Manual trading - best trading strategy.

[Anytime]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

[saurabh]

both are good sir for good ea good vps is needed and manual trading good practise is needed using good strategies to get results is needed

[Victoryindia]

mere hisab se manual trading or signal both are better trading stragity as saurab say u need good practise for manually trading to get good no of amount or good result.signal is also better for us agar hume signal mil jata hai toh maximum time woh profit hi deta hai

[anubhavsingh]

According to me, any preplanned trading can not work in this market as you can not predict its condition after few hours.
But according to me, every trader hsould follow proper technical and fundamental analysis before opening and closing any deal.

[nilu]

If people using manual trading then we can learn lot of thing while we are trading. If we USe EA and Signals then we can't learn things even we are trading for some years.

[soumen]

manual trading accha he. par mere khayal se ye too hard he. agar aap kisi signal ka sahara lete ho to aap ko thoda asani milega. kuch log to without indicator ke trade karte he. par mere khayal me ye nehi ate he ki wo log karte kaise he. indicator ke sahara lenese aap ko bahut sare subhidha prapt hote he. aur ha main manula close karne me jyada bharosa karte hoon.

[andry777]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

Yes, I ever knew that there are many traders who used EA and most of them are beginner traders in forex. It is okay to use EA or signal but the fact, there is no one who could success in trading if they used EA only without any analysis or use informations from forex signal directly to market. EA will be so effective in trading if that was used well, I means not 100% automated trading but we still must monitor and make open or close position if that was necessary.

[rajuonline]

Main bhi sochta hoon ki manual trding is best among all. apne dam par trde karna or ea se help lena bahut difference he. par main manual trading abhi bhi sikh nehi paya hoon. par main manual trading sikh raha hoon. yehi manual trading strategy ki fyde he.

[s19]

Main bhi sochta hoon ki manual trding is best among all. apne dam par trde karna or ea se help lena bahut difference he. par main manual trading abhi bhi sikh nehi paya hoon. par main manual trading sikh raha hoon. yehi manual trading strategy ki fyde he.

i also give the more weight to manual trading...EA dont have ability to think but we have...for learning it need a lot of pracitce...do it one day you are able to do this

[mayengbam]

i have heard about many robots making profits but havent tried one yet. but it seems there are really good ones. i use a few ea and sometimes they bring good profits too. so ea s are also good in my opinion

[arjun]

we must create it manually trading system first , if successful, then we change it to automatic ( EA ). if EA bought from other people and we do not know basically. it is tantamount to suicide.

[andry777]

Manual trading is good to build our analysis and psychology in trading, EA is not good for beginner but maybe it could
help for expert traders. In the first time we learned forex, we shouldn't use EA because it's risky and we can't learn
anything if we used EA. Manual trading is good for starting point and also to sharpen our analysis in one or more pairs.

[mayengbam]

depending on ourselves for our own success is basically the right choice, but if we can get help through reliable ea or robots is also a good option. i guess it may even speed up the success. but it all depends on us to decide what is good for us.

[Victoryindia]

depending on ourselves for our own success is basically the right choice, but if we can get help through reliable ea or robots is also a good option. i guess it may even speed up the success. but it all depends on us to decide what is good for us.


if we do manually trading then if we loss then also we can learn many thing but if we used ea an if we loss then we will not able to learn anything so manually trading is best.

[siberian]

if we do manually trading then if we loss then also we can learn many thing but if we used ea an if we loss then we will not able to learn anything so manually trading is best.

Yes, that was right. In manual trading, trader will do analyze by himself so when there is mistakes in his analysis,
he can learn from his mistakes. But if trader used EA, he could learn because it is not his analysis. But for expert
traders, EA can help to trade in certain condition. EA is like automated indicators, that's in my mind.

[pivot-trader]

in my opinion manuall trading is the best. with manual trading, we can get knowledge but if with automatic trading? NO.

[denira]

in my opinion manuall trading is the best. with manual trading, we can get knowledge but if with automatic trading? NO.

I do not think it was a friend because of trade using the EA program is also made ​​of the ability of traders to trade forex manual is not without foundation at all even professional traders

[pivot-trader]

I do not think it was a friend because of trade using the EA program is also made �6�7�6�7of the ability of traders to trade forex manual is not without foundation at all even professional traders

in my opinion, trading with ea is have disadvantages. we can learn how to prediction market with right. and never can.

[mayengbam]

in my opinion manuall trading is the best. with manual trading, we can get knowledge but if with automatic trading? NO.

yeah to learn, manual trading is the best because we will have the idea about how the profit/loss occurs if we trade manually which we will know if trade with an EA. So looking from the angle of learning manual trading is the best

[venkiaries61]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

Absolutely correct, EA doesn't have sense, All EA must end in lose. I used many EAs, all of them were fail in reversal direction. I have own experience in EA test. I personally recommend you to trade manually. If you heard profitable EA, then that should costs heavily.

[denira]

yeah to learn, manual trading is the best because we will have the idea about how the profit/loss occurs if we trade manually which we will know if trade with an EA. So looking from the angle of learning manual trading is the best

I agree with your opinion, however, that started trading with the manual is the best way to master the trade and master the mental emotion of our trade

[arjun]

in my opinion manuall trading is the best. with manual trading, we can get knowledge but if with automatic trading? NO.

I think both of these require knowledge and also generate knowledge..
if we use the EA, then we must understand the computer language to be able to make the EA.

[pinpin]

Manual trading - best trading strategy

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?
I think the manual is the best trading
because I never had a bad experience using EA
3 times I nearly MC because EA
and now I discourage using EA
because I think using the EA requires significant capital, and I do not have large capital

[arjun]

I think the manual is the best trading
because I never had a bad experience using EA
3 times I nearly MC because EA
and now I discourage using EA
because I think using the EA requires significant capital, and I do not have large capital

I guess no need to use a large capital to be able to use the EA,
if you are a little capital, you can open an account cent,
many traders who do so.

[mayengbam]

I think the manual is the best trading
because I never had a bad experience using EA
3 times I nearly MC because EA
and now I discourage using EA
because I think using the EA requires significant capital, and I do not have large capital

yes as i have said earlier also manual trading is very very important to learn and gain experience of trading. And what we require is good experience and we can get it through trading directly with ourselves

[soumen]

I think both of these require knowledge and also generate knowledge..
if we use the EA, then we must understand the computer language to be able to make the EA.
ha yaar aap ekdam sahi ho. dono ko samajh neke liye gyan hi jaruri he. to isliye dono alag alag jagah pe thik he. aur ha manual trading me accha khasa jankari rakhna parta he. indicator aur trend follow karna parta he. tab jake manual trading best trading strategy hoga.

[anubhavsingh]

manual trading mere hisab se sabse achi trading hoti hai kyunki isse aapko kafi acha experiance mil sakta hai jo ki aapki long term trading ke liye bahut hi zada faydemand saabit hoi sakta hai..
Forex market me jitna role analysis ka hota hai usse zada role experiance ka hota hai..jo ki amnual trading se kafi acha mil sakta ai

[pinpin]

I guess no need to use a large capital to be able to use the EA,
if you are a little capital, you can open an account cent,
many traders who do so.
yes you are right, but I've been wary to use ea
because I would want to trade using my own abilities

yes as i have said earlier also manual trading is very very important to learn and gain experience of trading. And what we require is good experience and we can get it through trading directly with ourselves
yes, with that we can grow and learn from our bad experiences
that way we will become good and successful trader

[blackprince4u]

yes you are right, but I've been wary to use ea
because I would want to trade using my own abilities

yes, with that we can grow and learn from our bad experiences
that way we will become good and successful trader

Right.,.,.,By using some EA we cannot learn trading. Because we just watch trades being opened and closed we don't know about any strategy instead when we do a proper analysis and open trade than we learn many things from our trades it gives us experience.

[Raja Krsnan]

Manual trading is for those who are responsible for all that one does. One who is involved in learning definitely goes for manual trading. That does not mean EAs are bad, but with it we do not learn anything.

[arjun]

Right.,.,.,By using some EA we cannot learn trading. Because we just watch trades being opened and closed we don't know about any strategy instead when we do a proper analysis and open trade than we learn many things from our trades it gives us experience.

EA memerlukanb people who use more knowledge. because they have to learn about computer languages ​​, and we should be acutely aware of the manual trades, in order to change from manual to automatic. so I disagree when using EA we do not learn trading.

[anubhavsingh]

EA memerlukanb people who use more knowledge. because they have to learn about computer languages ​​, and we should be acutely aware of the manual trades, in order to change from manual to automatic. so I disagree when using EA we do not learn trading.

