I like merchants in both trading systems. because when the market is so slow, I try to trade the scalping advertising strategy making some small profits and when the market price is very high, I try to trade with swing trading system and generate big profit easily. Assuming you have a decent scalping method and not a newbie chasing the market, I would say scalpers get more while the swing trader will include daily movements up 100 pips, we all know that the move may involve prices going up 30, down 20, up 70, down 30 etc. A decent broker can take every move. I should add: in theory