a jain yeh acha trading setup hy is me scalping allow hy apko change karna chiye apna trading terminal jo apko scaling allow nhi karta kya kheyal hy apka?

[irena_xcn]

Scalping iss considered very risky by most traders, somevery skillful ones pride on these skills, i know eveb beginners sometimes try to do it. for brokers, they wouldn't want you to lose everything i guess, that's why they do it

[ernestina]

I do not really know how to scalp but I think that instaforex allow for scalping and even hedging. If a broker does not allow for scalping then its clients that like to scalp will migrate to other brokers that allow for scalping.

[younesjoe]

i think that instaforex accepte a scalping we have no problem , me to i like a scalping it's the most fast strategie to earn money but one things it's risk because we choose a bigg volume to have a bigg profit in just little pips

[alvabra2010]

I think the brokers don't allow scalping, firstly because it is considered to be a risky form of trading. Secondly, at times it could be lose on the brokers end because even before the trade could be forwarded to the bank, it is closed and the amount has to be paid by the broker. Thirdly, it puts a lot of pressure on the server because of continuous open and close order within a span of short time.

[sudsind]

scalping is basically pip hunting for 1-5 pips and closing the position usually before 2 minutes, that's basically what scalping is but people modified it according to themselves, broker usually don't like filling and exiting orders so fast and they also sometimes were not be able to send orders to the servers in terms of very short term scalping, these created problems and heaps of orders with very short timeframe exit,

[macblanc474]

some brokers don't acquiesce scalping because the affairs of accident is top during scalping back we yield alone 5 pips or 10 pips. so already u accident abounding times u will don't accept the achievement of trading in Forex and u will leave Forex assuredly and again agent cannot accomplish money.

[Xasir]

It is amazing that some brokers do not allow scalping. I'm thinking of scalping more commission they get, because scalping traders to open many positions in very less time so that the broker is earning more and is advantageous for a broker.

[zulqurnaine]

Yes some broker didnot allow to use scalping but insta forex in not imposed such kind of condition. It is not good reason to ban on using scalping only because server of broker couldn't handle transaction. it is more profitable when there is scalper because the brokers will get more earning from many open positions.

[bedi]

Yes some broker didnot allow to use scalping but insta forex in not imposed such kind of condition. It is not good reason to ban on using scalping only because server of broker couldn't handle transaction. it is more profitable when there is scalper because the brokers will get more earning from many open positions.

broker does not agree to use the scalping trades possible in the way business karnakan 2-3 pip forex with a target in a short time. that's what causes the broker does not allow..

[ex22]

when you comprehend the methods scapling well I'm sure you are going to not think twice to work with this technique particularly when kondsisi sidway happens towards the market you're trading currencies

[MIMIH]

HELLO/Scalping is a trading method that consists in taking profits in anticipation rapidements very small movements. This is generally very popular with beginners who want quick results. Although this technique is not easy, it can be very lucrative if it is properly managed

[hitesh]

yeah this usually because they're the market maker type, which trades against us. So there's no way they will be allowing their traders to do a scalping, it's just the same like they're giving their money to us freely.

[irfan]

Basically scalping is the most effective but dangerous way of quick earning in forex trading and most of the time scalping becomes gambling when a trader has not a sufficient experience and knowledge of trend analysis hence many brokers don't allow scalping because they want to save their customers from huge losses.

[aarti]

it's not always about the profit, but some brokers do have their own reason why they don't allow their traders to do scalping. as far as i know, scalping involve short time TF, and this mean that the platform will pull the recent data continuously to guarantee that the chart represent the real data. Such action will need a lot of bandwith that effect the broker server. more over if the number of traders that doing the scalping is in large scale. it can make the server down.

[vanigota]

maybe that is becasue some of the broker was got the loss when we are got the profit from here, so they are do not allow the forex trader to make the scalping and then some of the trader can make the scalping being really profitable

[grabbani]

To my consideration the thing is it is quite amazing that some brokers do not allow scalping. I think from scalping they should get more commission because in scalping traders open many positions in very less time so broker will earn more and it is beneficial for a broker. This is how the brokers are trading with us.

[faria]

several stockbrokers don't make it possible for scalping since the prospect of decline will be large in the course of scalping due to the fact all of us get solely 5 pips as well as 10 pips. thus after oughout decline many times oughout will certainly don't have the desire regarding buying and selling with forex trading and also oughout will certainly abandon forex trading for good and then dealer are not able to make money using oughout with advances. so they don't make it possible for oughout regarding scalping. this is actually the major reasons

[jhang]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

scalping ki waja se na forex broker ka server buzy ho jata ha or us se traders ko order pass karney main kafi mushkil hoti ha or es se kafi masley hotey haen esliye na akser broker ye allowed nahi kartey ahen

[truegoa]

some brokers dont allow scalping bcoz the chances of loss is high during scalping since we take only 5 pips or 10 pips. so once u loss many times u will dont have the hope of trading in forex and u will leave forex permanently and then broker cannot make money from u in spreads. so they dont allow u for scalping.this is the main reasons

Thats what I heard from any other forum about this restriction. But, that reason still cant get into my sense.Since this scalping method, once we master it, more profitable and earningfully beside any other method -> will stay wealthy in forex. And surely, to reach little pips like 5 to 10 pips (in my case 3-5 pips) is much easier than bigger pips, thats why for me it makes no sense that this loss higher ratio than any other method like they said.