AApki baat ek dum sahi ahi
EA me trade karne wale logo ko trading ache se nahi aati kyunki jitne analysis manula trading me hoet hai utne EA me nahi jhote
Forex seekhne ke liye aapko manual trading ep dhyaan dena padega tabhi aaap forex me master kar sakte ho

[pipsdragon]

EA memerlukanb people who use more knowledge. because they have to learn about computer languages ​​, and we should be acutely aware of the manual trades, in order to change from manual to automatic. so I disagree when using EA we do not learn trading.

we can still learning, but in my opinion we can not increasing ours pshycology level if we trading just using eA or robot.

[denira]

we can still learning, but in my opinion we can not increasing ours pshycology level if we trading just using eA or robot.

could be because we are too trusting trading robot so it will not affect trade emotions for that we should start with trading manuals to train the emotions

[mayengbam]

if we are to learn forex trading then manual trading is the perfect choice. But if anybody is here just to make profit then he can try all the robots EAs available on the market paying a good sum and trying it on his real account but the result may not be as he expected. Manual trading is hard, time consuming and stressful. so those who doesnt have patience and hate doing hard work its better to leave straight away because its not his type of business.

[Mr. Tukul]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

for me, i believe manual trading is the best system...
follow your heart and open your trade position...that's the best way...

[Mr. Tukul]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

for me, i believe manual trading is the best system trading...
just follow your heart, and then buy or sell...

[dead]

for me, i believe manual trading is the best system trading...
just follow your heart, and then buy or sell...

I also trust the manual trading because I also still use manual way, and I think I have not proficient to use the manual way and not want to switch to the robot

[denira]

I also trust the manual trading because I also still use manual way, and I think I have not proficient to use the manual way and not want to switch to the robot

it's a good way because then we follow the steps necessary to do the learning because we also do not understand how and what is best for us but we must learn in a good way

[arjun]

I also trust the manual trading because I also still use manual way, and I think I have not proficient to use the manual way and not want to switch to the robot

should we make robots that came from that we develop its own system.
ea not in the can from others.
manual system that is made into a robot, just easier for us not to be too much trouble to make transactions at any time.

[mayengbam]

for me, i believe manual trading is the best system trading...
just follow your heart, and then buy or sell...

wont it be risky if we trade with our heart only, its like betting. We need analysis of the market before we open a position else trading we wont be successful in many of the trades we open

[Mr. Tukul]

wont it be risky if we trade with our heart only, its like betting. We need analysis of the market before we open a position else trading we wont be successful in many of the trades we open

I agree with you...we need to analyze market too, but sometimes we are confused...because our indicator shown different result, up and down...which one we must follow...sometimes follow the heart is the best way, but sometimes not open a position is the best choice...

[anubhavsingh]

I agree with you...we need to analyze market too, but sometimes we are confused...because our indicator shown different result, up and down...which one we must follow...sometimes follow the heart is the best way, but sometimes not open a position is the best choice...

Rightly said brother
If you are not sure about the market, then you should keep yourself away from it
various tardres loose lots of there money in unpredictable market..So teh best way is to keep yourself away from it at the time of uncertaininty

[pinpin]

I agree with you...we need to analyze market too, but sometimes we are confused...because our indicator shown different result, up and down...which one we must follow...sometimes follow the heart is the best way, but sometimes not open a position is the best choice...
but if we follow your heart, I feel will lead to loss
I think your heart is the emotional factor
and in this necessary business analysis and a calm mind, not just your heart

[medhat4forex]

Will not let you on a strategy that can bring you a lot, but how Sabulgk Atager is using technical indicators such as Bollinger Bands and Stochastic

[Mr. Tukul]

but if we follow your heart, I feel will lead to loss
I think your heart is the emotional factor
and in this necessary business analysis and a calm mind, not just your heart

if you've been doing this business, I believe that someday our intuition of the market will be formed...
but this intuition can not be formed in a short time, your experience in the trade that will shape it ...

[makjon]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

depend your own style, if we enjoy with manual trading or using feeling and can get a lot of profit why not, but if i prefer to use an indicator because the indicator is our analisys to do open buy or sell in trading

[alwi]

first thing that we should do is learn as many as possible strategy that we like. then combine it into the one that is comfortable with. trading with our own strategy make us enjoy the trade.

[denira]

whose name really have our own strategy will certainly provide comfort for ourselves when making trades and I think it's very good

exactly what you are saying that by using our own analysis or the strategy it will provide comfort in our trade because we know how we make decisions

[zoomfire]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

yes of course.Even i believe in manual strategy.even if i lose in manual i wil not worry so much as mistake is mine and i can rectify it.
but if i lose in EA or robot purchased,the mistake is not mine.So i will always do manual strategy.

[Mr. Tukul]

exactly what you are saying that by using our own analysis or the strategy it will provide comfort in our trade because we know how we make decisions

profit or loss if we trade with analysis and our own systems, we can usually accept whatever the outcome ...
so we are not too dependent on the signals given by other traders ...

[soumen]

yes of course.Even i believe in manual strategy.even if i lose in manual i wil not worry so much as mistake is mine and i can rectify it.
but if i lose in EA or robot purchased,the mistake is not mine.So i will always do manual strategy.
aapne ek baria baat ki he. ha manual trding se agar hum loss bhi kare to utna kharab nehi lagta. ku ki hum dobara uss mistake se kuch alag karenge. aur khud se sikha bhi ja sakta he. or robot ko buy karne ke baad agar loss ho jaye to usse jyada dukh nehi hoga.

[dead]

profit or loss if we trade with analysis and our own systems, we can usually accept whatever the outcome ...
so we are not too dependent on the signals given by other traders ...

exactly what you are saying that having his own analysis is better than getting a signal from one trade or another trader because we should realize that it's not good for our analysis of learning

[pipsdragon]

exactly what you are saying that having his own analysis is better than getting a signal from one trade or another trader because we should realize that it's not good for our analysis of learning

i like your opinion, but sometime use other trader prediction is needed too. for comparing with ours own prediction.

[vicky]

i like your opinion, but sometime use other trader prediction is needed too. for comparing with ours own prediction.

I am agree with you . although i think its not wise to follow others but it may good to see what others saying and if there is same with our then it will help us to decide to enter our trade but when we have some knowledge then its not good to blindly follow others which actually not give us learning and make us lazy too.

[blackprince4u]

i like your opinion, but sometime use other trader prediction is needed too. for comparing with ours own prediction.

yes for beginners they must compare their analysis with someone Else's analysis because in beginning our skills are not good enough to make a perfect analysis.

[anubhavsingh]

yes for beginners they must compare their analysis with someone Else's analysis because in beginning our skills are not good enough to make a perfect analysis.

mere khayal se new traders aur beginers ko kisi experianced traer ki help zarur leni chahaiye
Unhe time time pe experianecd traers ke sath apne trades aur strategy ko discuss karna chahaiey..asia karbne se new comers ko kafi acha experiance milega

[vicky]

yes for beginners they must compare their analysis with someone Else's analysis because in beginning our skills are not good enough to make a perfect analysis.

I think if they do this then better becaus ei think it may give some good idea of their own analysis because they can take their mistake from others . but i think its better to develope their own also and sometime its naturally happen when experience level grow.

[arjun]

yes for beginners they must compare their analysis with someone Else's analysis because in beginning our skills are not good enough to make a perfect analysis.

does not seem to be that way, we can see the analysis of others but do not combine them.
you must believe in your analysis, and there is always a reason why you open a position contrary to others.

[blackprince4u]

does not seem to be that way, we can see the analysis of others but do not combine them.
you must believe in your analysis, and there is always a reason why you open a position contrary to others.

But we shouldn't make it a matter of our ego.I think there is nothing special if we consider someone's analysis and compare it with our own.And opening contrary trades is not important if you do not get profit from those trades.

[vicky]

does not seem to be that way, we can see the analysis of others but do not combine them.
you must believe in your analysis, and there is always a reason why you open a position contrary to others.

I think if there is strong support of others analysis i think we can use it if we have less experience becaus efor this less experience it may our analysis is wrong . anyway its not happen for experience trader when they are more confidence of their own analysis but it may happen newbie traders.

[ganguly]

mere hisab se manual trading or signal both are better trading stragity as saurab say u need good practise for manually trading to get good no of amount or good result.signal is also better for us agar hume signal mil jata hai toh maximum time woh profit hi deta hai

[venkiaries61]

both are good sir for good ea good vps is needed and manual trading good practise is needed using good strategies to get results is needed


Yes i agree with you. If we want to do manual trades, we should have some necessary practice and have experience in live account with cent account. If you want to do with EA, go for vps only. Don't believe on your home systems.

[SG Trader]

Yes i agree with you. If we want to do manual trades, we should have some necessary practice and have experience in live account with cent account. If you want to do with EA, go for vps only. Don't believe on your home systems.

yeah, i think many traders dont have much time to trade, so the solution is automatic trading with expert advisor.
i also trade with ea when i tired and bored. but must be carefully robot not always profitable, we must monitoring a few times.

[Raja Krsnan]

I do all my trading manually and so far not tried any EA. My trial runs with a dozen EAs did not give me the desired result eventhough others reported fantastic results. I did rather trust my own skills, knowledge, talent than instincts that is designed by someone with a particular market condition in mind.

[SG Trader]

I do all my trading manually and so far not tried any EA. My trial runs with a dozen EAs did not give me the desired result eventhough others reported fantastic results. I did rather trust my own skills, knowledge, talent than instincts that is designed by someone with a particular market condition in mind.

thats a good thinking, but i think not problem if we are use ea, especially if the ea is our creation and our modifications . its more than good.
if we can do it, it means we are able to overcome any problem in busy activity when trade.

[dickvr46]

I think the manual is the best trading
because I never had a bad experience using EA
3 times I nearly MC because EA
and now I discourage using EA
because I think using the EA requires significant capital, and I do not have large capital

I guess no need to use a large capital to be able to use the EA,
if you are a little capital, you can open an account cent,
many traders who do so.

[Victoryindia]

i heard that many people loss in robot and trying to sell their eas to recover their money, thatshwy i think manually trading is the best and we can earn and learn from that

[SG Trader]

i heard that many people loss in robot and trying to sell their eas to recover their money, thatshwy i think manually trading is the best and we can earn and learn from that

maybe it depend by ourselves. i think many a profitable robot. robot just solutions for trader who dont have much time to trade, because he/she very busy in their activity.
if we can manage our time, we can manually trading.

[blackprince4u]

I would not agree on all points with you might not use Expert advisors but if you just trade on news you also have to use technicals just charts wont help you to predict the market and earn money so you need reference of technical analysis and predictions.

not only the technical we should keep in mind about fundamental while trading because some times all our technical analysis is ruined by a high impact news.

[rakesh]

I agreed with you that manually trading is best.
As i have saw many people have burn their account with EA, etc so i dont trust EA at all.

[denira]

I agreed with you that manually trading is best.
As i have saw many people have burn their account with EA, etc so i dont trust EA at all.

I do not think it is also because the robots are also trading well and demonstrated that many successful traders use robots in their trade but we have to deepen trade Traffic manual before using the robot

[Victoryindia]

I do not think it is also because the robots are also trading well and demonstrated that many successful traders use robots in their trade but we have to deepen trade Traffic manual before using the robot

but maine to bahut logo to harte hue hi dekta hai, maybe 90 percent robot trader are loser only bahut kam log hai jo consistently robot se kama paata hai

[sagar]

yea manual trading is to me the best way to trade forex, and if you are choosing manual tarding then you should have a trading stategy you believe in so much that your emotion cant dictact to you at all

[venkiaries61]

yea manual trading is to me the best way to trade forex, and if you are choosing manual tarding then you should have a trading stategy you believe in so much that your emotion cant dictact to you at all

For me also manual trading is the best choice for Forex trading. We can able to close the position as we wish according to our strategy. We can also able to avoid over trade.

[denira]

For me also manual trading is the best choice for Forex trading. We can able to close the position as we wish according to our strategy. We can also able to avoid over trade.

well at least from your own opinion and more of the benefits of trade with the manual and it makes us more and more to learn about fundamental analysis and so on and problems of psychology course

[siddesh]

totally agree with you, I'm also trading in the manual and i use the ea will close my position if the target tp reach or a ea the detecting signs of reversal.

[anubhavsingh]

I agree with your opinion, however, that started trading with the manual is the best way to master the trade and master the mental emotion of our trade

manual trading hi sabse acha tarika hai forex trading me
aapko apni studies pe hi depend rehna chahiey aur khud pe bharosa karte hue manually trading akrni chahiye
manual trading ke bahut fayde hote hai jo ki kisi aur tarike se nahi lioye ja skate

[anubhavsingh]

For me also manual trading is the best choice for Forex trading. We can able to close the position as we wish according to our strategy. We can also able to avoid over trade.

har experianced trader aapko amnual traing ke liye hi prefer karega kyunki manual tradin gse acha koi tarika hi nahi hai
manual trading me aap timely market ki direction analyse kar saket ho aur ussi hisab se apni deals ko open aur close kar sakte ho

[Ganesh]

manual trading is no doubt the best but i will say that trading without the help of any signal can be a bit tricky coz these signals dont even help you but make descisions a bit easy for you and do close trade manualy i will say coz it is much profitable.

[BojanHajdinjak]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

Right. Even if we have expert advisor who can trade like we (manualy) he have no control
on computer, conecctions, freezings of platform, on trades execution in the time of events etc etc.
We can find programmer on the net if we know how to trade profitable nd order programm code but in
such case programmer will receive our "secret" to.
So manualy is the best.

[realfun07]

Manual trading is the best to do and it is the best trading strategy.As some of the traders rely on robots or EA and trade with help of them which at times can lead to heavy losses during uncertain market conditions.I prefer to trade manually and not with robots.

[gosians]

No doubt that manual trading is best but still some peoples like robots or EA, I like manual trading, everything will be in your hand you can open and close position at any time. Mostly traders are manual traders.

[sanjeev]

i heard that many people loss in robot and trying to sell their eas to recover their money, thatshwy i think manually trading is the best and we can earn and learn from that

I guess no need to use a large capital to be able to use the EA,
if you are a little capital, you can open an account cent,
many traders who do so.

[cumil]

I guess no need to use a large capital to be able to use the EA,
if you are a little capital, you can open an account cent,
many traders who do so.

oh yea? what you've ever use on a robot / EA?
I disagree with you, ea or robot must require substantial funds, and it used for rent a VPS, and if there are brokers that provide free vps, but at least balance on the account minimum of $ 250. and it's big enough for me, and I prefer the manual

[nuh514]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

Robot are not 100 per cent reliable, moreover these are also very expensive so manual way to trade is the best strategy which is most reliable but in this strategy you have to work really hard in order to get command over this trading.

[Ganesh]

some people do use robots and robots are also right, but for me i cannot afford to keep a big capital in my a/c or buy service for this so i preffer manual and also in manual m in complete controll of my trade so that i can open and close positions whenever i want and also according to my own amount of profit's.

[realfun07]

I guess no need to use a large capital to be able to use the EA,
if you are a little capital, you can open an account cent,
many traders who do so.

There are traders who have other things to do and they still want to be a part of trade for 24 hours , these kind of traders use EA , but these EA can lead to huge losses in case of uncertain market conditions or during event of any news update.

[mayengbam]

Beginners should trade manually and learn the market.

And if a trader can invest a good capital and afford to purchase a good robot, he can try them and order a vps server to run his robot 24X5. Though most of the premium robots claim to make good profits its not a gurantee that the trades will be always making profits

[Jazpa]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?
I believe you. We must believe in ourselves, and on our abilities. We should not depend only upon EA or forex robots. After all they are human made too. So there is chance of error too. It will be better if we go for the trading manually until we get experienced and successful. And even if we lose, we don't have to regret as we lost in our own decisions.

[sachin]

totally agree with you, I'm also trading in the manual and i use the ea will close my position if the target tp reach or a ea the detecting signs of reversal.

[netra]

we must create it manually trading system first , if successful, then we change it to automatic ( EA ). if EA bought from other people and we do not know basically. it is tantamount to suicide.

[denira]

we must create it manually trading system first , if successful, then we change it to automatic ( EA ). if EA bought from other people and we do not know basically. it is tantamount to suicide.

Why you should buy ea, ea is not a lot that are distributed for free but only beginners who are still doing a lot of searching that often use this facility without even trying to learn on their own with the knowledge to understand forex

[SG Trader]

i dont have many time to do manually trade. so i just use a profitable EA which i have been test before with BT and demo account test .
maybe this way are good if you are very busy.

[chirayu]

I think both of these require knowledge and also generate knowledge..
if we use the EA, then we must understand the computer language to be able to make the EA

[sunil]

mere hisab se manual trading or signal both are better trading stragity as saurab say u need good practise for manually trading to get good no of amount or good result.signal is also better for us agar hume signal mil jata hai toh maximum time woh profit hi deta hai

[sunil]

I would not agree on all points with you might not use Expert advisors but if you just trade on news you also have to use technicals just charts wont help you to predict the market and earn money so you need reference of technical analysis and predictions.

[ketan]

Manual trading is the best to do and it is the best trading strategy.As some of the traders rely on robots or EA and trade with help of them which at times can lead to heavy losses during uncertain market conditions.I prefer to trade manually and not with robots.