[sufanw1]

Because if it is allowed to use the broker scalping technique afraid to lose. Because scalping is a lot we can freely use and take advantage of each moment and whatever we want. That's why many brokers do not allow scalping. That is my opinion why in the broker not allow scalping.

[CemonG]

To my consideration the thing is it is quite amazing that some brokers do not allow scalping. I think from scalping they should get more commission because in scalping traders open many positions in very less time so broker will earn more and it is beneficial for a broker. This is how the brokers are trading with us.

ha ...ha ... hahahaha .... it's not well done fella hope if we only get commissions from trading, trading results isn't bigger than a Commission broker?? Maybe you don't think of others because it's not your own money, so make a transaction without any substitute analysis is perfect ... scalping can be done from already had speed in analysis and speed on the use of computer devices.

[hitcola]

in fact I don't know as I don't found any reasonable reason for the brokers to prevent scalping! I know that all fair broker do allow scalping with no problems

[jab we met]

Now more and more traders like scalping trading, but as far as I know, there are some brokers which don't allow scalping, I am really confused about this. cause you know, brokers can get profit when traders close their tradings, no matter traders get profit or lose money, this mean the more transactions traders make the more profit brokers will get. Anyone who can explain it.

i also do not know why some broker do not allow the use to scalp the forex market i think we need lot of experience for scalping so trader may think due to scalping may trader suffer big loss if trade going to bad

[nabila]

Now writer and author traders suchlike scalping trading, but as far as I hump, there are whatsoever brokers which don't provide scalping, I am rattling confused about this. justification you mate, brokers can get earn when traders immediate their tradings, no thing traders get vantage or decline money, this colligate the more transactions traders work the more clear brokers faculty get.

[penjualdolar]

i also do not know why some broker do not allow the use to scalp the forex market i think we need lot of experience for scalping so trader may think due to scalping may trader suffer big loss if trade going to bad

yes you are right, it is difficult to understand why we make prohibiting scalping broker, because brokers will get our profit from every transaction we have closed, because the broker is the main income of the spread....

[place]

confuse but i saw many of scalper have in forex brokers who are doing scalping.and this is our pride who can make quick profits with little time.so brokers should not stop to allow scalping for my view.

[ayusri]

i also do not know why some broker do not allow the use to scalp the forex market i think we need lot of experience for scalping so trader may think due to scalping may trader suffer big loss if trade going to bad

brokers only broker who cheat and a minimum capital that usually do not have the correct licenses that prohibit sclaping, broker broker broker too many rules is a huge potential to cheat and defraud traders with memanikan prices on meta trader, the broker should not prohibit any form of the style and way of trading because traders are doing a good trading profit or loss will not affect the broker because he is just as dealers trading from the trader's mandate to be delivered to the market, brokers are too many rules is that certain brokers scam and would deceive us away from the trader to the broker which makes bnayak rules because later he will deceive the trader, as traders we must be good at reading the situation, most of the rules makes the broker will be quiet and not crowded people trading there, now the competition is very tight broker broker cheated just a little noise traders will be busy fulfilling forum forums and other people will read it and avoid broker as the broker would be hurt by the scam broker lonely trader to trader rules that harm would be detrimental to the broker's own future, for us please select a broker that traders are not many rules properly licensed and broker rapid pay as withdrawl, and in this case of course that never prohibits broker of any rule in the style and way of trading.

[isbhacker]

A broker that dont allow scalping I think is because The broker has large orders to handle and cannot put orders every second by a single trader.They have thousands traders and If they trade at same time ten it is difficult to handle Although scalping gives benefit to brokers more.

[barn]

scalping is the strategy of the transaction quickly. so quick and fast to open position to close the position. it's just because of scalping that many times it will make the connection path is sometimes so busy making other transactions requotes.

[redlion]

this is the first time that i heard that brokers don't allow scalping. i dont think that the broker has a right to do that because what trading method to follow is the traders decission not the brokers. if there are any such brokers they should be made known to everyone on forums like this so that traders could keep away from them.

[lovebird]

Ordinarily brokers don't transfer organization to the inter incline regularly so if many one eliminate earn from the line then broker pay from his steal, Broker opine that all traders will unconsolidated amount so he store that quantity without sending message to interbank, so they don't consent scalping

[ishvara]

I have been suspecting many reasons why brokers could not allow scalping, but now i think that it is best for me to actually find out these reasons from the support section of a forex broker that does not allow scalping.

[elking]

There are a lot of companies do not want to work Scalping see that the reason the server is slow and the company's non-implementation of orders very quickly and thus the risk of the transactions

[shakilfx0]

Scalping is harmful for new trader.He can be loser any time. Every minute has been changed in forex market.I always avoid scalping.Every trader should avoid scalping.