[anubhavsingh]

I would not agree on all points with you might not use Expert advisors but if you just trade on news you also have to use technicals just charts wont help you to predict the market and earn money so you need reference of technical analysis and predictions.

agar aap sirf news ke hisab se tarde karte hai to aapek liye techbncials follow karna useless hai
news ke samay koi bhi technical kaam nahi ate aur aapko koi bhi supoport aur resistence kaam nahi aayega
major news ke waqt market ki movement bahut zada ho jarti hai aur sare techncials fail ho jate hai

[ketan]

Beginners should trade manually and learn the market.

And if a trader can invest a good capital and afford to purchase a good robot, he can try them and order a vps server to run his robot 24X5. Though most of the premium robots claim to make good profits its not a gurantee that the trades will be always making profits

There are traders who have other things to do and they still want to be a part of trade for 24 hours , these kind of traders use EA , but these EA can lead to huge losses in case of uncertain market conditions or during event of any news update.

[vikas]

Manual trading is good to build our analysis and psychology in trading, EA is not good for beginner but maybe it could
help for expert traders.

[venkiaries61]

Manual trading is good to build our analysis and psychology in trading, EA is not good for beginner but maybe it could
help for expert traders.

Yes, i greatly agree with you. Beginners should do trading manually. This is the good way to learn something in Forex. If you use EA. Then it should dumb your mind. So, go for manual trading.

[aniket]

Right. Even if we have expert advisor who can trade like we (manualy) he have no control
on computer, conecctions, freezings of platform, on trades execution in the time of events etc etc.
We can find programmer on the net if we know how to trade profitable nd order programm code but in
such case programmer will receive our "secret" to.
So manualy is the best.manual trading is no doubt the best but i will say that trading without the help of any signal can be a bit tricky coz these signals dont even help you but make descisions a bit easy for you and do close trade manualy i will say coz it is much profitable.

[hotshotboyz]

I like to trade with manual strategy system.
But sometime I need to use EA for a short time...

[mayengbam]

the best traders out here in this business trade manually. so obviously manual trading is the key to succed. there are lots of EAs and robots free as well as paid one who claims to make consistant profits, though using them may be profitable but depending on ourselves for our own success is more meaningful and fruitful than depending on some other source

[aniket]

we should trade with the help of both means manualy and with help of indicators also
combination of both will give u more profit than using one of them

some people do use robots and robots are also right, but for me i cannot afford to keep a big capital in my a/c or buy service for this so i preffer manual and also in manual m in complete controll of my trade so that i can open and close positions whenever i want and also according to my own amount of profit's.

[netra]

yeah, i think many traders dont have much time to trade, so the solution is automatic trading with expert advisor.
i also trade with ea when i tired and bored. but must be carefully robot not always profitable, we must monitoring a few times.

[netra]

maybe it depend by ourselves. i think many a profitable robot. robot just solutions for trader who dont have much time to trade, because he/she very busy in their activity.
if we can manage our time, we can manually trading.

[netra]

thats a good thinking, but i think not problem if we are use ea, especially if the ea is our creation and our modifications . its more than good.
if we can do it, it means we are able to overcome any problem in busy activity when trade.

[anubhavsingh]

I like to trade with manual strategy system.
But sometime I need to use EA for a short time...

short time ke liye EA use karne me koi bhi dikkat nahi ahi bhai
lekin me apko yahi prefer akrunga ki kabhi bhi manual trading ka sath nahi chodan cahahiye..m,anula trading is the best form of trading

[waheedpcc]

Manual trading is good to build our analysis and psychology in trading, EA is not good for beginner but maybe it could
help for expert traders.

yeah man i totally agree with you that manaul tradrinng is power fula and also you can understand better your psyclogy towards the trade

[anubhavsingh]

yeah man i totally agree with you that manaul tradrinng is power fula and also you can understand better your psyclogy towards the trade

har foreex trader ko yahi recomend kiya jata hai ki techncials aur fundamentals dekh ke manula trading pe h bharosa rakha jaye
manual trading sabse effective aur powerful hoti hai
kayi log EA pe bhi bharosa karte hai jo ki me recommend nahi karunga

[Ronak]

har foreex trader ko yahi recomend kiya jata hai ki techncials aur fundamentals dekh ke manula trading pe h bharosa rakha jaye
manual trading sabse effective aur powerful hoti hai
kayi log EA pe bhi bharosa karte hai jo ki me recommend nahi karunga
mene jabse trading start ki hai tab se aaj tak EA ka upyog nahi kiyaa.mein sirf apne aap vishwas raaakhtaa hu aur mere apne analysis pe hi trade kartaa hoon..kyun ki mujhe abhi thodaa kam knowledge hai to me aur sikhnaa chahtaa hu..EA pe depended rehte ham kuch sikh nahi sakte

[ishvara]

I have seen many people also losing because of the EA or robot that they used in their trading. Manual trading has stood the test of time and i know that it is very effective in forex trading.

[akshayfuriya]

I think the manual is the best trading
because I never had a bad experience using EA
3 times I nearly MC because EA
and now I discourage using EA
because I think using the EA requires significant capital, and I do not have large capital

[vikas]

does not seem to be that way, we can see the analysis of others but do not combine them.
you must believe in your analysis, and there is always a reason why you open a position contrary to others.
I think if they do this then better becaus ei think it may give some good idea of their own analysis because they can take their mistake from others . but i think its better to develope their own also and sometime its naturally happen when experience level grow.

[vikas]

both are good sir for good ea good vps is needed and manual trading good practise is needed using good strategies to get results is needed

I think if there is strong support of others analysis i think we can use it if we have less experience becaus efor this less experience it may our analysis is wrong . anyway its not happen for experience trader when they are more confidence of their own analysis but it may happen newbie traders.

[ketan]

yes of course.Even i believe in manual strategy.even if i lose in manual i wil not worry so much as mistake is mine and i can rectify it.
but if i lose in EA or robot purchased,the mistake is not mine.So i will always do manual strategy.

[netra]

both are good sir for good ea good vps is needed and manual trading good practise is needed using good strategies to get results is needed

[netra]

I guess no need to use a large capital to be able to use the EA,
if you are a little capital, you can open an account cent,
many traders who do so.

[nikhil_rrane]

Manual trading is a very good than robotic trading. Because the capital we are using is our hardly earned money, by using robot we are not able to get any education about the forex. we will not get the practice of the trading so manual trading is very useful.

[speedy]

I am doing the manual trading from the first day of my forex trading. Manual trading is good for all the beginners because we can learn a lot in this type of trading. Where as trading with the help of EAs is not so beneficial for beginners because we must know the basics of trading and that is only possible by manual trading.

[princeali]

ya absolutely right , manual trading hi best hai , kyu ki mainai bahut sarai ea's test kiya hai aur maximum i found losses in demo accounts . aur thodai mini accounts bhi loss karai hai mainai . well behtar hoga ki hum manual sai hi achi si knowledge kai saath forex trade karai . kyu ki achai ea's free mai miltai nahi hai aur unki prices bhi bahut zyada hoti hai .

[cumil]

Manual trading is helpful to improves traders skills and experience. A trader earn and learn at the same time while trading manually so it is the best option to trade manually instead of trading with EA.

I've tried use the EA, and I think after I compare both I prefer the manual because it makes me challenged and need analysis for get profit, and I'm proud if I get a profit with the results from my analysis

[miracle]

Manual trading is a very good than robotic trading. Because the capital we are using is our hardly earned money, by using robot we are not able to get any education about the forex. we will not get the practice of the trading so manual trading is very useful.

before using robot trading first we must master manual trading. because robot trading also need to be control by trader as we know market is moving up to him.

[dmambi]

Most of us hear agree that Manual trading is the best and it should be used by the newbies to get better exposure in this market to make profit in long term. Then why the Trading robots have become so much popular among people , can any one share here.

[newentry]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?
i think this is a wise decision, last years ago, i used EA and i got bad results and i think, if we trade with EA so we got nothing, no practicing and etc
so now i used manual trading and i realized that with manual i can practice some good strategies, grow up and develop my skills and we can control our emotion

[SG Trader]

now i think manual trading is the best strategy, because i can feel a bad market and good market. if i trade with ea , the ea cannot feel like that, so ea will trade every time without see the good and the bad market. but all it depend on each trader. i just prefer the manual

[100c�]

i think this is a wise decision, last years ago, i used EA and i got bad results and i think, if we trade with EA so we got nothing, no practicing and etc
so now i used manual trading and i realized that with manual i can practice some good strategies, grow up and develop my skills and we can control our emotion

@ Anytime and @ newentry I totally agree with you. Both are you right, I also saw many trader who have already taken big losses and when I investigate that why they have taken big loss and I found that when one news will publish and effect of this news will not observe by the robot because they don't know how to trade on this situation. So manual trading will improve our trading skills and knowledge.

[YJSP]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

I think if you want to become a successful trader, it is better for you to manual trade, because the automate trade system can last for some time, when the market conditions changed, we should know how to adjust the system at least.Of course in a certain time, both of the two trading ways can make money.

[hiren]

mere hisaab se manual trading hi best hai.
but manual trading main practise ki bahot jarurart hai per humko time pass hota hai isi tarah se hum ko uske expiriance ho jata hai and than hum market k king ban sakte hai.
manual trading hi best hai.

[dmambi]

May be people with more money in hand and less time may go for trading with the help of Forex robots as they want to enjoy the life with rest of the money. Also people who have successful strategy to make profit may create EA's to automate the trading .

[nikhil_rrane]

May be people with more money in hand and less time may go for trading with the help of Forex robots as they want to enjoy the life with rest of the money. Also people who have successful strategy to make profit may create EA's to automate the trading .
Expert adivisors are good for trading but i think it is always better to trade manually because you can predict the risk reward ratio before trading. While robots do the thing which are fit within them. Just follow technicals and fundamentals and do manual trading.

[Ronak]

Expert adivisors are good for trading but i think it is always better to trade manually because you can predict the risk reward ratio before trading. While robots do the thing which are fit within them. Just follow technicals and fundamentals and do manual trading.

EA helps sometime for our queries or confusion..but manual trading is best for learner and the for them experience is big thing to achieve so manual trading is must for beginner .rather than trusting EA

[arihant]

If people using manual trading then we can learn lot of thing while we are trading. If we USe EA and Signals then we can't learn things even we are trading for some years.

[cumil]

ya manual trading is always best than using using robot and things.Because we earn knowledge from self trading and after getting experinece then we can earn a lot of profit too

Yes. we have much to learn to master the technical analysis, the ability to analyze price is very influenced by the experience and discipline of a person to learn, in the manual trades we can learn money management, we can get a lesson on the psychology of management and also we know how risks will be taken in each transaction so that we can manage these risks, different than using EA

[patil]

हम इसे मैन्युअल रूप से व्यापार प्रणाली बनाने चाहिए पहले, यदि सफल, तो हम इसे स्वचालित (ea) के लिए बदल. अगर ea अन्य लोगों से खरीदा है और हम मूल रूप से नहीं जानता. यह आत्महत्या के लिए समान है.

[nikhil]

aapne ek baria baat ki he. ha manual trding se agar hum loss bhi kare to utna kharab nehi lagta. ku ki hum dobara uss mistake se kuch alag karenge. aur khud se sikha bhi ja sakta he. or robot ko buy karne ke baad agar loss ho jaye to usse jyada dukh nehi hoga.

[patil]

हम इसे मैन्युअल रूप से व्यापार प्रणाली बनाने चाहिए पहले, यदि सफल, तो हम इसे स्वचालित (ea) के लिए बदल. अगर ea अन्य लोगों से खरीदा है और हम मूल रूप से नहीं जानता. यह आत्महत्या के लिए समान है.

[vineet]

I believe you. We must believe in ourselves, and on our abilities. We should not depend only upon EA or forex robots. After all they are human made too. So there is chance of error too. It will be better if we go for the trading manually until we get experienced and successful. And even if we lose, we don't have to regret as we lost in our own decisions.

[dmambi]

हम इसे मैन्युअल रूप से व्यापार प्रणाली बनाने चाहिए पहले, यदि सफल, तो हम इसे स्वचालित (ea) के लिए बदल. अगर ea अन्य लोगों से खरीदा है और हम मूल रूप से नहीं जानता. यह आत्महत्या के लिए समान है.
Bilkul sahi hai, hume pehale manual trading me success pana jaroori hai. Iske baad hum usku EA me badal sakte hai. EA hum kud bi lik sakate hai nahi tho kisi programmer se kikava sakate hai. Our strategy is always good.

[simbagi123]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?

you r rite bilkul manual traiding thik ha kioun ea or auto traiding ki waja se loss k chanse kafi hane es k liye app ko expert hona parrta lekin manual traiding old and newbie dono k liye thik ha

[chintan]

For me the best way to minimize the risk is by using manual trade, Because we can have more flexibility in our trade. We can set our own stop loss and target profit value. And we can choose our custom indicator, etc.

[chintan]

Mujhay naheen lagta kay froex robots abhi itnay popular howay hain froex community. Every body is showing concerns fro robots that means these robots are not still popular among the froex community.

[s19]

Mujhay naheen lagta kay froex robots abhi itnay popular howay hain froex community. Every body is showing concerns fro robots that means these robots are not still popular among the froex community.

i am not agree ther are many robot that are very popular and famous. but when you trade with robot its need more margin.
best is manual trading in this we can set our own trading method and with sutable SL & TP. wiht the help of manual trading we learn the market inviroment also.

[popatji]

I have seen many people also losing because of the EA or robot that they used in their trading. Manual trading has stood the test of time and i know that it is very effective in forex trading.

[popatji]

Yes, I ever knew that there are many traders who used EA and most of them are beginner traders in forex. It is okay to use EA or signal but the fact, there is no one who could success in trading if they used EA only without any analysis or use informations from forex signal directly to market. EA will be so effective in trading if that was used well, I means not 100% automated trading but we still must monitor and make open or close position if that was necessary.

[popatji]

Manual trading is good to build our analysis and psychology in trading, EA is not good for beginner but maybe it could
help for expert traders. In the first time we learned forex, we shouldn't use EA because it's risky and we can't learn
anything if we used EA. Manual trading is good for starting point and also to sharpen our analysis in one or more pairs.

[vicky]

ya with EA analysis is also vey impoartant aspects because depending on ea will not be a good idea. you must be self depedent always. you must be able to take your own descision

That is why we not fully depend on EA because if we have knowledge ans seen there wrong going on with EA we can close the position . so its really urgent to analysis ourself if do trade although EA.

[newentry]

I have seen many people also losing because of the EA or robot that they used in their trading. Manual trading has stood the test of time and i know that it is very effective in forex trading.

last time ago, i used EA...and i think that was very good, no need much time to wait my orders,,,but i got some problem, in two days i lost 60 %
and it was very bad..from this happening i do not want use EA anymore

[vineet]

depend your own style, if we enjoy with manual trading or using feeling and can get a lot of profit why not, but if i prefer to use an indicator because the indicator is our analisys to do open buy or sell in trading

[bhanu]

har foreex trader ko yahi recomend kiya jata hai ki techncials aur fundamentals dekh ke manula trading pe h bharosa rakha jaye
manual trading sabse effective aur powerful hoti hai
kayi log EA pe bhi bharosa karte hai jo ki me recommend nahi karunga

[chintan]

but maine to bahut logo to harte hue hi dekta hai, maybe 90 percent robot trader are loser only bahut kam log hai jo consistently robot se kama paata hai

[dmambi]

For the beginner manual trading is always better than trading with automated software. Once we mastered a strategy then we can try to convert it to a EA to make money. So depending on the EA developed for our trading style is better i think.

[hetal]

ya manual trading is always best than using using robot and things.Because we earn knowledge from self trading and after getting experinece then we can earn a lot of profit too

[SG Trader]

ya manual trading is always best than using using robot and things.Because we earn knowledge from self trading and after getting experinece then we can earn a lot of profit too

maybe the advantage using the robot is when we busy in our activity and just have a short time to see the chart. if we like that, i think we can choose the automatic trading, but you must carefully to choose the best robot, because from my experience the good robot still can make big loss, so you must monitoring your robot for some time.

[s19]

maybe the advantage using the robot is when we busy in our activity and just have a short time to see the chart. if we like that, i think we can choose the automatic trading, but you must carefully to choose the best robot, because from my experience the good robot still can make big loss, so you must monitoring your robot for some time.
yes i agree with you. if robot give us profit then some time its give very big loss to our account. we should watch the status of robot and we also update with market because some time big events happen & in this case EA not work well.

[popatji]

I think manual trading is more better than automated trading like use an EA, many holy grail EA around the market, but which one EA can really make profit consistently and never go to MC really very less, even have but i think very less people will share it out. Market movement will alway change from time to time and EA will not alert with it, and when we alert with it, maybe the time our account was already go to MC.

[popatji]

Manual is certainly the best way to trade. But EA has their place in forex trading too. If you know how and when to put them on, they serve a position to enhance your manual trading systems. Example using EAs for exits for your manual trading system is very good, because if the market is changing trend and may not reach your TP target, an Ea can close the trade on profit for you. Some times when you are not chance to trade, EA can just trade for you maybe one or two days and not the week.

[SG Trader]

Manual is certainly the best way to trade. But EA has their place in forex trading too. If you know how and when to put them on, they serve a position to enhance your manual trading systems. Example using EAs for exits for your manual trading system is very good, because if the market is changing trend and may not reach your TP target, an Ea can close the trade on profit for you. Some times when you are not chance to trade, EA can just trade for you maybe one or two days and not the week.

maybe depends by each trader suits by their needs. many trader say manual trading is better than automatic trading because we can get more knowledge about an strategy that we use and also many trader say automatic trading is better than manual beacuse is easy to do without hard think and spend more time to analyze. for me, the both is better, maybe sometime we can use the both in different day

[bhanu]

both are good sir for good ea good vps is needed and manual trading good practise is needed using good strategies to get results is needed

[yamibux]

Already trading in the individual, which depends on the trader and his experience and knowledge of this market is the best types of trading
The trading by which is the worst ever, for it makes the individual ignorant of everything going on inside this large market
For this trade does not benefit by any dealer not make you a winner and you'll learn, but learning to become eligible to win the largest number of points

[popatji]

Main bhi sochta hoon ki manual trding is best among all. apne dam par trde karna or ea se help lena bahut difference he. par main manual trading abhi bhi sikh nehi paya hoon. par main manual trading sikh raha hoon. yehi manual trading strategy ki fyde he.

[bhanu]

for me, i believe manual trading is the best system trading...
just follow your heart, and then buy or sell...

[bhanu]

I agree with you...we need to analyze market too, but sometimes we are confused...because our indicator shown different result, up and down...which one we must follow...sometimes follow the heart is the best way, but sometimes not open a position is the best choice...

[bhanu]

if you've been doing this business, I believe that someday our intuition of the market will be formed...
but this intuition can not be formed in a short time, your experience in the trade that will shape it ..

[bhanu]

profit or loss if we trade with analysis and our own systems, we can usually accept whatever the outcome ...
so we are not too dependent on the signals given by other traders ..

[dmambi]

Even though we are doing manual trading and happy with that or not, sometimes feel to have a automated system which can generate profit for us even when we are sleeping. That is why these Forex robots are evolved. I feel trading with Forex robos is also not a bad idea, but one should money to buy a good Robo and invest the money required in his account.

[realfun07]

for me, i believe manual trading is the best system trading...
just follow your heart, and then buy or sell...

No doubt manual trading is best and better than using robot for trading but you mentioned just follow the heart and trade.So you mean no study or analysis , just follow what your heart says.You need to wacth your account dude.

[SG Trader]

Even though we are doing manual trading and happy with that or not, sometimes feel to have a automated system which can generate profit for us even when we are sleeping. That is why these Forex robots are evolved. I feel trading with Forex robos is also not a bad idea, but one should money to buy a good Robo and invest the money required in his account.

i think all is depend by traders. when a trader feel busy and cant do analysis for short time, maybe they can use automatic trading. many website to sell a expert advisor for trader, but we must be carefull sometime the expensive robot is not profitable. you must choose the good robot and also the setting of robot. meanwhile, a manual trading is good. we can do trading by our skills and also can improve and develop our skill with own strategy

[shah.zoor]

sab se achi trading manual trading hoti hai, kyunki isse aapko kafi acha experiance mil sakta hai jo ki aapki long term trading ke liye bahut hi zada faydemand saabit hoi sakta hai. agr aap EA use karaingay to ho sakta hay kay aap ko profit bana lay, laykin apko trading to aye aaeygi.

[narendra]

Right.,.,.,By using some EA we cannot learn trading. Because we just watch trades being opened and closed we don't know about any strategy instead when we do a proper analysis and open trade than we learn many things from our trades it gives us experience.

[realfun07]

I agree with you...we need to analyze market too, but sometimes we are confused...because our indicator shown different result, up and down...which one we must follow...sometimes follow the heart is the best way, but sometimes not open a position is the best choice...

A robot or a expert advisor can not react properly in volatile markets as well as uncertain markets and moreover there is no robot which is 100 % accurate so best thing to do is trade manually based on your study and analysis.

[yamibux]

I'm with you, my brother, we Alaimad on ourselves in the trade and leave the vehicles that entered in that field it's hard to win, but impossible to win it can not continue to perform and one will end up (margin)

[aryan]

yes for beginners they must compare their analysis with someone Else's analysis because in beginning our skills are not good enough to make a perfect analysis.

[aryan]

But we shouldn't make it a matter of our ego.I think there is nothing special if we consider someone's analysis and compare it with our own.And opening contrary trades is not important if you do not get profit from those trades.

[aryan]

not only the technical we should keep in mind about fundamental while trading because some times all our technical analysis is ruined by a high impact news.

[speedy]

not only the technical we should keep in mind about fundamental while trading because some times all our technical analysis is ruined by a high impact news.

Yes, we should take care of technical and fundamental analysis both and at the same time we should be aware of all the latest news because sometimes news change the whole trend in minutes.

[jai]

No doubt that manual trading is best but still some peoples like robots or EA, I like manual trading, everything will be in your hand you can open and close position at any time. Mostly traders are manual traders.

[krishan]

हम इसे मैन्युअल रूप से व्यापार प्रणाली बनाने चाहिए पहले, यदि सफल, तो हम इसे स्वचालित (ea) के लिए बदल. अगर ea अन्य लोगों से खरीदा है और हम मूल रूप से नहीं जानता. यह आत्महत्या के लिए समान है

[krishan]

हम इसे मैन्युअल रूप से व्यापार प्रणाली बनाने चाहिए पहले, यदि सफल, तो हम इसे स्वचालित (ea) के लिए बदल. अगर ea अन्य लोगों से खरीदा है और हम मूल रूप से नहीं जानता. यह आत्महत्या के लिए समान है.

[SG Trader]

Yes, we should take care of technical and fundamental analysis both and at the same time we should be aware of all the latest news because sometimes news change the whole trend in minutes.

in my opinion will be good if we are trading with technical and avoid the news,
so altough we are a technical trader, we also must see the fundamental news in forex calender and do not to trade when there a important news which affected the pair

[jai]

oh yea? what you've ever use on a robot / EA?
I disagree with you, ea or robot must require substantial funds, and it used for rent a VPS, and if there are brokers that provide free vps, but at least balance on the account minimum of $ 250. and it's big enough for me, and I prefer the manual

[jai]

I've tried use the EA, and I think after I compare both I prefer the manual because it makes me challenged and need analysis for get profit, and I'm proud if I get a profit with the results from my analysis

[s19]

I've tried use the EA, and I think after I compare both I prefer the manual because it makes me challenged and need analysis for get profit, and I'm proud if I get a profit with the results from my analysis
i agree with you when we are going to be trade with EA we can not learn trading in proper way..
EA reduce our learning strenght & challenged..EA may be failed due to any reasing but manuall traidng never fail. EA can not trading according to market enviroement but we are able to trade in direction of market.

[amit]

Yes. we have much to learn to master the technical analysis, the ability to analyze price is very influenced by the experience and discipline of a person to learn, in the manual trades we can learn money management, we can get a lesson on the psychology of management and also we know how risks will be taken in each transaction so that we can manage these risks, different than using EA

[sunil]

i think this is a wise decision, last years ago, i used EA and i got bad results and i think, if we trade with EA so we got nothing, no practicing and etc
so now i used manual trading and i realized that with manual i can practice some good strategies, grow up and develop my skills and we can control our emotion

[SG Trader]

Manual trading is simply the best. Because its not possible for a trading robot to think and take decision like a human beings. That's why it can't save us in adverse situations.

agree with you. so i think manual is better than automatic trading.
with manual also we can improve our skill and get a lot of knowledge about forex analysis than we use automatic trading.

[eddis]

I've tried use the EA, and I think after I compare both I prefer the manual because it makes me challenged and need analysis for get profit, and I'm proud if I get a profit with the results from my analysis

if we using expert advisor we must using vps to maximaze profit in trading activities
we also need very big balance to make a good result iin account
manual is more profitable and more realistic to became as trader professional in forex trading

[realfun07]

Manual trading is simply the best. Because its not possible for a trading robot to think and take decision like a human beings. That's why it can't save us in adverse situations.

You are absolutely right as it is humans that made robot and not vice a versa and robots cant react to news updates and perform wise trades and also they are not accurate.EA might lead to heavy losses in uncertain markets so always prefer to trade manually.

[dmambi]

oh yea? what you've ever use on a robot / EA?
I disagree with you, ea or robot must require substantial funds, and it used for rent a VPS, and if there are brokers that provide free vps, but at least balance on the account minimum of $ 250. and it's big enough for me, and I prefer the manual

Even $250 is also a very small amount for using Robot for trading. They need a large account balance in multiple of $1000 which we can not afford to invest immediately. Also Robots can not trade efficiently in news release time, i feel manual trading is the best method .

[cumil]

I think with a manual trading we can learn from the beginning and the basic and most important we can learn about trading psychology well ,and trading according to our wishes well

why much people assume that trading using robot not profitable? whether they have tried it? they assume that the robot is a drain on their money, I could not figure out to them, if one day you find a profitable robot then you will be proud and comfortable trading with him because the robot will help you make money so much,

do not worry about the risk, you can restrict risk in forex trading with the robot as long as you can control it ...

[krishan]

विशेषज्ञ adivisors व्यापार के लिए अच्छे हैं, लेकिन मुझे लगता है कि यह हमेशा बेहतर मैन्युअल व्यापार है क्योंकि आप व्यापार से पहले जोखिम इनाम अनुपात की भविष्यवाणी कर सकते हैं. जबकि रोबोट बात है जो उन्हें भीतर फिट हैं. बस technicals और बुनियादी बातों का पालन करें और मैनुअल व्यापार करते हैं.

[krishan]

मैनुअल ट्रेडिंग रोबोट व्यापार की तुलना में बहुत अच्छा है. क्योंकि राजधानी हम प्रयोग कर रहे हैं हमारे शायद ही पैसा कमाया है, रोबोट का उपयोग करके हम विदेशी मुद्रा के बारे में किसी भी शिक्षा प्राप्त करने में सक्षम नहीं हैं. हम व्यापार का अभ्यास नहीं मिलता तो पुस्तिका व्यापार बहुत उपयोगी है.

[realfun07]

you should be so confident my friend while doing a good trade manually. it will create confidence and also as you said that your strategies will grow more and there will be no problem for you.

Manual trading is the best trading strategy as one should not trade with EA as robots can not react to uncertain markets and not trade properly during time of news updates.Softwares are also known to have bugs so one must trade manually.

[SG Trader]

Even $250 is also a very small amount for using Robot for trading. They need a large account balance in multiple of $1000 which we can not afford to invest immediately. Also Robots can not trade efficiently in news release time, i feel manual trading is the best method .

dont worry friend, in forex trading there is a cent account.
so we can using it if we are need a large capital resilience. trading with $250 is same as 25000 cents.
this is good way if you using expert advisor in your trade.

[widhie75]

Manual trading is the best trading strategy as one should not trade with EA as robots can not react to uncertain markets and not trade properly during time of news updates.Softwares are also known to have bugs so one must trade manually.

Market is moving dynamic but EA didn't....

so the difference between manual & using EA is we will know how good we can trade stable...which is stable trade is more important than high profit but then bangkrupt in next day/month.

also EA dont have feeling when market suddenly turn back against OP.......some EA have strict SL & cut loss but most dont use SL.

in manual, to reduce loss,,,we can just cut loss when make mistake.

[s19]

Market is moving dynamic but EA didn't....

so the difference between manual & using EA is we will know how good we can trade stable...which is stable trade is more important than high profit but then bangkrupt in next day/month.

also EA dont have feeling when market suddenly turn back against OP.......some EA have strict SL & cut loss but most dont use SL.

in manual, to reduce loss,,,we can just cut loss when make mistake.

friend you are right..manual trading is best then EA trading.
but In my view EA is not bad if you watch proper way EA trading.
like first give very hug profit to EA like for 0.01 lot size 1000$. second when every come good news disable EA.
i See some EA that dont use stop loss but they open order in both direction.

[sanjeev]

कुछ लोगों उपयोग रोबोटों और रोबोट भी करना सही, लेकिन मेरे लिए मैं के लिए मेरे एक / ग में एक बड़ी पूंजी रखने या इस के लिए सेवा खरीदने ताकि मैं preffer पुस्तिका और भी अपने व्यापार के पूरा नियंत्रण में मैनुअल मीटर में इतना नहीं वहन कर सकते हैं मैं किखोलने के लिए और पदों बंद कर सकते हैं जब भी मैं चाहता हूँ और मेरे लाभ है अपनी राशि के अनुसार.

[sanjeev]

पुस्तिका व्यापार नहीं सबसे अच्छा संदेह नहीं है लेकिन मैं किसी भी संकेत की मदद के बिना है कि व्यापार कहेंगे थोड़ा मुश्किल coz के इन संकेतों आप भी लेकिन मदद नहीं निर्णय थोड़ा आप के लिए आसान बनाने के और करीब manualy व्यापार coz मैं कहना यह है कर सकते हैंबहुत लाभदायक है.

[akshayfuriya]

I also trust the manual trading because I also still use manual way, and I think I have not proficient to use the manual way and not want to switch to the robot

[arihant]

exactly what you are saying that having his own analysis is better than getting a signal from one trade or another trader because we should realize that it's not good for our analysis of learning

[s19]

exactly what you are saying that having his own analysis is better than getting a signal from one trade or another trader because we should realize that it's not good for our analysis of learning
taking signal from other trade is other things...and manual trading and robot trading is other things...there is no relation in both of them.
manual trading is batter way for trading but need a good analyses..
we can trade in direction of trend and with news also.. robot always trade with their fundamental.

[sanjeev]

फिर पुस्तिका व्यापार हमेशा सबसे अच्छा रोबोट का उपयोग कर का उपयोग कर से things.Because हम आत्म व्यापार से ज्ञान कमाने और experinece फिर मिलने के बाद हम भी लाभ का एक बहुत कमा सकते हैं

[sanjeev]

या मैनुअल व्यापार हमेशा best.Because अगर Ea और रोबोट के साथ व्यापार से हम एक नुकसान तो वहाँ भारी अफसोस है, लेकिन अगर हम पुस्तिका व्यापार के द्वारा एक lossing पीड़ित तो वहाँ इतना अफसोस नहीं है क्योंकि नुकसान हमारी गलती की वजह से हो जाएगा नहीं हो

[raja]

when we are already familiar with how our own trading strategies despite frequent loss that sometimes we get ..
then eventually we will experience a consistent profit and reflection we are increasingly sensitive to changes in price movements that make us more careful and patient

Demo trading is important, to learn to operate the MetaTrader4 and test strategies, once can generate profit and confident with the analysis, the next trading on real account to learn psychology of trading, better use of your account cents, to minimize the sacrifice of money, because most new traders have a margin call, when trading on real accounts for the first time

[aafx100]

Yes; I agree with the manual trading but EA is not bad too, profit or loss does not related to any trading. Trading is a individual's character how he plays it either for loss or profit, there is no one to compel him for loss.

[realfun07]

Yes; I agree with the manual trading but EA is not bad too, profit or loss does not related to any trading. Trading is a individual's character how he plays it either for loss or profit, there is no one to compel him for loss.

EA can be trusted with in uncertain markets and also they can't react to news updates so it might lead to losses for the trader in volatile and uncertain markets. Manual trading is the best trading strategy and trade with money management.

[sanjeev]

सब पर फिर Ea beginners के लिए उपयोगी नहीं है, लेकिन विशेषज्ञों के लिए यह मददगार हो सकता है. शुरुआती पुस्तिका व्यापार पहले करने के लिए और सच प्रवृत्ति की पहचान के अनुभव और कौशल प्राप्त करना चाहिए

[raja]

EA can be trusted with in uncertain markets and also they can't react to news updates so it might lead to losses for the trader in volatile and uncertain markets. Manual trading is the best trading strategy and trade with money management.

trader should try to manage the risk, do not focus on profit and profit only, traders should have a strategy, I think just use one or two indicators, it was able to make a trend analysis, analysis of market entry and exit, if the trader can discipline it can generate profits consistent

[s19]

Manual trading is the best choice. Because robots are not so intelligent that they could do anything special for us. Besides this they could damage to our accounts in such adverse situations.
manual trading is best but trading with robot is not too bad.
if you have a good robot then you can use for trading. but in robot trading there is no learning. if you have enough balance like $1000-$1500 for 0.01 lot size than you can make profit.

[raja]

manual trading is best but trading with robot is not too bad.
if you have a good robot then you can use for trading. but in robot trading there is no learning. if you have enough balance like $1000-$1500 for 0.01 lot size than you can make profit.

many traders fail the manual way, and many traders fail to EA. may be the cause because the strategy was not profitable, so the trader should always update trading strategies

[s19]

many traders fail the manual way, and many traders fail to EA. may be the cause because the strategy was not profitable, so the trader should always update trading strategies
in my view there are many factor of failure. not only trading strategy is its main reason. beside updating our trading strategy we also need to modify our money management.
In case of EA after getting profit we should try to minimize the risk level.

[raja]

in my view there are many factor of failure. not only trading strategy is its main reason. beside updating our trading strategy we also need to modify our money management.
In case of EA after getting profit we should try to minimize the risk level.

trading strategy, psychology and money management, this is an important factor, at this time I was fighting my real account in order to survive, and will get a lot of trading experience, I think just the experience of using a real account trading extremely influential in successful trading

[sanjeev]

हा bilkul साही se पुस्तिका व्यापार bhohat बॉक्स कुछ apne aapko जो सिख sakte जीवन kam hai आ स्केट. आप की जैसी लालच, भय या emtion sikhte मैं कर्ण हो नियंत्रण. चमगादड़ तु फलक apko जीवन Kaye मुझे jagah सममूल्य kaam आ Sakti है

[s19]

trading strategy, psychology and money management, this is an important factor, at this time I was fighting my real account in order to survive, and will get a lot of trading experience, I think just the experience of using a real account trading extremely influential in successful trading
there is one other point beside trading strategy, psychology and money management that is fundamental analyses.
if we have good money management with good trading strategy and we dont focus on news then it also become a reason of failure and loss.
In manual trading we count all factor.

[aryan]

But we shouldn't make it a matter of our ego.I think there is nothing special if we consider someone's analysis and compare it with our own.And opening contrary trades is not important if you do not get profit from those trades.

[aryan]

not only the technical we should keep in mind about fundamental while trading because some times all our technical analysis is ruined by a high impact news.

[sachin]

depend your own style, if we enjoy with manual trading or using feeling and can get a lot of profit why not, but if i prefer to use an indicator because the indicator is our analisys to do open buy or sell in trading

[arihant]

yeah man i totally agree with you that manaul tradrinng is power fula and also you can understand better your psyclogy towards the trade

[akshayfuriya]

I totally agree with you. Both are you right, I also saw many trader who have already taken big losses and when I investigate that why they have taken big loss and I found that when one news will publish and effect of this news will not observe by the robot because they don't know how to trade on this situation. So manual trading will improve our trading skills and knowledge.

[Anand]

Manual trading or signal both are better trading stragity.Sometimes Ea,signal instruments not give you good profit but Mannual strategy give you profit.

[hima]

in my views if peoples use manual Trading about this they can get lots of information and trading tips and knowledge of forex although we cant get or learn any thing if we use EA's and signals

[s19]

Manual trading or signal both are better trading stragity.Sometimes Ea,signal instruments not give you good profit but Mannual strategy give you profit.
yes i agree with you that both trading is batter. its depend on trader which way he will select manual trading or EA trading.
EA can not trade with news but with manual trading we can trade with news also and able to make a good profit compair to EA trading.

[SG Trader]

depend your own style, if we enjoy with manual trading or using feeling and can get a lot of profit why not, but if i prefer to use an indicator because the indicator is our analisys to do open buy or sell in trading

what do you mean sir that trading using by feeling?
i think is very dangerous and not including in good rules in forex trading. we have analysis in forex and we should do that. if we are dont using some analysis it mean we are do gambling and not do a trading business.

[nikhil]

mene jabse trading start ki hai tab se aaj tak EA ka upyog nahi kiyaa.mein sirf apne aap vishwas raaakhtaa hu aur mere apne analysis pe hi trade kartaa hoon..kyun ki mujhe abhi thodaa kam knowledge hai to me aur sikhnaa chahtaa hu..EA pe depended rehte ham kuch sikh nahi sakte

[realfun07]

Manual trading or signal both are better trading stragity.Sometimes Ea,signal instruments not give you good profit but Mannual strategy give you profit.

Moreover EA can not react properly to news updates which are there and it might lead to losses. Also during the times when the markets are uncertain EA can not trade well and again it might lead to losses.So always trade manually based on your analysis.

[tibasingh]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?
hnn waqai manual trading bahot he nast ha par ab main es ko churr kar ahesta ahesta auto trading par aa raha houn or ab indecaters bhi use karne laga houn nahi to main ne ye kabhi use nahi kiye the par ab use kar raha houn kioun k manual trading sirf long term par he kamyab ha

[SG Trader]

Moreover EA can not react properly to news updates which are there and it might lead to losses. Also during the times when the markets are uncertain EA can not trade well and again it might lead to losses.So always trade manually based on your analysis.

this thing make some trader thing more confused.
yes, indeed EA is not good is some market, so i think you must follow or monitoring your ea. set the time when you want to run your ea, i think this is a good way to avoid the bad performance of EA.

[nikhil]

mene jabse trading start ki hai tab se aaj tak EA ka upyog nahi kiyaa.mein sirf apne aap vishwas raaakhtaa hu aur mere apne analysis pe hi trade kartaa hoon..kyun ki mujhe abhi thodaa kam knowledge hai to me aur sikhnaa chahtaa hu..EA pe depended rehte ham kuch sikh nahi sakte

[SG Trader]

No doubt manual trading is best and better than using robot for trading but you mentioned just follow the heart and trade.So you mean no study or analysis , just follow what your heart says.You need to wacth your account dude.

yeah, i think also manual is better than using the robot,
because we can improve our skill and get a knowledge when using manual trading. but we need a long process for the best result in our manual trade. while, with the robot we dont need a effort, just find a good robot or buy some robot in the forex website.

[hiren]

Yes i agree with you. If we want to do manual trades, we should have some necessary practice and have experience in live account with cent account. If you want to do with EA, go for vps only. Don't believe on your home systems.

[MTEBESSI]

I have tried a lot of EA and the problem is that I can't believe on that EA so I prefer manual trading. If I lose with my own mistakes I can correct them after but if EA doesn't trade correctly I can't rectify it to trade correctly.

[nikhil]

I think if you want to become a successful trader, it is better for you to manual trade, because the automate trade system can last for some time, when the market conditions changed, we should know how to adjust the system at least.Of course in a certain time, both of the two trading ways can make money.

[kamla]

That is why we not fully depend on EA because if we have knowledge ans seen there wrong going on with EA we can close the position . so its really urgent to analysis ourself if do trade although EA.

[edison]

yes manual trading is good but atleast you know fundamental analysis because without that it is gambling

[hiren]

I think if there is strong support of others analysis i think we can use it if we have less experience becaus efor this less experience it may our analysis is wrong . anyway its not happen for experience trader when they are more confidence of their own analysis but it may happen newbie traders.

[safeerforex]

As my point of view, i think manual trading is the best trading strategy. As i have saw many people losing money with EA, signal, etc

What you think about this?
han bilkul thik he kaha app ne k manual tarding waqqai he bast strategy ha es main ye to ha k app ko time to dena parrta ha par es main app ko itna loss nahi ho sakta jitna app ko dosrey tareeqoun se ho sakta ha esi liye main to manual trading he karta houn

[kamla]

I think if they do this then better becaus ei think it may give some good idea of their own analysis because they can take their mistake from others . but i think its better to develope their own also and sometime its naturally happen when experience level grow.

[nikhil]

Why you should buy ea, ea is not a lot that are distributed for free but only beginners who are still doing a lot of searching that often use this facility without even trying to learn on their own with the knowledge to understand forex

[nikhil]

well at least from your own opinion and more of the benefits of trade with the manual and it makes us more and more to learn about fundamental analysis and so on and problems of psychology course

[nikhil]

I do not think it is also because the robots are also trading well and demonstrated that many successful traders use robots in their trade but we have to deepen trade Traffic manual before using the robot

[burayak]

in doing forex business will be a lot of strategies and systems that can generate consistent profits if we master it and understand it properly so that we will always benefit from the discipline to use it.

[rakesh]

For me the best way to minimize the risk is by using manual trade, Because we can have more flexibility in our trade. We can set our own stop loss and target profit value. And we can choose our custom indicator, etc.

[rakesh]

Mujhay naheen lagta kay froex robots abhi itnay popular howay hain froex community. Every body is showing concerns fro robots that means these robots are not still popular among the froex community.

[anchitkole]

Manual trading is helpful to improves traders skills and experience. A trader earn and learn at the same time while trading manually so it is the best option to trade manually instead of trading with EA.

[chintan]

i agree with you when we are going to be trade with EA we can not learn trading in proper way..
EA reduce our learning strenght & challenged..EA may be failed due to any reasing but manuall traidng never fail. EA can not trading according to market enviroement but we are able to trade in direction of market.

[chintan]

friend you are right..manual trading is best then EA trading.
but In my view EA is not bad if you watch proper way EA trading.
like first give very hug profit to EA like for 0.01 lot size 1000$. second when every come good news disable EA.
i See some EA that dont use stop loss but they open order in both direction.

[wolfkamikaz]

my experience started with robots becaufe as I imagined it all helps to make easy money without understanding the strategies and the basics of forex so I lost a lot with robots but now with manual after I read many books and I started forex strategies to win well I think manual is a very good way to win in forex

[waqasma]

There is no doubt in it that manual trading is best because it gives you experience to trade more perfectly and also it motivates you to earn more but by signals you can get an idea that in which currency pair you should trade. You can analysis it manual and then you can trad it in your way.